12. Zachary
CHAPTER 12
ZACHARY
The moans coming out of our room were more pornographic than anything I had ever seen online. Whoever was with Teo was giving him the sex of his life and I was completely aroused because of it.
I was about to open the door when I heard him scream, “More! I want more!” I stopped in my tracks, and waited for the sex-a-thon to end.
When he left me the other morning in Pennsylvania, I was so drunk I hadn’t realized exactly what had happened, but soon enough, I found the bathrobes and his note. Honestly, the smell was strong too. I recognized it immediately. One, or both of us, had jerked off, and I wasn’t about to ask him which one of those it was. He seemed fine about it, so I wasn’t going to burst our friendship bubble.
I was eager to try again tonight, but it seemed like I was too late. I shouldn't have been playing hard to get. I shouldn’t have been playing anything, but I wanted him to take the initiative, not me. Lately, it felt like I was inadvertently setting up little gay traps and he was getting caught in every one of them. But was that what he wanted? Or was he just humoring his best friend? Being sexually fluid was one thing, but I had feelings for him. I needed him to have those back. I couldn’t just fool around with him occasionally for the rest of my life.
“Fuck me!”
Okay, I was pretty sure a man wouldn’t say that to a woman. Maybe our jack-off session had awakened something in Teo?
I would be so pissed if some himbo was in there giving it to him. That's what I wanted to do. Badly.
I adjusted my hard dick in my pants, and banged my head against the door.
Shit.
I hadn’t meant to do that.
I was seconds away from leaving, trying to decide if he had heard me or not, when the door opened and I fell backward.
“I thought I heard a noise. What are you standing there for, Zach? Come in!”
He was shirtless, his face was flushed, and all he wore was a pair of gray sweats, which I had an intimate view of because I had landed on my ass. My face was at crotch level.
What game was he playing? ‘ Come in?’
“Uh, don’t you have company? I heard-”
“I had the TV volume too loud.”
“Bullshit.” I took his offered hand and tried to ignore all of the muscle groups flexing as he pulled me up. “What were you watching? It sounded like someone was really having a good time.”
He smirked and put an arm up on the door jam. I stared at his hairy armpit.
“Maybe it was a good show?”
“I bet.” I entered our room, looking for his partner, but after a careful search, found nothing.
“I told you no one is in here.”
“What show were you watching?” I headed to the TV.
“Why is this such a big deal for you?” Teo beat me to the remote and held it out of my reach as I tried to grab it .
“Cause I know when you’re lying and I want the truth.” I took a few steps and he dodged backwards, running around to the other side of the couch.
“The truth? I don’t think you can handle it!” The son-of-a-bitch waggled his fucking eyebrows playfully.
“I can handle anything you’ve got!” I leapt over the couch, hoping to catch him by surprise, but all I caught was the fabric of his sweats as I knocked him on his ass.
I didn’t pull them completely off and it’s not like his dick went straight into my mouth, but his dick did leave a moist memento on my face.
Teo was speechless, while he re-covered himself, and I tried to not think about his hard dick pressed against my cheek as I went over to my desk, attempting to erase the last four minutes of our lives by pretending to use the computer.
“It was porn, okay?” Teo proclaimed from across the room. “I was watching porn.”
It seemed he felt the need to explain his hard dick, but the porn wasn’t a surprise. It was more Teo’s choice – whatever scene he had been enthralled with had plenty of manly, guttural moans and I don’t recall hearing any high-pitched squeals.
“I’m…sorry?” I had no idea how to handle this situation. “I really thought you had someone in here and wanted to tease you. I didn’t mean for it to turn into…this.”
Teo pulled on a shirt and smiled. “It’s alright. I’d break down the door if you had some dude in here without my approval.”
That got my attention. “So I need your approval now?”
He nodded and walked over to my side of the room. “Yeah. How else are you gonna know if they’re good enough for you?”
I did not want to reveal how much it turned me on that Teo wanted to screen guys for me, so I played it off. “I’ll be sure to send them your way first, Mr. Decker. ”
“That’s all I’m asking.”
The playoffs continued – without me, unfortunately. The next two games were in Chicago, and I didn’t want to miss that many days of class. I wasn’t on the team, so they wouldn’t be excused absences.
Teo was disappointed I wasn’t going, but kept me updated as often as he could. I wasn’t sure if Teo asked them to hang out with me more while he was gone, but Aiden and Jayden pretty much moved into our room once Teo headed out. I felt very…monitored.
I was looking forward to having some alone time, but honestly, it wasn’t all bad. Despite it being winter, the twins wore very little while inside for their at-home workouts. Apparently, they didn’t want to trek to the gym through the snow – the soccer team squeaked out just before the first big snowfall.
I suggested that maybe the frat’s next project could be to fundraise to put a gym either in the basement or the barn, which were both used for storage at the moment.
“Zach, that’s a great idea!” Jayden bounded across the room and picked me up in his arms, squeezing me against his bare chest. “We’re definitely doing that!”
I tried to ignore the bulge in his boxer briefs, but in my position, my hand was trapped down there between us. Bulge grazing was definitely happening.
Additionally, the twins seemed highly invested in the outcome of Teo’s game. They were his friends, but not as close as I was to him. I asked if they wanted to join the soccer team or something and they both got cagey. One of them ran into the bathroom and started to fill the jacuzzi tub that neither Teo or I had ever used. But thoughts of soccer and Teo were gone once the other stripped in front of me and headed into the bathroom. It happened so fast; I was still processing the piercing.
“Joining us, nutZach?” one of them called from our bathroom .
Hilarious. “I don’t think there’s room.”
“You can sit on my lap,” one of them suggested.
“I’d rather you sit on mine,” I called back.
There was a slight pause, before the reply. “That works for me.”
I took a breath, shrugged, and willed my dick to stay soft as I took my clothes off. I didn’t have many queer friends – realistically, I only had the twins and Malik. Wasn’t that part of the point of being gay? Being comfortable with male nudity and hanging out with other guys?
I tried not to think about the twins staring at my junk as I entered the bathroom, but was shocked to find that the lights were off and several candles were lit. They’d be hard pressed to see anything even if they were trying.
“I’m honored, guys, but I’m not entering a throuple with a set of twins,” I said before stepping over the lip and sliding under the hot water.
Both were leaning back with their eyes closed on opposite sides of the tub, but when I bumped one or both of them under the water, they finally looked at me.
“Dude, if Aiden and I wanted to seduce you, we would’ve done it by now.”
“Yeah, can’t bros just have a nude soak together? Didn’t take you for a prude, Zach.”
“You guys are assholes.”
That got them chuckling as I settled my limbs into a comfy position, though it was impossible not to touch at least one of them in some way.
“I told you it wasn’t big enough for all of us.”
“We don’t have cooties, Zach.”
“I know, I was just-”
“What’s wrong with a throuple with twins anyway?” one of them asked. I thought it was Aiden.
I shrugged, keeping my eyes closed, aware of the warm water bubbling against my chest. “I don’t know. I guess I’m just old-fashioned. I believe one hole is enough for me.”
“Barf!”
“Boring!”
“Which of us is hotter?”
I laughed. “You guys are identical!”
“Are we?”
That got me to open my eyes. “Aren’t you? I can’t tell you apart in the dark.”
“I’m a better kisser,” one of them said.
“Well, I don’t think I’ll be finding that out tonight.”
“Jayden’s being a dick. Honestly, if we’re shirtless, I have a scar on my chest from when I fell out of a tree we weren’t supposed to be climbing when we were seven,” Aiden explained.
“He picks himself up and has a branch sticking out of his chest,” Jayden added, miming a branch with his finger.
“Yeah, and my little brother decided to yank it out!”
“We’re the same size, bro.”
“I’m four minutes older.”
“Whoa!”
I looked over at Jayden and his eyes were wide, staring back at me. “What is it?”
“I know you were joking with the porn comment, but if you wanted to touch my dick, you could’ve asked.”
“What the fuck are you talking about?”
“Nice try, Zach, but someone just touched my dick and it didn’t feel like my brother’s hand.”
Jesus Christ! I couldn’t help the mental image that conjured, but still…
“Jake, knock it off.”
“Jake?”
“Who the fuck is Jake?” Aiden mirrored his brother.
“The ghost that lives here,” I said, knowing a half-smile had crept onto my face .
“Get the fuck out!”
“That’s the lamest excuse for a pass ever.”
“Why would I make a pass? You know I like Teo.”
They seemed to consider my reasoning for a second, before Jayden said, “Doesn’t mean you can’t have a little fun.”
I pulled my hands out of the water to show them, and I knew the second Jake did it again. Jayden launched himself out of the water with a noise that sounded like someone kneed him in the balls. It seemed like half the water followed him out.
Looking over at Aiden, he seemed confused, but his face was pale.
Then I saw the reason why.
Jake was stroking his hair. I could see the movement on the top of his head. Seconds later, Aiden followed his brother, leaving me behind to clean up the watery mess.