Better than Sunshine (Sunset Siesta #4)

Chapter 1

Chapter One

AUSTIN

A man deserved to hear the whisper of the ocean breeze with his first cup of coffee, not the battle cry of a demolition crew attacking the derelict mansion next door. This was a truth I held self-evident, right up there with never trusting a politician who claimed to understand the tides.

My careful universe, rebuilt shard by shard over thirteen years, had developed a significant, ear-splitting crack. Its name was Heron House. More accurately, its new and apparently noise-immune owner.

I cradled my ceramic mug, its familiar weight a small comfort as I leaned against the porch railing of my conch house. The coffee was strong and black, the way I liked it. No frills, no nonsense. Just like my life.

Or how my life used to be.

The meticulous order of my home—every plank of clapboard siding painted a crisp white, each rich green shutter aligned with military precision—reflected the internal calm I fought to maintain.

The house was my sanctuary, a fortress against the world’s unpredictable turmoil.

Now, that fortress had a thunderous siege engine parked on its border.

For the past two weeks, since the arrival of one Iris Holloway from somewhere up north, my days had become a relentless assault.

Sunrise, which once painted the Gulf in silent strokes of apricot and rose, was now heralded by the guttural roar of a rented generator, followed swiftly by the echoing thud of hammers against ancient, protesting wood.

Today’s special included an off-key rendition of some pop song by Sutton Vale I vaguely recognized from my brother Eli’s dive shop radio, punctuated by an occasional yelp.

Whether of frustration or accidental self-injury, I couldn’t tell.

And didn’t want to.

Heron House itself had always been a fixture, a grand, decaying Victorian lady sighing her slow surrender to the salt and sun next to my property.

Three sprawling stories of off-white, peeling paint like sunburnt skin, porch railings sagging like weary shoulders, and gardens so overgrown they probably hosted species unknown to science.

But old Lady Lawson had possessed the good grace to let it crumble in peace.

Until she passed away and left the entire thing to this Holloway woman, some sort of relative.

The new owner, however, seemed to believe resurrection required a full-blown rock concert. Starring herself.

A particularly violent screech, like a pterodactyl being put through a woodchipper, rattled my coffee cup against the railing.

My gaze moved to rest on the tropical crimson of my hibiscus hedge that separated our properties.

I closed my eyes and inhaled a slow, deliberate breath, counting the seconds like prayer beads.

One… two… The ghosts of the past were always quieter in the early morning, before the world woke up and reminded you of all the ways it could go wrong.

Three… four… This stillness, this order, wasn’t just a preference. It was a necessity. A way to keep the edges from fraying, to keep the memories locked tight where they couldn’t do any more damage.

Five… six… And now this. This cheerful, oblivious destruction of my carefully curated peace. Today even the gorgeous red blooms couldn’t soothe me.

She had no understanding of the delicate balance of a place like Dove Key, where the hush was as much a part of the landscape as the mangroves.

Holloway thought she could just waltz in, all bright ideas and Home Depot enthusiasm, and bend a hundred years of history to her will without ruffling a feather.

As it happened, my feathers were thoroughly ruffled.

And then some.

The screeching stopped, replaced by a series of resonant thwacks.

I pictured her, a vague image culled from glimpses through the hedge I kept trimmed to perfection—a flash of long, sun-streaked blonde hair escaping a messy ponytail, the surprisingly determined set of a dirt-smudged jaw.

A whirlwind of limbs usually covered in some new form of construction debris. But limbs that were undeniably female.

That thought made me scowl. She probably wore flip-flops to operate heavy machinery. Her crew wasn’t much better. The whole damn enterprise reeked of amateur hour.

Enough. I couldn’t sit here and let my blood pressure rise with the sun. It was time for escape.

Line Dancer was waiting.

I drained my coffee, the last dregs mirroring the gritty mood that had settled over me.

Inside, my kitchen—with its natural maple Shaker cabinets, honed granite countertops, and the stainless-steel section I’d installed for cleaning fish—was a practical haven.

I grabbed my gear bag, the worn canvas familiar in my hand.

The drive to Sunset Siesta Resort was short, but long enough for me to attempt a mental reset.

My home was one of several conch houses, plus the monstrosity next door, that anchored the northern shore of the residential district on the island’s northwest quadrant.

My mood had improved enough that I tapped my truck door shut in the parking lot instead of slamming it.

As I passed the open-form pool area, the resort was already stirring.

A few early risers headed for the beach, the scent of breakfast from Driftwood Grill mingling with the salt air.

It was a different kind of noise here. The hum of a working place. Of family.

My family.

Their lives were all moving forward in a steady current of engagements, weddings, and babies. Sometimes I was a stone in that current, unmoving, watching the water flow around me.

Prepping Line Dancer was therapy. The familiar rituals of checking fuel and oil, stowing bait, wiping down the already spotless fiberglass deck.

The rhythmic clink of ice into the cooler.

My charter for the day was a family of four from Ohio: an eager dad, a slightly apprehensive mom, and two kids, a boy and a girl, practically vibrating with excitement.

The boy, maybe ten, with eyes like saucers, hit me with the inevitable question before we’d even cleared the no-wake zone.

“You think we’ll catch a shark, Captain Austin?”

I managed a noncommittal grunt that I hoped sounded encouraging.

“Sorry, kid. We don’t hunt sharks here. Other outfits do, but the ecosystem has plenty of challenges without depleting its apex predators.

” I smiled to soften the news. “But we’ll likely catch plenty of snapper, maybe a dorado if we’re lucky.

The sea’s got its own ideas about what it wants to give up. ”

I didn’t voice my hope that the Gulf would give up a sudden, localized waterspout aimed directly at Heron House. Purely for noise abatement, of course.

Once we were out on the open water, the familiar sense of rightness settled over me.

Dove Key became a low, green smudge on the horizon, the only sounds the thrum of the diesel, the cry of a distant tern, and the slap of the hull against the chop.

The ocean didn’t judge. It didn’t demand.

It just was. Honest. Mostly predictable, if you knew its language. And I spoke it fluently.

I guided the family, showed the dad the subtle flick of the wrist needed to cast into the mangroves for snook.

The girl had a surprising knack for it, and I helped her reel in a respectable red snapper, her face a mask of fierce concentration and then pure joy.

I answered their questions about tides, currents, and the best way to cook their catch with the practiced ease of a thousand charters.

“What a day!” the dad, Drake, exclaimed several hours later, his face ruddy with sun and excitement as he landed a feisty jack crevalle.

He tossed it in the ice cooler. They’d caught as many fish as they could handle and learned the importance of returning the ones they didn’t plan to have the restaurant cook for them.

“You run a tight ship. Best charter we’ve been on in years. ”

I just nodded with a slight smile, accepting the compliment with my usual economy of expression. It wasn’t about running a tight ship. It was about respect for the process, for the environment. You read the water, you found the fish. Simple. Clean.

As I guided Line Dancer into her spot at the Sunset Siesta dock, the familiar resort spread out before me, a sprawling collection of buildings that had been the backdrop to my entire life.

More history than hotel, as my sister Harper often joked, though it was currently undergoing its own metamorphosis.

An hour later, hosing down the deck where the scent of salt and fish created a familiar, almost comforting perfume, Harper stepped onto the boat.

Even six months pregnant with twins—God help her and her husband, Chase—she moved with a brisk, purposeful energy.

Her chestnut hair was pulled back in a practical ponytail, but wisps had escaped to frame a face that looked both tired and determined. A file folder was tucked under her arm.

“Good trip, Austin?” She paused at the edge of the slip, her hand resting on her prominent belly.

“Yeah. Ohio folks. They were happy.” I turned off the hose. “How are you? You’re looking more… uh… expanded.”

Smooth, Coleridge. Real smooth.

A weary smile touched her lips. “Feeling like I’m smuggling a pair of particularly active bowling balls. But otherwise, yes, expanded is the word.”

“Expanded? Harper, you look like you’re about to launch your own little fleet.

” Braden’s cheerful voice preceded him as he sauntered up and hopped on board.

Our youngest brother was all easy grins and restless ambition, his light-brown hair already escaping the baseball cap he wore.

He ran Tidal Hops, the brewpub at the resort, and had an opinion or a joke ready for any occasion.

Though we were very different personalities, he was the sibling I tended to gravitate to.

He bent over and peered at Harper’s belly. “Seriously, sis, are you sure there are only two in there?”

She laughed. “Pretty sure, little brother, unless Chase managed to sneak in a third when I wasn’t looking.

And perish that thought. He’s currently designing Nursery Wing Alpha and Bravo.

” She turned back to me. “And yes, Austin, I’m on light duty, which apparently means juggling seventeen crises instead of twenty.

Chase and I should finish moving into Mom’s place this week. ”

“Good timing,” Braden chimed in, leaning against the rail. “That guest cottage was getting a bit snug for Team Bowling Ball, I imagine. Mom’s got to be thrilled to have an excuse to extend her Eat, Pray, Love world tour.”

I smiled. Braden could lighten even my moods, and Mom deserved her escape.

She’d come up with the idea of moving into the two-bedroom guest cottage Harper and her young son, Finn, had occupied for years, letting the growing family have the house we had all grown up in.

Then she’d announced she was off on an extended holiday, giving them plenty of time for the big move.

“She sent a postcard from Juneau,” Harper added, dropping onto the padded bench seat. “Apparently, she’s an expert on glacier calving now and is off to Italy next. Says she’ll be back after the twins arrive, then who knows where she’ll jet off to.”

“Good for her,” I said. “And the main house has more room for… all that.” I gestured vaguely at her midsection.

“Tell me about it.” Harper’s gaze swept over the resort grounds, a familiar worry line creasing her brow. “The resort reno is chugging along without too much drama at the moment. Lobby demo starts next week, which is going to be fun.”

Braden winced. “Maybe not so much for the guests trying to check in alongside a cloud of hundred-year-old plaster dust. But hey, progress, right?” He nodded toward the end of the beach where four bungalows stretched along the sand. “Those things have been a hit.”

“The bungalows are an absolute gold mine,” Harper agreed, her eyes lighting up. “Booked solid for months. Chase, for all his occasionally terrifying focus on minute design details, knows his stuff.”

“He usually does,” I agreed.

Chase was a good man, and I was glad Harper had him.

She’d earned some peace and reliability in her life.

As she talked about spending more time off her feet, I was the familiar observer to all this forward momentum washing over me.

It wasn’t a bad feeling. Just… separate.

The thought of more little humans running around, more noise, more chaos, brought a faint, strange pang.

More noise, I told myself. That’s all it was. Couldn’t be envy.

Braden’s face had soured. “Yuck. Too damn much domesticity going on around here.”

“Well, you’re safe. What I have isn’t contagious.” Harper patted the folder. “Thanks for the break, but I’d better get back to it. Just wanted to give you a heads-up about the lobby demolition traffic, Austin.”

“Noted.”

Braden pushed off the rail. “And I’ve got a new shipment of hops calling my name. Don’t work too hard, you two.” He gave us a wave and headed toward Tidal Hops.

As I gave Harper a hand up, she gave me a look with a familiar flicker of sisterly concern in her eyes. “Heron House still sounding like a war zone?”

The question brought the morning’s irritation roaring back. I rubbed my dark scruff. “You have no idea. It’s a violation of the Geneva Convention on noise pollution.”

She smiled and winced sympathetically. “Oof. Good luck with that. And try to get some actual rest. You look like you’re running on fumes and black coffee.”

“I’ll try.”

Then she was walking away, her focus already on the next item on her to-do list. She was right. I was tired. Tired of the noise, the disruption, and this low-grade, simmering anticipation for a confrontation with a woman I hadn’t even officially met.

I finished securing Line Dancer. On the other side of the pier, the resort dive boat, Sunset Diver, was tied up. As I walked the length of the wooden structure toward my truck, the thought of my tranquil house and the crumbling mansion next door loomed like a gathering squall.

A reckoning was coming, whether I wanted it or not.

And it sure as hell wouldn’t be quiet.