18. Theodore
18
theodore
My muscles protested as I lifted the saddle off of Maleficent. She huffed as I rubbed her back, then rubbed my hands up and down her mane. The last few weeks, she was my saving grace, as my mind was a chaotic mess of emotions with Nova at the epicenter of it all.
I thought when we all said we were ok with pursuing her that it would ease my anxiety, but it had only increased since we left everything out in the open. The beginning of the school year was busy for Nova and Sol, showing me that Nova really didn’t have breaks for herself. She was constantly working, providing for Sol, something that, ideally, two people should share the burden of.
The more the days passed by, I worried she would change her mind. She would talk herself out of whatever this could be, even though each time I kissed her I felt her need burning just like my own. But the longer I went without seeing her, the more I worried that I had imagined her need and longing in my head.
It was a dirty day on the ranch, which gave me an excuse to use the back door to the cabin and not have to run into Colt who was starting to give me the look I hated. He was five seconds away from sitting me down and making me talk about my feelings that I didn’t even understand.
Unlocking the door as quietly as possible, I snuck into the house, removing my boots and muddy jeans at the door. I faintly heard Colt in the kitchen cooking what smelled like Italian. My stomach grumbled as I realized that I hadn’t had lunch. I would definitely hear about it later. Once my muddy clothes were off, I slipped into the room, closing the door softly behind me.
A gasp made me turn around quickly to see Nova in just a towel by the bed. My eyes widened as I blinked a couple of times to make sure I wasn’t imagining her in my bedroom, naked with nothing but a towel between me and her.
My brain was stunned, no matter how hard I tried to get words out, I got distracted by her legs or the curve of her neck or the tops of her breasts peeking out. My mouth watered with the need to taste her even though I had never been with a woman.
“I’m sorry,” she squeaked, grabbing the clothes on the bed.
“I didn’t know,” I said, turning around to leave.
“I just need to change, if you need the shower, you can go ahead,” she said, the panic still in her voice.
I didn’t know what to do, frozen with fear that I would do something wrong.
“Hey, it’s ok.” Nova’s voice was closer than before. “Colt and Sol drew me a bath and?—”
“I came through the back, and I didn’t see them,” I said softly.
“Ok.” Nova smiled, a slight blush on her cheeks, so close that I could pull her towards me and kiss her.
She looked up at me expectantly and all thoughts of being a gentleman went out the door. I grabbed her by the waist, pulling her towards me.
“I want you so much, Nova,” I murmured, leaning down.
“I think I’m tired of fighting this, but I’m scared,” she said, looking up at me. “It’s not just me who will be hurt if this doesn’t work, but Sol is my priority.”
I nodded. “She’s our priority too, but we still need to talk, we want this to work.”
This time it was Nova who pulled me forward, kissing me, licking the seam of my mouth to deepen the kiss. I groaned at her boldness, kissing her for what felt like the first time. It wasn’t rushed or in front of people. It was just her and I, like I had wanted since I kissed her the first time.
She moaned as I brushed my tongue against hers, pulling her body flush with mine. Her breasts pushed against my chest, the softness of her body was exhilarating. Even though I was nervous about doing anything else other than kissing her, I wanted more. Running my hands down her sides I skimmed the edge of the towel. It would be so easy to flick the towel off her body and have my fill of her.
“Theo,” she groaned against my lips, threading her hands through my hair.
“Nova,” I whispered, kissing down her neck.
Her hands roamed my body down to the front of my boxers running her hands over my cock. I shivered from the contact, nipping her neck and thrusting into her hand. She whimpered and it snapped the last thread of restraint I had. I bent down to pick her up when the door opened and I pushed her behind me, seeing Atlas at the door with a raised brow. He looked between Nova and I as his smile grew.
“Sorry,” he said, closing the door behind him. “I hope I wasn’t interrupting anything.”
I glared at him, wanting her to myself even if it was just for five minutes, this need for her attention to be solely mine was a new feeling. I had never felt like that with one of the guys.
“Just a kiss,” Nova mumbled against my back.
“Sorry, I can go,” Atlas smirked.
He knew exactly what he was doing but this might actually work out in our favor.
“I was just wanting to relax Nova even further,” I said, blushing from my boldness.
Atlas narrowed his eyes on me until his eyes grew as he remembered that I had never been with a woman before.
“Oh, I think that’s something we can do,” he purred, walking to us. “That’s if it’s alright with you, Nova.”
I grabbed her, pulling her in between us, her back to my front as she looked at Atlas. She leaned against me as Atlas stopped in front of us. Nova’s ass brushed below my cock sending pleasure through me.
“P-please,” she whined.
“Can I kiss you?” Atlas asked, tilting her head up.
“Yes,” she whispered, and then their lips made contact.
They moaned, deepening the kiss and Atlas pushed her against me. I kissed her neck as I grabbed Atlas’ hair, tugging enough to cause him a little pain, but not pull them away.
“Fuck, Nova,” he groaned, looking at me as he kissed her.
My stomach tightened in pleasure, with the small movements of Nova’s ass, I could come from that alone.
I tightened my grip on Atlas’ hair. “I think it's time you taught me.”
“Fuck,” Atlas whimpered. “I can teach you, baby.”
“Teach?” Nova leaned her head to look at me.
“Nova, I’m taking this towel off and if at any point you don’t like this, just say stop, ok?” Atlas said, cupping her face. “We will stop immediately.”
“Ok,” she said, her voice husky, making my dick throb with need. “My body isn’t how it used to be and?—”
“You're gorgeous, you gave life,” I growled. “Your body can do what we can’t, it’s your badge of honor for the sacrifice you made for your child.”
“You’re beautiful, Nova. I don't even have to see you to know that. Whether you have stretch marks or anything that you think is imperfect, I can guarantee that I will love every part of you.” Atlas kissed her.
She moaned as he pulled the towel off, letting it hit the floor, and all oxygen left my body. I didn’t have the best view of her body, but it was enough to make me forget about everything except this gorgeous woman in front of me.
“What are we teaching?” she panted, as Atlas kissed down her chest, trailing down her stomach, kneeling right before her pussy.
Our breathing grew quicker as we waited to see what Atlas was going to do.
“Theo has never touched a woman before.” Atlas kissed her loudly above her slit.
Nova shifted her head back to look at me as my face grew red from embarrassment.
“Theo,” she moaned, running her hand up my hair. “Never?”
Her face twisted with pleasure. I glanced down to see Atlas lifting her leg up, licking her pussy as he stared at me.
“Nope, he’s only ever been with us,” Atlas groaned.
“I was never interested in casual sex,” I said, needing to touch her, but my hands were trembling, and I didn’t know why.
She pulled me down for a kiss as she gasped into my mouth. I captured her moans, setting one hand on her hip, gripping at her hips, thrusting into her.
“Oh, fuck,” she moaned loudly.
“Oh, darling, you better be quick or we are going to have to put that mouth to good use,” I growled, looking down at Atlas who was looking up at us as his tongue flicked up and down then sucked on her clit, at least that is what I assumed was happening.
“Nova, I think it’s time we gave Theo a taste, show him how to make you come,” Atlas said, kissing her pussy one last time before standing up.
“Yes,” Nova murmured.
I grabbed Atlas, kissing him, desperate to see what she tasted like. A loud moan cut through the silence until I realized it was me chasing her taste on his tongue. Nova whimpered, pulling my attention back to her.
“You guys are so sexy,” she said, looking at us through half-lidded eyes.
“Lay down, Nova,” I commanded.
“In the middle of the bed,” Atlas added.
She turned around, got on the bed and bent over seductively, throwing us a little look over her shoulder. We had a perfect view of her ass, and I took a deep breath to keep myself from pounding in her.
“Shit,” Atlas groaned, palming his cock through his slacks.
She laid down with her hair fanned out against the bed, palming her breasts, letting her legs fall apart so we could see her hot center. Nova was intoxicating, like she was weaving her spell, pulling me towards her.
“Wait,” Atlas said. “I have a better idea.”
He grabbed her leg, pulling her to the edge of the bed, kneeling before her and I followed.
“Watch me,” Atlas said, throwing her leg over his shoulder.
He trailed a finger down her slit from her swollen clit down to her opening then back up, circling around her clit. Nova sighed when he leaned forward, licking her pussy, then sucking on her clit. Atlas alternated between kissing or sucking her clit and diving his tongue into her pussy. They moaned together as I got impatient.
“Atlas,” I growled.
“Your turn,” Atlas said with glistening lips, making my mouth water. “But let me rearrange her.”
He picked her up sitting behind her, spreading her legs for me as his hand went down her stomach, swirling his fingers over her pussy. He spread her even more.
“Theo, be a good student and make Nova come hard,” he said, his voice deep with desire.
I wasted no time flattening my tongue against her pussy, licking all the way up to her clit, looking up at them. Nova whimpered, running a hand through my hair as I did it again, sucking on her clit softly, worried about doing it too hard.
“That's it, Theo,” he groaned, palmed her breast, then pinched her nipple. “Flick your tongue over her clit a few times before sucking on her again.”
I nodded, doing exactly what he said.
“Does it feel good?” Atlas whispered in her ear.
“Yes,” she moaned, spurring me on.
I kissed her clit, lavishing it with attention, wondering if this was enough to have her come for me.
“Now slide your finger in her slowly,” Atlas commanded. “Fuck her slowly.”
I watched as my finger disappeared in her tight pussy, fucking her slowly as I watched, completely mesmerized. Nova’s hips rolled, fucking herself on my finger.
“More,” Nova whined, and I went with my instincts.
I pushed another finger in her as I kissed her clit, flicked my tongue, kissing it again and sucking a little harder.
“Oh!” she cried out, trying to close her legs.
“Oh, no, Nova, keep those legs spread open, we aren’t done with you yet,” Atlas growled.
Nova was drunk on pleasure, shooting confidence through me as I doubled my efforts. I wanted to make her feel good; I needed it.
“Look at our good boy,” Atlas cooed. “Doesn’t he look great on his knees, pleasuring you?”
Y-yes,” she whined, her gaze was intense before she closed her eyes.
“Eyes on me, Nova,” I clipped, curling my fingers.
Her eyes opened quickly as I did it again.
“That’s it, Theo, look what you're doing to our girl.” Atlas kissed her neck.
“I’m—I’m…”
Nova’s pussy fluttered around my fingers as I doubled my efforts curling my fingers more until her pussy clamped down on my fingers. I kissed, licked, and sucked her through her orgasm while Atlas said things in her ear that I couldn’t hear.
“Too—too sensitive,” Nova whined, trying to close her legs.
Atlas kept them open as I gave her one last lick. I got up, capturing Nova in a kiss desperate to do more for her.
“Let me see what she tastes like on your lips, Theo,” he groaned, kissing me.
Our tongues tangled, urgency clawed at me for release when a knock on the door made us all freeze.
“Momma, food is almost done!” Sol yelled, as I raced to the door in case she tried to come in.
“I’m almost done!” Nova shouted back. “I’ll be right there!”
“Hurry up, Momma!”
Nova quickly got up from Atlas’ lap, her face bright red. She put on clothes in a hurry without looking at us and a sinking feeling made me worry.
“Hey, are you ok?” Atlas asked, thankfully.
“Yeah,” she glanced at him and then me. “I just… that was close, she could have come in and…”
“Next time we will be more careful,” I said, licking my lips while still tasting her.
“Ok,” she said, looking down as she left the room.
“Shit, maybe we shouldn’t have done that.” Atlas rubbed the back of his neck.
“I didn’t even think about Sol,” I muttered. “Did we fuck up?”
“I hope not,” he sighed. “We will figure this out.”
He kissed me softly, and just like my cock deflated by what had just happened.