19. Everett

19

Everett

T he honey cake recipe was simple, which I supposed shouldn’t be shocking. It wasn’t like they had tons of exotic ingredients back in the nineteenth century, that Peter’s mother could have used in her cakes. The strangest thing in there was lard, and Marsha at the grocery store both had it, and said we could replace it with butter, when she read the recipe.

“Or even coconut oil if you’re one of those vegans,” she promised, glancing in our cart and seeing the ground beef and Italian sausage, then giggling. “But I guess you’re probably not.”

“What’s a vegan?” Peter asked, coming up with a giant bottle of honey. “Is it a kind of vegetable?”

“It’s a person who doesn’t eat anything that comes from animals.” I had a horrible thought, suddenly, that maybe Peter didn’t know his hamburgers were from cows. Shit, was he about to declare himself a vegan, because no one had warned him?

He cocked his head, looking down at the jar of honey. “Even honey?”

“Even honey,” Marsha agreed. “But some people are vegetarians and eat honey and eggs and milk, but not meat or fish.”

Peter’s eyes narrowed, trying to make sense of the difference, and I couldn’t really launch into it in front of people. The explanation would doubtless come back to Peter’s past, and I didn’t think it was a conversation to have in front of people. Instead of asking the expected question, though, he just turned to her and shook his head. “But fish is meat.”

Her shoulders hunched, trying to keep herself from laughing. Finally, she looked up, nodding. “I agree, sweetheart. But I guess some people don’t.”

Peter just shook his head the same way we always had at adult antics as children, turning to me. “People are weird.”

Marsha cackled. “You’ve got that right.”

“You harassing those poor boys?” Ezra asked, pushing a cart with cantaloupes toward the produce section. He held up a melon, waving it a little. “You boys should eat one of these. Best melons in the state.”

Peter had frozen in place, blinking at him.

When Ezra met Peter’s eye, he stilled, and they stared at each other for a moment. “Peter?”

Marsha frowned at her husband. “Honey, we don’t know Everett’s friend. Remember? Hasn’t been a Peter in town in decades since old Doc Hawking died.”

Peter stepped forward, looking at Ezra and holding the honey to his chest. After a long, tense silence, he smiled. “Ezra. It’s been so long.”

The old man blinked repeatedly, but a tear slipped down his cheek anyway. “I—I missed you all.”

I knew from what Peter had told me that the children often didn’t remember each other when they left the woods. He’d been remembering others who came and went in his time there, since he’d left, and there had been dozens over the nearly two hundred years. Dozens that had come and gone, and been forgotten. I was frozen. I couldn’t coach him, couldn’t tell him how much it would hurt a person to hear that he’d been forgotten. But I also couldn’t expect Peter to understand?—

“We missed you too, Ezra. You were always the best at playing pirates. Remember the time you came back with a whole blueberry pie as booty?”

The old man clasped a hand to his mouth, nodding. He motioned to Marsha. “Stole it from her mother’s windowsill.”

Marsha had frozen in place, her head cocked, glancing between her husband and Peter. “She thought you were homeless,” she whispered after a moment of silence. “She invited you to live with us.”

He turned back to her. “And she made the best blueberry pie in the world, and her daughter was the prettiest lady I’d ever seen. How could I say no?”

Peter passed me the bottle of honey and rushed Ezra, leaning in and giving him a hug. “I’m so glad you found a family.”

Ezra looked over his shoulder, meeting my eye. “Me too. And now it’s...it’s your turn, is it?”

When Peter pulled back, his face was bright and animated. “Yes. You know Everett. He’s my best friend. And maybe...well. We’ll figure things out.”

“I’m sure you will,” Ezra agreed, smiling at us both. “You picked a good time to come out. Cell phones and computers and—there’s a lot of magic in the world nowadays.”

Peter beamed. “There is. But there’s always been magic in the world. We just knew where to look, and most people didn’t seem to back then.”

Ezra nodded, wiping his eyes. He motioned to the cart. “Going to make honey cakes?”

Peter nodded. “I am. We are. Maybe...maybe sometime you could come. William is still out there. You—you were best friends.”

“We were,” Ezra agreed. “I’m not sure any of them would want to see me anymore.”

“You’re wrong.” I’d never heard Peter so serious in all our time together, not even when he was talking about what he wanted out of life, tense and sad and thinking about running off into the woods. “We’re family, Ezra. Always will be. Always.”

The old man almost fell forward, hugging Peter again, nodding. When they pulled away, both were wiping their faces. Marsha was staring at Peter like she’d seen a ghost. Or like she’d entirely forgotten he existed until that moment.

I took the melon Ezra was still holding in one hand. “I think we will try this. If you say they’re the best in the state, obviously that’s worth trying out.”

Ezra nodded. “Almost as good as the ones I grow in my garden in season.”

“We’ll have to get you one of those in the summer, so you can compare,” Marsha suggested. She sounded hopeful, and I realized she was feeling me out, not Peter, for whether we were staying.

“That sounds amazing,” I agreed. “Maybe we’ll have a barbecue in the summer, invite everyone, and you can bring one with you.”

“We would love that.” She reached out and grabbed Ezra’s shoulder. “My mother taught him how to make that blueberry pie. We could bring one of those too.”

Peter leaned against me, his head on my shoulder. “It’s a plan. I can’t wait.”

If ads affect your reading experience, click here to remove ads on this page.