Chapter 39 Cole #2
“And then you were being stubborn again. Oh… and keep it up with the ass massage back there. It feels great.” Finn groans out the last part.
Her arms immediately go limp, hanging below her head. Finn lets out a loud laugh, carrying her into my room. I don’t know why he’s bringing her in here, but I follow behind all the same.
“Your bed is the biggest,” Theo says, walking in beside me.
Okay… that makes sense. I guess you need a lot of room for four people. I’m so out of my depth here.
I pride myself on always being in control and understanding what is going on around me, but Finn and Theo are going to need to take the lead here.
It’s an uncomfortable feeling to relinquish that control. But if therapy has taught me anything, it’s that being uncomfortable is okay. It’s usually when we grow the most.
Riley bounces across the mattress when Finn tosses her down. He’s on her in an instant, looming over her like a hungry lion. Somehow, in the mess of getting up here, his hair tie fell out. So, his wild hair does kind of resemble a mane.
“Why are you like this?” she asks, laughing. It looks like she’s trying to push him away, but she ends up just running her hands over him.
“Don’t act like you don’t love that I’m like this.”
She makes a grumbling sound.
“So… you would change me, if you could?” The question is said jokingly, but there’s a hint of vulnerability to his words. His shoulders tense ever so slightly.
Her fingers slide into his hair. “Not a damn thing.” She kisses him gently. “I wouldn’t change a single thing.”
Then they’re kissing again. Clothes are peeled off and tossed off the bed. When Finn starts kissing his way down her body, I realize I’m just standing here watching.
They’re about to have sex, and I’m just leering in the corner. I know they’re both okay with my presence, but it doesn’t change the lingering unease seeping through my mind.
“Are you two going to help at all, or are you just going to be voyeurs over there?” Finn asks, settling himself between her legs.
Theo laughs, rounding the far side of the bed. He crawls up beside her, giving her a kiss that makes me realize just how much I was missing between them years ago. There’s no way that chemistry just sprouted up a few weeks ago.
“Cole,” Riley says, extending her hand toward me. She must sense my anxiety because she adds, “I want you, too. Please.”
She looks at me with those big pleading eyes that could get me to do just about anything.
I move onto the bed on her other side. One of her hands plays with the short hair at the base of my skull. The motion helps soothe some of my nerves.
“If this is too much, it’s okay,” she says, staring at me and me alone.
I know she means it. She would be okay if I weren’t on board with this whole group sex thing. We could figure it out.
I shake my head. “No, it’s just new.” Her eyes soften, fingers trailing over my face.
“It’s okay to change your mind,” Theo says. He’s propped up on his elbow. “Just tell us. Okay?”
I nod.
“None of this works if we don’t communicate,” Theo adds.
I nod again. “I will.”
“Are we done talking now? Because I can’t keep my mouth away from her pussy any longer,” Finn says.
My head falls to Riley’s chest, laughing. You can always count on Finn to break up a tense moment, whether it’s intentional or just him being him.
“What? I’m just following directions.” Finn glares at Theo. “You literally just said to communicate. I’m fucking communicating.”
Riley reaches down, smoothing Finn’s hair away from his face. “And you like following directions. Don’t you, Finn?”
He leans into her touch. “From you? Hell yes.”
Huh.
“Then, make me come, handsome,” she says.
Well… fuck me.
A devilish smirk takes over Finn’s face. “With my mouth or my fingers?”
“Both.”
His smile widens. “Your wish is my command, angel.” Then he descends on her wet pussy.
I might not be the one between her legs, but I can still see her arousal glistening on her skin. She moans, arching her back off the bed.
I move on instinct, closing my mouth around her nipple. I gently glide my teeth over it, then soothingly lap at it with my tongue. Her fingers tangle in my hair, tugging me upward. I move up until her lips land against mine.
Like always, her kiss soothes my soul while simultaneously setting my whole body on fire. I might not be the primary source of her moans, but I greedily swallow every one of them down.
She throws her head back into the pillows. Her whole body tenses as she lets out a raspy groan. Watching her orgasm sweep through her is intoxicating.
There’s something so delectable about seeing the tremors travel across her entire body, from her toes to the tips of her fingers. Her orgasm is on full display, and it is turning me the fuck on.
Apparently, I am on board with group sex. I think I might be more than just on board with it.
Finn slides off the bed, stripping off all his clothes. I’m pretty sure he hits himself in the face with how rushed he is, but he doesn’t react.
Theo grabs Riley’s hips, flipping her until she’s on all fours. She lets out a quiet yelp of surprise, but her post-orgasm haze has her in a compliant state.
Finn climbs up behind her, gripping her hips. “You had this pussy all to yourself last night while I was saving people’s lives.” His stare is locked on me. “So, I’m calling dibs.”
My eyes dart to Theo. Is he not…
“Theo doesn’t mind waiting for his turn. He likes to watch,” Finn says. “Me… I’m not as patient.”
His hips thrust forward as he buries himself inside of her. They moan in unison. Riley’s blissed-out eyes turn to me, and she pats the mattress in front of her.
I should probably get my clothes off first, but I’m so turned on I can’t even think straight. I sit, leaning against the headboard with my legs on either side of her arms.
Finn continues his steady pace while she frees my aching cock from my pants. It bobs against my chest.
The slightest touch of her fingers has tingling building in my balls. I can already tell I’m not going to last long, and she hasn’t even put her mouth on me yet.
“Oh fuck,” I groan when her lips close around me. I didn’t let her do this last night because I didn’t want to come in her mouth. I wanted to claim her pussy again. Now, I can’t think of anything better than coming down her throat.
She keeps one hand on the bed to support herself, while the other twists along the base of my cock, along with her mouth.
She moans around my cock when she comes, and the gentle vibrations tip me over the edge. My orgasm hits me like a freight train.
The intensity of this moment slams into me from all angles. She licks my cock clean until every wave of pleasure has run its course.
I lay there unable to move. I’m still wearing all of my clothes with just my spent dick pulled out. What the fuck just happened?
Finn looks about as drugged out as I do. He flops across the end of the bed, throwing his arm over his eyes.
Somewhere between me watching Riley come and having one of the best orgasms of my life, Theo moved off the bed and got undressed. He stands at the edge of the bed, motioning Riley closer to him.
She looks sexy as sin crawling across the bed. She is so beautiful.
“On your back,” he says when she gets close enough. There’s a blissful smile on my face as she obeys his commands.
Finn isn’t the only one who likes following directions.
He maneuvers her legs so her heels are planted on the edge of the bed. He runs a finger through her folds.
“Do you think you can come again for me?” he asks her.
She nods. “Yes.”
“Good girl,” he says, leaning down to kiss her cheek.
I’m seeing a whole new side to both of my brothers today. I guess that’s to be expected, but my mind is still kind of blown.
Theo grips her thighs, spreading her wide for him. Their eyes stay locked through every motion until they both come.
It’s just as intoxicating watching her come with Theo as it was when Finn made her come. And when Riley turns to me with a soft, barely awake smile, I can’t help but smile in return.