25. Beautiful and Breedable
25
BEAUTIFUL AND brEEDABLE
ANNA
“T hen why are you still single?”
I took a slow, deep breath, anticipating Caleb’s answer. I didn’t mean to eavesdrop them, but when I saw their familiar silhouette in the backrooms while going through shelves, I was going to greet them but held back when I heard their talk.
“I like Anna.” My cheeks heated at hearing Caleb’s tone, firm and sweet. Like there was no other option for him. It shouldn’t, but… it made me feel special.
“That’s not the answer to my question.”
I heard some shuffling and peeked to see Caleb standing across from Kyle. They both looked total opposites, with Kyle in khakis and a light blue shirt and Caleb in dark, ripped jeans, muddy Converse and a white tee. Kyle pushed his glasses on the bridge of his nose as Caleb’s lip piercing glinted when he licked it.
They were both so hot.
And they wanted… me .
“She’s my teenage crush, and I’d do anything to date her.”
My heart rate increased, and I felt like I should leave. Just as I prepared myself, I heard Kyle’s words and paused.
“You know she has a kid, right? Besides Aaron, your ex.”
“So? I like Alice and I’d be a great stepdad.” Caleb’s face was relaxed, his eyes dark and sultry as he continued, “I’ll give her another.”
My eyes widened, my hand cupping my mouth as I leaned back on the wall, blinking at the shelves. Shaking my head, I left them in the backroom before I overheard something that would make me confront them and…
No . I couldn’t even think about the possibility.
But did Caleb really mean it? About giving me a… baby? Making me pregnant? And what did Kyle think about that? He loved kids, and Marissa was pregnant when… oh gosh .
What am I even thinking right now? I swear, these two men make me feel hormonal and turned on and conflicted all at once.
I went upstairs, smiling politely at the familiar receptionist, and took a few deep breaths. It didn’t help that my fresh-er panties were already soaked after overhearing their talk, and I felt hot in the air-conditioned library.
I’d be a great stepdad. I’ll give her another .
His husky words echoed in my mind, my breath wavering at the thought of Alice accepting Caleb—not like she hadn’t already, wanting to invite him for her tea-party. I ran a hand through my hair and made my way to Religious and Spirituality shelf to get a few books for my mother. Maybe I should pick something for myself as well, to ward off the thoughts of two men and possibly getting pregnant again.
I always wanted a bigger family ?—
No. I’m not going there.
I jumped when I heard a whistle and heard the smoky, deep voice, “Look what we have here.”
Speak of the devils.
“That’s not how you address anyone, Caleb.” Kyle smiled at me, his brown eyes bright behind his glasses, “Hi, angel.”
“Hey there, mama,” Caleb said, blocking Kyle and walking beside me, dimples poking his cheeks. “Did you miss me?”
He wants to breed you .
I kept my tone leveled and said, “Hi boys.”
“Why are you blushing?” Caleb asked, peering closer, but I covered my face with the curtain of my hair.
I ignored him and asked, “What are you two doing here?” I knew what they were doing here. Planning to cage me and have their way?—
Anna stop .
“I asked him to volunteer with me,” Kyle replied and stood on my right when I went through titles of various spiritual books. “Are you looking for something specific?”
“I saw a book about tantric orgasm down there if you wanna try.”
We both pointedly ignored Caleb. I replied to Kyle, “Not for me, but for my mom.”
Kyle hummed, looking at the titles by tilting his head to the side, and why did he look extra good-looking today? With his dirty blond hair glowing and his jaw looking a bit sharper than before. With his unbuttoned shirt on the top, I could see his skin, warm and soft. I wanted to lick it.
I shivered when I felt the body heat radiating from Caleb, who was behind me. “I saw you,” he whispered, leaning close and brushing his lips against the shell of my ear.
“Saw me?” I turned to meet his obsidian eyes. “Where?”
He tucked a lock of hair behind my ear and said, “Saw you eavesdrop us.”
“ Caleb ,” Kyle said in a warning tone, but Caleb kept his eyes pinned on me.
“Did I tell you how beautiful and breedable you look today, pretty?” Caleb purred, his hands gliding down my waist to pull me closer.
Beautiful and breedable?
“I-I don’t know what you’re talking about,” I stuttered, my heart hammering in my chest.
The look on his face darkened as his hips pressed against mine, the feel of his prominent bulge making me bite my lip.
“I can bend you between these shelves and show you what I mean, mama,” he cooed, his hands tightening on my body as a shadow passed over his face. Kyle stepped behind me, kissing my nape, my neck arching for more of the warmth of his soft lips and hot tongue. “You can suck on my cock while Kyle breeds you, hm? I’m sure you’d like that, won’t you, pretty?”
“Don’t lie, angel.” Kyle held my hair back, his lips brushing over my ear as he whispered, “Tell us what you want because we want you.”
I gasped when Kyle pressed closer, and I felt the outline of his hard boner between my ass cheeks.
“Come on,” Caleb whispered, tilting my chin up to meet his eyes. “Agree to go on one date. With both of us.”
I bit my lip. I had learned not to rely on men and their words since Timothy and Felix both broke their promises, but Caleb and Kyle… could I trust them?
I didn’t care to think about it since I knew my answer. I nodded, “Okay. One date.”
“That’s my girl,” Kyle whispered as Caleb leaned down and kissed me. I hummed in the soft kiss, his piercing playing with my lip before Caleb pulled away and Kyle swooped in and I heard Caleb murmur, “That’s our girl.”
I was gasping for breath by the time they pulled away, still sandwiching me between them, making me worry… and wet.
“What are you doing?” I whispered when Kyle kneeled on the floor, his eyes hungry behind his glasses.
“Shh, don’t worry your pretty head about it,” Caleb said, diverting my attention to him as he cupped my face. “I lost a bet, so he’s earning his reward.”
I took a sharp intake of breath when Kyle’s large hands trailed over my bare legs, tugging up the skirt of my dress. “Reward is checking out my panties?”
“Of course, not. It’s eating you out,” Caleb said, peppering small kisses over my jaw. He licked my pulse, making my knees wobble.
“In public?” I wanted to argue, but my voice was low and sultry.
“This library is practically empty and no one’s on this floor,” Caleb pointed out. He was right, and we were in the room’s corner so no one could see us but… we were in a library on a Sunday. In the Spirituality and Religion section. Are we all going to hell if we do this here?
“We won’t let anyone see your pretty face when you cum on my tongue, An,” Kyle said, his mouth getting hungrier as he kissed my thigh, tugging my dress up and groaning at the sight of my damp panties. “You’re already s’wet, angel.”
I bit my lip and clutched Caleb’s arms for support even though he was holding me up with my back to him, his hands lightly groping and squeezing my breasts through the dress. His ringed fingers playing with the piercings on my nipples through the bra, toying with me.
“Tease her first, Kyle,” Caleb said, his fingers pinching my nipples and piercings, making me moan and arch into his touch. “She likes it slow.”
Kyle held up the fabric of my dress to my waist and said, “Hold this up for me, angel.”
“Oh fuck,” I whimpered when he pulled down my panties, the cold air of the air conditioner slapping against my bare sex making me quiver. Kyle spread my legs wider and slowly kissed his way to the apex of my thighs.
“Try not to be too loud, mama,” Caleb whispered in my ear, licking it and adding, “Or I’ll have to use something to gag your pretty cries.”