Chapter 33
LOLA
We spent the rest of the afternoon walking around the small town, and after the guys had shown me all their favorite spots, we went back to the house to rest before having dinner.
Because Leo couldn’t go one day without standing in the kitchen, he insisted on cooking dinner for us. We weren’t very hungry because we had a late lunch, but he promised that the chicken salad he’d make wouldn’t be too heavy on the stomach.
We ate on the balcony overlooking the town and lake, and I couldn’t stop admiring this place, stunned by its beauty. It was so calm and relaxing here, and it felt like a vacation.
After dinner, Kline and I helped Leo clean up in the kitchen, and in the meantime, I listened to Bennett and Watson talk about the many boat rides they took to get to the town on the other side of the lake. I couldn’t help but think they were disappointed they couldn’t go on that boat, and I felt as if I ruined this weekend for them.
“Why don’t you guys just go on the boat? I don’t mind staying here alone.”
Watson and Ben turned around with frowns between their brows, and Watson said, “Are you crazy? We’re not leaving you here.”
“Besides, it wouldn’t be fun without you. We’ll stay here,” Ben stated.
“But I can tell that you really like going on that boat. I don’t want to ruin the fun for you.”
“You didn’t ruin anything, Lola,” Kline assured me, but I still wasn’t happy with ruining their initial plan.
“Still…I want you to go if you’d like to. I don’t mind.”
“Kitten, we won’t leave you. We’ll stay here and have just as much fun. Probably even more than we anticipated. You’ll have to live with us not leaving your side even if it means changing our plans.”
I looked at Bennett and sighed listening to his words. How could they all be so damn good to me? It clearly meant a lot to them to make me happy, and while I knew I deserved men like them, I had yet to come to terms with the fact that I would get anything I wanted from them if I only asked.
Not that I would use that to my advantage anyway.
I didn’t want anything other than them.
It made me emotional as I started to understand what it meant to be with them. They would always make sure that I was happy and pleased, and normally, that wasn’t something most men were capable of doing.
My eyes were watery and my vision got blurry as a sob escaped me. I quickly held my hand in front of my mouth to stop another one to erupt, but it didn’t work out as smoothly as I hoped it would because the next sob was even louder.
“Woah, hey…baby, where’s this coming from?” Leo wrapped his arms around me and pulled me against his body. “Baby, please don’t cry.”
“How are you guys even real?” I croaked out with my hands thrown into the air before I gripped Leo’s arm tightly.
Kline chuckled and put his hand on my neck. “Are these happy tears?”
“Yes! God, you’re all just so…perfect. I don’t understand. Shit, look what you’ve done to me…” I was an emotional wreck, and I had no idea all these feelings were in me. Apparently, only they were able to make them come out.
The guys all looked amused by my sudden outburst.
“Fuck me, you’re sweet,” Kline muttered, gently squeezing my neck.
“Your reaction is just the one we were hoping to see one day. It means you know that we care about you, kitten. We care about you a whole damn lot,” Bennett said with a gentle voice.
I needed a moment to calm down, and after wiping away my tears, I loosened Leo’s grip and stepped back to look at them all. I took a deep breath and ran my hands through my hair, laughing at how silly my reaction was. “I’m sorry. I haven’t yet realized just how lucky I am.”
“Take your time. We’ll be right here,” Watson said with a grin.
“We’re not overwhelming you with all this, are we?” Bennett asked, looking worried.
“Yes. I mean…it’s a little overwhelming, but in a good way. I’m not used to this. Having a man—or four—care so much about me.”
“We’ll take it slow,” Ben promised me but that wasn’t what I wanted.
“No, don’t. I like it just the way it is. I think I like being thrown into the cold water without a warning. Which is ironic because I would literally die if that would happen for real.”
The guys laughed, and I joined in shortly after. They were helping me feel good, and no matter the situation, they always found a way to make me smile.
My heart was pounding loudly in my chest, and it seemed that my brain had shut off completely because what I said next came purely from the heart.
“You guys are making it really easy for me to fall in love with you.”
I froze, and I felt my cheeks turn bright red.
They were staring at me while I wished to run and hide, but my feet weren’t able to move. Had I said the wrong thing? After everything they told me, did I manage to change their minds by being too vulnerable?
“Well, shit…” Watson murmured as a smirk spread on his lips. “And I thought Leo would be the first to break and admit his feelings for you.”
“I was damn close just minutes ago,” Leo confessed. “No, scratch that. I was damn close weeks ago already.”
“Yeah, same here,” Bennett said, smiling gently.
“Ah fuck it. Me too,” Watson admitted.
I looked at the three of them wide-eyed before my gaze landed on Kline. He hadn’t said anything yet, and while I didn’t expect him to out his feelings, I hoped he would too.
He ran a hand over his head and chuckled. “I don’t want to make this a competition, but I’m damn sure that I was the first to fall for her.”
My heart was doing all kinds of flips.
I was not only falling for four men, but I had four men falling for me too. How insane was that?
“No fucking way. I was first,” Leo argued.
“Doesn’t fucking matter who was first. It matters how we continue on from here.” Watson looked at me with a determined gleam. “Are you sure about this, Lola? Do you want all four of us?”
“Yes.”
“How sure are you?”
I furrowed my brows. “Very sure.”
“Jesus, stop interrogating her. We’ve made her cry once already. She’s gonna change her mind if you keep that shit up.” Leo pulled me into his arms and kissed the top of my head.
I couldn’t help but laugh at how often the two fought over the littlest things. “I’m okay, I promise. Like I said…I’m just a bit overwhelmed. And now even more so,” I said, looking at them with a soft smile.
The feeling of falling in love with a person was already intense. Having that feeling times four wasn’t easy to digest, but I knew with them by my side, it would soon settle.
***
We watched the sun go down over the lake, and with the darkness rolling in, I admired the stars in the sky, and the moon shining down onto the water. The balcony we were sitting on wasn’t big enough for all five of us, but Kline and Watson weren’t much into star gazing anyway.
They stayed inside on the couch, talking over the TV, while Leo and Ben kept telling me stories about their time spent in this small town.
“If you want, we can hike up there tomorrow. It’s not a long hike, and there’s a restaurant with a perfect view over the whole lake,” Leo explained.
“That sounds like a good idea.” I smiled at him and squeezed his hand on my lap before I got up. “It’s getting chilly out here.”
“Let’s go inside.” Bennett grabbed the light blanket I had wrapped around me before, and we all headed inside.
I smiled at Watson when he looked up, and he held out his hand to me. Placing mine in his, he pulled me to him and made me sit on the couch between him and Kline, and I immediately melted into him as he kissed me.
Watson wasn’t one to hold back, and I loved that he just took what he wanted. Well, especially when it came to me.
I placed a hand to his chest as he deepened the kiss, rubbing his hand along my thigh before he rested it on my hip. Without breaking the kiss, he moved me on top of him, making me straddle his lap.
I could hear the others move around the living area, and without looking, I knew exactly where this was headed. Their clothes were starting to come off, and Watson worked on unbuttoning my jeans.
“Lift your arms, kitten,” Bennett told me as he moving his hands along my back. He was standing behind me, and once I broke the kiss, I tilted my head back to find him right there without a shirt on.
I lifted my arms, letting him take off my top, and with a quick flick of his fingers, he undid my bra. I took that off as well, giving Watson the perfect view of my tits.
He kept his hands on my hips though, and it was Bennett who cupped my breasts from behind. He leaned in and kissed my shoulder and side of my neck, whispering to me how much he adored me.
I smiled and leaned back against his body, admiring him from below.
“Are you going to let us show you just how much we want you, kitten?” he asked, his voice low and raspy.
I nodded and moaned when his fingers pinched my nipples. “Yes, please.”
“Good girl.” He moved one hand from my breast to my jaw, cupping it, and leaning in to kiss me. Another moan escaped me when I felt Watson’s thumb press against my clit over my jeans. He circled it, knowing exactly where the right spot was without even seeing it.
These men were something else, and it was so easy to let myself go in their arms. They not only made sure I would feel good, but they put me first.
After Bennett broke the kiss, Watson made me stand up so he could take off my pants. I watched him undress me, and afterwards, I watched him remove his own clothes.
“Come here,” he demanded as he took my hand and lead me to the end of the couch. “Lean over the armrest.”
I followed his instructions. I rested my forearms on the armrest and knelt on the couch while arching my back. Watson went down on one knee behind me, with his hands on my ass, and his eyes glued to my exposed pussy. “Beautiful,” he murmured as he admired my most private body part. “This view is better than the one out the window.”
I bit back a grin, then cried out in pleasure when he licked through my folds with his tongue without a warning.
“Easy,” Kline warned Watson, but I didn’t mind. I didn’t like when they made me wait. I’d get impatient quickly.
Bennett came to stand in front of me. He had taken off his pants too and was now rubbing his shaft with one hand while brushing my hair to one side.
I licked my lips and waited for him to guide his tip to my mouth while Watson continued to flick his tongue against my clit.
Bennett’s right hand was cupping my jaw when he took a step closer, and with the tip of his cock, he ran it along my bottom lip slowly. “Open, sweetheart.”
I parted my lips and let him slide into my mouth. He inched forward slowly until his hardening cock was fully inside my mouth, and he held it there while I looked up at him.
“So goddamn sexy,” he whispered with admiration in his eyes. “Wish I could stay like this forever.”
A smile tugged at my lips, but it was hard to smile with a cock in my mouth. Instead, I started to move my head back and forth. I twirled my tongue around his tip every time and pulled him in as deep as I could.
Ben’s groans turned me on just as much as the sounds Watson’s mouth made while he pleased my pussy.
After some time, Watson moved away, and he sat back down on the couch behind me to let one of the other guys get a taste.
“I’ve been thinking about this pussy all day,” Leo said as he ran two fingers through my slit before his mouth took over.
He wasn’t only using his tongue, but he also pushed two fingers inside of me, finger-fucking me while his mouth sucked on my pussy.
My moans were muffled, and I pushed myself up to wrap one hand around Ben’s base, needing to have more control. I kept his cock in my mouth the whole time, but he pulled out when his shaft started to throb.
I knew he wanted to come inside of my pussy, and I wasn’t upset about that. Kline moved around Bennett, making him take a step aside. I looked up at him and licked my lips before reaching out my hand to hold his thick cock in my hand.
“Nice and slow, baby. I’ll set the pace.”
There was no arguing with Kline. I didn’t dare to.
“Keep those pretty eyes on me while I fuck this mouth.”
I gave him a quick nod, and once he was positioned right, he started to move his hips back and forth, sliding his cock in and out of my mouth in a steady rhythm.
I never doubted them to make me feel good. Every move, every touch was perfect, and the fire burnt bright every time the five of us had sex.