Chapter 2
Chapter Two
Theo gently lowers me back to my feet, making sure I’m okay. They all surround me, tenderly checking that I’m not only able to stand, but still able to think. It takes a minute to come out of the haze of pleasure. Once I do, I’m grateful for them.
Noah kisses my forehead. “You did so well, Little Deer.”
“We’re proud of you,” Finn adds. “How do you feel?”
“Good,” I answer, leaning into his embrace.
Theo smiles on my other side, letting go enough that Finn is holding me steady now. “Do you need a break?”
“No.” I shake my head. “I’m good.”
“Even to keep running?”
I frown at him. “I was caught.”
“By me. Not by them. You run until we’ve all had our turn,” he explains.
Despite all of the pleasure he just gave me, I can’t deny the way my body instantly drips at the idea. And it isn’t just his cum leaking down my thighs.
“Ready to run?” Noah asks, excitement palpable on his face.
I nod, and they all step back.
“Updated rules,” Theo starts. “If you try anything dangerous to escape us, you won’t get to cum for a week. Am I clear?”
I whimper. “Yes, Sir.”
“Good girl.”
“Run, Little Deer,” Noah commands. “I can’t wait to catch you.”
Then I’m off again.
My legs are a tad unsteady, but I fight hard to keep myself running straight and upright.
The footsteps behind me are loud, but it doesn’t take long for me to outrun the sound.
There are other sounds around that I didn’t hear before.
Birds singing, animals running, and rushing water.
I wonder briefly if we’ll see the deer again.
Sunlight pours through an upcoming thin spot in the trees that lets out into an open area filled with bright green grass. On the other side is a crystal blue lake with a waterfall a few miles away. The water looks so beautiful.
I stop at the edge of the grass, looking around and straining my ears for any sign of them. My heavy breaths fill the space, and I know I need a break. I work out, but damn, this is hard. Especially after a good orgasm.
Bending at the very edge, I dip my hand in and feel the cool water. A swim would be fucking amazing right now. Theo might call that dangerous, though, since no one else is around. And even with them chasing me, there’s no guarantee they’d find me if something did happen.
Logic says no, but I really, really want to.
Footsteps come behind me, and I spin, looking up at Finn. He cocks his head with a grin. “Not even water will help you escape, Little Deer.”
“I just like it,” I explain.
He crouches down behind me with a chuckle. “I know. Growing up on a beach will do that.”
“How did you—”
“I know more about you than you think, Brooke. Noah too. Just because Theo asked you out first doesn’t mean we never thought about it.”
“Can you explain that more?”
“Later. Can I get my prize now?”
I bite my lip. As much as I want to swim, I want him more. “Are they far behind?”
“What, don’t even want it without a show now?” he taunts, moving closer to push a strand of dark hair from my shoulder.
“No,” I rush. Shit, I don’t want him thinking I wouldn’t want him without them. Theo’s been encouraging it, so I don’t feel bad whatsoever. “I just want to know what to expect.”
He moves, pushing me back with his body until I’m lying on the grass and he’s pinning me down. “Expect pleasure, Little Deer.”
Nodding, I wrap my arms around his shoulders. “Yes, please.”
A chuckle, and then he kisses me slowly. He moves more carefully than Theo, but I remind myself that this is our first time. I’ve been passed around while they all get me ready, but with just him? We haven’t had this chance yet.
He breaks the kiss, and I smile at his boyish looks. Adorable blonde hair that has no ability to be tame falls around his face. His eyes search my face before he sighs. “You’re beautiful, Brooke.”
“So are you,” I reply, giggling as he rolls his eyes. “I’m serious.”
“Yeah, yeah,” he dismisses, lifting my leg around his waist and settling between my slick thighs. I didn’t even notice him lower his shorts. Our eyes connect as he slides into me, ripping a moan from my throat. He’s thicker than Theo, and it keeps catching me off guard. “You feel so good.”
I sigh in pleasure as his thrusts start.
It doesn’t take much to get the perfect angle that has me scratching down his back.
I know I should be focused on the pleasure, but all I can think about is how peaceful and perfect this is.
The soft grass under me, the waterfall in the distance, and the quiet sounds of nature.
This is exactly what I would have wanted my first time to be, and I love that it’s like this with Finn.
He sits back, adjusting slightly and ensuring I’m still comfortable before his hand slips between us. I gasp when he brushes my clit. It’s still so sensitive from before, and the running didn’t give it a chance to calm down.
“Finn,” I whimper. “If you do that—”
“That’s what I want, Little Deer,” he murmurs, eyes watching in fascination as he fucks me. “Let me see you squirt again.”
“Oh, fuck.” He holds steady, building my pleasure with a slow pace that has me withering in his arms. My heels dig into the dirt, and I try to push myself to move and get more from him. He just doesn’t let me.
Each torturous second that ticks by drives me insane. I’m chasing the orgasm I got so used to receiving without a fight. My brain doesn’t want to accept the lack of immediate pleasure. I need to cum.
Maybe begging will help. “Please, Finn. Harder. Faster. Anything.” I’m damn near sobbing. “Please!”
He hums and tightens his grip on my thigh. “You got caught. This is for me.”
I cry out in annoyance, grabbing at the grass. “I need more.”
“Oh, yeah? Tell me, Little Deer, did you want to be caught?” He taunts me more by slowing. I’m half tempted to rip up this grass and throw it at his pretty face. “The truth.”
“Yes,” I sob, desperately trying to move my hips.
“Why?”
“Because I wanted to be fucked.”
“You just were. Was it not enough?”
“No. I need more.”
“Are you gonna try and be caught again when I’m through with you?”
“Yes.”
He releases my thigh to move my chin, forcing my gaze to the tree line. Noah and Theo stand there, smirks on their faces. He did that on purpose. “Good girl.”
His thrusts quicken as does his thumb. I moan and gasp, calling for him as he gives me what I asked for. This is what I’m used to. Delicious sex that makes me cum fast and hard. It’s perfect.
I cry out as my thighs shake around him. I’m so fucking close, and I know I’m going to do exactly what he wanted. With his name on my tongue, I squirt for him.
He groans, cursing as his hands grab my thighs, holding me tight as he thrusts a few final times and then releases inside me. His hot cum mixes with Theo’s, and I bask in the happiness that comes with it.
We breathe heavily together, the fresh air making me even more grateful to be out here.
There’s only one thought as I glance towards the other two watching us.
I wonder what Noah will be like.