Chapter 5
CHAPTER FIVE
Suzie
In what world am I living in right now?
I cannot be getting naked with my high school sweetheart and his boyfriend .
The same ex that broke up with me 'for my own good'. The man who broke my heart, stomped on it and walked away as if we meant nothing to each other.
Wait. Stop. We can't go there.
Tonight is about fun. About getting him out of my system.
I focus back on the strong, capable arms holding me up as I'm carried to their bedroom. I don't focus on the fact that it's clear from their living space that both men stay here together or what that means for how long they've been in a relationship and how quickly he got over me.
Thankfully, before my brain can spiral too far down that particular rabbit hole, Pete puts me down in front of the bed. Now I can concentrate on his ridiculously handsome face and how hungry he looks as he stares at me.
"Fuck, Suze. You're stunning. I can't believe I'm being given this second chance." He reaches across and pushes aside the strap for my dress, baring my shoulder. This dress—although flattering—doesn't leave much room for things like bras, so when he pushes down the other strap, it slips down my arms, leaving my chest naked.
Both men breathe in audibly and Pete immediately cups me, lifting me up so he can take a nipple in his warm, wet mouth.
Dexter moves in too, but he doesn't take up the empty spot next to Pete. No, he chooses to pull down the dress, letting it fall to the floor so I'm standing in nothing but my pink, strappy heels and a barely there thong.
He groans as he takes in my body, and I've never felt more desired in my life. Falling to his knees, he pushes Pete to the side, so he's right in front of my crotch, and if he were to look too closely, he'd find some very wet panties.
Before I can get too embarrassed by it, he—I kid you not—dives right in. Pulling the gusset of my thong away with a finger, he takes one of my legs, lifts it, and drapes it over his shoulder. And with a hand on my hip to hold me steady, the man just... eats me out.
I mean I could probably describe it in a bit more detail, like his tongue delved in between my folds, and licked up every single bit of juice it could find. And his teeth gently scraped at my small button, sending shocks of pleasure up my spine. Then there's the way he practically purred as he feasted, leaving no doubt about how much he was enjoying it.
As Pete sucks, bites, and licks at my nipples, Dexter does the same to my pussy and within a few short minutes I come. Spectacularly.
And they haven’t even undressed yet.
Dexter continues to lick at my folds as I come down from my first orgasm, and when the aftershocks finally dies down he kisses me, tenderly, on the inside of my thigh before pulling away. "You were right, baby. She tastes better than anything I've ever had. Even you."
Pete chuckles against my chest before picking me up, bridal-style and unceremoniously dumping me on their big bed.
He takes his boyfriend by the hand, helps him up and cups his face in his hands before claiming Dexter's mouth in the hottest kiss I've ever witnessed.
Okay, I got it now... This three's company thing definitely has some merit.
If I hadn't just come so hard, just watching the two of them together would have pushed me close to the edge.
Pete has always been a dominant man. It’s one of the reasons I was so attracted to him in the past. But watching him push at Dexter is indescribable. He cups his face, almost reverently, with so much tenderness my heart melts, but Pete kisses him with so much passion, and so much force that I can feel their kiss all the way inside me.
A needy moan slips from my lips and they pull away from their embrace, both men turning to look at me.
"Like what you see, gorgeous?" Dexter grins at me before turning back to Pete. "I think our little darling is hungry for us, baby. Are we going to give her what she wants?"
Pete rolls his eyes at Dexter, clearly used to his boyfriend's teasing. But he also proceeds to slowly undress himself. With a grace that seems so out of place in a man of his size, he unbuttons his shirt, then slips it off his shoulders, letting it drop to the floor.
Dexter, not willing to be left behind, follows his partner’s moves, and quickly shoves his shirt, then pants and boxers down onto the floor. Almost in sync both men straighten up, affording me my first look at both their naked bodies together. The combination leaves quite the impression.
And holy shit, are they hot.
And packed.
One day, when I'm old, and living happily ever after with my house full of cats, I'll think back on this day and how much I regret I wasn't more classy and suave.
But right now? All I can think about is having one or both of them inside me.
I bite down on my lip and I swear my legs fall open of their own accord. Pete growls as he jumps on the bed and rips—rips!—my thong off my body.
"Sweetheart, I promise I'll take my time later. But if I don't get in you right now, I'm going to die," Pete says as he hovers over me. "Please tell me you're protected."
I nod, holding my breath as I wait for him to give me what I need. It's moments like now, I'm grateful I've been on birth control for ages already.
And then his cock nudges against my folds, and pushes in, stretching me in the most delightful way.
Dexter slips onto the bed with us, climbs up next to me and takes my mouth in a kiss as Pete slowly starts thrusting. It's nothing crazy or even really kinky, but having these two hot men with me is mind-blowing. With Pete's cock filling me, and Dexter's fingers pulling at my nipples as he fucks my mouth with his tongue, I'm overwhelmed with sensation in the best kind of way.
"I wish you could see what I see, baby," Dexter says to Pete, his voice hoarse. "How well she's taking you. Fuck, I can't wait to get in there and fill her up, too."
My pussy clenches at his dirty words, and I wrap my legs around Pete, pulling him closer, urging him deeper.
"Please," I cry out. "Pete, please."
"I've got you, sweetheart," he says, his words soothing and soft. "Daddy's got you."
We all freeze.
That was... different.And new.
Fucking hell... it was hot.
Mentally shrugging off the awkwardness, I decide to go with it.
"Yes, please, I need you, Daddy."
As if my words are the permission the men need to carry on, Pete starts thrusting again, and Dexter's hand moves from my breasts down to my clit. His fingers slip past my hidden hood, and delve into my folds.
Pete groans as Dexter touches him briefly and then Dexter's wet finger moves back to my clit, and slowly, carefully, and with single-minded determination, flicks at it.
Arcing my chest up, I cry out as overwhelming pleasure courses through my system.
"That's it, gorgeous. Fuck, you're stunning when you let go."
My pussy clenches around Pete, and I pull him into his climax with me.
He struggles to hold himself steady over me, his chest heaving as he looks at me, his expression filled with an unnamed emotion I refuse to acknowledge right then. I just can't .
Instead, I look at Dexter, trying on my best needy voice. "I need more , Daddy. I need you, too."
Unsurprisingly, the words have the same effect, the same power , they had the first time I used them.
Pete groans as he pulls out, and I feel a rush of heat as he spills out of me. It's messy, but so fucking sexy, knowing he filled me like that.
He's quickly replaced with Dexter, who has other ideas. Instead of dropping down over me, he takes my hand and helps me up onto my hands and knees. "I want to see this sexy, round ass of yours as I fill your cunt, gorgeous,” Dexter murmurs, his voice filled with a hunger that matches mine. “And maybe, later, you'll let me spank it so I can enjoy it even more.”
"Oh my word," I moan, the words so soft, I don't think they even heard me.
I’m going to be ruined for anyone else after this.That was not the plan.
Dexter wraps himself around my back, his large erection nudging at my entrance as he wraps an arm around my waist, pulling me up so my back is flush against his chest.
With one hand cupping a breast, and the other moving to my pussy, he delves in, opening me as he nudges me from behind.
Once again, I'm full. Filled to the brim. And it's exquisite. And from this angle, with Dexter's mouth on my neck, his lips and teeth tugging on my earlobe I can't focus on anything but the feel of him. In me and around me.
One moment bleeds into the next, and I lose myself in them. In the feeling of being with them, and having them.
Dexter comes, and then I do.
And again later, we all do. Together.
It's one of the most beautiful experiences of my life. And I will cherish it.
Forever.
My one night of answering all my forbidden desires.