Chapter 4
Sophie
Somewhere along his walk Mr. Grumpy Pants got a personality transplant. It’s the only explanation for the guy that returns.
He still looks the same, but he gives me a smile. Or at least, what I think must pass as a smile from him, which is to say he doesn’t grimace. “I don’t think we started this new roommate situation on the right foot. I’d like to start again.”
I eye him suspiciously from my place on the couch where I’ve taken to scrolling through his streaming services. I looked through his profile. Mainly, he watches sport games and documentaries.
I added my own profile, identifying myself as Roommate. I figured it was politer than logging him out of his account, so I could sign into mine. I added a few of my movies and TV shows to my favorites to get the algorithm populating.
Then I tried to call my mom again, but my phone service isn’t that great right now. It might have something to do with that thick, white fog that’s rolling in.
Tobias is purring against my thigh, quiet and happy without a care in the world. All he knows is that he’s with me, and he’s safe.
“I’m Whiskey, and this—” He gestures toward a big beast of a dog that pushes her way into the cabin. “This is Bella. She’s a Bernese Mountain Dog that adopted me a few months back.”
Several of the actors on the show used to bring their dogs along, and I always loved it. I hold out my hand for her to sniff. Every dog is a good one if you ask me.
She gives me a long sniff before licking my fingers. Her tongue tickles, and I can’t help the giggle that escapes my lips. Animals are so easy to love. They don’t judge us.
Bella gives Tobias a sniff then settles onto the hardwood floor with a soft sigh, like she can’t believe she has guests. She seems just as much of an introvert as her pet parent.
I glance up to find Whiskey staring at me, an expression I can’t quite describe on his face. He’s looking at me like he’s craving something sweet, and I’m the last candy apple at the carnival.
He seems to realize he’s staring and gives his head a shake. “I didn’t get your name earlier.”
“That’s because you were busy trying to throw me out.” I don’t know what it is about this man, but I want to spend all my time teasing him. I like how gruff he gets when he’s annoyed.
“Bygones.” He waves a calloused hand as if erasing the last two hours including the fact that he tried to have me arrested.
“And calling me a witch.” I cross my arms over my chest. I know he’s playing some game, but I’m not sure what it is just yet. Still, I like the idea of playing with him. Way more than I probably should.
“If the broom fits…” This time he gives me a real smile, not just that grimace he was showing off earlier. I kind of like it.
He clears his throat. “I was just about to make myself some dinner. I could make enough for two if you’d like.”
“My name is Sophie,” I tell him.
“Sophie,” he repeats my name softly and for some crazy reason, I find myself blushing.
It’s not like I’ve never been around attractive men before. It’s that none of them have ever done it for me. Not like this rugged mountain man who seems to be slowly learning what it means to be human.
“Do you like butternut squash soup?”
My mom and I spend most of our time surviving off whatever is in the frozen aisle of the supermarket. Neither of us like cooking too much. We’d much rather be reading scary stories and talking about upcoming storylines for her show. “I’ve never had it before. Is it good?”
“Perfect for an autumn night like tonight when the weather is chilly. Come on, I’ll share my should-be-famous recipe with you.”
Something howls outside. “Is that a wolf?”
“Probably.” He walks into the kitchen, and I follow him, watching as he puts squash on the cutting board on the island. He reaches for the knife block, selecting a large one that looks almost small in his massive hands.
He seems too nonchalant about this. Then again, maybe he hears them everyday, the same way I was used to seeing zombies every day. “Do you have a lot of wolves around here?”
“Oh, these woods are filled with all sorts of creatures.” Something about the way he says it reminds me of the way a kid might tell a story around the campfire.
“What’s the scariest thing you’ve ever seen around here?”
I’ve always been drawn to supernatural things, probably because my mom let me read her Stephen King and Dean Koontz novels when I was in the fifth grade. Ever since then, I’ve been obsessed with everything spooky.
“Oh, I don’t know that I’ve seen anything scary.” He taps the knife methodically against the bamboo cutting board, keeping a perfect rhythm. “Well, there was that one story, but you probably don’t want to hear about it.”
“Don’t tell me my rental cabin is haunted,” I half-joke with him.
Annoyance flickers in his gaze, probably at my mention of the rental cabin. I know I don’t imagine it. He quickly schools his expression. “I wouldn’t use the word haunted exactly. I think most ghosts are friendly after all.”
“You have a ghost?” I gasp.
His eyes light up, and yeah, this is what he wanted.
He wanted an audience to tell his story to.
He reminds me of those old-timers that I saw sitting out on the bench outside Emma May’s grocery store, swapping stories about who had the largest fish.
Only there’s no fish here. Just ghosts. “Now, don’t be worried. I’m pretty sure she’s friendly.”
“Has anything spooky happened because of her?” I don’t believe in ghosts, but if they do exist, I’d want to meet one. I mean, how cool would that be?
“Sometimes, I wake up and the furniture has been rearranged, dishes left in the sink, writing on the bathroom mirror, and well, there are the strips of white fabric left in the woods outside. Poor thing.” He stops there and shakes his head before moving to the stove and grabbing a large pot.
He puts chopped onion and salt in before grabbing his grinder and adding black pepper too.
He nudges the cutting board and knife toward me, putting down three garlic cloves. “Chop them. If you eat, you work.”
After a few minutes of silence, I can’t help but ask, “Do you know why she’s here? Is it you or this place?”
“Well,” he pauses and looks up from his pot. “You don’t scare easy, do you? I don’t want to freak you out seeing as we’re roommates and all.”
His words are easy going enough but I see the slight tension in his neck. He really hates having someone in his space. Is it weird that his annoyance makes me want to stay even more, like I could have the best vacation ever just because I know it would drive him nuts?
“I mean, I don’t like…enjoy scary movies and stuff. But you can just summarize the whole story for me. I think I should probably know,” I answer, playing along.
He sighs deeply. He could win a Razzie. Maybe all the Razzies for the next ten years. “I suppose you should, so if weird things start happening, then you can be completely prepared.”
“So, the furniture moves and there are creepy messages left behind in your bathroom mirror…what else?”
“There’s the uh…the crying. You can hear her wailing some nights, and the white strips of fabric left behind.
And the worst one of all, the way she comes right up to the windowpanes sometimes and scrapes her long, dirty fingernails against them.
” He shudders. “That sound alone could drive a person to the brink of insanity.”
“Not you though,” I point out. I want to add that he already seems halfway there with this lame ghost story of his. Probably best not to insult my host directly.
“There are nights when the whole room gets freezing, and you wake in a cold sweat because you could swear she’s there, staring right down at you. It’s a chill unlike any other. It’s cold that seeps all the way into your bones.”
“And you don’t know why she’s here?” I push the chopped garlic cubes to him. He adds them and broth to his pot. The whole kitchen smells like onion and garlic, filling me with a cheery warmth despite my host’s chilly reception.
“There’s a rumor, but well, it’s just that.
It’s a rumor. People talk, you know? They make up stories to explain the things they don’t understand.
It doesn’t make any of it true.” He glances around then leans in close, filling my nose with a whiff of his pine and something scent.
“They say she was a bride. Married her true love on Halloween. They booked this cabin for their honeymoon.”
“What happened?”
“That’s the thing. No one knows for sure. A hiker stumbled across the cabin the next day. The door was ajar, and he pushed inside very carefully. She was sitting in the middle of the floor, still in her wedding dress. But utterly alone.”
He pauses there for a minute, probably trying to let this story take its dramatic effect. “She never spoke again.”
“Was her groom ever found?” This guy should write for one of those urban legend sites online. There are too many details missing to make this story even halfway believable.
“No on ever saw him again after the wedding. But late at night, she paces this cabin, searching desperately for her lost love.”
I shiver then, watching the way his eyes light up. Yeah, he really does think I scare easy.