Chapter 10
Chapter Ten
SILAS
A door clicks shut in the distance, stirring me partially awake. I open my blurry eyes and catch Ollie walking out of her bathroom.
Her hair is drawn up into a bun on the top of her head, and she’s now wearing a baggy pair of sweats and a crop top with no bra. She looks incredibly comfortable and sexy at the same time.
“Oh, you’re awake,” she says as she stops midway into her room.
“Barely,” I mumble. “What time is it?”
“Ten,” she says.
“Shit.” I rub my forehead. “I’m sorry.” I swing my legs over the end of the bed, and I stand, feeling so fucking sore that I groan.
“You okay?” she asks as she entwines her hands together.
“Fucking sore.” I hobble over to her bathroom, where I shut the door and take a piss. When I’m washing my hands, I glance up at my bloodshot eyes in the mirror and the frown on my face. The frown that appeared the moment I saw Sarah.
I thought I was prepared to see her. But I was so fucking wrong.
The moment my eyes found her, this dreadful feeling sucked all the air from my lungs, and I froze.
I can barely remember anything that she said other than that whatever she was saying was fake.
It was all fake.
She didn’t mean to come work at the Agitators? Bull-fucking-shit.
And the fact that she dyed her hair blonde, how I loved it, and wore the bodysuit I fucking loved on her? It was all premeditated to fuck with my head.
That’s exactly what happened too. She fucked with my head to the point that I kept looking back at her to see if she was really that fucking evil. And she was.
Evil . . . but also fucking pretty.
And I hate that I even thought that.
I hate that I felt a little something when she hugged me.
I hate that her smile thawed a part of my heart.
I hated everything about the goddamn interaction.
But most importantly, when Pacey pulled me to the side and told me to get my shit together, I hated that he pointed out that I was ignoring Ollie.
And he was right. I was. Because I didn’t know how to act around her. I’m not good at making an ex jealous and flaunting a new girlfriend—even though she’s fake. I felt like Sarah was watching my every move.
I push my hand through my hair, knowing I need to talk with Ollie. She deserved to be treated better.
My mouth feels dry, so I wet my finger with toothpaste. I quickly wipe down my teeth, then swish around her mouthwash for thirty seconds before spitting it out. That feels fucking better.
I exit her bathroom and head back into the main space, where I find her sitting cross-legged on her bed.
When she glances up at me, I just blurt out the first thing that comes to mind. “I’m fucking sorry, Ollie.”
She looks away and says, “It’s fine. No need to apologize.”
Yeah, she’s upset. From her downcast eyes to the slump of her shoulders, it’s plain as day. I fucked up . . . again.
I close the distance between us and hop up on her bed. I hook my finger under her chin and lift so her eyes meet mine. “It’s not fine. I was an ass, and I’m sorry.”
She tries to look away, but I don’t let her. That’s when I notice her eyes welling up with tears.
Shit.
“Fuck,” she mumbles. “I don’t know why I’m getting emotional. This is stupid.”
“Your feelings aren’t stupid.”
“That’s the thing, Silas. I shouldn’t have feelings about this.
It’s just . . . ughh,” she groans. “I felt embarrassed, okay?” She swipes at her eyes.
“And I’ve been wrestling with this emotion ever since you saw Sarah.
I realize that this is all just a job to us, going to these events, but it felt embarrassing when you completely forgot about me.
It’s more of a vanity thing on my end, but it mattered, and it just felt like .
. .” She pauses, gathering her words. “It felt like being with Yonny all over again. Like everyone else in the room is more important than I am, and I’m just an accessory to his agenda.
And I know that’s how this is supposed to be, but I guess it just hit me differently.
” She swipes at her eyes again. “Fuck, I hate crying.”
“I’m sorry,” I say again. “I didn’t mean to make you feel that way.”
“As I said, it’s fine.” She sets her phone on the charger on her nightstand, then scoots to the far end of the bed, where she slips under her covers. “I’m tired, so I’m just going to go to bed. You can let yourself out.”
She turns her back toward me, and I realize I have two options here. I can either let her be and probably end up fucking this friendship up more than I want, or I can stay and let her know that she isn’t just an accessory.
I choose the latter.
I switch her light off, and I pull her covers back and slip under them as well.
Startled, she turns to face me and says through teary eyes, “What are you doing?”
“I’m not going to leave you sad like this. You say it’s fine, but it’s not.”
“I don’t want to talk about it, Silas. It’s stupid, okay? I’m probably due for my period, so I’m more emotional than I care to admit.”
“Doesn’t lessen how you’re feeling,” I say softly. “I treated you like shit, and you don’t deserve that, even if you’re my fake girlfriend. I can understand where your embarrassment came from, and even though you asked me not to leave you, I still went off with Pacey.”
“That was fine. I talked with Winnie, and we had a good conversation. I’m not mad about that.”
“Doesn’t matter. I still went back on my word.” I take a chance and reach out to her, placing my hand on her bare waist. I allow my thumb to caress her skin. “I’m really sorry, Ollie. You deserve better than the way I treated you today.”
More tears spring from her eyes as she nods. “Thank you. I’m sorry I’m being so emotional about this.”
“Don’t apologize. You have no reason to apologize. I really fucked up, Ollie. I’m having a harder time dealing with the idea of Sarah being around than I thought I would.”
“I could tell you still have feelings for her,” Ollie says quietly.
“That’s it, though. I don’t,” I say. “I was mad. Irritated. Frustrated with her mindfuckery. That’s all this is to her, a way to fuck with my head, and it worked. And I’m so fucking mad at myself for letting her have that kind of control that I shut down. I shut down on myself and on you.”
“Are you sure you don’t still have feelings for her?”
“Positive,” I say, gripping her waist. “Did I think she looked good? Of course. That’s not something I can turn off, but when it came to how I felt, I was more irritated with her than anything.”
She slowly nods. “I can understand that feeling. I was irritated with Yonny the other night. He was kind, nice, and told me I deserved better than when we were together. What was the point of that?”
I rub my thumb along her skin again. “To fuck with you. That’s what they do. They try to mentally fuck with you. They try to keep us holding on to what we used to have.”
“Did it work for you?” she asks.
“It did. What about you?”
“A little,” she admits and then sighs, rolling to her back.
I keep my hand on her stomach, and I feel her breath force her stomach to rise and fall.
“I hate him. I think that’s the first time I truly admitted that.
I really hate him. Sure, was I captured for a moment at the fundraiser?
Yeah, but afterward, I felt empty and irritated, and I hate that he did that to me.
” She turns toward me and reaches out to play with my sweater. “Is that how she made you feel?”
“Yes,” I answer, feeling like I have a kindred spirit in her. “Really fucking irritated. To the point that I ignored the one person who could force me to smile, even when talking about donkey perversion.”
That makes her laugh as she curls into my chest and wraps her arm around my back. I return the embrace, letting my hand float up the back of her short shirt.
“I’m really fucking sorry, Ollie.”
“I know. Thank you.” She pulls away and sighs. “Now I’m the one who’s exhausted.”
“I think we both deserve some rest.”
“We do.” She yawns. “Okay. I’m going to shut my eyes.”
“Okay . . .” I swallow and ask, “Do you mind if I stay?”
“Not at all,” she says. “As long as you don’t snore.”
I chuckle. “No need to worry about that.” I lift and pull my sweater over my head before I lie back down and snuggle into one of her pillows.
I feel the need to wrap my arm around her and pull her into my chest, but I know that’s not the kind of friendship we have, so instead, I tuck my hands under the pillow and get comfortable. I would love nothing more than to take off my jeans, but that would also push my luck.
“Ollie?” I ask, hoping she hasn’t fallen asleep yet.
“Yeah?”
“Is your name short for anything?”
She turns toward me again and smiles. “How long have you been wanting to ask that?”
“Day one,” I answer.
“Day one, huh?” She smirks, and fuck, it’s so cute, especially with her resting on her pillow, free of makeup, a sleepy look in her eyes. “What took you so long?”
“Thought it was appropriate now. I like Ollie, but I was curious if it was a nickname for something else.”
“It is, but no one, not even my parents, calls me by my real name.”
“What is it?”
“Not sure I should tell you. I don’t want you thinking you can use it.”
“When would I use it?”
She moves an inch closer till our knees touch and says, “If you were mad at me. Or obsessed maybe. Or in some passionate—yet fake—moment when you call me by my birth name, thinking it will make me weak in the knees. It won’t happen.”
“Good, because I have zero intention of using it.”
“Well, as long as you have no intention of using it . . .” Her teeth run over the corner of her mouth before she says, “My real name is Oliana. Oliana Owens.”
Ollie-ahn-uh.
My lips rub together and test her name on my tongue. “Oliana.” I tip her chin up and say, “That’s really fucking pretty.”
“Don’t get any ideas,” she says, pointing her finger at me.
“Oliana,” I repeat to myself.
“Stop.” She playfully pushes at my chest, but I capture her hand.
“It’s really . . . really fucking pretty.”