Chapter 15 Sophie #2
And when Benny presses his cock between my cheeks, I don’t fight it. I don’t fight him. I can’t. My legs are numb and my brain is so hazy and foggy from all the love and intimacy I’ve just experienced.
“That’s my good girl,” Benny whispers in my ear as he starts to thrust inside me.
Matthew watches me intently as Benny pulls out, thrusting back inside of me with a steady, even rhythm.
His ring rubs along the inside of my ass and it makes me see stars.
I can already feel another orgasm forming, and I cry out because I’ve never felt pleasure like this.
I’ve never felt so much pleasure in all my life.
Benny holds my hips as Matthew kisses me and I can feel his cock pressing against me. Again. Wet and sticky and hard.
How does he do that? How does he have so much stamina for a man who’s had sex a handful of times in the last twenty-four hours?
It’s insane.
I don’t think twice about grabbing his cock, and Matthew chuckles as he kisses me. He pushes forward against my sex, and combined with the stretch of Benny filling me, I can’t help but moan in ecstasy because it all feels so good.
“You want him to fuck you again, don’t you?” Benny chuckles darkly.
Words are hard right now, but I manage to nod.
“You hear that, Matty? Our princess can’t get enough of your cock.”
Matthew lets out a laugh as he kisses me. “Feeling’s mutual.”
I tense because the heat of his voice is too much and I’m already stretched so thin. But I can’t deny that the idea, the thought, is sending my insides into overdrive.
Last night was a blur. A wonderful blur, and something inside of me broke. But now, there’s no alcohol to blame, and no ex-fiancé to stir up unwanted feelings, and…
There’s only us.
Benny, me, Matthew. Elijah who sleeps like the dead, apparently.
“I don’t know if I can take you both,” I whine as Benny slams into me.
He chuckles. “Well, only one way to find out.” He nods at Matthew. “Go slow. When I pull out, you push in. Got it?” His voice changes. It’s not bitter or commanding, but stern. Guiding.
And all at once I remember last night, when he had the same tone, when he was instructing Matthew on what he wanted to see.
But now I realize as Matthew slowly presses his cockhead inside of me, as Benny slowly pulls back, telling him “good boy,” that he wasn’t ordering Matthew last night. He was guiding him through his first time.
Just like he’s guiding him now, in this moment.
The realization makes my heart want to leap out of my chest as I remember Matthew’s words. “I had everyone who cared about me there.”
Before I can say anything, Benny pushes back inside me, and I feel like I’m going to rip in half. Because for the briefest moment, I feel them both filling me, stretching me, and it’s too much.
“I’m not going to last long,” Matthew says as he starts to build a slow rhythm. “Four is my limit.”
“Me either,” Benny says. “And I don’t think our princess is going to be able to take much more.”
I focus on my breath, and then I see Elijah, on his knees. Watching us intently, his cock gleaming with precum.
“Elijah…”
He slowly strokes himself, watching us.
“I’ll be the judge of that,” he says as he shifts around the bed, around Matthew, and I know without question what he’s doing. When he angles his cock above me, above my mouth, I don’t question him. I wrap my lips around him and close my eyes and suck him, my tongue rolling around his shaft.
Benny thrusts into me and pulls back.
Matthew thrusts into me.
I feel equal parts pain and pleasure and I think nothing is ever going to be as perfect as this.
Us.
“I’m coming,” Matthew says, and then I feel him detonate.
It’s like a domino effect. Warmth fills me as Matthew buries his face in my neck, as Benny grunts out a curse and stills, pumping my ass full of his release.
And Elijah stares down at me as his body tenses and he says, “Me too.”
I barely have a moment to comprehend his words as I shatter around their cocks. Elijah fills my mouth and I work to swallow him so I don’t choke in this position.
When the haze clears and he pulls out of my mouth, Elijah drops beside me and kisses me. “That was so hot,” he says, and I can see the truth in his eyes as he stares down at me.
“Yeah it was,” Benny chuckles as he finally slips out of me. Matthew’s the last to vacate me and I’m more than aware of the cum dripping out of me everywhere.
“I love you,” Matthew says again.
Elijah kisses me. “I love you too.”
I kiss them back as Benny gets up, and a moment later, I feel him with a warm rag, cleaning me up.
“God, I need a shower,” I mutter, my eyes getting heavy.
Matthew chuckles. “Yeah, I think we could all use a shower.”
Elijah scoots into Benny’s side of the bed and pulls me close while Benny finishes cleaning me up.
“Such a hot mess,” Benny says with a chuckle. Then he smacks my pussy lightly and I jump. “All good, princess.”
Elijah grumbles. “Sleep first.”
“Sleep is good,” I say.
And as I drift off to sleep, I think there’s something I forgot. Something important, but I can’t figure out what it is.
I’m too tired to focus. I know I’ll need to pack up tomorrow and get ready to head home, but for right now, I just want to enjoy being in the arms of my brother’s best men for a little longer.
So that’s exactly what I do.