Chapter Fourteen
Danny’s groan of pleasure as I slide slowly down onto him is the confidence boost I need to keep going.
My hands splay across his hard chest, and I watch his eyes fall close and feel his grip on my thighs tighten until it hurts.
I kind of love the way he looks so affected, and for a moment I imagine it’s not like this with everyone. It’s because it’s me— us—here with him.
“That’s it Leigh, let him fill you up,” Chase speaks at my shoulder, running his hands up my back to my collarbone, where he wraps them lightly around my neck.
“All those nights we were here in the same house with you, not daring to sneak into your room and crawl right into your bed. I think you might have been wanting us to, right?”
My skin is on fire as I finally have all of Danny inside me. For a beat I pause and then nod. “I did.”
“Thought so. So many missed chances,” he sighs into my shoulder and I shiver. “All the times you had to play with this pussy yourself while you pictured me sneaking past our parent’s room to come climb into your bed.” He clicks his tongue and I shiver. “Ride him, Leigh.”
I’d frozen in place, letting his words kindle the fire inside me to new heights. It’s so unbelievably hot when he talks to me like this. Heeding his orders, I raise myself up and then slowly sink again. Chase squeezes lightly at my throat and I moan against the pressure.
Danny’s hands slide up to my breasts, pinching my nipple and the both of them together roughly spark the pleasure inside me to new heights.
“Chase, please I need you too.”
“How do you want me?” he asks, his voice sounding somewhat strangled.
I look back at him again over my shoulder and he meets my needy gaze with another deep, owning kiss.
“You want me to fuck you too, Leigh? Both of us at the same time?” His words float into my mouth and I nod as he bites my bottom lip.
“I want it to be both of you.”
He pulls away slightly, his forehead meeting mine as Danny uses his grip on my thighs to start guiding me as I ride him, rolling my hips to meet his low, even thrusts.
“Have you done something like this before?”
I shake my head and he considers this. “Good. You need to relax yourself, okay? Just trust us to get you through it.”
Why the fuck were those words so hot? I nod and Danny wraps a hand around the back of my neck, pulling me down so that my chest meets his. In a more gentle move than he’s offered me all night, he kisses my temple and tightens his other hand on my thigh. “Focus on feeling me inside you.”
I exhale a shaky breath. For a second I wonder if this is a bad idea. If after tonight they’ll look at me like a conquest they could check off their bucket list, just another girl who’d let them use her body.
Do they sweet talk everyone? Start out rough to turn her on and then switch it up to this caring gentleness to keep her doing what they want? The thought lodges in my throat.
I don’t want this to just be a game. I want it to be more.
“What’s wrong, Leigh?” Chase asks, his hand rubbing small circles on my back while he reaches into his nightstand drawer. I shake my head against Danny’s chest as I hear the cap pop open on whatever he’s grabbed, and then a wet noise of him rubbing it on himself.
Danny’s mouth is feather light on the top of my head, still slowly fucking into me while he waits for Chase to finish prepping us. “You still have your necklace on, you can take it off if you want this to stop.”
The thought of quitting makes me insane. “I don’t want to stop,” I say through that tight feeling in my throat. “I want you. I want this.”
A cold gel-like feeling hits my ass, making me jump, but Chase’s hand keeps his soothing rub on my lower back as I feel his other hand drift lower, and what feels like his thumb running through the lube. My heart could not beat any faster than it is right now.
“Your voice doesn’t match your words.” Chase says. There’s a light pressure for a moment as he gently pushes his thumb against the tight ring, and slides inside me.
I gasp at the feeling, unfamiliar and let myself explore the bite of pain. Danny swoops up my mouth with another kiss as Chase moves his thumb slowly in and out.
“You need to relax, Leigh. Try to breathe so your body eases up.”
I nod, focusing on Danny’s expert mouth, and the way he feels inside me. This slow pace is agonizing, enough to keep me close to the edge, but not enough to push me over.
“That's my girl,” Chase murmurs, pushing in two fingers this time. The pain expands, but if I relax into Danny’s chest and focus on the way Chase talks to me, it’s less distracting.
He’s right, if I keep my body from tensing it even starts to feel a little better.
Not in the same way Danny feels, but something deeper inside me ignites at the friction from Chase’s movements.
“Are you good?” he asks and I nod. He adds more lube and slowly pushes three fingers inside me. I groan into Danny’s chest at the intrusion. “I know, baby. It gets easier, right Danny?”
“No,” Danny says through gritted teeth. “His cock is huge. Don’t trust him.”
I choke out a laugh, and Chase reaches down to grip my hair and drags me back so that I’m flush with his chest. “Play with her clit.”
Danny does as he’s told and I melt as his thumb brushes in circles around it. Chase’s fingers pull from me. There’s a ripple on the bed as he adjusts his position and then I feel his cock press up against me.
Chase looms over my shoulder, leaning down to kiss the top of my head and then the side of my face. “Does Danny’s touch feel good?”
I nod, my skin breaking out in a feverish sweat at the sensations. “Yes.”
“Tell Danny thank you for being so nice with you. He’s not usually this careful with people,” I hear the smirk in his voice.
“Thank you, Danny,” I choke out and his eyes darken at my words.
“Anything for you, Leigh.” His voice is low and his grip on me tightens.
“Now I’m going to fuck you, and you’re going to try and take both of us at the same time, okay?”
I nod, quivering under his touch as his lips drift down the side of my face. Behind me and below me are hard chests, muscled arms, and hammering hearts. It’s the most intoxicating feeling I've experienced and I feel wasted. Addicted.
“I’m ready,” I say and I feel Chase’s hands fall to my hips.
“Danny, hold her to your chest.” Danny follows directions, pulling me back down with another devouring kiss. His tongue dances with mine, his cock deep inside me with his hand between our bodies, still circling my clit.
“Relax, Leigh.”
I take another deep breath and then I feel him, the head of his cock pushing slowly inside me. It takes my breath away, the largeness of him. The pain is much sharper this time and he pauses for a moment with his hand on my lower back, waiting for me to try and calm again.
He pushes in another inch and I grip the sheets, sweat covering me as I try to manage the different ways they are both making me feel.
“It’s okay, baby, just focus on his hand on you.” When I do, he pushes forward another inch.
They find a rhythm with each other, slowly filling me in a way I never imagined possible. The pain somehow compliments the two different pleasures they’re giving me. Chase forcing me toward brand new sensations, and Danny keeping me tethered so I don’t sink too far into my nerves.
“Jesus, are you almost in? I need to fuck her for real.” Danny bites his lip and it’s intensely attractive.
“I’m okay, it’s okay, “ I say. “Please, just give me more. I can handle it.”
Chase pulls my hair, forcing my head back as he looms over me. “You were made for me, weren’t you Leigh? I fit so goddamn perfectly in here,” I watch as he looks down at where he’s filling my ass and he finally pushes to his full length inside me. “I knew you’d take both of us so well.”
I nod, unable to form thoughts. “I’m okay,” I say again. “Please.”
Danny breaks first, thrusting inside me so deeply that I lose my breath. He tangles his hand in my hair and pulls me down to him, thrusting up into me while Chase hesitates.
“You won’t hurt me,” I say. “I want to know what it’s like for you to lose yourself. Make me feel what that’s like.”
He moves lower, covering my back with his chest and tugs my head so that he’s capturing my mouth in his. Thrusting in, they move in and out, taking their pleasure from me, matching each other’s speed. Chase tugs my lower lip in between his teeth as he pulls away, dragging out the kiss.
“I can’t lose myself in you,” he says as he pulls away. Rejection burns until his hand grips my shoulder to pick up the force of his thrusting. “If I lose control you could get hurt.”
My chest throbs. He doesn’t know that I would let him. Painful or not, I would trade that to experience Chase wanting me so intensely that he was overcome, losing sight of that iron control he always has so he can take his pleasure from my body.
But he doesn’t. He’s afraid to hurt me. This man I thought loathed my existence simply wants to make sure I’m okay.
I just nod, throat tight with emotion at being lost in the two of them. I can’t keep up with sensations, the pleasure, the pain, the everything. Tears prick at my eyes. I don’t want it to end. “I’m going to come.”
“Let me feel it,” Chase says, and Danny picks up his movements on my clit.
“Look at you, Leigh.” Danny says, his hand gripping my face so I’m forced to look at him as I spiral.
“Getting fucked by your brother’s best friend while he’s fucking your ass.
” That smile of his lights up his face like he’s pleased by my destruction.
He growls and the sound scorches me from the inside out. “You dirty fucking girl.”
“I’m so close,” I keen and they pick up speed, fucking me into a whirlwind while I tighten under their hands. “Chase,” I call out, and he’s there in a moment. His mouth on my temple, wrapping his arm around my chest to pull me flush against him.
“Let go, baby, we’ve got you,” he says, and that last reassurance tips the scale for me.
I explode. My body freezes, tightening under Danny’s hand on my clit and Chase’s muscled arm across my chest. They both keep up their pace as I fall headlong into my orgasm, and for every moment of it Chase is whispering into my ear.
Fuck, Leigh. You feel like heaven. Just like I knew you would. You’re mine, Leigh. You’re mine.
Mine, Mine. It echoes in my head as that blinding light in my head starts to fade.
By the time I can think again, I blink open my eyes to see Danny slamming into me and sinking his teeth into his lip as he comes.
There’s a buzzing in my ears like they’re filled with cotton, the strength of my orgasm making it hard to think. Hard to even hold myself up.
Chase keeps me anchored to his chest as he thrusts a final time inside me, then bites my shoulder and moans as he stills, and I can feel him filling me.
My legs are shaking. I have no control over my body for this moment and after a minute has passed I just allow Chase to roll me from on top of Danny onto the bed.
I hear them speaking to each other but there’s an overwhelming exhaustion tugging at my vision. I think it’s Danny who uses the most gentle touch to clean me up, but I’m half asleep when someone pulls me to their chest.
“Thank you,” I murmur, and I blink open my eyes to see Danny climbing into bed. Chase must have his arm tucked around my stomach. “Can I sleep here?”
The arm around me flexes possessively. “You’ll stay right here, Leigh. Rest now, we’ve got you.”
The dark house is silent, except for the sounds of our breathing, and I fall from consciousness into dreams of neon masks and hearts that bruise too easily.