Chapter Three - James
CHAPTER THREE
James
Without Vanessa's things, James's apartment looked like a high-end real estate listing. Immaculate. Perfect. And utterly lifeless—just like the rest of his carefully curated existence.
He loosened his tie and poured himself a scotch, allowing one small wrinkle in his evening routine. His phone buzzed—probably another message from his mother about the family dinner he was definitely not attending. Instead, he found himself opening Instagram.
The algorithm knew exactly what to show him.
There she was. Vanessa. She was wearing a dress he'd bought her for Christmas, laughing at something off-camera. The caption read: Some people walk into your life exactly when you need them to followed by a heart emoji.
James took a larger sip of scotch than strictly necessary. The next photo showed who had walked into her life—Trevor Martinez, board member at First National, leaning in close with practiced intimacy. James recognized that move. He'd perfected it himself for countless social media photos, the carefully calculated angle that suggested romance without being too obvious.
She'd already replaced him.
The word 'replace' stung more than he wanted to admit. James Park wasn't replaceable. He was the one who replaced others—at work, in deals, in life. He was the upgrade, not Trevor Martinez with his second-rate business school and derivative investment strategies.
He scrolled through the comments, each one hitting him like a personal betrayal: You guys are perfect together! ??(Posted by the wife of a client he'd secured for Vanessa last year) So happy for you V! Upgrade! ?? (From his former tennis partner's sister) Power couple alert! ??
The last one was from someone in Product Development, who'd just asked him to review her proposal yesterday. He made a mental note to be particularly thorough with his criticism. Let them all see what happened when they bet on the wrong horse.
His fingers tightened around his glass. She'd probably been planning this while she sat across from him at Le Petit Jardin, crafting her speech about his emotional unavailability. Well, he'd show her exactly how emotionally available he could be—with someone else.
Setting down his glass harder than necessary, James pulled up Trevor's profile. Harvard Business School (James had gone to Wharton). Summer home in the Hamptons (James preferred Nantucket). Recent feature in Business Insider about "40 Under 40" (James had made that list two years ago).
"Trevor Martinez," James tested the name, hating how it sounded. Had Vanessa been thinking of Trevor when she'd criticized James's work hours? When she'd complained about his distance? When she'd—
His phone buzzed again. This time it was Mike: Dude. You seeing this?
I see it , James typed back.
Want to get a drink? Plan some strategy?
James was about to agree when another notification popped up. The building's community newsletter, which he usually deleted without reading. But there, in the bottom corner, was a photo that caught his eye.
The lobby woman—Hannah something—surrounded by elderly residents and cardboard hearts, leading some kind of Valentine's craft activity. She looked exactly as he remembered—plain, unpolished, and completely unaware of the camera. Nothing like Vanessa's sleek, perfectly curated presence.
Vanessa had always rolled her eyes at his building's community events. She'd dismissed James's family's approach to volunteer work, suggested he distance himself from anything too "local."
His fingers hovered over his phone. No need , he wrote to Mike, I already have a strategy.
??? Details needed.
James looked at the newsletter photo again, studying it with new intensity. Hannah. The woman who straightened the lobby's artwork, who helped his elderly neighbors without being asked, who smiled at him even though he'd barely acknowledged her existence.
She had a nondescript, forgettable sort of look. Nothing attention-grabbing like Vanessa—just plain, unremarkable features and an easygoing demeanor that would irritate Vanessa to no end.
He could picture it perfectly: Vanessa opening social media to find him—successful, ambitious James Park—happily coupled with the kind of genuine, community-minded woman she'd always dismissed as beneath their social circle.
The kind of woman who wore sensible shoes and bought her clothes off the rack. The kind of woman who would make Vanessa question everything she thought she knew about him.
Vanessa said I cared too much about status, James texted. Time to prove her wrong. Let's go full 'man of the people.'
He scrolled through the newsletter, finding more photos of Hannah. Here she was helping with a senior citizens' craft fair. There she was organizing a building food drive.
Each image was like a weapon in his arsenal, a way to show Vanessa that she'd been wrong about him—that he could be exactly what she'd wanted, just not with her.
And Hannah? She'd be easy to convince. She probably dreamed about being asked out by someone like him. Really, he'd be doing her a favor. One fancy dinner, a few strategic social media posts, and everyone would win.
Well, everyone except Vanessa.
Three dots appeared as Mike typed. Then: Brilliant. She'll hate it. When do we start?
James smiled, a sharp edge to it that would have worried anyone who knew him well. He opened Nero's website, checking their Valentine's Day availability. Booked solid. But with his contacts, that wouldn't be a problem.
We start now , he replied to Mike.
He glanced at Vanessa's post again. She thought she could replace him that easily? Show him up with Trevor Martinez and his summer home and his Business Insider feature?
Fine. He'd show her exactly what she was missing. And if he had to use the lobby woman—Hannah—to do it, well...
She'd probably be grateful for the attention anyway.
══════════════════
For the first time in three years, James Park lingered in his building's common areas. He'd chosen a strategic position in the small library adjacent to the lobby, laptop open as if working, but his attention was focused on studying his target.
Hannah—he'd made sure to learn her name properly—was helping another resident sort through a stack of old photographs. Her head was bent close to the elderly woman's, brown hair falling forward as she listened to what was undoubtedly another endless story about her grandchildren.
James had always avoided these conversations, but Hannah seemed genuinely interested, asking questions that made the woman's face light up with pleasure.
Perfect , he thought, making mental notes. Vanessa had always said he was self-absorbed, too focused on status to care about "real people." Well, what could be more real than dating someone who volunteered with the elderly?
He watched Hannah walk her to the elevator, noting how she naturally offered her arm for support. No calculated movements, no checking for witnesses to her good deed. It was genuine, which made it even more useful for his purposes.
"James?" A querulous voice interrupted his observations. "Is that you hiding behind that computer?"
He looked up to find Mrs. Chen watching him with shrewd eyes. Normally, he would have made an excuse and escaped, but he needed to start building his community-minded image.
"Mrs. Chen," he said, summoning his best client-meeting smile. "I was just catching up on some work."
"Mm." Her eyes flicked to Hannah, now helping Mr. Thompson with what appeared to be a jammed mailbox. "Interesting place to work. You usually prefer your apartment."
James forced himself to maintain eye contact. "Sometimes a change of scenery is good for productivity."
"Indeed." Mrs. Chen's expression suggested she wasn't fooled. "Though some scenery requires more careful observation than others."
Before James could respond, Hannah's laugh cut across the lobby. She'd succeeded in unjamming Mr. Thompson's mailbox and was now sorting through the rescued letters with him, apparently unbothered by the fact that this was definitely not her job.
Vanessa would hate her , James realized with satisfaction. Everything about Hannah—from her sensible flats to her obvious lack of designer labels—would drive his image-conscious ex crazy. But more than that, Hannah's natural warmth would make Vanessa question everything she'd accused him of being.
Too career-focused? Here he was, dating someone who clearly valued community over ambition. Emotionally unavailable? Just look at how comfortable he was with someone so openly caring. Unable to connect with "real people"? Well, the photos would speak for themselves.
"You know," Mrs. Chen's voice cut through his plotting, "my husband always said you can tell a person's character by how they look at others. Whether they see people, or opportunities."
James smiled blandly, already composing the perfect Instagram caption in his head. Something about finding unexpected connections, about learning to value the simple things in life. Vanessa would recognize the pointed reference to her criticisms.
"I should get back to work," he said, standing. He'd seen enough to know Hannah would be perfect for his plan. One fancy dinner, a few strategic public appearances, and Vanessa would realize exactly what she'd let slip through her fingers.
"Yes," Mrs. Chen said quietly. "I suppose you should."
As James packed up his laptop, he caught another glimpse of Hannah. She was now helping a young mother manage a stroller through the front doors, cooing at the baby while holding the door open. Such a natural caretaker. Such an obvious contrast to Vanessa's sleek sophistication.
Some people walk into your life exactly when you need them to , Vanessa's Instagram caption echoed in his mind. Well, Hannah had walked into his lobby at exactly the right moment. The fact that she had no idea she was about to become a pawn in his game was irrelevant.
After all, he was James Park. He didn't lose—not deals, not face, and certainly not to Trevor Martinez.
And if Hannah got a nice dinner and a taste of his world in the process? Well. No harm done.