Chapter 11
ELEVEN
NOAH
It’s takes only seconds to reposition Lauren between Sean and I. I’m laying flat on my back with her back to my chest. My cock is already nestled inside of Lauren—making my life hard enough as I fight tooth and nail to not come already—with Sean teasing his cock over her pussy.
He looks right at her. “Tell me you want this.”
She doesn’t hesitate. “I want this.”
I reassure her anyway. “We don’t have to, baby. We have all the time in the world. I know we jumped into the deep end, but if you don’t want to, then we don’t have to.”
Her words turn firm. “You want to own me? Prove it.”
I scoff out a laugh at the bratty attitude. My hands come up to grip her waist tightly, probably hard enough to leave bruises, as I lower my mouth to nip at her ear.
She shudders at the sensation, paired with Sean spreading her legs and staring directly at her pussy. His eyes are dark and hungry. “You told me a year ago that you couldn’t have kids. What did you mean by that?”
I pick my head up to look at him. “She never told you?”
Lauren laughs. “We didn’t get there yet.”
My eyes pinch. “But you…?”
Sean goes to open his mouth, but Lauren talks before he can try. “It was literally a glory hole at four in the morning. Logical thinking wasn’t present.” She turns her gaze back to him. “I had my tubes tied when I was twenty-one.”
His eyes fill with questions but he doesn’t press it.
Thank fuck.
So not the time.
Instead, he crawls up the bed and looks down at us both. Like a switch is flipped, his dominant personality overtakes his curious and gentle one. “Then we’re both going to breed this fucking pussy at the same time. Think you can handle that?”
She doesn’t even get a chance to nod her head before Sean is pressing against her, forcing his length into her pussy—right alongside me. My grip on Lauren’s waist goes even tighter at the sensation.
Lauren cries out. “Sean!”
Sean pauses. “You okay?”
Her head nod is fast and eager, even as her breath comes out in pants. “Don’t stop. Just so…full.”
Sean groans and raises his arm. At first, I think he’s going to swat one of mine away and grip her chest, but he does something else entirely.
He wraps a hand around her throat and picks her head up from my shoulder, whispering.
“No brain-dead praise-slut here. You look at Daddy when there are two cocks inside of you.”
Her mouth drops open at the words and sensation. And, of-fucking-course, Sean fucking spits inside of it, right as he bottoms out his entire length inside of her.
All of us pause, adjusting.
I breathe in deeply, trying not to lose it. With his full weight pressed against the both of us, I actually fucking whimper the words, “Sean. Move.”
He listens, slowly withdraws while keeping his focus entirely on her, his hand still on her throat, and thrusts right back in, analyzing every single reaction and emotion she could possibly have. Lauren cries out, her moan rough on her vocal cords, and I do the exact same.
The motions repeat more times than I can count as we all get adjusted. And as we do, I’m hit with a deep realization.
How I love Lauren.
How I love Sean.
How I never want to give this up.
How I know this is wrong, but it feels so goddamn right.
Deciding to take a risk, I manage to say, “Lauren?”
Sean releases her throat long enough for her to answer. “Ye-yeah?”
I look at him as I lay my feet flat on the bed, getting ready to thrust into her myself. Her skin is sweaty between us, and I know that the time for being gentle is quickly running out. “For what it’s worth…you’re our first doing this with, too.”
And then I thrust up into her.
Right as Sean goes back to choking her with a fervor.
Her entire body shakes from the force of the thrust, a harsh scream coming out of her mouth.
I do it again. Twice. Three times. I lose count of the amount of times I thrust up into her, stretching and ruining her for anyone else, all while rubbing against Sean’s cock inside of her.
Her tits bounce with every thrust, and if I weren’t scared of blowing my load inside of her at the snap of my fingers, I’d be ruining them just as much as we’re ruining her cunt.
Looking up at Sean, I goad him. “What? Not going to fuck her, too? I thought she was our girl?”
Lauren cries out.
Sean hisses, “I was trying not to break her.”
I thrust in harder than ever. Sean shudders, and I know I must have hit a sensitive spot of him, too. “She can take it. Now fuck our girl so she’s ruined for anyone else.”
He shakes his head but pulls out the moment I go in, fucking her in tandem with me. Every time I pull out, he’s thrusting in. Our cocks rub together with every motion, adding to the sensation of it all, and I feel my balls start to draw up as the minutes go by.
I groan out the words, “I’m gonna come. I need to come.”
“Me too. I’m right there,” Sean says.
Lauren whines loudly. “Please!”
That’s all I needed to hear. I give one last, final thrust into her before my cock is twitching and my orgasm wracks through me.
Fire lights me up from the inside out as I come inside of her, unable to even speak.
Sean follows immediately after, stilling inside of her as his dick twitches against mine.
He groans, keeping his grip on her throat in a possessive hold, maintaining eye contact as we fill her up.
Minutes pass. We all stay stock still, riding the wave of pleasure that’s crashed over us all. Sweat coats each of us as our exhaustion sets in.
Sean pulls out first, sighing. As gently as I can, I follow suit.
He speaks first. “C’mon. Shower time.”