Chapter 17 #3
“Oh, fuck!” He growls as his cock swells before twitching against my tongue, hot cum filling my mouth as his orgasm overtakes him. “Oh, Plum, fuck…” he moans my name while I swallow every drop.
When he’s finished, I release him, licking my lips and leaning back. I pull his sweats back up his shins, and when they reach his knees, he tugs them the rest of the way up. The way he’s looking down at me right now is intoxicating. Like I’m a goddess, and he’s eager to worship me.
“Stunning, Plum.” Nick’s praise sends a shiver across my skin, and I smile at him, meeting his heated gaze. He’s watching me with the same look in his eyes that Benson has. Nick no longer has his hand in his sweats, but there’s still a very clear bulge.
A thought occurs to me as we stare at each other, and I tilt my head to the side. Is Benson the only virgin in the room? I mean, I’ve never seen Nick with anyone around town. Never so much as heard a rumor about him dating anyone, or even hooking up with anyone.
Maybe he’s just discreet, but that’s what I thought about Benson, and I was exceptionally incorrect.
“Are you a virgin?” I blurt, and Nick’s eyebrows shoot up, clearly not expecting the question.
He drapes his arms across the back of the couch, and I glance at Kai for a second.
He looks uncomfortable physically, like the ties are starting to hurt, but he also looks…
Something. Content, maybe? Relaxed? Happy to be here?
I feel a little guilty about having him tied up and effectively muzzled, but he looks like he’s exactly where he wants to be. Boner tenting his sweats and all.
“Um, what?” Nick asks.
“Well, it’s just that I’ve never seen you with anyone before.” I shrug, starting to feel exposed and a little shy since I’m completely naked on my knees in a room full of men who are not naked.
“Did you expect that you would’ve caught me fucking someone in the middle of the supermarket at some point?” Nick chuckles, tilting his head at me, a little smirk tugging his lips up.
“No.” I shake my head, feeling silly.
Benson senses my discomfort and reaches for me, lifting me into his arms before helping me onto the bed. I pull the blankets over my lap, feeling a little vulnerable being the only naked one.
Nick stands, catching Kai’s attention. The beta looks excited about whatever he thinks the alpha has planned, which makes me nervous in a good way.
“Then what made you ask if I’m a virgin? Because not stumbling on me as I’m balls deep in another omega can’t be your reasoning,” Nick taunts, grinning wider when I growl in response. I know he’s just trying to get a rise out of me, and it works.
I rise up on my knees, still on the bed, but now I’m facing Nick, glaring at him in challenge.
“Maybe it’s because I’ve never even heard a rumor about you fucking anyone else.” I glance at Benson, who looks much too entertained by this exchange.
He meets my eyes, nodding slightly. Is that permission to tell Nick his not-so-secret secret?
I mean, he already told Nick as much during our game of two truths and a lie last weekend.
Or is Benson trying to tell me that Nick is messing with me and knows damn well why I’m asking?
The sparkle in the younger alpha’s eye tells me all I need to know.
“Maybe you just have the vibe of someone inexperienced in making a woman come,” I say, slowly turning my attention back to Nick.
He’s within arm's reach of me now. “Maybe you just don’t give off big knot energy, Alpha.” I mock in a teasing tone, crossing my arms to match his pose.
Nick very much gives off big knot energy.
I can’t stop myself from looking down at the bulge.
What was it he said that night? “I’ve never knotted anyone, love or otherwise.”
Doesn’t mean he’s not a virgin…
“Are you just saying that because you want me to show you my knot, Plum?” He holds my gaze, not looking away for a second, and my heart starts racing.
“Are you asking what I want, Nick?” I ask, pressing my hands to his chest and leaning into him, our lips so close to touching.
“Mmm.” He nods, moving to give me better access to his lips, daring me to kiss him.
“Good, because right now, I want…” I trail my hand down his chest, over his abdomen, and all the way to the waistband of his sweatpants.
“To suck…” I whisper, our lips brushing in a featherlight kiss.
“On a candy cane while we decorate for Christmas,” I announce cheerily, pushing back from the alpha, sitting on my ass as I grin up at him.
I can’t help but think about how much fun it’s going to be. I love decorating, but even better? The three of them are going to be as hard as stone the entire time. Benson is the only one who might be okay for a while, since he came in his pants and then down my throat.
Nick blows out a breath, chuckling and shaking his head at me. Gripping his junk in his large hand, he gives it a rough squeeze, groaning. Meanwhile, Benson unties Kai, who looks like he just went twelve rounds in a sex den.
“No jerking off,” I order, pointing at him as he rubs himself with his newly freed hand.
“Coming in my sweats doesn’t count. It’s been a really long time since I’ve um…” Kai glances between the two alphas. Nick lifts his brow at the beta, while Benson crosses his arms over his chest. “Well, this is awkward.” Kai’s tan cheeks blush bright red under our attention.
“What? Since you had sex with someone?” I snap, eyes narrowing on the beta. Suddenly ready to tie him right back up. Kai clears his throat, nodding as he drops his gaze to the floor.
“She’s about to claw your eyes out.” Benson snorts. “Better finish that thought, and quick.”
My blood boils, and my vision gets a bit blurry as my heart rate spikes. I’ve never had the urge to pillage a small village before, but I’m starting to see the appeal. It would have to be a village of evil betas who broke the hearts of their poor, devoted girlfriends.
No innocents were harmed in the making of this felony…
Kai’s head snaps up, and he searches my face, his cheeks getting impossibly redder.
“I haven’t been with anyone but you!” Kai blurts, hands going up in surrender, eyes wide.
“You were my first, Plum, and my last. I always knew it was you. Even if I wanted a quick fuck, my dick only gets hard for one woman!” I glare at him again, and he takes a step forward.
“And to be clear, I have never wanted a quick fuck. Well, I have.” More glaring, and Kai shakes his head.
“With you, I mean! Remember when we used to, um…” He swallows, like he’s trying to find a way to make this sound more respectful.
“M-mess around in the morning before my shifts at the library?”
Nick scoffs, “I forgot you were a fucking librarian.”
“Plum, you still look like you want to bury my body in a shallow grave.” Kai ignores Nick, taking another step toward me when it’s clear neither alpha is going to rescue him.
“Crawl,” I say, pointing to the floor. Mostly just to see what he’ll do.
Shocking me, the beta hits the floor on his hands and knees, eyes locked on me, and crawls to the edge of the bed. He reaches for my legs, taking them between his trembling hands and pressing delicate kisses to my inner ankle and several more up my calf.
“I’m so sorry, Plum.” Kiss. “I would never betray you.” Kiss.
“My body knows who it belongs to and would never let me betray you.” Kiss.
“I will crawl on my hands and knees for you for the rest of my life. I promise, Sweet Plum, you are the only woman these hands have ever touched.” One more kiss, “the only omega these hands will ever touch again.”
“I believe you,” I whisper, breathless for an entirely different reason now. His lips touched my skin for the first time in so long, and it feels so damn good. I want to kiss him, damn him. I want to present for the three of them. Bend over and wiggle my cute ass in the air.
I’m going to settle for teasing them instead.
Kai releases me but doesn’t get up until Nick grabs his elbow, helping him to his feet.
“Go change. Wear something festive for decorating. She’ll like that,” Nick says to him, and Kai nods, eyes still locked on me. “Alright, Omega, get dressed so we can get started. I’ll go grab the boxes.” To Benson, he says, “Meet me down there once you put some clean pants on, yeah?”
Benson chuckles, pressing a kiss to my head before heading past Nick toward the door.
“Something festive!” I holler at his back, and he waves his hand in response.
When it’s just Nick and me, I stretch out on the bed, leaning back on my hands. I’m still very naked. His eyes darken as he takes in the sight of my body.
“Benson is a virgin, and you were Kai’s first and only…
” Nick puts his knee on the bed and drops his weight over me, holding himself up with his hands on either side of my body.
“Two things I can’t claim. I am not a virgin.
” Nick presses his face into the crook of my neck and nuzzles, marking me with his scent.
I let out a little gasp of need, my head falling to the side to give him room.
“But, when I knot you, you will be my first.” He bites down on the sensitive skin of my shoulder, hard enough that I know it’ll be red for the rest of the day, and I moan.
“My knot will belong to you, and only you, Omega. You will be the first and the last to have that claim over me.”
“Promises, promises,” I mutter, eyes falling shut as he licks the ache away from my bruised skin.
Are Nick’s words just a part of the game we’ve been playing for years, or does he really mean them? And if he does mean them, am I ready for what they mean?
I don’t know for sure, but I really want to find out, and that’s something I haven’t felt in a while.