Chapter 5 #2
Kaye pulled it all the way out before pushing it back in again, growling. “You going to come on it for me? Good girl, you’re taking it so good. I’m so proud of you.”
The praise was making me shiver, and I wanted to please him so badly.
“Can you fuck my ass too?” I begged, his eyes darkening as he stroked his hard cock.
“You think you can?”
“I want to try. Please, I want you inside me when I come,” I pleaded, lifting both my knees back to expose my ass to him.
“Such a slut for me,” he whispered, slipping two fingers into my ass. It was a tight fit, my breath catching as he tried adding a third finger.
Zack leaned down to kiss me, scrambling my brain as Kaye got to work on preparing my ass more, and when he finally pushed his cock inside, I felt like I was going to tear in half.
“You’re okay, fuck, look at that,” Kaye groaned, fucking in and out of my ass while his groin bumped against the base of the toy, nudging it with every thrust.
“I need to come,” I squeaked against Zack’s lips, only making him kiss me harder as Kaye pinched my clit, and I screamed as the orgasm tore through me.
Zack grunted, and I didn’t realize what was happening until I came down from my high to find Alec behind him, buried in his ass.
The toy was eased from my spent pussy as Kaye kept fucking my ass, my hand reaching out for Zack.
“I want to choke on you while he fucks you,” I demanded, not having to tell them twice as they moved closer so Zack was braced above me, lowering himself enough that his cock was down my throat.
Every time Alec thrusted into his ass, Zack’s cock felt like it hardened even more.
I was desperate for air, but Alec held his hips down on my face and railed him, Zack letting out the hottest whimper ever as he came down my throat.
He pulled back enough to let me breathe, and when Alec was ready to come, he pulled out and jerked his cock over me, coating my tits in warm cum.
They both collapsed beside me, and Kaye was the last one to finish, pulling out and coming on my pussy with a snarl, his muscles tense as his climax seemed to go on forever.
He dropped down beside me, instantly tucking me against him as we all caught our breath.
One of the others pressed against my back, and I nuzzled into Kaye's neck as I let out a content sigh.
I was exhausted.
I woke up to someone carrying me into the bathroom, the lights remaining dim as I was placed in the bath. The hot water soothed my aching body, and I groaned.
“The guys are sorting out some breakfast,” Alec murmured as he slid in behind me, wrapping his arms around me and kissing my neck.
“What time is it?” I asked sleepily, tilting my head to give him better access.
“Nine. We all crashed hard last night.”
“It’s morning?” I mumbled with confusion, trying to get my bearings as I looked towards the window. The blinds were shut, but sunlight shone around the edges.
“Yep. You want to talk about anything?”
“Can we talk about you and Zack?”
“We can.”
I didn’t know exactly what to say about it, but I was curious.
“How long have you guys been seeing each other?” I finally decided to say, his lips skimming my shoulder.
“About a year. We met first year of college and became good friends. It turned into more last year when we caught up for the first time in ages and got wasted together. We ended up fucking and just kind of kept meeting up after that.”
“Is he your boyfriend?”
“We haven’t labeled anything, but I guess. I crash at his a lot now he’s moved here,” he replied, his hand lifting to brush my nipple with his thumb.
“Does Warren know?”
“Yeah. He walked in on us once so we had to explain it. He was fine about it, so was Kaye. Are you?”
“If you want to be with him, then I’m happy for you. What does this mean for us though?”
His lips on my skin stopped moving, his voice quiet. “What do you mean?”
“Do we go our separate ways now?”
“Fuck no. I want to play more like last night. I was a little nervous to tell you about it, to be honest. I shouldn’t have started something with you in the woods when you had no idea about me and Zack. If you’re not okay with sharing—”
“I’m totally okay with you guys. Maybe we can play more later? Zack could fuck me while you fuck him.”
“Stop, or I’ll come in the bath,” he chuckled, nibbling my earlobe. “Your body needs a break. I still can’t believe you took that whole toy. I think I have a stomach bulge kink, is that a thing?”
“We can do that another time too. If you push down on my stomach when you fuck me, you’d feel your cock.”
“I don’t want to push too hard,” he mumbled, cupping my breast. “Let’s get you all cleaned up and rinse off in the shower. You need food after all that energy you burned last night.”
We spent half an hour in the bath, and once we were rinsed off and I was dressed in nothing but one of Zack’s shirts, they sat me at the table and pushed a plate of fruit and pancakes in front of me.
“Coffee,” Kaye said affectionately as he placed the cup in front of me and joined me at the table, the guys all sitting down with their own coffees and pancakes.
I could sense Kaye’s need to touch me, so I kept my leg pressed against his while we ate, the topic switching to Warren.
“We have to tell him if this is going to become a thing,” Alec stated, sipping his coffee and eyeing Kaye. “He’s going to fucking kill us.”
“We just need to explain it in a way that says we like Rose, not that we just want to gangbang her,” Kaye grunted, his hand on my thigh.
“The second we all say we’re seeing her, all he’s going to hear is we’re running a train on her,” Zack said dryly, glancing at me. “Got any ideas?”
“Is this a relationship? What are the rules? I think we need to figure all that out first,” I pointed out, and Alec frowned.
“It’s a relationship. I said this morning this is what I want.”
“Just want to make sure all of us are on the same page.”
“I’ve always wanted you. Ask Warren later, he punched me on your nineteenth birthday for saying you’re hot,” Alec grinned, motioning to Zack. “And if you’re good with me and him, then that’s all there is to it. I don’t want anyone else.”
“So just the people in this room right now?” I asked carefully, not seeing how that was fair to the guys, but Kaye nodded.
“I’ve never wanted anyone like I want you.”
“So we just tell Warren we’re dating. Easy,” I shrugged, and Alec laughed.
“You think we can tell him the three of us are dating you and he won’t lose his mind? He knows what we’re like, Rose. He’ll picture all the fucked up shit we do to you.”
“He also knows you’re good guys who won’t hurt me.”
“You’d have to blackmail him to keep his fists off my face,” Alec grumbled, but he nodded. “We tell him tomorrow. He’s busy today, apparently. Do you want to take a photo of me? I won’t be recognizable once we tell him.”
I giggled, picking at my food. “You’re being dramatic.”
“So, this is official?” Kaye asked, wanting confirmation as his hand stroked my thigh. “We’re doing this?”
“We’re doing this,” I grinned, leaning over to kiss his cheek. “Maybe leave the celebratory sex until later though. My poor pussy.”
They all laughed, and I took the time to message Maisie.
Rose: We need to meet up tomorrow afternoon. I have to tell you something!
She didn’t reply straight away, so I finished my coffee while I waited, finding her response once I was done eating.
Maisie: Afternoon is good! Sleepover?
Rose: Sold! See you tomorrow!
We cleaned up from breakfast and spent the day lounging around watching TV and gaming, ordering pizza for dinner. Despite knowing my body was hurting, it was really hard not to throw myself at the guys when Alec and Zack started making out on the couch later that evening.
I was sitting across Kaye’s lap, giving me a good view of the other two, and I must have made a noise or something because Kaye chuckled in my ear.
“Baby, you can’t handle another round so soon.”
Zack was definitely in charge this time, and my breath hitched slightly as he took hold of Alec’s throat to kiss him deeper. Alec tugged at Zack’s shirt, the two of them fighting for control after a moment and making me groan.
“I think I’d die if I came again, but fuck this is hot,” I mumbled as Alec started pulling Zack’s sweats down.
They ended up a tangled mess of naked limbs as they ground against each other on the couch, and I squirmed as Alec kissed down Zack’s chest towards his cock.
The moan that Zack made when Alec’s mouth wrapped around his cock should have been illegal, his head dropping back on the couch.
I was mesmerized, watching as Alec gagged on his cock greedily while Zack’s fingers threaded through his hair to encourage him deeper, and I whimpered, wishing I could join them.
Alec seemed to work harder once he knew I was really getting into it, and I hesitated before crawling across the couch to Zack, cupping his chin, and kissing him.
He happily kissed me back, my hand moving to his chest to feel his rapid heartbeat.
“Fuck it, I’ll be gentle,” Kaye promised, and I had no idea what he was talking about until I felt him lift the long shirt I was wearing out of his way and his tongue lightly brushed my pussy.
I gasped, Zack taking advantage of it as he pushed his tongue into my mouth. His free hand cupped the back of my neck to keep me close, and it was a struggle not to push Alec out of the way and sink over Zack’s cock.
Kaye licked small circles over my clit, keeping to his word of being gentle, and when Alec moved back, Zack pushed my head down towards his cock, encouraging me to take over.
I eagerly swallowed him down, reaching for Alec’s as he stood in front of me, and I moved between the two with my hand and mouth, my legs trembling the more Kaye worked me.
My muscles definitely hurt a little when I came, but it wasn’t unpleasant since Kaye was careful and didn’t keep prolonging it.
“I’m going to come, baby,” Zack gritted out, his hips thrusting up slightly. “Don’t swallow it.”
I had no idea why, but I waited until he’d filled my mouth with cum before leaning back, blinking at him to wait for instruction. “Share with Alec.”
I didn’t even have time to figure out what that meant before Alec dropped down on the couch and yanked me on top of him, fusing our mouths together.
His tongue forced its way into my mouth to tangle with mine, and I felt Zack’s cum leaking from the corners of my mouth. Alec swallowed what I gave him, licking me clean, and then he was flipping me around to face Kaye, burying his tongue in my pussy.
“Oh fuck,” I panted, instantly reaching for Kaye’s pants to get his cock out.
“You don’t have to,” he said straight away, trying to halt me.
“Try and keep me away from your cock. I dare you,” I threw back, a smirk tugging at his lips.
“By all means, help yourself.”
I pulled it free and licked the head, finding it covered in pre-cum. He let me take control this time, so I sucked him deep and held it, wanting to do it how he liked it.
I waited until my throat was going tight around it before pulling back to breathe, and he stroked my hair.
“You’re so perfect. Always happy to please me.”
I swallowed him down again, being rewarded with more affectionate strokes to my hair, and I’d barely finished swallowing the load he spilled down my throat when Alec pulled me back and lifted me, carrying me towards the bedroom.
“Dude, she’s too sore,” Kaye called out, but Alec ignored him and laid me down on Zack’s bed, crawling between my legs to return to eating my pussy.
He was gentle as he added a finger while looking up at me to watch my face for signs of discomfort as he fingered me, and I hauled him up by the hair after a moment, bumping my pussy against his cock.
“You sure?” he asked with concern, waiting for me to nod before fisting his cock and teasing my pussy with it, pushing inside as slowly as possible.
I was tender but didn’t care, lifting my hips to force him deeper. I just needed him inside me.
The other two joined us, and we spent hours continuing to mess around.
They all came on my face this time, and Kaye took a photo to add to his collection, apparently still having the photo he’d taken of me in the woods on my knees.
I also discovered that Alec would in fact eat my ass.
I was awake enough to shower before sleeping this time, and when I woke up to pee at four in the morning, the ache between my legs told me I definitely needed a rest day.
I quietly crept from the room and out into the hallway in one of Zack’s shirts, only making it a step before the bedroom door opposite it opened and I came face-to-face with a startled Warren.
“I can explain,” we both said at the same time, making me frown.
“What can you explain?” I asked quietly, my eyes shifting over his shoulder to see Maisie asleep in the bed behind him, the blanket pooled around her naked waist as she slept on her stomach.
Warren’s eyes were on the guys sleeping in Zack’s room behind me, and I couldn’t exactly make up a reason for why I’d been in there. It was pretty fucking obvious.
“Uh, you good with this?” Warren asked awkwardly, jerking a thumb back at Maisie.
“That depends. Are you good with that?” I asked dryly, motioning to the guys. “We’re dating.”
“I’m good with it if you’re good with me and Maisie fucking,” he said quickly, and when we went to shake hands, we paused and pulled back, silently agreeing that we didn’t need to touch hands to make the deal.
“You need the bathroom?” I asked as we wandered along the hallway.
“It’s fine, you go first,” he encouraged, and I ducked into the bathroom to pee before emerging, giving him an awkward smile.
“Uh, good night.”
“Good night,” he mumbled as he locked himself in the bathroom, leaving me to head back to bed.
I crawled back into my spot between Kaye and Alec, Kaye sliding an arm around me.
“You good?”
“Had to pee. So, uh, good news. We don’t need to tell Warren about us. I just ran into him in the hallway.”
“What’s he doing here?”
The blanket rustled and Zack yawned. “He comes here sometimes to fuck girls instead of taking them back to his house. Doesn’t want Rose hearing it.”
“Well, we agreed not to fight about it since he’s got my best friend in his bed across the hall from us,” I snorted, and Alec groaned.
“He’s fucking Maisie? Even I told him that’s a bad idea.”
“Hey, I hope they’re happy together forever so we can be happy together forever,” I joked.
“Breakfast will be interesting in the morning,” Kaye sighed, nuzzling into me. “Go back to sleep, it’s early.”
Alec curled into me as Zack spooned him, and it didn’t take long for us all to go back to sleep, where I dreamed of masked men chasing me through the woods.
I kind of hoped they’d want to do that again sometime because Halloween had been the hottest night of sex I’d ever had in my life.
Maybe, just maybe, they’d even let me chase them one night?
I couldn’t wait to fucking ask.
The End.