Chapter 18
Eighteen
THEO
My heart is hammering in my chest at the speed of light, or the speed that the reindeer carry Santa around the world in one night.
For years I have held back, not wanting to take this step with anyone, as trust does not come easy for me, but within the short time I have spent with Colt and River, I have seen that I can trust them. Hell, my heart is telling me that love is right over the fucking horizon.
Most people would probably say that instant love is crazy, something that happens only in movies or cheesy romance books.
But when you actually feel it, it just makes sense—it feels right in your bones.
Love is love, no matter how fast it comes, and honestly, I want love in my life more than anything.
I deserve love.
“Are you sure, baby?” Colt asks, cupping my jaw with both hands.
The heat from his touch, the warmth from his breath, wash over me.
My lips part. My eyes close, and I nod.
I want to melt beneath him, having River at my side, soothing me through what I am about to do. Go all in, right?
As Colt faces me away from him, I see River still lying on the bed, looking as inviting as ever. A shiver runs through me at seeing his cock in his hand, pumping slowly, his thumb collecting the pre-come at the tip, using it as lube.
“I want you to taste him, boy. While I eat your ass, before I fuck it.” Colt’s deep voice penetrates my soul, and I do as he commands.
“Can I have that sweet mouth, Daddy? Please?” River begs.
“Yes, baby. Theo, suck his cock. I want to see you please him while I please you.” I shiver again at Colt’s command and I have to hope that this feeling, this anticipation, does not go away in our relationship.
All three of us are totally naked, and I have to say that we all look fucking good. Each of us brings something different to the bedroom. Normal is overrated, right?
Moving to the bed, River licks his lips as he watches my every move. His legs spread wide, his hands are out beckoning me to him, and his fingers are flexing in a come here motion.
Crawling onto the bed, my ass is on full display for Colt, but any concerns and fears leave me when I hear Colt growl in appreciation behind me. There is no way I would do this with any other man, as I just never felt safe or wanted before now.
It makes a person vulnerable to be in this position, but thankfully both River and Colt make me feel safe.
A hand settles on my ass, giving me a little love tap. “Ass up, baby.”
I arch my back more as I crawl and hell, I feel sexy while I do it. Licking my lips, I wink at River, inching my mouth down to the thick cock he has in his hand. He taps my tongue with the head a few times, making me moan.
“Can I command, Daddy, or will you tell us what to do?” River’s voice is thick with desire, deep and husky.
It sounds so sexy.
The bed dips behind me from Colt’s weight, and both of his large hands settle on my hips, before sliding down to my ass cheeks.
“Fuck, look at this ass. Perfection— both of my boys are perfect and designed just for me. I have missed out on you both for so long, but now that I am about to have you, you will be mine.”
A groan slips free when I feel his full weight, his chest to my back, his cock nestled between my ass cheeks. He rocks back and forth, making me whimper, and my dick leaks.
He kisses between my shoulder blades, my eyes closing in delight. A sigh slips from me, and the feeling of being where I want to be washes over me, then the head of a warm cock hits me on my bottom lip.
“Taste, baby.” River smiles.
Warm breath hits my ear, and the deep sound of Colt’s voice soothes me.
“Taste him, Theo. Open that delicious mouth, and fill it with his big cock. Do it for Daddy. Let me see you take him, like your ass will take me.” My ass clenches at the thought of being filled by him.
Dipping my head I lick the tip, sending a wave of shivers through River. His eyes close at the sensation, so I delve right in. Covering his shaft with my mouth, I swallow him whole.
“Fuck, he has no gag reflex,” River pants.
“My boy is keeping things from me.” Colt slaps my ass, making me jolt, the heat from his body gone as he leans back.
Wetness touches my tight hole as I suck on River’s cock. He moans in front of me, his hand on the back of my head, guiding me into a rhythm that he likes. My tongue licks over him as I suck and bob up and down, one hand cupping his balls.
Colt’s tongue pokes at my hole, and I jerk forward at the sudden intrusion as he breaches the outer ring.
“Easy, baby. I will not go in until you are ready. I will talk you through it; it is my job to take care of you, Theo. You be a good boy and take care of River for me, okay? Can you do that for Daddy?” Pulling off River’s cock, I look over my shoulder and I take my fill of Colt’s tattooed body, and my mouth waters.
“Yes, Daddy.”
“Like what you see, babe?” I nod.
“Fuck, yeah,” slips out, making him grunt, and his hand comes down, spanking me for swearing.
“I need a spanking too, Daddy.” River sounds bratty, making me chuckle.
He is trying to get a spanking because obviously he likes it.
“Later, baby boy. Theo, get to making River come down your throat. I want him to fill your mouth while I fill your ass.” He presses against my asshole and I moan, pushing back, needing more.
Watching Colt, he spits on my hole. Why is that so sexy?
Slowly he pushes a finger into me, the intrusion making me moan his name.
Never have I ever felt like this.
They make me feel things I never thought I would get to experience—every touch and word makes me crave more, opening up something deep inside me I didn’t know existed. There’s a trust and hunger here that’s completely new, and I’m lost in the way they both take care of me and each other.
Colt works his finger in and out of me, getting my tight ring to relax, then he adds another finger, scissoring the digits to open me up to be ready for him.
“Oh God, that feels good. I am ready, Daddy,” I cry.
That earns me a hard push of his fingers, the tips hitting my prostate and I cry, my head falling back in ecstasy.
“I say when you are ready, my baby boy.” He kisses my back, then licks at my damp skin.
Nodding, I go back to pleasing River. He is looking at me with a gaze full of adoration and desire, and that one look pushes me to please him to the best of my ability with my mouth.
“We come together, my boys,” Colt informs us.
I feel his thighs touch the back of mine, the head of his cock pressing against my hole.
“I am going to push in steadily, baby. It will hurt for a second, but you need to relax.”
“It will be the best feeling ever, honey.” River cups my jaw, my mouth still full of his cock.
“You okay, Theo?” I nod when Colt asks as he pushes into me more.
My body is coiled tight, but my ass is relaxed. I have read about how it may hurt if you tense up. So I focus on River, his smile, the way he is looking at me, then I grunt when Colt slips past the last barrier of muscles.
“Oh, fuck me, you are right, baby. God, this ass is perfect. The tight little hole, so good.” Colt’s dirty praise does it for me.
Who knew?
Colt stays still as my body adjusts to his size and the fact that he is the first dick that has been inside of me. He is claiming me, like I belong to him and so does River. My body comes alive at the thought of being his.
“You need to move, Daddy. Please,” I beg, panting.
Colt starts to fuck me, his hands on my hips, holding me while he fucks into me slowly at first, then he picks up the pace.
I get back to sucking River. My mind takes over and I no longer feel like the old shy, nerdy Theo who arrived here in Silverpine.
My head bobs up and down on his dick, taking him all the way down my throat. My tongue tickles the underside of the head while he pants my name, calling out encouraging words.
Every nerve tingles in my body, my skin damp with sweat as Colt fucks me. I notice everything that he does, and my whole body is like a live wire, loose on a string of Christmas lights.
“On your back; I want to see your face when you come, baby,” he demands, pulling out of me.
I hiss at the loss, then flip onto my back. Colt pushes my legs back, my knees almost hitting my shoulders, as he opens me up for him His cock slides right in with no resistance, my ass welcoming him inside.
“Oh, yes,” I grunt. “You feel so good, Daddy. You are fucking me so good.” I arch my neck, pushing my head into the bedding, and lips touch mine.
I kiss River back with no hesitation. We are all connected and fuck me, it feels beyond anything I have ever felt before. We moan against each other’s mouths while Colt grunts and growls as his hips piston in and out of me.
River moves to lie next to me, his body aligned with mine, his hands moving to tweak a nipple, making me hiss, and breaking the kiss.
“I am one lucky Daddy to have two sexy boys laid out for him like this. One taking my cock so well, while the other waits like a good boy.”
River preens at the praise, his hand finding my cock, and he starts to jerk me off in time with Colt’s thrusts.
Fucking heaven, I tell you.