Chapter 21 #2
Suddenly, all I could think about was the way Indi's hips had felt grinding against mine. Their hands on my ass.
"Anything, yeah?"
"Why didn't you fuck me during my heat? It's clear you like me, Joon did, and everyone else..."
I didn't want to admit it, but there was something in my omega hindbrain that just couldn't let go of the slight.
The sting of Indi's rejection, no matter how many times they pulled me closer now, continued to fester under the surface. The wound only became more infected after they'd rejected me again in the bathroom.
It was... confusing.
They sighed, dropping their cup into the cup holder to rub the back of their neck.
If I didn't know better, in the low light of the car supplied by the lightpost overhead, I'd say that the alpha's cheeks had darkened with embarrassment.
"I know it'll probably sound pretty fuckin' stupid now... but at the time I didn't know that you were into me, so... I don't know, Eva. I didn't want you to feel like I took advantage. You'd signed up to fuck strangers, not an alpha in your circle."
God, Indigo Garotti really was a golden retriever trapped in a Doberman's body.
"And, things with Joon...?" I prompted, setting my cup beside theirs.
"Like I said, we talked... we both like you. I know it's a little unusual, two omegas in one pack, but..."
"I like him," I said honestly, my knees spreading to give Indi an easier path for the fingers moving along my thigh. "And I like you. I would've been thrilled if you'd fucked me during my heat... I've had a crush on you for like ever."
"Heatlock is messy. I don't regret waiting."
"You really meant it earlier? Even if I say no to the contract, you'll still want me?"
"Eva,” Indigo laughed, giving my thigh a playful squeeze. "You could burp out a live frog onto the floor, and I'd still want you."
I laughed, throwing the alpha's hand off with a roll of my eyes. "I really think I'd be more likely to burp like... a bunny or something cute! Why a frog?"
"Hey, frogs are cute!" Indi argued. "Though not half as cute as a certain pink-haired omega's making my car reek of strawberries and green tea."
"Oh, shut up.." I muttered, even as I slid across the seat towards them, carefully climbing over our drinks to crawl into their lap.
"Afraid, I can't. I'm babbling now, you see, she keeps gettin' closer to me, has this body like sin and---"
I closed the distance between our lips. Partly to shut them up... but mostly because I was so done with being interrupted.
There was no doubt in my mind. I wanted Indi.
And now that I knew they wanted me back, I wasn't going to stop.
Indigo's lips were soft, cold, and flavored with root beer from their milkshake.
Their hands found my hips, pulling me more firmly against them as we continued to kiss, the passes of our mouths quickly changing from tender to heated.
"Eva, if you don't want this, we need to stop now. I've hit my ceiling for stopping myself from fucking you," they mumbled, breaking our kiss to drag their teeth deliciously against my jaw.
I moaned, tilting my head to offer them more room. "I already told you, Indigo. I want you."
They took it for the permission that it was, using their grip on my hips to keep me steady for a heavy grind. "I swear you wore this just to drive me crazy."
"Maybe, just a little."
"How can you be scared and so horny at the same time?" They chuckled, one of their hands leaving my hips to grope at my breast, lips grazing over my scent gland, making me perfume more than a high-end drugstore counter.
"Be so serious," I whimpered, unzipping my jacket and flinging it back into the passenger's seat. "You know what I like."
The spark in Indigo's eyes made me wish, with a note of insanity, that we were bonded.
I would've loved to get some insight into what they were thinking.
Even if it wasn't like a walkie-talkie system, the hum of Indigo's arousal.
.. the dark twinge as they considered how best to terrify and stimulate me.
.. I could feel the slick pooling in my panties at the thought already.
The windows of the jeep were already starting to fog as I pulled Indigo's hoodie up, the alpha helping me to remove the sweater entirely, revealing their tattooed chest.
Their hand caught one of my pigtails, forcing my lips back to theirs for a heavy nip, hand going between my legs to rub my clit through my panties. "Grab a condom out of the console."
"We don't need one." I wanted to feel Indigo as closely as possible, craved that when I finally got out of the truck, it was with their cum pooling in my underwear.
They smirked, nibbling at my scent gland and making me go liquid in their hold. "I'm not too fucked about making sure I'm the dad, but damn would beating Cameo to the punch feel fucking good. You want my cum, doll?"
I nodded, taking hold of the alpha's belt, undoing the buckle.
"I want to be feeling you leaking out of me for hours, Indi.
.." The metal clanked as I popped the button of their jeans, lifting myself enough to make space to free their hardened cock.
"I'll go live just to show everyone how pretty my pussy looks when you're leaking out of it. "
Indigo groaned as my hand wrapped around their cock, and I felt.
.. strangely powerful. Usually, I preferred to be a little more submissive in bed, but this brief stint into teasing and demanding from my alpha had my skin feeling hot all over.
I stroked upward from their knot to their head, pausing when I felt the brush of something foreign against my skin.
"Fuck, Eva..." the alpha growled, "if you're not careful, I'll be pounding your sweet cunt for everyone to see. Better they get a look while I'm still warm inside you."
I glanced down, the silver of the piercing through the head of Indi's cock catching the low lights, a welcome surprise.
"You're pierced?" I whispered, licking my lips. "I've never—"
"Been with somebody with a pierced cock before?" they supplied, hips kicking into my hand eagerly. "Don't worry, doll, I think you'll find it's a nice surprise."
Indigo pulled the lever on their seat, and we fell backwards, their thumb pressing lazy circles against my clit, making me whimper and squirm.
They swept the strap of my dress off my shoulder, dragging their teeth over the sensitive skin upwards to my scent gland for a seductive suck that had me whimpering.
“Stop teasing,” I begged, basically pulling them into me.
“This is my first time really having you,” they said. “And I’ll have you exactly the way I want.”
I whined, feeling need like I’ve never felt it before. I’d waited, and wanted them for so long, and being so close had me feeling insistent.
But it seemed they really wouldn’t be rushed, no matter how many times I pressed down on them, my slick cunt rubbing against them.
Indi took my freed nipple into their mouth, licking their tongue over it.
“Fuck yes,” I said, pulling them closer, my nails clawing their scalp.
“You make it impossible to wait,” they said. “I wanted to take my time, but I can’t help it.”
“Don’t,” I said. “Take me. Please.”
They adjusted us so I was lined up right at their entrance.
“Relax for me,” they said, as they began to slide in.
God, they were big, filling every part of me so perfectly. I reached the first part of their piercing and gasped. It was an odd feeling. Not a bad one, but it rubbed inside of me harder, pressing into me in places I’d never felt before.
My body fell against theirs, hugging them as close to me as I could. Indi let their arms drape around me, tucking me into their chest as they fucked up into me.
“You feel just as perfect as I knew you would,” they whispered into my ear.
I could almost feel tears threaten to pour over my eyes.
“You too,” was all I could manage between moans.
“And if you have our baby,” they said, “we’d be the luckiest pack in the fucking world.”
“Indi, I’m…” I stuttered as my whole body shook.
It only took a few more thrusts for them to fill me up, coating my insides in cum.
After a while of cuddling and finishing our half-melted shakes, Indi took me home, walking me right up to the door.
They kissed me in front of my apartment, as if we’d just wrapped up a first date.
“I know we talked about a lot tonight,” they said. “But think about it.”
“I will,” I promised. And I would, I was… interested, I couldn’t lie.
Once my door was open and I was safe inside, they left, and I took a deep breath.
Tonight was… intense.
I should take some time, go to bed, and maybe take a shower. But I didn’t do any of that.
Instead, I sat my ass down at my computer and started researching. I pulled up the contract and searched for anything I didn’t know, checking off anything I was interested in and crossing off anything I wasn’t, which I was glad I did.
Who knew watersports wasn’t having sex on a jet ski?
Me… now.
Once I was satisfied, I did some more digging on these kinds of…
arrangements. Though there wasn’t anything exactly like we had, at least, nothing people were discussing on the internet, there were some resources.
Some of them were obviously… exaggerated, but it seemed a lot of people had some kind of contract when it came to forming BDSM relationships, especially with free use.
I continued scrolling, researching until the sun was almost up.
Until I was ready to make my choice.