Chapter 14 #2
I nodded. “Just when I think she couldn’t make me more proud, she goes and proves me wrong. She really is something else.”
“And we haven’t known her long enough to take any credit for it,” Carter said with a laugh.
“Yeah, that’s fucking annoying, right?” I joked.
“What’s fucking annoying?” Adley said as she walked into the kitchen, which earned her a slap to the stomach from Miriam who was beside her.
I pointed in the direction of where Eliza had just left the room. “How perfect your friend Eliza is.”
Adley sighed. “It really is annoying, but I still adore that girl.”
“There’s definitely something special about her,” Miriam added. The way her eyes sparkled when she looked over at Adley told me those words were definitely only meant in a friendly way. It was clear her straight girl crush was no longer an issue for her.
Adley looked around. “Where is Eliza?”
“I’m in here,” Eliza shouted from the family room. “Come here! I have something to show you.”
Adley grabbed a handful of chips before leaving the kitchen with Miriam following close behind her. I heard a bunch of excited voices, and a few seconds later, a slow song started to play.
I was tempted to go take in the scene, but I stopped myself. Those two deserved their moment.
Even Eliza was giving them space. She came back into the kitchen soon after the music started. She pointed toward the other room. “They are so freaking cute. I can’t take it. I must have the worst gaydar because I had no clue about either of them.”
I had to hold onto my laughter while I nodded. “Sorry, kid, but you really do. I pegged Miriam from the first moment I saw her.”
“Shit.” Eliza snapped her fingers. “Maybe you two can teach me.”
“Teach you how to have good gaydar?” Carter asked. “Sorry, but I think that’s just something you’re born with. Jax’s gaydar is much better than mine.”
Eliza shook her head. “Such a shame.”
A few more minutes passed before Adley and Miriam entered the kitchen, both looking flushed. While I’m sure they had kept it PG, there was definitely more than just dancing going on in that room.
The girls hung out in the kitchen for a little bit before announcing that they were going to go upstairs to hang out in Eliza’s room.
Once they were upstairs, I held my hand out toward Carter. “I still hear music playing in the family room. What do you say we pretend we’re back in high school going to a dance together?”
“I’d love that.” Carter put her hand in mine. “There’s only one problem.”
I wracked my brain trying to come up with what the problem could possibly be, but I couldn’t come up with anything. “Okay. I’m stumped. What’s the problem?”
Carter smirked. “You haven’t asked me yet.”
Ah, there it is. “Carter Miller-Cooper, if I had more time to prepare, I’d hire a plane to fly overhead or I’d find a way to have it written in the stars.
Maybe I’d find a way to ask using your favorite drink at the cafe or get your family involved.
Alas, I don’t have that kind of time, so I’m going to have to settle for this.
” I got down on one knee as if I was proposing and took Carter’s hand in mine.
“Carter Miller-Cooper, will you go to homecoming with me?”
Carter pulled me back onto my feet. “Jax Michaels, I’d be honored.”
Her use of my maiden name surprised me. “Haven’t heard that name in a while.”
“Well, we’re supposed to be in high school, right? I don’t know about you, but I’m not trying to be married in high school.”
“Touché.” I brought Carter's hand to my lips and kissed the back of it. “Follow me, my dear.”
“It would be my pleasure.”
When we got to the family room, the lighting was perfect for a romantic night.
Good job, Eliza. Carter and I wasted no time before starting to dance.
I put my hands on her waist and she clasped her hands together behind my neck, resting her arms on my shoulders.
Our bodies were flush up against each other as we swayed back and forth to the music.
We stayed like this through three songs before an idea popped into my head. “Wanna take a bathroom break with me?” I whispered into Carter’s ear.
“You want me to go-” Carter’s eyes went wide when she realized what I was hinting at. “Oh.” She cleared her throat and looked around as if she had to confirm that no one was around. “Let’s go.”
We were barely inside the bathroom when Carter pushed me up against the door and started to undo the buttons on my pants. She put a hand over my mouth. “You have to be careful so we don’t get caught. I’m sure sex on school property results in automatic suspension.”
I swatted her hand away and smirked at her. “I love when you talk dirty to me.”
Carter gave me a smoldering look before dropping to her knees to pull my pants down. She licked between my legs before making her way up my body, kissing and licking along the way. My body was already humming and a guttural moan left my throat.
Carter put her hand back over my mouth. “What part of being quiet don’t you understand?”
Fuck, I loved it when she scolded me.
Carter kept one hand on my mouth and moved the other between my legs.
As her fingers circled my clit, she leaned in to whisper to me.
“We don’t have much time. I need you to touch me while I touch you.
I want to come all over your fingers, so the rest of the night everyone smells me on you and knows exactly what you did. ”
Fuuuck. I moaned once again as my heart beat so rapidly in my chest, I thought it might actually break through my skin.
Out of nowhere, Carter shoved three fingers so deep inside of me that I screamed out in pain. It was the best kind of pain though. My heart raced as my body begged for more.
Carter brought the fingers out only to shove them in even harder this time. “Why the fuck aren’t you touching me?”
I could feel warm liquid pooling between my legs. Carter wouldn’t even have to touch me to make me come if she kept talking like this.
Carter removed her hands from me so I could pull her pants down, but as soon as I did, one hand was on my mouth and the other was fucking me so hard I honestly didn’t know if the pleasure or the pain was more intense.
I massaged Carter’s clit until it was hard beneath my fingers, because I knew that was one of the secrets to getting her to come fast. The other secret was hitting just the right spot when my fingers were buried inside of her. The whimpers she made as I curled my fingers told me I had succeeded.
Carter continued to push me closer and closer to the edge by mixing pleasure and pain.
Intense tingles, almost like an electrical circuit, ran through my body, and with every thrust of her fingers, became worse.
Since my body was completely out of my control, I struggled to continue to pleasure Carter, but I was determined to make her come all over my hand just like she had promised.
When her fingers curled inside of me, a warm liquid shot out and my body crumbled. As I struggled to stay on my feet, I curled my fingers inside of her while using my thumb to massage her rock hard clit.
“Fuck! Yes!” Carter gasped before melting up against me.
I held her up and laid my head against her chest. “Wow. That was so much better than I remember from high school.”
Carter’s body shook against mine as she laughed. “You’re ridiculous.”
“No, seriously. That was so good, I might go out and get Your Name tattooed on my ass. Oh wait…”
Carter playfully pushed me away. “I guess we better get back to the dance, huh?” she asked.
“The dance… of course.” My brain was such mush at this point, I could barely figure out how to continue our role play.
Carter gave me a knowing smile. “Or we could just head to bed.”
I let out a sigh of relief. “Bed sounds wonderful.”
Carter nodded at me. “You might want to pull your pants up first.”