A Game Of Love (A Forbidden Game #2)

Chapter 10

Bishop

When we get back to Lilly’s parents’ place and fill them in on what happened back at the dorm room, Lilly lets them know we’re spending the night in the pool house.

“Oh, no, you’re not,” Chase mutters, shooting me a glare.

“Dad, I’m an adult. I live across the hall from him. Hell, I’ve been sleeping at his place for the past few nights. It’s not a big deal.”

Oh shit!

Chase swings his angry gaze at me. “What?”

“Dad!” Lilly groans, grabbing my hand. “Stop.”

“Chase, leave her alone,” Ellie sighs. “She’s an adult now. She can do what she wants. As long as she’s making good choices.”

“She’s my baby,” Chase grumbles. “And I’m not going to let him defile her.”

“Okay, big guy. Don’t act like the lot of us weren't getting it on since we were like, what? Fifteen, sixteen?” Rain scoffs.

“Eww,” Lilly scrunches up her nose adorably.

“That’s different,” Chase mutters.

“How? We were younger than her.” Rain laughs.

“You’re not helping.” He glares at her.

“Go,” Rain says, shooing us towards the back of the house.

“Goodnight!” Lilly yells at a still grumbling Chase as Ellie talks him down.

“You two be good. Be safe and keep it down,” Rain says, pushing us outside before closing the door.

A little stunned, Lilly leads me to the pool house. “Wanna swim? I’m too awake to sleep.”

“Yeah. I could go for a swim.” Like I’d miss a chance at seeing her in one of her sexy bikinis.

Lilly grins as if she knows what I’m thinking. Grabbing the hem of her shirt, she pulls it up over her head.

I groan as I take in her bra-covered breasts, letting my eyes roam her body, following the movement as she grabs the waistband of her jeans and pulls them down, too, leaving her only in her underwear.

“Fuck,” I whisper under my breath, a wave of heat hitting me as my cock stiffens.

She grins wider, turning away from me. She reaches behind her back and unclasps her bra, letting it fall to the floor.

“That’s not fair,” I grumble when she doesn’t turn around. She laughs, grabbing her swim top and putting it on. I pout, missing my chance to see her perfect tits.

Looking at me over her shoulder, she shoots me a wink, then grabs her panties and pulls them off.

“Fuck me,” I groan, palming my aching cock.

“Maybe if you’re a good boy,” she laughs.

My eyes are locked on her toned ass, and I nearly cum in my pants when she bends over to slip her feet into her swim bottoms, showing off her bare cunt to me.

“Lilly,” I growl, taking a step forward.

She giggles, pulling the bottoms up and darting away. “Hurry up,” she teases before dashing out of the pool house.

Little minx.

Grabbing my top, I toss it off and grab a pair of swim trunks from the dresser, quickly changing into them before rushing out after her.

She stands by the door, waiting for me with an amused look on her face.

“You’re mean,” I pout, my cock still hard and no doubt on display as it presses against my trunks.

“Who, me?” she asks, fluttering her eyelashes like she’s all innocent and shit.

“Come on. Let’s go swim,” I mutter, glaring at her playfully.

“Yes. Swim.” She nods, shooting me a wink.

I laugh, bumping her with my shoulder, making her laugh too.

“So, did your mom really just give us permission to have sex?” I ask with a chuckle.

“I think so?” She grins up at me. “Rain is so different from my other parents. I love it, but also in moments like this...” She laughs, shaking her head. “That will never not be weird,” Lilly sighs.

“Can’t be as bad as her sitting you down and giving you condoms.” Toby’s voice has us both jumping.

Spinning around, we find him lying on his back in the pool, eyes closed as he floats.

“I remember that,” I snicker, walking over to one of the pool loungers. “The look of horror on your face was the best thing ever.”

“Yeah, yeah,” he sighs, flipping me off.

“What did you do with them?” Lilly asks, moving to stand next to the pool.

Toby’s eyes open, and he moves to stand up. Slowly, he makes his way over to her, eyes filled with hunger as he drinks her in. I get how he feels. It’s what I feel every time I look at her.

“Do with what?” he asks, tipping his head back to look up at her, his dripping hands wrapping around her ankles.

Lilly chews on her lip, looking a little embarrassed by the question. “The condoms. What did you do with them?”

Toby’s lips lift in a smile. “Nothing.”

“Nothing?” She frowns.

“Well, not nothing. I gave them to him.” Toby looks at me, and I groan. Thanks for selling me out on that one, buddy.

She looks over at me. “You?”

“Yes, okay. He gave them to me,” I sigh, shrugging. “I’m not proud of it. But at least I was covered.”

Her brows scrunch up. “I don’t want details,” she mutters.

“I wasn’t offering them,” I chuckle. I had a past before her. One I’m not ashamed of, but also one I’m not sad to see go. She’s the only girl I want for the rest of my life. No other woman matters.

“How come you didn’t use them for yourself?” Lilly asks, taking a seat on the edge of the pool.

Toby moves in between her legs, resting his hands on her thighs. I watch as she shivers at his touch, and his throat bobs as he swallows hard. “I wouldn’t need them if I wasn’t having sex.”

She reaches out, running her fingers through his wet strands. He sighs as if her touch soothes his soul.

I get it. She does the same for me.

“How come you never used them?” she asks, voice barely a whisper.

I know why. And I’m not at all surprised. To him, there was never anyone but Lilly. And while I felt that in my heart and soul, I never expected to ever have a chance with her. If I knew I’d be where I am with her now, I would have waited. It might be one of my biggest regrets. But it’s not something I can change.

He chuckles, rubbing his hands up and down her thighs. “You would need to have sex for condoms. And seeing how I’ve never had it, I didn’t need them.”

Her hands pause as she blinks rapidly. “W-what do you mean?”

“What I mean is, the only person I’ve had sex with is you, Lilly,” he confesses.

“No.” She shakes her head in disbelief. “I saw you. At the party a few months ago.”

His face darkens. “That was something I’m not proud of,” he grunts. “Something I regret. I’ve received...” he clears his throat. “You know. In the past. But that’s it.”

“So... I was your first?” she asks, eyes flicking between his.

“Yes, baby,” he murmurs, leaning down to press a kiss to each of her thighs. “My first, but also my only.”

She bites her lower lip, tears shimmering in her eyes.

I feel like I’m intruding by watching, but I can’t seem to look away or bring myself to leave.

What we have with Lilly is different for each of us. But it doesn’t make it any less real or powerful.

Toby is like a brother to me. I want him to be happy and healthy. Lilly is good for him. She makes him want to be a better man.

She makes me want to be a better man.

I can do this. I can share her with him. I just hope he’s able to do the same. Because the idea of this girl hurting more than she already has in the past makes me want to rip the world apart.

“I’m gonna sound like a baby for saying this, but that makes me really happy,” her voice cracks as the words leave her mouth.

Toby wraps his arms around her and pulls her into the water.

She goes willingly, clinging to him like a koala bear.

Placing his hand on the back of her head, he holds her to him as he murmurs things into her ear.

I see her nod a few times before whispering back.

“I’ll give you some time alone.” Getting up, I’m halfway to the pool house before Toby speaks.

“Stay,” he grunts.

I stop, turning around to look at him. “Are you sure? I don’t mind.”

He sighs heavily. “I’ll get my time alone with her soon,” he says, giving me a pointed look. “So stay, swim.”

Excitement perks up inside me. “Okay.”

“Oh fuck,” Toby hisses, eyes going wide when he sees me run towards the pool.

Laughing loudly as I run, I jump and scream, “Cannonball!” before plummeting into the water.

Lilly’s scream sounds muffled through the water. When I break the top, she’s laughing loudly, a bright smile on her face.

Smoothing my hair back, I wipe the water out of my eyes before I start to stalk towards her.

Her eyes widen. “No,” she squeals, moving to get behind Toby. “Save me!” She laughs harder.

“No one can save you now,” I say in an evil villain's voice.

“Think again.” Toby grins before launching himself at me, forcing us both underwater.

It has to be midnight by now as we lay on the loungers. The cool fall air nips at our skin. We’re wrapped in towels with blankets for added warmth.

Not wanting to end the night too soon, we opted to sit outside and talk.

It was nice reminiscing about the olden days. The days we didn’t have a care in the world apart from when the next time we’d all get to hang out again.

For the past hour, any issues we have seemed to be put aside. I got a glimpse of what this could be. It can work. I know it can.

And seeing Lilly cuddled up with Toby with that smile on her face makes me want to be able to do that for her every day.

My eyes lazily track the sky, taking in the stars, the night air fills with the sounds of crickets and the occasional frog.

Rolling my head to the side, I smile when I see Lilly cuddled up to Toby, sleeping with her head on his chest.

“Take her inside,” he mumbles sleepily. “It’s cold.”

Getting up, I carefully scoop her up into my arms. She makes a small sound before curling into me, snuggling against my chest.

“You should head inside, too,” I tell him.

He waves me off, moving to his side and burying his face in the blanket. Chuckling softly, I bring Lilly into the pool house.

Laying her down on the bed, I stand back and wonder if I should remove her swim clothes. They’re still wet, and I don’t want her to get sick or have them irritate her skin because of the chlorine.

But I also don’t want to just remove her clothes without her permission.

“Are you just going to stand there and stare at me all night?” she murmurs, her eyes fluttering open.

“You’re awake.” I laugh softly.

“Yup.” She grins sleepily, her eyes closing again as she stretches. A sweet little moan of pleasure leaves her lips, and my cock stiffens.

When she opens her eyes, they drop to my erection, and she grins wider. “Someone's excited.”

“It can’t be helped when I’m around you.”

She bites her lip, desire burning bright in her eyes. “I can help with that.”

My brows raise. “You were just sleeping a moment ago.” I chuckle.

“And now, I’m awake,” she sighs, moving her legs so that they lay open. My attention drops to her core, and I groan when I see the outline of her pussy. “Bishop.”

My eyes snap up to hers, arousal flooding my body, and I lick my lips.

“Yes?”

“Make love to me,” she whispers, her smile gone as her expression grows a little more vulnerable. “Please.”

“Right now?” My brows furrow. “Are you sure?”

“Don’t you want to?”

I snort. “Of course, I fucking want to.” I blow out a breath, running a hand through my hair. “But we have school tomorrow.”

“Fine,” she sighs dramatically. “We can just sleep instead of having sex.” She rolls onto her side, sighing heavily again.

With a low growl, I bend down and snatch her up, throwing her over my shoulder with a squeal.

“What are you doing?” She laughs as we head towards the bathroom.

“Showering. Gotta get you cleaned up before I get you all dirty again.” My voice is thick with need.

I told her I wanted to spend hours between her legs and to worship her like the queen she is. I wanted to taste her clean skin, not coated in chlorine.

Fuck school. Fuck practice. It’s worth being tired if it means spending the night with my girl, showing her just how fucking wild she makes me.

I hope she knows that once we do this, once we take that step, I’m not going to be able to keep my hands to myself.

She’s feeding a wild beast, and they always come back for more.