Chapter 9
The Devil You Know
Harper
Okay, I can do this. I can walk into this party with Luke’s cum dripping out of my pussy and a plug wedged in my ass. I try to look normal and hope my face isn’t as red as it feels.
“Relax.” Luke tugs me into his side and pats my ass right over the plug.
Oh! My eyes widen as a jolt of pleasure races through me. Fuck.
We’re in the hallway almost to the door. The muted sounds of the party in full swing reach us.
Luke leans down so his lips touch my ear. “You sure you don’t want to do the demonstration instead, princess? You could ride my cock in front of everyone.”
My breath catches. In fear? In excitement? The thought of Luke fucking me in front of everyone is a tangled-up mixture of both. Fuck, what are these guys doing to me?
“Just the gossip,” I say.
Chuckling, he straightens. “Whatever you want, princess.”
“He’s obviously not a football player.” Eli moves up beside me. “But he’s athletic. So maybe hockey or basketball. We’ll try to make sure you hear everyone’s voice, but it may be hard over the party noise.”
I nod and swallow. Yeah, that’s the part I’m not looking forward to. If we can identify the guy who tried to get to me, then we can deal with the problem head on. But the other issue is the Cheermonsters and whether they had a hand in it.
Did they orchestrate the whole thing?
I pull out my phone as we reach the door and text the group chat that now includes Kenz.
Me:
We’re coming in.
Penny:
We’re ready.
I’m sure they are. This is a disaster waiting to happen, but I can’t hide forever. Kenz messages me separate from the group chat.
Kenz:
You want me to mingle and spread the word, right?
Me:
Yeah
Kenz:
We’re talking later
Me:
Definitely
Luke tips up my chin, and his icy blue eyes search mine. “You ready?”
That softness in his tone makes my heart beat in double time. I’m not going to survive a year of being theirs and not feel something for them. But these moments with Luke are wreaking havoc on my heart.
“As ready as I’ll ever be,” I admit.
Luke touches his lips to mine. It’s brief and stirs something needy inside me. He slides his hand over my ass and pushes on the plug while he puts his mouth on my ear.
“Jack may get the first time in your ass, princess, but I want this ass after.”
I don’t know why I bother wearing panties. I’m wet from his words and from before. When he backs away, our eyes lock. He smirks and traces his finger down my neck. A shiver shakes me.
“Let’s go,” Caden says. “Fuck later.”
My face feels like the surface of the sun as Caden opens the door and winks at me. Later will be epic, but this... I draw in a breath. This is going to be a shitshow of epic proportions.
The music is loud. The lights are low. And the hum of the crowd is overwhelming. The room seems to pulse with the beat. Somehow it seems like more people are here than last time.
When we walk into the room, guys step up to pat my guys on the shoulder or back, congratulating them for their win. Fuck, I didn’t even ask, though I assumed. They always win, but Caden left with me.
Luke’s hand never leaves my hip as he ushers me through the party to the sectional couch. He sits in the corner and draws me down across his lap. Jack sits to one side of Luke while Caden takes the other.
Eli and Nico brave the crowd to get us drinks and to find the girls and bring them over.
I startle when Caden puts his hand on my bare knee and slides his fingers beneath, massaging the sensitive skin there. Sparks ignite and flow through my blood. He throws me a knowing smirk before he scans the crowd.
Luke slides a hand around my thigh right above my knee and between my legs. “My offer is always open, princess.”
I press my thighs together around his hand. “Not tonight, Death.”
His dark chuckle skitters down my spine and he squeezes my leg. Caden’s soft, almost ticklish touch keeps me aware and aroused.
“Harper!” Penny follows Eli back and waves. She’s in a crop top and a short skirt, showing off a lot of skin. Her blond hair falls in curls loose around her shoulders.
Nat has her black hair swept to the side. Her red halter top matches the lipstick on her full lips. Her black skater skirt is a little longer than Penny’s but not by much.
Vicky has a skintight t-shirt with a Rolling Stones logo on it. Her brown hair is in a high ponytail like mine. Her dark jeans look painted on her skin, with just a hint of her waist showing between her jeans and shirt.
Izzy is petite, and her red hair is cut short. She wears long dangling earrings that brush her bare shoulders which are covered with freckles. Her blue eyes meet mine, and she smiles. Her pink lips match her dress, which clings to her curves.
These girls dressed to party and get guys.
A little pinch of jealousy races through me at the thought of these girls sitting amongst my men. Nico follows behind them. Both he and Eli have a couple of bottles and glasses.
I definitely need to be drunk to get through tonight. Between the fear still clinging to me and the things I’m about to put out there that the entire school will know by Monday morning, yeah, drinking sounds real good about now.
Luke runs his fingers over the back of my neck. Shivers of desire race over me. “Relax, princess. You’re the only one we’ll be fucking tonight.”
I rest my head against his chest and watch as the girls stop before me and Luke.
Luke keeps his hands on the back of my neck and between my thighs. “Find a seat. No laps. No touching us. We’re Harper’s, you understand?”
My pulse increases. Penny’s eyes widen at his claim that they’re mine. I want to drag his mouth down to mine and show him how much I appreciate that.
“Yes, we understand,” Penny finally says and sits down between Caden and Nico. Izzy sits between Jack and Eli, Vicky is on Eli’s other side, and Nat beside Nico.
Nico and Eli pour drinks into the cups and pass them out. Caden takes a sip out of mine before handing it to me.
“Don’t want you to pass out on us tonight, little nympho.” His green eyes hold mine as he tweaks his fingers beneath my knee. Tingles scatter from his touch. He leans in close. “I’ve heard you can make a woman come from the back of her knee. We’re going to have to experiment.”
My breath catches at the heat in his eyes and the pulse of desire aching within.
He leans back with a smug smirk. When Penny smiles up at him, his smile vanishes and he arches an eyebrow. Her smile falters and then she turns to Nico.
Smiling, I shake my head as he gives me a smoldering look.
By the time I finish my drink, I’m feeling good and horny as hell from Luke’s and Caden’s hands on me. The girls and guys have relaxed, and everyone is talking. The party bubble thing happens again, where no one gets close to us.
I catch Kenz a few times as she mingles. She always gives me a wink as she steers Brandon in another direction. She agreed to at least start the rumor mill spinning about us. After all, she’s my best friend. Of course she knows I’m fucking the horsemen.
I haven’t seen the Cheermonsters yet, and there isn’t anyone who isn’t a football player who has the same build as my attacker. Of course, I only got a glimpse of him, but if he’s the same guy from last night, Luke saw him too.
Luke’s lips touch my ear, and shivers rake me. His hand tightens on the back of my neck. “I could slip my cock inside you and no one would know. Or I could slide my hand under your skirt and fuck your pussy with my fingers until you come all over my hand.”
He slides his hand higher on my thigh and I gasp.
“Shh, princess. Don’t want anyone to guess you’re soaking wet for my touch already.” Luke kisses me beside my ear.
He’s not wrong. I’m slightly buzzed from the alcohol. Their touch makes me want to straddle Luke and fuck him in front of all these people so everyone knows I’m taken. I’m theirs and they’re mine. There’s no going back now.
Luke’s cool eyes burn with desire. Fuck, I want to burn with him so fucking bad.
“Come on, sweetheart.” Jack stands and holds his hand out to me.
Luke loosens his grip and helps me up, smacking me on my ass and reminding me of the plug stuck inside me. Jack wraps his hand around mine and pulls me back into the house away from the party, using the code on the door.
When the door shuts behind us, the noise falls away. In the dark silence, a little trickle of fear pours down my spine, and I draw closer to Jack. Chuckling, he opens a door to a guest bathroom.
“Hands on the counter.” The lock snicks behind me.
I put my hands on the counter and watch Jack in the mirror. He comes up behind me and drags his fingertips up the outside of my thighs, lifting my skirt.
“How does it feel?” His low voice sends shivers through me as his hands slip into the sides of my panties.
“Fine.” I meet his eyes in the mirror.
He pushes my panties down my legs until they flutter around my ankles. He draws my hips back against his jeans. “Bend over.”
When I lean down on the counter, his fingers slide between my legs, rubbing my clit. I tighten around the plug.
“So wet, sweetheart.” Jack drops to his knee behind me and then his tongue thrusts into my pussy.
“Jack!”
He grips my hips to keep me from pulling away as his tongue fucks my pussy. In and out, making me squirm. Rubbing my clit with his fingers. I was already almost there on Luke’s lap, so it doesn’t take much for me to come.
Moaning, I tighten all around his tongue and the plug. My pussy convulses empty as he kisses it before standing behind me. I shift my legs wider and tip my ass up, waiting for him to take his cock out and thrust deep inside me. Wanting it.
“Fuck, sweetheart. You’re tempting me to do a whole lot more than I should right now.” His hands spread my ass cheeks.
I whimper, wanting more, needing more.
He tugs on the plug and pleasure ripples through me in waves. “Maybe one more.”
He draws the plug almost all the way out and then thrusts it back in. My knees weaken. Over and over, he draws it out and thrusts it back in, pushing me closer and closer to the edge.
“This ass is mine tonight, sweetheart. My cock is thicker than this plug and will fill you so fucking full and go deeper inside.” He thrusts the plug inside. “I’ll have Caden eat your pussy, while Eli fucks your mouth. Before I fill this ass with my cum.”
I moan at the image he paints and how good the plug feels sliding in and out of my sensitive hole.
“You’re going to come so hard around my cock and then we’ll start again, but this time Caden will fuck your pussy while I fuck this ass.”
I cry out as my release pours over me. He draws the plug out and slips his fingers into my still quivering pussy.
“Fuck, you feel good, sweetheart.” He thrusts his fingers in and out a few times until a second orgasm rips through me. I tremble against him as he pulls his fingers out. “Use the toilet and then we’ll get this back inside that ass to stretch you out.”
Straightening, I move toward the toilet as he turns on the sink to wash the toy and his hands. He plans on staying in here? He just got me off three times, and I’m worried about peeing in front of him?
I go to the toilet and while the water runs, I use it. His laughing blue eyes meet mine.
“Good girl.”
I shake my head. If I weren’t mostly buzzed and swimming in alcohol, I probably wouldn’t be able to go in front of him. He’s lubing up the toy with a thick lube as I wash my hands.
“Bend over, sweetheart.”
I don’t hesitate this time, but bend over to let him push the toy back in. He rubs lube all over my hole and inside me before he slides the toy back in deep. Sparks reignite in my blood.
He washes his hands and then raises my panties to cover me. Turning me to face him, he lifts my chin. Our eyes lock before his mouth takes mine. He squeezes my ass, massaging it around the plug. I grab his hard cock through his jeans and rub my hand over him.
He lifts his head on a groan and rests his forehead on mine. “Fuck, sweetheart. We need to get back out there. You need to finish your business and then I need to fuck you.”
“Any advice?” I whisper against his lips.
“Climb on Caden and make sure Penny hears every word you say to him. Make sure he knows just how grateful you are to have his big fat cock in your pussy.” Jack kisses my cheek down to my ear. “These girls want to be popular. There’s no way they’ll keep that information to themselves.”
“Yeah?” The word is breathy as Jack looks down at me.
“Yeah, then do the same to everyone. If all four girls can confirm it, it’ll spread like wildfire.”
I hope he’s right, because I’m about to confirm my slutty reputation.