CHAPTER TWENTY-SEVEN
Paolo
After fulfilling my fantasy of tying Jelly up, I thought the least I could do was fulfill hers.
Did I want to share her with another man?
No. But did I want her to have that fantasy with two men who would keep her safe and cared about her?
Yes. So, here we were at Cayenne about to make it happen for her.
Jelly and I walked down a private hallway in Cayenne. She was holding my hand. I scrubbed my other hand over my face, not entirely on board with what was about to happen. But it killed two birds with one stone, metaphorically speaking.
Nico had begged me to share her with him.
Jelly’s kinkiest fantasy was sex with two men.
And when I’d asked her to choose a guy out of all the men we knew, she fucking chose Nico. Did I enjoy the fact that they were into each other? Hell, no. But it would’ve been awkward if he wanted her, but she had wanted Leo or some other guy.
So, here we were. I stopped walking at the room Nico had directed me to.
I looked around and saw him approaching.
He looked handsome as usual, the fucker.
He was wearing a suit, but his button down wasn’t buttoned all the way up and he wasn’t wearing a tie.
I wondered if he’d already been with a couple of women this evening, but he’d said he wasn’t going to do that.
I trusted him. Nico was typically a man of his word.
“Hey,” he said, grinning. His eyes trailed over Jelly like she was the turkey at Thanksgiving. I hated it. But for some reason, it turned me the fuck on. Maybe it’s because I had something he wanted?
Who knows? I took the chance to look her over again, too.
She looked hot as fuck, but she always did.
She was wearing a short, tight, strapless cocktail dress.
Her breasts looked amazing. And her dress was so short if she bent over just a little, I’d be able to see her underwear easily.
Plus, she was wearing four-inch fuck me heels.
She’d also worn more makeup than she usually does.
It was dark and smoky around her eyes and made her look…
mysterious. And she’d straightened her hair.
It was always fairly straight, but tonight there was no curl or wave to it at all.
It flowed like a black waterfall over her shoulders and more than halfway down her back.
She looked like every man’s dream.
“You look gorgeous as usual, Jelly,” Nico said, his eyes continuing to blaze over her.
“Thanks,” she whispered, her eyes trailing over him, too.
“Is this our room?” I asked, impatient to get this over with.
“Not exactly,” he said with a smile. “I thought we might need a little warm-up.”
He gave three quick raps on the door, and soon the window turned from opaque to clear. Jelly glanced at me. I pulled her in front of me, her back to my front, and whispered in her ear. “Look like we’re going to observe some people first.”
“Having sex?” she asked.
“Fucking,” I corrected.
She nodded. Nico moved over beside her, and we waited for whoever was about to come out.
Soon, a hot blonde woman with a great body came through a door on the back wall in the room. She was wearing a short skirt and a bra top. I could see her hard nipples through the top, and I could already feel my dick starting to pay attention.
Two muscular men joined her, one blonde, one dark-haired. They were each shirtless and already stripped down to their underwear. I thought I recognized all three of them as being strippers at Sugar.
I glanced at Jelly. She was staring straight ahead, her lips parted just a little. Nico was watching her, too. I got the sense that while the threesome in the room went at it, he was going to be observing Jelly the whole time.
It made me feel crazy possessive. I wanted to grab her away from him and hide her behind my back. But I didn’t. Instead, I decided to focus on the show in front of us.
The blonde guy picked the girl up, holding her hands behind her back and pushing her towards the dark-haired guy like an offering.
He grinned and pulled his hard dick out. The other guy pushed the woman to her knees in front of his friend. She immediately took him in her mouth, giving him what I could tell was a stellar blowjob. He threw his head back, his mouth open in a silent yell.
Nico leaned forward and pressed a button, and we were immediately able to hear the sounds in the room. Which were basically like porn.
“Sorry,” he said. “Forgot to turn that on.”
“Fuck, baby. Suck harder with that pretty mouth,” the guy said. He put his hands on her head and started controlling her rhythm. The other guy still had hold of her arms, so she was basically at their mercy. She was moaning and humming.
“What do you need, baby?” The blonde guy asked. “Are you wet?”
She nodded even while continuing to suck the other guy off.
“Pretty little slut needs my dick,” he said, causing her to moan even more. “You don’t get your reward until we’re ready.”
The other guy began moving her head even quicker and getting rough with her. “I’m going to come,” he groaned out. The sucking sounds got louder, more obscene, and he pulled out, shooting his cum all over her.
My dick was hard as hell in my pants, and I could see Nico was sporting some major wood, too. I didn’t need to see anymore. I was ready to go.
But maybe Jelly needed more.
The men pulled the woman up between them, pulling her soaked shirt over her head.
She was topless now. The men moved her to a couch with high arms. The blonde guy rolled on a condom, pushed her over one of the arms, flipped her skirt up, and started fucking her hard.
He grabbed her by the hips hard enough it was sure to leave bruises as he thrust into her brutally.
“Does my little whore like that? Can you take it harder?”
“Yes,” she moaned. “Fuck me harder.”
He increased his pace and roughness even more. Her tits were bouncing so much I wondered if it was painful for her. But I sure as fuck enjoyed watching it.
Then the other guy laid down on the couch under her and grabbed hold of her by the arms. He held her still and sucked, licked, and bit her nipples while the other guy continued his punishing rhythm.
Now that she was being held still, her body had nowhere to go, and it seemed his thrusts were even harder for her to take.
She was screaming now, but I could tell it was in pleasure. Then the guy beneath her started moving her back forcefully at the same time the other guy pounded into her. I winced, but my dick got even harder. I didn’t fuck that rough, but I enjoyed watching it.
Finally, she cried out as she came really fucking hard. The guy fucking her pussy yelled and came soon afterwards, pumping into her a few more times before falling over her back. And the other guy just kept licking and sucking her tits.
“Ready?” Nico asked, his huge cock hard as a rock in his pants.
“Yes,” Jelly breathed, and I noticed her legs shook a bit as she started walking after Nico.
I glanced back at the threesome in the room, wondering if they were finished. The dark-haired guy quit sucking on her tits and flipped her over on the couch. He lubed her breasts and his dick up, then pushed her tits together and started fucking them.
“Goddamn,” I breathed before turning to follow Jelly and Nico into a room across the hall.
When I walked in, Nico and Jelly were already kissing.
He moved fast, too, because he was already kissing down her throat while his hands worked her tits out of her dress.
Before I’d even closed the door fully, he was lavishing her nipples with attention.
She was already gasping and arching her back.
My eyes were locked on the action until I happened to glance up. I sucked in a breath. Her eyes were on me. Nico might be the one getting her worked up, but I was the one she stared at.
I walked over and got behind her, holding her tits up for Nico to get better access. He groaned, took his dick out, and started stroking it.
“What do you want?” I whispered in her ear.
“I… I’m not sure,” she gasped out.
“Do you want one of us in your cunt and one of us in your ass?”
She turned and looked at me over her shoulder while Nico continued suckling her tits. She nodded.
Fuck. I wasn’t sure my cock had ever been this hard in my life. “Are you ready?”
“Yes.”
Nico stopped sucking, reached out and pinched each nipple hard, watching as she cried out. “I want her ass,” he said.
I nodded, and we switched sides. While he rolled a condom on and lubed her up, I pushed three fingers in her pussy, watching as she struggled a bit to take them.
She was dripping wet, though, and I knew it wouldn’t be too difficult for her.
I finger fucked her hard for a few moments, waiting on Nico to take her ass before I pushed inside her pussy with my cock.
He bent her over and slowly began pushing his way inside.
She cried out, wincing at his size. I watched as she adjusted to him and waited until her eyes grew glassy with lust before I notched myself at her entrance.
Nico held her upright as he slowly fucked her ass.
As he pulled out and pushed her towards me, I entered her, groaning at how tight her hot, wet, channel was.
“Fuck, baby.” I moved my fingers to her clit and circled them around in her juices.
She was gasping, and I could tell she was getting ready to come. The first of what I hoped would be several climaxes for her. Nico gave me a chin nod as he continued thrusting into her. “Same time,” he said.
I pushed in at the same time he did, and I hissed at how much tighter she was with both of us inside her.
“My God.” I had to hold myself back from fucking her hard.
I wanted to thrust inside her, taking her fast. But I held back.
She was crying out in a mix of pain and pleasure as we both entered her, and I didn’t want to hurt her.
Nico started moving faster as her continuous cries began to take on more of a tone of pleasure than pain.
I followed suit, throwing my head back at how fucking good it felt.
“Jesus!” I yelled out as her first climax hit suddenly.
Her pussy clamped around me like a goddamn vise, even tighter because of Nico fucking her from behind.
I gritted my teeth trying to hold back. It was too damn good to blow my load already.
Nico increased the speed even more as her legs gave out from under her and we were essentially holding her up by fucking her.
I sped up, too, and I was gasping with need.
Nico reached around and grabbed her clit, pinching it hard, and she came again.
It was even harder than the first time. She flopped back against Nico’s chest, eyes glazed over with pleasure, and I came harder than I’d ever come in my life.
Nico came, too, and for a moment all three of us were crying out together, locked in a sensual dance as Nico and I pushed into her.
Jelly just hung between us, taking us, letting us use her body for our pleasure.
It was un-fucking-real, and I was hard again almost immediately.
I could feel Nico’s massive cock moving against mine through her walls.
“Fuck!” I gritted my teeth. It all felt so insanely good—like nothing I’d felt before.
Nico and I had shared girls before over the years, but Jelly was something else altogether.
I not only felt ridiculous amounts of lust for her; I also cared about her.
That combination was a heady aphrodisiac, and, though I never wanted to share her again, I had to admit it was one of the best sexual experiences of my life.
After all three of us had come again, we stopped to get cleaned up.
Jelly was like a rag doll, so Nico and I worked on cleaning her up together.
Before her left, Nico wrapped her hair around his wrist, pulled her head back and kissed her long and feverishly.
Then he pulled back, releasing her and kissing her cheek.
“That was amazing, beautiful. I’ll never forget it. ”
As he walked away, I pushed her legs apart, settled my shoulders between her thighs, and began slowly, lovingly eating her out.
I fucked her with my tongue, I lavished her clit with attention, both licking and sucking, and worked to make her come as many times as I could before she begged for mercy.
“Come on my tongue, baby,” I said as she moaned, writhed, and did as I commanded.
I heard a noise and turned to see Nico watching us, lust firing in his eyes once again. He gave me a chin nod, and left the room, making sure to close the door behind him.
“That’s all I can take,” Jelly eventually gasped out after I made her come yet again. I moaned against her clit, and she shuddered as more aftershocks wracked her body.
***
That night in bed, after a long shower, I propped my head on one elbow and looked at her.
“What?” she asked, smiling up at me through a yawn.
“Was it everything you hoped it would be?”
“It was so much more,” she admitted. “But… I think I’m good. I don’t know that I’d want to do that with anyone but the two of you, and I’m not sure I could ever top that experience anyway.”
I traced my finger along her collarbone and shoulders, visible above the sheets. “I don’t want to share you anymore,” I confessed.
“No?”
I shook my head. “I like having you all to myself.”
She cocked her head. “Did you not have a good time?”
“I had the best time,” I admitted. “It’s just… I feel possessive of you. I don’t like thinking of anyone else with you, even if I’m there.”
She gave me a dreamy smile, and I could tell she was about to drift off. “That’s okay. I get it. I would never want to share you with someone else.” With that, her eyes closed, and her breathing evened out.
I flopped back on my pillow, thinking about the night we’d had.
I’d enjoyed every second of it. But Jelly was mine.
Mine. I wanted her to be mine. What did that even mean? I was beginning to get concerned.
I’d never felt this way before.