33. Captive Audience
Madison
My hand is on the doorknob. I hesitate for just a second, then I’m lifted off my feet.
“No!” I yell. “Wait!”
Some of the panic in my voice is real, but I know that I just have to call out yellow and they’ll give me a time-out. If I want this to end, I only need to yell red. But once I’m in that room, there isn’t a way to tap out if Noah has me gagged and tied up. Will he even give me an out?
Noah isn’t checking in with me like he normally does, but this isn’t Noah. This is a persona who doesn’t give a shit what I want as long as he can take me any way he wants. I struggle in his arms.
Coop closes in on my front and lifts my feet, holding my ankles tight as I try to kick at him. “Now, sweetheart, is that any way to treat two guys who are going to give you the time of your life?”
“Let me go.” I twist and turn, but they hold fast to me.
Noah kicks open his door, and they toss me on the bed. I land in a tangle with my dress’s skirt around my legs. Before I can scramble up, the lock clicks into place. Warily, I slide off the edge of the bed as they contemplate me.
“She’s a feisty little whore.” Coop relaxes against the door, crossing his arms and ankles like he has all the time in the world. His blue eyes flow over my body like it’s already his. A shiver works down my spine. My gaze drops to the large bulge in his pants. My pussy throbs in response, and I draw in a breath.
Fuck, I want them. I want everything they’re going to do to me, but this time I’m not giving in easily.
Now that they have me trapped, there’s little chance to escape.
My gaze flicks to the open bathroom door. If I get in there, I can lock it and potentially wait them out. It would be a shame, but if I were really in this situation, that’s what I’d do. The overachiever in me still wants to win.
Noah watches me closely. His dark eyes never leave me, even though he appears relaxed beside Coop.
He’s the hunter and I’m the prey. Tingles chase down my spine.
Maybe I can reason with them. I don’t know the rules of the game. The end goal is to get fucked, but how much fight do I need to put up before I give in? Do they want me to cry or would that ruin things? The guys aren’t really cruel. So maybe reason is the way to go.
“Look, we can still just leave. No one’s done anything they can’t apologize for or forget.” I edge slightly toward the bathroom like I’m swaying a little.
“Why would we want to forget about you, kitten?” Noah pushes off the door, triggering my flight instinct.
I lunge for the bathroom. If I make a run for it, I might make it. But my feet never land back on the floor as Noah lifts me against him.
“Now, now, kitten.” His voice sets my insides on fire with want.
“Let me go.” I struggle in Noah’s arms. My elbow sinks into soft flesh. Suddenly I’m airborne again, but I land with my back on the bed and Noah’s weight pressing down on me. His hands tighten on my wrists and hold them next to my head. His legs straddle mine, locking them down.
He leans close to my ear and whispers, “Color?”
Still my Noah. Something settles deep inside me. My chest rises and falls as he lifts. His dark eyes find mine and hold them.
“Green,” I respond quietly. “You okay?”
He grins before taking my mouth. His tongue thrusts between my lips, claiming me as his. His cock grinds against my pussy through our clothes. For a second, I forget to fight, drowning in the taste of him and the feel of him against me. Wanting to give him all of me.
He pushes up, grabs the front of my dress, and rips it down the center. I gasp, suddenly back in character as I try to scramble away from him, holding my torn dress together against his hungry eyes.
Coop circles behind me and grabs my wrists, pulling them above my head.
“Please don’t.” I bite my lip, waiting, anticipating Noah’s brutal wreckage of my dress. I try to hide how much I want him to destroy it, to ravage me.
Grinning, Noah reaches for the rip and tears it all the way down. His gaze takes in my white bra and panties. Licking his lips, he grabs my ankles. My panties dampen more. His gaze focuses on that spot. Can he see how wet I am for him? For both of them?
With a nod of his head, Noah and Coop arrange me on the bed, even as I pull weakly at their grips.
I didn’t notice the ropes on the bed before, but Noah loops one over my ankle to hold it in place before spreading my legs wide and hooking the other ankle to another rope. I tug against the restraint, but it doesn’t go anywhere.
Coop settles behind me on the bed and holds me up with my arms in front of me. His hardness presses into my ass. I barely keep from pressing back against him.
“Please.” I lift my pleading eyes to Noah. I’m not sure what I’m pleading for. I don’t really want them to let me go.
“Please what?” He gives me a considering look as he pulls a length of rope through his hand. “You’re getting fucked tonight, kitten. Beg all you want. Beg for my hard cock in your mouth. Beg for me to fuck your pretty pussy. Tell me, Please stuff me full of cock. Fuck, I love it when you beg.”
He wraps the rope around my wrists like he did earlier today. My pussy throbs when I remember the way he took me. Hard and rough. Not the gentle Noah of morning, but a wild side with an edge that makes my breath catch and my panties melt.
Coop runs his hands up my arms. Sparks light beneath his touch and scatter through me. “You want to tell me something, sweetheart, or is this happening? No turning back. I’m going to ride this hot little body until you can’t walk straight.”
Noah finishes binding my wrists and hands the rope to Coop. He moves out from behind me and lays me back on the bed. Our eyes meet and he holds there for a second, giving me the out. I press my lips together and he grins. Stretching my arms, he ties the rope to the bedpost.
“That’s better.” He slides off the edge next to Noah and they both look down over me. My dress hangs in tatters beneath me, clinging to my shoulders. My white panties are drenched with the thought of what these two can do now that they have me helpless. My breasts swell and my nipples harden, longing to be touched.
Remembering Noah’s promise of a blindfold and gag, I spout off, “Let me go or I’ll scream.”
Coop laughs darkly, making my pussy ache, but Noah turns to grab two scarves off the top of the dresser.
“Last chance, sweetheart. One word.” Coop gives me a look that says all this will all stop if I say red, but I don’t want it to stop.
Please don’t stop. Take me. Use me. Fuck me.
Noah pulls the scarf between my teeth and ties it behind my head. It isn’t too tight and I can still close my mouth. Then he wraps the second one around my eyes. It’s not completely black, so some light bleeds through the fabric. But then someone dims the light in the room.
The coldness of metal touches my skin and the scraps of my dress release from me.
“Did you wear these pretty panties for me, sweetheart?” Coop’s fingers trail along the line of my panties, making me shiver. “I could just come all over these pretty panties, leaving you to soak in my cum.”
I try to protest, but it comes out a jumbled mess. I shake my head from side to side. The straps of my bra release after the slide of the metal against my shoulders.
“These tits need fucked.” Noah grabs my breasts with his hands and squeezes them together tight. I groan at the slight pain. But the memory of his thick cock between my breasts makes me wet. “That sounds like a yes, please to me.”
Coop chuckles while his fingers run under the edge of my panties. My stomach twitches beneath his touch, needing so much more. Would it ruin the illusion if I come as soon as they touch me? The cold touch of a metal edge slides across my hip. One then the other, and Coop peels away my panties.
I’m completely naked, spread out before them on the bed, unable to see or say a thing. I can’t move. The ropes hold me tight.
I’ve never been so helpless and turned on before. The bed shifts, and their warmth and touch move away. The rustle of fabric tells me they’re removing their clothes. Anticipation wells in my belly. My pussy pulses with aching need.
Hopefully this game includes me coming, because it won’t take much to push me over the edge.
* * *
Coop
When Noah told me of his plan for Madison, I couldn’t wait to participate. While we undress and stare at her naked body spread out for us to use as we like, my cock aches with how hard I am. I could’ve come all over those white panties and still been hard enough to fuck her pretty cunt.
Consent is a huge must for both of us. But when Madison pretends she doesn’t want it while her eyes beg me to take her, my cock throbs with need. As long as it’s just pretend and she knows at any minute we’ll stop, it’s good. I don’t long for her fear, but sometimes a little challenge can be fun.
She would have let us tie her up and use her, but this way we are dominating her. Making her take us how we want.
I stroke my cock. Her nipples harden to points. Her breasts are full. Her pussy glistens with her wetness.
I could slide into her right now and fuck her until she begged for more. If she wasn’t gagged.
But this is Noah’s night and his show. He stares at her spread out before us with lust in his eyes.
“She looks so perfect tied up, ready for us to use.” Noah lazily strokes his cock. “In a perfect world, I would take pictures and capture this moment forever. Record my cock thrusting into her pussy until she shatters into a million pieces.”
She groans against the gag. Her leg tries to shift, but Noah retied her legs to hold her tight. So many ways to use her beautiful body.
“Shame we had to gag her.” I nod toward her mouth. “Her mouth would feel great wrapped around my cock.”
Noah chuckles. “She got me in the ribs with her sharp little elbow. If you stick your cock in her mouth, she might bite it off.”
“Worth it.”
She jerks on the ropes, mostly for show. She doesn’t really want to get away. We gave her every option to stop. Speaking of... I grab a ball from the dresser. It’s small and metal, like the knife Noah used to cut away her clothes.
The back of the blade brushing against her pale skin was erotic in its own right. But we don’t get off on making her bleed. And actual pain and damage is one of her hard limits. Something we would never tread past.
I kneel on the bed next to her head and lean over her face, making sure my cock brushes her cheek as I place the ball in her hand. “Don’t drop this, my dirty little whore.”
Her fingers curl around it. We’ve done this before when her mouth was occupied. She drops it, we stop. I slide my cock across her parted lips. Her tongue flicks the underside as I thrust it back and forth over her lips.
“Fuck. Maybe we don’t need her mouth to be open.” I grin at Noah as he moves between her legs on the bed. She shifts slightly at his movements. I gaze down at my cock between her lips. I pinch her nipple. “Drag your tongue against my cock again like a good slut.”
She whimpers but does it. Precum flows out my tip. I rub it against the scarf in her mouth.
“A little present for you to suck on,” I whisper before backing off the bed.
Noah runs his fingers up her parted legs. His large hands against her captured thighs make my cock twitch. She trembles beneath his touch as he reaches her inner thighs. “So many options.”
He spreads her pussy open with his fingers, and she moans. His thumb teases the edge of her opening.
“We could fuck you separately or together. We could just keep you open for us while we jerked off all over your body and then rubbed our cum into your skin.” Noah presses the tip of his thumb into her cunt. “You’d like that, wouldn’t you? Being covered in our cum while we fucked you over and over again.”
She moans as her hips push against his finger.
“You want that, don’t you, my little whore?” I slide my finger up the arch of her foot, and she jerks.
Noah pushes his thumb inside her. She moans. “If she wants it, then we should make sure she’s hot for it.”
He pulls out and she whimpers. His gaze meets mine, and he nods up her body as he lowers himself to the bed between her legs. I sit next to her on the bed.
“Do you want us to make you come, slut?” I pinch her nipple and she inhales sharply.
“I think that’s a yes.” Noah laughs as he presses his tongue against her clit before licking her pussy. Her hips rock with the motion.
“How does she taste?” I roll her nipple between my fingers gently. She sucks in a breath.
“Sweet.” Noah sucks on her clit, and her body arches as much as it can. A moan escapes her mouth. “I could spend hours sucking on her little clit.”
Her moans grow as he returns to sucking. I pinch her other nipple before lowering my mouth over her breast and suckling her.
“She likes that,” Noah says. I lift my head to watch him thrust three fingers inside her. “Her cunt is dripping for us.”
She moans and mumbles something against the scarf.
“What’s that? More?” I lean toward her mouth like I’m trying to listen to her. “Pretty sure she wants more.”
Noah smirks before lowering his mouth to her pussy. I take her nipple into my mouth and suck, making her skin redden. I tease the other nipple with my fingers, pulling, pinching, rolling.
Her breathing is uneven. Her hips sway with every move of Noah’s tongue and fingers on her, in her. I lift my mouth from her breast and stare down at the redness I’ve left behind. I kiss it one more time before moving to her other nipple and sucking it hard.
She moans as her body arches against me.
“Her cunt is so fucking hot and tight. I can’t wait to put my cock in it.”
I shift to watch Noah fuck her with his fingers. They glisten with her wetness as she moans and whimpers with every thrust. I ease my fingers down her stomach and toy with her clit, rubbing her pussy in circles while he finger fucks her cunt.
The scarf muffles her cry as she arches against us again. I slip a finger inside with his, stretching her, to feel her pulse around us.
“You like that? Our fingers inside your cunt, fucking you until you come like a good little whore?” I lean down and suck on her clit.
“Fuuuu,” is all that gets past the scarf as her pussy gushes its release around our hands.
Noah meets my eyes. “Trade.”
I nod and he straddles her stomach. He grabs the lube from the bedside table and squirts it between her breasts.
She makes an indignant noise as he rubs it around her breasts and over his cock before passing it to me.
“Fuck her ass. Save her pussy for last. We’ll have a grand finale.” Noah winks before he rubs his fingers around her nipples, red and sensitive from my attention.
“I bet I’m going to love fucking your ass, my little whore. Pushing my fat cock inside your tight little hole until you can’t stop coming.” I lube up my cock before sliding my hands beneath her and between her ass cheeks. There’s enough give in the rope that her legs can bend slightly. I slide my fingers into her ass and lower my mouth to her clit, sucking, licking, teasing.
She twists beneath me as much as she can as she releases a muffled cry.
Noah has his cock in between her breasts. I stop to watch him glide in and out of them while I fuck her ass with my fingers. I pull my fingers out when she tightens around them and thrust my cock into her puckered hole.
She moans. I match Noah’s hips as I fuck her ass while he fucks her tits.
“We really should record this so she can watch it. So she can see how well she takes cock.” I part her ass cheeks as I watch my cock shuttle in and out of her.
She whimpers as her breath quickens.
“Ball check,” I say.
Noah chuckles darkly. “Clutched so hard, like she never wants to let it go. Like she wants us to fuck her until she can’t stop coming.”
Noah increases his pace and I match him. She tightens all around me, her hot, tight ass forming a fist around my cock. I drive in one last time and explode, filling her with my cum, shuddering through my release and watching her pussy clutch at the air while she comes.
I withdraw and step away to wash my cock. When she moans, I turn to watch Noah come all over her neck. His cum drips down over her and covers her from her chin to the tops of her breasts. She looks so fucking pretty covered in cum. My cock twitches as it begins to harden again.
Noah walks over to me where he grabs a washcloth. “Time to untie her feet. You want her mouth or her ass again?”
He’s not being quiet. She can hear us, but this shit turns her on too. Listening to how we want to take her.
“I want to fuck her mouth.”
Noah nods and walks over to wipe his cum off her neck. “You know, I think we can do this without untying her feet just yet. Make her take it until she’s begging for more.”
She whimpers, and he unties the scarf from around her mouth. She licks her lips.
Straddling her chest, I lean over, using the headboard to hold myself up as I thrust my cock down into her mouth. I glance over my shoulder and watch Noah slide into her ass. She swallows around me.
“Maybe we’ll fuck her pussy together.” He winks at me and thrusts inside her hard. She swallows around me. “You want to take two dicks in your tight cunt, kitten? At the same time?”
She groans around my cock, sending vibrations through me. Fuck, we’ve never done that before, two cocks one hole. But with Madison, fuck, just the idea of her squeezing the two of us so fucking tight with her pussy as we stretch her out makes me almost nut.
“Sounds like she’s game.” I stroke my thumb over her cheek. “Aren’t you a good slut for us.”
Her tongue strokes over me as I lift out of her mouth and then press down, hitting her throat with the head of my cock. She swallows around me, sending a rush of need flowing through me.
I pull out of her throat so she can breathe easier. “Suck my cock, sweetheart.”
As she sucks on me, the sounds of Noah’s flesh slapping against hers fill the room. I rock in her sweet, talented mouth until she moans hard. Her body arches below me as she comes.
Noah curses as he slams into her ass until he groans. She sucks on me again, and I can’t hold back my release, coating her mouth and throat with my cum.
“Such a naughty slut,” I whisper as I come down, stroking her cheek as she swallows my cum. “Drink it all, my little whore. Because the next time I come it’s going to be with Noah in your tight pussy.”