22. Adam
— ? —
Adam
The phone goes off at almost three in the morning and I almost let it ring out.
I don’t know the number. Nobody good calls at three in the morning from a number you don’t know, and my first thought, my honest first thought, is that it’s a bill collector who doesn’t understand business hours. I let it ring twice more. Then, against my better judgment, I pick it up.
“Is this Adam Carrington?” A woman’s voice, careful, the kind of careful people use right before they ruin your night. “I’m calling from your brother’s foundation. I’m so sorry to call this late. There’s been an accident.”
The rest of it comes at me in pieces. Clarence. A car. The rain. The hospital. They’re calling me because I’m listed as family, because of course I am, because no matter how hard I’ve worked to burn it all down I’m still his brother on some form somewhere.
“Is he?” I start, and I can’t make the rest of the sentence happen.
“He’s in critical condition. That’s all I’m able to tell you over the phone.”
I’m already pulling on yesterday’s jeans.
I’m already grabbing my keys. And the whole time there’s this voice in the back of my head I haven’t heard in years, a small one, a young one, saying please, please, not him, please be okay, the way I used to think it when we were kids and he’d climb too high and I’d stand at the bottom of the tree waiting for him to fall.
The rain hasn’t let up. It comes down on the windshield the whole drive and I barely see the road through it, and the irony of that isn’t lost on me, that he was out in this same rain a few hours ago and I’m only now getting in a car because of it.
I think about every fight. That’s what the drive turns into, a highlight reel of every rotten thing I’ve ever done to him. The time I told our parents the broken window was his.
The night I showed up at his place drunk out of my mind and put my fist in his face because I needed somebody to blame for my own life falling apart, and he didn’t even hit me back.
The hundred times he tried to fix things between us, called, showed up, offered, and I shut the door in his face because being angry at Clarence was easier than admitting I’d wasted my whole life being jealous of him.
He never did anything to me. That’s the thing I’ve spent a decade refusing to face. He’s always just been better than me, and he was good at it, and I couldn’t stand it.
And now he might die before I ever told him any of that.
***
The hospital at four in the morning is too bright and too quiet. A nurse points me toward his room and I walk down the hall on legs that don’t feel like mine, and when I get to his door I don’t go in. Because I can see through the window first, and what I see stops me cold.
Charly’s in there.
She’s asleep in the chair pulled up next to his bed, folded over at an angle that’s going to wreck her neck, her head resting on the mattress right beside his hand. Like she fell asleep holding it and didn’t want to let go even unconscious.
Even asleep she looks wrung out, dark under her eyes, still in her scrubs from a shift she clearly never went home from. And she is not going anywhere. You can tell just looking at her. She has parked herself in that chair and the world is going to have to drag her out of it.
I stand at the glass and watch her sleep next to my brother, and I wait for it.
The jealousy. The thing that’s run my whole life.
She was mine first. I picked her. She used to look at me like I was the best thing that ever happened to her, and some small ugly part of me has spent weeks furious that she stopped.
But it doesn’t come. I look at her asleep with her hand tucked under his, and I finally get the thing I’ve been too stupid to see this whole time.
She loves him.
Not the way she used to look at me. And I get it now.
What she felt for me was built on a lie I sold her, because lying was always the thing I was best at.
She never really knew me, because I never let her.
But this? This is a woman who pulled a full shift and then planted herself in a hospital chair and won’t leave.
She’d sit there till she dropped before she let him wake up by himself.
You can’t fake that. Nobody’s that good an actor.
You can’t fake the way she’s holding his hand in her sleep.
That’s not a thing I lost. That’s a thing he actually earned. And I’ve never earned that from anybody in my life, because I never even tried.
So I don’t go in. I turn around and head back down the hall before she wakes up and has to look at my face on top of everything else she’s dealing with. First time in my life I think I’ve ever done the right thing with nobody around to give me credit for it.
***
I come back in the afternoon.
I sit in the parking lot for two hours first, watching the entrance, and when I finally see Charly come out the front with a doctor, deep in some conversation, walking toward the other building, I know it’s my chance.
I go up. The nurse at the desk recognizes the name and waves me through, and then it’s just me and him.
He looks terrible. My brother, the careful one, the one who always thought everything through twice before he did it, lying there wired up to machines, the bruises down one side of his face gone yellow and green at the edges now, and I have to sit down because my legs quit on me.
I don’t know how to do this. I’ve never apologized to anyone in my life and meant it. I’ve said sorry the way you say excuse me, a thing you do to keep moving. I don’t know how to say it the other way.
So I just start talking.
“Hey. It’s me. I know, I’m the last person you want in here.” I scrub a hand over my face. “I’m not going to do a whole speech. You’d hate that, and honestly I don’t have one in me. I just… I need to say some things while you can’t argue with me, because that’s the only way I’ll get through them.”
He doesn’t move. The machine breathes for him, slow and even.
“I’m sorry. For all of it. And I mean it this time, not the way I usually throw it out.
” My voice cracks, which has honestly never happened to me before.
“I blamed you for everything, man. For Mom and Dad picking you over me, except they never actually did, I just told myself that because it was easier than admitting which one of us was the good one. For building a real life while I coasted. For the way people actually liked you. And then for Charly.” I have to stop on her name for a second.
“All of it. And none of it was ever your fault. You just kept being a good person, and I hated you for it, because every time I looked at you I had to see what I wasn’t. ”
The words are coming easier now that they’ve started, like a thing that’s been stuck for years finally working loose.
“I knew the engagement was fake. Did you know that? Of course you did, you know everything.” A laugh that isn’t really one.
“I knew, and it should’ve made me happy, and instead it made me crazy, because I couldn’t stand watching her move on even into a lie.
I wanted it to blow up. I waited for it to blow up.
” I lean forward, elbows on my knees. “But somewhere along the way it stopped being fake, didn’t it?
Everybody could see it. Everybody but me, because I didn’t want to. ”
He breathes. I keep going.
“I came by while you were out, Clarence. Saw her asleep in that chair holding your hand like she’d fight anybody who tried to move her.
And that’s when it finally hit me. She didn’t pick you because I lost her.
She picked you because you actually showed up for her.
Every day. The way I never showed up for anybody, including you. ”
I heard what happened at the party. Word travels fast in that crowd, and the word is that the nurse stood up in the middle of a ballroom and tore Celeste’s whole story apart in front of everyone, and that Kara Whitfield backed her up just to twist the knife.
I keep waiting to feel something about it.
My last move, gone, blown up by the woman I threw away, and she did it defending the brother I’ve hated for thirty years. But I’m not angry. I’m just tired. And under the tired there’s this other thing I don’t want to look at too hard, because it feels a lot like relief.
I’m the one who sent Celeste after him. I handed her the whole thing and pointed her at him. And Charly stepped in front of it without even knowing I’m the reason she had to. That’s the whole difference between us, right there.
She steps in front of things. I’ve spent my entire life hiding behind them.
And that’s where it breaks, finally, the thing I’ve kept welded shut my entire adult life.
It’s not loud. I’m not a man who knows how to cry loud.
It’s just my face in my hands in a quiet hospital room where there’s no one to see it and no one to perform it for, my shoulders shaking, ten years of being the favorite who turned into nobody coming up out of me all at once.
“I’m sorry,” I say again, into my hands. “I’m so sorry. You deserved a better brother than me. You always did.”
He doesn’t answer. He just keeps breathing, which is the only thing I need him to keep doing.
***
When I can talk again, when I’ve got my face back under control, I take the envelope out of my jacket.
It’s all there. Every dollar I took from her.
I’ve been carrying it around in some form or another for weeks, telling myself I’d give it back when the timing was right, when it wouldn’t look like losing, when I could do it on my terms. There’s never going to be a right time.
There’s just now, and a brother who can’t watch me do it, which is somehow the only way I could bring myself to.
I set it on the table by his bed where she’ll find it. I write the note on the back of a foundation pamphlet because it’s the only paper in the room.
I’m sorry for everything. I should have given this back a long time ago. Take care of each other. -Adam.
I read it twice. It’s not enough. Nothing I could write would be enough. But it’s true, and that’s more than I’ve managed in years, so I leave it.
I put my hand on his arm, just for a second, the most I’ve touched my brother since we were boys.
“Get up,” I tell him quietly. “She’s waiting. Don’t make her wait.”
Then I go.
***
The parking lot is wet and gray and my phone buzzes before I reach the car. My mother. You okay, sweetheart? Any news on your brother? Call me.
A week ago I’d have called her back inside a minute, because she was one of the last people still answering me, and I needed somebody on my side so badly I’d have taken anybody.
I look at the message and I don’t answer it.
Instead I turn around and look back at the hospital, at the lit-up window somewhere up there where my brother is fighting to stay alive and the woman who loves him is going to walk back in and find an envelope and a note and finally be free of me.
And it lands on me, standing in the rain, the thing I think I’ve known for a long time and refused to say. I’ve spent years clawing to get back a life that isn’t mine anymore. It stopped being mine the day I threw it away, and I’ve been fighting ghosts ever since.
Charly was never going to come back to me.
Clarence was never the reason I failed. The only person who ever cost me anything was me, and I made everybody around me pay for it instead.
I get in the car. I don’t drive off angry, the way I’ve driven off from every hard thing in my life. I just drive, slow, careful in the rain, because I learned tonight what this weather can do to a person.
I’m not giving up. That’s not what this is.
I’m finally letting go.