Chapter 12
CHAPTER TWELVE
PENNY
“I…” I trail off. Why does he make me feel so shy?
“Of course you don’t have to do it if you’re not comfortable, but I think you are with us. Maybe you even feel like it’s a little too comfortable?”
I don’t move for a moment as I consider my options. But I know without a doubt what I want. He’s right, I’m just a little shy asking for it.
I pull my feet from Brax’s grasp and place them on the ground to brace myself as I undo my pants.
Ry helps lift my butt up as I slide my pants and underwear off at the same time, dropping them to the side.
I grab my top and pull it off over my head, throwing it with the rest of my clothes.
Ry places his hand on the top of my back and slowly pushes me forward.
I realize he’s trying to take off my bra and find myself impressed as he does it much faster than I’d expect.
He slowly slips the straps down my shoulders before it falls into my lap, and I toss it to the side.
I hear Ryker moan right before his teeth dig into my shoulder. He leans forward and stares down the front of my body. A flush goes through me at the same time he hardens against my naked ass in his lap. “Your turn,” he whispers in my ear.
“Truth or dare, Braxton,” I ask breathily as Ry grips my sides.
“Dare.”
“I—” Lord, how can I say that out loud?
“Dare him, Red,” Ry whispers in my ear.
My heart beats faster as I watch Brax’s heated gaze perusing my body.
“Look at the way he’s looking at you. You know he wants to do it. Just dare him.”
I bite my lip before speaking. “I dare you to lick my pussy until I come.”
I see the brief moment of shock on his face before he licks his lips in anticipation. He grabs my ankles and yanks me towards him, making me squeal before he dives in like a man on a mission.
“Brax!” I yell as he assaults my pussy with his tongue.
“Fuck, Red, watching you get all worked up like this is going to make me come in my pants.”
Ry’s grips my breasts before he pinches both my nipples, making my back arch off the ground as I cry out.
Brax must have a magic tongue because it doesn’t take more than two minutes for me to scream out my release as a flush moves through my entire body.
“Fuck, that was hot,” Ry groans from behind me. I glance up at him from where my head is resting in his lap.
I pant heavily as Brax pulls back with a smirk on his face, wiping his face with his hand and then licking his fingers clean.
“So hot…” I mumble.
Brax looks at Ry before he finally speaks. “Truth or dare, brother.”
“Dare,” Ryker answers so fast, I have to laugh.
Brax grins. “I dare you to make love to our woman until she comes on your cock… twice.” Ry let out a long groan as I get even wetter.
Brax moves over my body, pressing his lips to mine.
“If that’s okay with you, Baby?” I nod eagerly and he pulls me up from Ry’s lap so he can strip off his clothes.
“Truth or dare, Penny?” Ry asks, surprising me.
“Aren’t we still in the middle of one?”
“I think we can do two at once, so what’ll it be?” My eyes dart to Brax as I reply.
“Dare.”
“I dare you to make Brax come at the same time as you, anyway you want.”
I lick my lips as my eyes roam his body, thinking about all the possibilities.
“Strip,” I tell him.
Ryker moves towards me, turning my face towards him as he kisses my forehead, then my nose, then my lips.
Soon I’m wrapping my arms around his neck as he plunders my mouth with his tongue, making me moan.
His hands roam my body and when he squeezes my ass, I lift a leg to wrap it around his back, wanting to be closer to him.
He sits back on his ass and pulls my other leg around him and instantly my pussy is rubbing against his hard length.
I gasp as I start grinding myself furiously on him.
“Penny, you keep doing that, I’m going to blow my load before I’m even inside of you. And I’m under strict instructions to make you come twice.”
Without pulling my mouth from his, I pull my hips up to line myself up with his cock and slowly sink down on him. His fingers dig into my hips as he slows my movements, clearly wanting to feel me wrap around him.
He groans into my mouth as he bottoms out inside me.
“Fuck, Penny, you feel so amazing.” I pull my head back and glance over his shoulder at Brax, where he’s waiting there in all his naked glory. I give him a wink before turning back to Ry.
I push his chest as I command him, “Lay back.” He tries to pull me down with him, but I stay sitting and he watches as I slowly roll my hips, my hands pressed to his chest. Slowly, I start rocking my hips faster and faster.
“Hell, Red. You look gorgeous like that, like you’re riding a large buck.”
“I am,” I say with a grin as I start to rock my hips faster.
He grips my hips and helps me move against him before he moves one hand to my clit and starts rubbing furiously, making me moan loudly.
Braxton’s hands skate around my sides before reaching up and pinching my nipples, it pushes me over the edge and I cry out as I convulse around Ry’s hard length lodged deep inside me.
When I finally come down from my climax, I look down at Ryker and smile. “Wow.”
“That was amazing, I hope you're ready for number two, Red, because I can barely hold myself back right now.”
“I feel like I should say no, but I can’t help myself, I think I’m always going to want more of you two.”
“Good. I think you have a dare to take care of?” He raises an eyebrow at me and I lick my lips and tilt my head over my shoulder to look at Brax.
“Brax? Come closer.” He moves up against my back as his hands continue massaging my breasts.
“Brax… will you… will you…”
“She wants you to fuck her in the ass, Brax.”
“Ryker!” I gasp, turning my wide eyes on him.
“Am I wrong?” I glare at him, but it only makes him smile bigger.
Braxton kisses my shoulder before whispering, “Is that really what you want, Baby? You want me to fuck you… here.” He pushes a finger into my ass, making me gasp as I press myself further on to Ryker’s cock, making him moan.
“Yes, Brax!”
“That’s a good girl for telling me what you want, now lean forward.” He presses me down towards Ryker, who pulls my face to his, taking advantage of our lips being so close as he kisses me fiercely.
I moan into his mouth as my body tightens when Brax starts pressing in. It’s so tight!
“Fuck, I didn’t think you could get any tighter!” Ry groans, parroting my thoughts.
It doesn’t take them long to find a rhythm of push and pull between our bodies. I can tell Ryker is desperate to come when he starts gritting his teeth.
“I can’t hold out much longer,” he cries.
“Then don’t, come Ryker, come in me.” My words must push him over the edge as he grips my hips and fills me with his seed. I told them I can’t get pregnant, much to their disappointment, but I silently hope my IUD fails as I think about carrying their child. Where did that thought come from?
Ryker pulls me tight to him as Brax starts thrusting into me hard from behind.
“Oh… my… god!” I scream, never having been fucked in the ass by a person before. It’s different, but amazing.
I come again as Brax roars out his release behind me. He kisses my back before he slowly pulls out of me. Ry slowly pulls me off him before rearranging me at his side. Braxton finds something to clean us up with before dropping down on my other side.
They both drape an arm over my middle, as we all lay there staring at the ceiling in silence.
Our breaths are the only thing to be heard in the large cavern.
I think about how lucky I am to have these two amazing men at my side through this adventure.
I know my mission is finding Ria, but is it so bad if I find a home for myself along the way?
“Penny, I want to ask you something.” Ryker breaks the silence.
“What is it?” I turn to search his face, wondering what he wants to ask me, but I’m unsure of his expression. He looks… nervous? Hopeful?
“Is there room in your heart for more than one man?” My mouth drops open, but no words come out.
Braxton uses two fingers to turn my face towards him as he speaks.
“Baby, you should know this world can be a little harsh… a little dangerous for women. You would be safest if you had multiple mates to take care of you. We want you to have more men to help protect you. That is, if you don’t mind having lonelings as mates. ”
“You’re saying… that you want to be my… boyfriends? Is that what mate means?”
“No, Baby,” Braxton shakes his head at me with a loving look in his eye. His hand on my face gently caresses my cheek. “I’m saying I want you to marry me.”
I gasp as I pull my head back in shock. I slowly sit up and they both follow.
“Marry us, Red,” Ry whispers as he wraps his arm around my waist.
“You’re… you’re serious?”
“Yes.”
“Absolutely,” they answer.
“But why would you want to marry me?”
“Baby…” Brax reaches down and grabs my hands, pulling my knuckles to his lips for a kiss.
“You are the most gorgeous being I have ever laid eyes on. But your beauty also shines from within. You’re smart, funny and I haven’t smiled as much as I have in the two days since I met you, in the entire rest of my life combined.
” My eyes widen at the revelation. He smiles so easily for me.
That was… rare for him? Something about his smiles being just for me, makes a warmth build in my chest.
“Penny,” Ryker starts, and I turn slightly to see his face.
“The moment I saw you in that cave, I knew I was a goner. I can feel you, in here.” He places his hands on his heart and I mirror his moment on myself, because I feel the same thing.
“I don’t know if this is fate, but I know that every moment I spend with you, I find myself falling deeper and deeper in love with you. Marry us, Penny?”