Chapter 8 Monroe
MONROE
“So, how’d it go?”
I whipped my head up and saw Rose sitting in the chair in front of my desk.
“About as good as could be expected,” I said.
“Did you need the notarized letter?” she asked.
“I did, and even then, he was still unwilling to talk.”
“So, you didn’t get anything?” she asked.
“Oh, no. I got him to talk. Told me a lot of interesting things.”
“I knew I’d sent the right girl for the job. Okay, let me see your notes and we can get started on this thing.”
I set my briefcase down on my desk as she scooted towards it.
I pulled out the pad of notes I’d taken, her eyes scanning the lines quickly as she frowned.
I pulled out Knox’s case file and started pulling things out we could use in order to give Rose some time to digest the information in front of me.
“I need to make sure his family’s okay,” Rose said.
“I already called the Anderson P.D. on my way back. I gave them Knox’s mother’s name and told them where in town she lived. One of the officers on duty actually knows her, so they’ve got a deputy heading out there right now to check on them.”
“What excuse did you give them for checking in on her?” she asked.
“I told them I had a client who was worried about his family and that I was following up on my word to make sure they were safe. No other questions were asked.”
“Good, because we don’t need any more questions asked. It says here Knox said it was self-defense.”
“He was insistent on it, and contrary to everything that’s screaming in my head, I do believe him on that.”
“What do you not believe?” she asked.
“That Blaze wasn’t dead when Knox ran.”
“You mean Andrew Shepard?”
“He was insistent on calling the boy ‘Blaze’, so that’s how I’ve been addressing him. Knox said he was a prospect. Not even a full member of the gang yet.”
“Probably trying to show his strength to his crew to get initiated. We can use that in court,” she said.
“Is it possible to prove this was self-defense? I’ve requested the pictures the doctor took of Knox as protocol before putting him in jail to hold him, but is that going to be enough?”
“Not in a courtroom. It’s still circumstantial evidence.
It proves there was a fight on both sides, but it doesn’t prove who threw the first punch.
And if we put both The Dead Souls and The Black Saddles on the stand, all they’ll do is stand behind their own.
Their testimonies won’t do us a bit of good. ”
“And there weren’t any cameras out in the woods, so we have no footage. How in the world are we supposed to prove this was self-defense?” I asked.
“That’s a good question, and it’s one we’ll have to really dig in to find out. In the meantime, I do have some evidence that was sent my way while you were gone.”
“I’ll take anything I can get.”
“Assuming the doctor will cooperate on those pictures, samples of the dirt as well as Knox’s boots were processed.”
“Knox did say he was kicking the boy pretty badly when he did let loose. The guy made some-”
“I read the comment in your notes. We don’t have to repeat it,” Rose said.
“Sorry. Okay. Um… what’s going on with the evidence?” I asked.
“Multiple samples of dirt have DNA on them. All sorts. Knox’s. Shepard’s. Some guy named ‘Rex’.”
“Knox mentioned him, too. So that corroborates his story, for the most part,” I said.
“Having Knox’s blood on the ground so close to Shepard’s insinuates a fight between the two of them.”
“Have you already gotten crime scene photos?” I asked.
“I have. My husband’s printing them out as we speak.”
“We don’t get formal copies from the police department?” I asked.
“They’ll be embossed in the corner with an official seal. But emailing them is more convenient.”
“Doesn’t seem very secure,” I said.
But all Rose did was pan her gaze up to mine.
“I think I have a way to prove this was self-defense, but it’s a stretch,” she said.
“I’m all ears.”
“Knox’s boots were taken and processed, and samples of the blood on his boots were shipped off to labs. I put a very serious rush on them, and I got the results back a few minutes before you walked in. There is blood layered on Knox’s boot.”
“What do you mean?” I asked.
“In the photos of the evidence, you’ll see what I’m talking about. There are two very distinct layers of blood on his boot. One is clearly underneath the other. And you’ll never guess how it’s layered.”
“How?” I asked.
“Knox’s blood is on the bottom, and Shepard’s blood is on the top.”
“Which insinuates the fact that Knox was the first to bleed, which you can spin to mean that Shepard threw the first punch.”
“It’s a longshot, but it’s all we’ve got going for us right now. It proves self-defense, but it doesn’t prove that Shepard wasn’t dead.”
“I know there was a body carried off the scene. Do we know for sure it was Blaze?” I asked.
“I’m working on it, but the prosecutor is keeping things very close in that regard. Which is fishy in and of itself, so I’m holding out hope that the person in that body bag wasn’t Shepard.”
“But if this was self-defense, doesn’t that negate the killing? In a court of law, even killing in self-defense is seen as nothing other than self-defense.”
“But then there’s the family pressing charges if they come forward.
Right now, we’re battling the city of Redding and the police department.
If Shepard’s family comes forward after Knox is acquitted and wants to press charges on the supposed death of their son, we’ll have to go through all of this all over again, and the jury is more likely to side with a grieving mother than a hardened biker. ”
“So, we not only have to prove self-defense, but we have to prove that Shepard wasn’t dead when Knox ran,” I said.
“And right now, I’m working with the theory that Blaze is not actually dead, because an autopsy hasn’t been done and I haven’t had the opportunity to-”
Rose’s cell phone rang out into the room and interrupted her train of thought.
I knew where she was going with it, though.
Without a body and time to look at the autopsy report, we were working under the assumption that Shepard was still alive.
Which meant the charges brought against Knox were false, at best. As the defending party, we would get the opportunity to take a look at the body and get a copy of the autopsy results and run our own tests, if we wanted to.
And so far, Rose hadn’t gotten that phone call.
“I’m putting you on speaker, Mr. Potter,” Rose said.
“Who’s Potter?” I asked with a whisper.
“The prosecutor,” Rose mouthed.
“Ladies?” Potter asked.
“May I introduce my partner in this case, Monroe Williams,” Rose said.
“Miss Williams, nice to meet you.”
“Likewise,” I said.
“Look, ladies. This is an open and shut case. All of the evidence points to Knox. There was a great deal of blood spilled at that place, and a lot of it was Andrew Shepard’s.”
“It’s not as open and shut as you might think,” Rose said. “We have evidence to believe that this was, in fact, self-defense.”
“Those men went looking for a fight,” Potter said.
“According to my client’s testimony, which is backed up by the evidence we’re currently looking at, they actually went looking to talk,” I said.
“Talk? What do men like that talk about?” Potter asked.
“Boundaries. Territorial ones,” I said.
“Then what made Mr. Shepard pop off if you really claim he was the one to throw the first punch?” Potter asked.
“You aren’t going to get us to do your work for you, Gabriel,” Rose said. “You want information? Go find it yourself. When it comes to what our client has told us, that’s confidential and you know it.”
“Does the new girl know it?” he asked.
“I do. Hence why I didn’t answer,” I said.
Rose shot me a grin as I sat back in my chair.
“Mrs. Lowen, if your client admits to what happened, we can cut him a deal and make things easier for him,” Potter said.
“Admit to killing a man that isn’t dead?” Rose asked. “Why would he do that?”
“What makes you think Andrew Shepard isn’t dead?” Potter asked.
“Besides the lack of autopsy results and us not being able to come see the body for ourselves?” I asked.
“The assistant U.S. attorney is more than willing to-”
“Why would the assistant U.S. attorney need to be involved with this case?” Rose asked.
I furrowed my brow as the prosecutor sighed on the other end of the line.
I knew there was more to this than a simple open and shut case.
It was uncanny for prosecutors to call like this.
Whoever the hell this Potter guy was, he was stuck.
There was a good chance this case was about to hop out of his hands and he was looking to keep it in his lap.
Whether it was to make a name for himself or get whatever outcome he needed from it, I knew he wasn’t in this to defend Andrew Shepard.
He was in this for his own personal reasons.
“Mr. Potter, I don’t know who you are and I don’t know what is in this for you, but if you don’t answer Mrs. Lowen, I will personally subpoena Shepard’s body, hire our own coroner, and retest every single thing the county coroner has done to that body thus far.
I will make it my personal mission to prove that Shepard isn’t as dead as people say he is, and when that little secret slips somehow to the media, I will make sure your name is written all over it. ”
Rose looked at me with wide eyes as a shocked smile spread across her cheeks.
“Miss Williams, empty threats will get you-”
“I’m not sure why you assume the threat is empty, Mr. Potter.”
I heard him sigh on the other end of the line as I bit down on my tongue.
“The assistant U.S. attorney is trying to build a RICO case against The Dead Souls. Up until now, the attorney hasn’t been able to get any one of them in his custody.”
“And now that there’s one locked up, he wants to leverage it,” I said.
“Damn it, Potter. Are you serious?” Rose asked. “Is that boy even dead?”
“What do you want to talk about? Shepard or this case?” Potter asked.