27. You’re Mine
27
YOU’RE MINE
CALEB
I t was hard to move after one of the best soul sucking blowjobs I had ever received. But as much as I loved sharing Anna with Kyle, I didn’t want anyone to lay their eyes on her post-coital glow. Her tousled honey-brown hair, her soft hazel eyes, and her pouty pink mouth. God, I could worship her all day, every day, and it still wouldn’t be enough.
We cleaned her up as much as we could before she disappeared into the washroom, leaving Kyle and me alone.
“I could go for round two,” I said, straightening my tee-shirt and picking up Anna’s purse from the ground.
Kyle buckled his pants and said, “Only if we have tape to shut your mouth.” His brown eyes were twinkling with amusement. “I didn’t know you could be so loud.”
“It was unexpected, that’s all.” I looked away as heat crept up my neck. “I’m not usually that loud.”
“You weren’t when I tried it.”
I eyed him, remembering the clumsy blowjob. “You can try it again if you’d like.”
His eyes gleamed with a promise. “I will.”
Anna came back, and she picked a couple of the books from the shelves where we had just fucked. I didn’t even notice it was Religion and Spiritual shelf.
When we were leaving the library, Alice called Anna, announcing her sleepover at her friend’s house.
“What are your plans for tonight, pretty?” I asked as soon as her call ended.
“I have to go grocery shopping and…” she trailed off, looking between me and Kyle, and shrugged.
“We can go on a date,” Kyle suggested when we walked to the parking lot. Breeze felt nice on my bare skin. Clouds were disappearing, and the sun was setting slowly.
“We can go grocery shopping, cook and have dinner together,” I said, taking books from Anna’s arms. “I’ll even do the dishes if I can have a sweet dessert.” I winked at her, loving the soft blush pinkening her cheeks.
“Fine,” she rolled her eyes, making me grin.
“Even if you said no, I’d have kidnapped you to Walmart,” I promised her.
“Make it we. I’m sorry, An, but I’d join Caleb’s side to have you.” Kyle’s serious face with a soft smile made me chuckle. Anna didn’t say anything, shaking her head at us and hiding her face with her hair.
Kyle would drive in his car since I left my bike at Anna’s and I’d drive Anna’s car, let her be the passenger princess.
I didn’t have a relationship with three people before, and even though it was just a date between three people, it didn’t make me feel nervous or expect any things I had to perform. I could just relax, be myself, and make them happy.
I was even looking forward to doing the dishes.
Kyle
Caleb kept his words once we finished having dinner at Anna’s house and went to the sink to do the dishes. I tagged along, helping him since he and Anna did all the cooking while I had just chopped the vegetables.
Grocery shopping with them was easy and fun, with Anna giving us her list and Caleb pushing the shopping cart. It should have made us feel foreign to be a throuple out in public, but it didn’t. No one paid us attention, and if they did, it was only to check us out, with Anna being so pretty and Caleb’s tattoos and piercings standing out among the seniors at the grocery store. We also bought a couple of ice-cream tubs since Caleb wanted it.
He had a sweet tooth.
Talk between the three of us was normal, despite the differences between our ages. Anna was a great mediator for us and a brilliant communicator asking us about our life, work, and hobbies. I didn’t think Caleb was a humble person, but he downplayed his job as something he did on his computer, as if his code wasn’t responsible for protecting a trillionaire brand.
“Can we join one of your classes?” Caleb asked, loading the dishes into the dishwasher. Surprisingly, he was efficient in the kitchen and not a frat boy image I had of him. Since he lived alone, he knew how to cook well and take care of the house. “Or we can book a private class with you.”
I smirked, seeing Anna blush under our gazes, but her colorful eyes were stern as she gave Caleb a look. “If you both booked a private class, I’d charge extra,” her tone was flirty and fun. I don’t think I have ever seen her flirt or use that tone. Ever. It was hot, and I was glad she was having fun.
“I guess we can pay with our bodies,” I teased her, pushing my glasses. “Will that work, angel?”
Her blush deepened, her teeth biting the bottom lip, making my jaw clench since I wanted to do the biting and kissing.
“I’m sure it will,” Caleb purred, closing the distance between them, leaning over her as she backed into the kitchen island. “Me and Kyle will be hot and sweaty and tired after the class… so pliant and helpless to please you. For the payment, of course.”
“We will do whatever you want, An,” I whispered, joining Caleb as her breathing labored, her perfect breasts heaving underneath the flirty summer dress.
Anna looked at us both before pushing Caleb away. “Your roleplay should have a hint of reality. You both can afford the classes—heck, I’m sure you can buy my studio and yet?—”
“And yet, we want to worship you, dirty angel,” I said, caging her back to the island, pinning my arm on one side as Caleb planted his arm on the other side.
“What else do you want to role-play as mama? We can be your naughty students making out in the empty classroom and you can be our hot teacher, instructing us how to touch a woman.”
Anna and I looked at Caleb, my lips parting at the taboo fantasy, and yet my cock gave a twitch at the thought of clumsily making out with him and Anna catching us.
“You have thought about this before,” Anna announced, her cheeks red and eyes glazed. “Filthy boy,” she murmured underneath her breath.
“Oh, come on, you were my celebrity crush when I was fifteen. Of course, I have many dirty fantasies that include you,” Caleb said, running his knuckles over her arm, goosebumps making her shiver. “Do you wanna hear more fucked up ones where you—you both tease me? Where I bend you over my bike and breed you? Or the one where I find you in the woods and take you?”
His voice had a dark edge to it when he whispered the last fantasy, making my dick press against the zipper. I looked at Anna, her pupils dilated as I leaned closer and added to Caleb’s fantasy, “Imagine being scared and alone at night in the woods. No one but us running after you with the promise to fuck you and breed you if you’re caught, and you can do nothing but take it like a good girl. You’d like that, wouldn’t you, angel?”
Anna peered at me through her lashes, her neck bobbing as she swallowed. “I…”
She blinked, jumping when her cellphone rang. “I’ll be right back,” her voice was quiet as she picked up her phone and went to the guest room, closing the door behind her.
Caleb and I stared at each other, both of our bulges prominent. “I think we need to take it slow,” Caleb said, running a hand through his hair.
“You think?” I said, raising a brow. “I’m not sure she had any partner who wanted to fulfill her fantasies with her pleasure in mind before.”
Caleb sighed, leaning on the kitchen island. “That’s why I want to give her everything she desires.”
“Me too,” I said, thinking about the years of closeness between us and never making a move on her.
“Are you okay with sharing her?” Caleb asked, his eyes averting to my lips. I wasn’t sure why he was asking me again, but I was glad he wanted to confirm it before we did anything else.
“I don’t mind if it’s you.” I licked my lips, feeling hot. “I’ve never… shared a woman or man before, but it’s turning out to be less complex than I thought it would be.”
“ Good ,” he said, his eyes shifting to my face, an unknown emotion passing through them. “Because I don’t want to share you two with anyone else. You’re mine.”
My eyes widened at his deeper and almost harsher tone. Like he was announcing we were his without any labels set. Like he didn’t care about labels, but us, and that we were together with him.
It was possessive. Raw . It should make me question him more, but it didn’t.
Instead, I liked it. I liked it a lot.
Being his . When I shouldn’t have.
But I wanted to be his.
And Anna’s.