Chapter 55 Pick Your Poison
Pick Your Poison
Eli
I’m the first to arrive at Luke’s house. Well, second. The only reason I know is his bedroom door is locked and I can hear the shower running. Luke showered before leaving practice. Her car may not be in the driveway, but that’s so no one knows Harper’s here all night.
I could pick the lock to Luke’s door, something we all spent a summer learning. But I’ll let him have his time with Harper, because that’s exactly what I want. Time alone with our girl. I head down to the billiards room.
There’s a large closet down here. Caden’s isn’t the only place we’ve played seven minutes in heaven. Luke’s house may be smaller, but it’s still larger than most of ours. But when he held parties, he invited a smaller, more select crowd than Caden’s house parties.
Intimate is what I want tonight.
Setting my duffle down on the coffee table, I remove what I need, lining the objects on the table for everyone to see. Including Harper. I want her excited and nervous and so fucking wet.
The game I have planned will allow us each some time alone with Harper. I pause and look up at the ceiling. No sound permeates from upstairs. How long did Luke have her to himself? All I know is I’m making plans to sneak her into my bed soon. If this Penny ruse goes well, it shouldn’t be an issue.
Except our leader might make it one. Sharing isn’t in Luke’s vocabulary. He might be a dick about it after last night.
“Hey.” Caden glances around the game room. He arches an eyebrow.
I gesture to the ceiling. “In his room. Locked.”
Caden grins and sits on the couch. He picks up a silk blindfold and runs it through his fingers. “Games?”
I smirk. “Always. Grab that chair and put it in the closet.”
Caden takes the straight back chair and sets it inside. When he comes out, he resumes his seat and picks up the bottle of lube. Again he raises an eyebrow.
I uncover the silicone toy in the center of the table.
“Fuck.” He rubs his hands together. Glancing at the closet, he jerks his head. “Do we get to watch?”
“Fuck yeah, we do.” Jack strolls into the room with his computer bag. He drops it on the armchair and pulls out his laptop and some small wireless cameras.
Grinning, Caden leans back and grabs the remote for the TV. He puts on the game while Jack works to set up the cameras in the closet. I watch the monitor to help him position them correctly.
“I thought I’d never get out of there.” Nico thrusts a hand through his hair as he walks in. “My mom wanted to know how my day was. How’d my classes go? Did I make any friends? I lied and said I had a big test to study for to finally get out of there.”
“Does that mean you won’t be able to play long?” Caden gives him a cocky grin. Like that guy needs more alone time with Harper. The bastard gets to sleep here tonight. With her again.
Nico takes a seat beside Caden and glances over the items on the coffee table. “I’m here to play as long as we can.”
A low murmur of voices reaches us, and we all turn to watch the doorway. Harper pauses as she enters the room. Her brown eyes are wide and her hair damp around her shoulders. She scans the room. When she sees all of us, her cheeks flush pink.
Luke places his hand on her back and leads her forward. His hair is also damp, and he’s more relaxed than I’ve seen him in a while. We should definitely lock those two together when they get riled up. I’m all about our leader getting fucked as long as he doesn’t mess up what we have with Harper.
“Come here, kitten.” I hold my hand out, and she walks to me. I love when she obeys me. Luke sits next to Caden on the couch, settling in like he doesn’t have a care in the world.
When her hand slips into mine, I draw her forward to stand between my knees. She’s soft and pliant right now. Today, she wore Caden’s jersey. I can’t wait to see her wearing mine.
“What time is the exchange?” Nico refers to swapping jerseys with the cheerleaders.
“In about twenty minutes,” Luke says. “Sidney texted she’d make the exchange.”
Caden stands and comes up behind Harper. She shivers as his hands find her hips and leans into his warmth.
“That doesn’t leave me a lot of time.” He tightens his hands on her hips. But before he draws her away, I hold up a hand.
“Wait, please.” I lift my gaze to Harper’s. Her eyes have darkened already. “Lift your skirt, kitten.”
Did she obey me?
Her cheeks flush pink as she raises her skirt, showing me her lack of panties. Her bare pussy makes me want to lean forward and kiss it. Instead, I hold out my hand.
“They’re upstairs.” Her voice is low.
I glance at Caden, who slides his hands under Harper’s skirt and onto her thighs. She sucks in a breath. He gives me a smirk before he buries a finger in her pussy. She moans softly, but he pulls his finger out and shows me the wetness clinging to it.
“Luke fucked you.” It’s not an accusation. Just a statement of fact.
She nods, and Caden rewards her. He thrusts his finger back inside her, and she gasps. Her fingers tighten around her skirt while his finger works in and out of her wet pussy.
“Sore, kitten?” I raise my eyes to hers.
With her lips parted, she shakes her head. “Earlier, but not now.”
“You were supposed to bring me your panties.” I pull down my athletic pants and release my throbbing cock. I’ve been hard since she stepped into the room. “But seeing as Caden has a time limit to fuck you with his jersey on, you can suck my cock while he fucks you.”
Harper’s breathing quickens.
“You like that idea, little nympho? You just fucking soaked my hand.” Caden grins wickedly at me. Our girl is coming along nicely.
“Yes.” Her voice is quiet, but her eyes hold mine.
I stroke my cock as he pushes in the center of her back to bend at the waist. Wrapping her hair around my hand, I bring her face to mine. “I’m going to fuck your face, kitten. If it’s too much, what do you do?”
She licks her lips. “Snap my fingers or tap your leg three times.”
“Good kitten.” I tug her hair so her neck is arched back. “When we finish, I have a new game I want to play.”
“Yes, Eli.” Her words are breathless as Caden continues to thrust his finger in and out of her slick cunt.
When I lower her mouth to hover over my cock, her tongue darts out and licks the tip with a little noise of anticipation in her throat.
A shiver works through me. Caden removes his hand and steps to the side as he lifts her skirt around her waist, exposing her to the guys on the couch.
He slides two fingers inside her from behind as I thrust deep into her mouth.
Her throat vibrates around me as she moans. I hold her there, loving the feel of her throat trying to work around my cock while she grips my thighs.
Caden slowly works her pussy, thrusting his fingers in and out, and she rocks her hips with the motion. I follow his pace, lifting her almost all the way off my cock before sliding back in deep, nearly choking her with it. She doesn’t tap out though.
“Jack, bring me the lube.” Caden’s words make her suck a little harder.
Jack hands him the lube, and Caden drizzles it over her asshole. She makes a noise of surprise before I thrust in deep, holding her there.
“He won’t fuck your asshole, kitten. Not yet.” I tighten my grip on her hair. “But he is going to open you up, because I have something for you.”
She moans as he pulls his fingers free of her pussy, sliding them back through the lube to circle her puckered hole. I lift her head so our faces are level. Sliding my thumb over the sides of her mouth to wipe away the drool and brushing the tears away with my knuckles, I meet her eyes.
“Relax, kitten,” I whisper. I cradle her breast in my hand, squeezing it, pulsing my hand around it to distract her from what he’s about to do.
Caden eases his finger into her asshole. She pants as he slides it in a little before pulling out and then thrusting it in a little deeper. Her darkened eyes are unfocused, her lips parted.
I alternate between watching her face and Caden’s finger until he has it pressed in all the way to his knuckle. She shudders and clenches my thighs.
“You ready, kitten?”
Her eyes focus on me. “Eli?”
“Caden will fuck your pussy while his finger stays buried in your ass. I’m going to fuck your face. Can you handle that? Can you take both of us?” I’m curious what her answer will be. Will she protest?
“Yes, please.” She widens her stance a little, and I pinch her nipple through her shirt. She shudders at the bit of pain.
I search her eyes, but then nod to Caden. He draws his cock out of his sweats and lines up with her entrance. If Luke hadn’t already fucked her, I would have told him to get more lube just to make sure she doesn’t get too sore.
But with Luke’s cum and as wet as she gets, she should be good to go. Caden slowly eases his cock into her pussy, just like he did his finger in her ass, letting her adjust to his size and girth.
Her eyes close and her lips part as she pants. He finally sinks all of his cock into her pussy. For a moment, he closes his eyes and breathes. Her quick breaths fan across my lips. I can’t wait to feel her tight cunt wrapped around me again.
He opens his eyes and nods. His free hand slides around the front of her as I lower her mouth back over my cock. I hold her with my cock barely inside her mouth. She licks and sucks on me for a second.
As one we fuck Harper together, pulling out and pushing back in. Slowly at first, until we build up speed. Caden rubs her clit, but keeps his other finger buried in her ass, unmoving.
She moans low around my cock as her knees try to buckle.
“Fuck, you feel so fucking good wrapped around my cock.” Caden grimaces as he thrusts back and forth. “I don’t know how much longer I’m going to last, little nympho.”
I’m not doing much better as she licks and sucks when she can while I thrust in and out of her throat. Her tears drip onto my thighs, but she doesn’t tap out. Her fingers dig into my thighs as she rocks her hips in time with Caden.
She hollows out her cheeks around me, sucking me hard, and it’s game over. My cum spills into the back of her throat as I hold her down over me. Her swallowing around my tip makes my balls ache as they empty.
I lift her head, and she gasps in a breath. “Open your eyes, kitten.”
Her eyes meet mine while she sways with every thrust of Caden’s cock into her cunt.
“Come for us again.” I reach forward and pinch her nipple.
She cries out as she comes all over Caden’s cock. Groaning, he releases deep inside her pussy. Caden draws his finger out of her ass before thrusting it back in.
“Ahh.” Her fingers tighten on my thighs.
“Come one more time, little nympho. Come around my finger in your ass.” Caden’s cock is still buried inside her as he works his finger in and out of her puckered hole.
My hand in her hair holds her head up when she would have dropped it. “How does it feel, kitten?”
She pants and opens her blown eyes to mine.
“Being filled in three holes at once?” I clarify as she looks a little lost to the pleasure. “Did you enjoy sucking my dick with Caden’s cock in your cunt and his finger in your ass?”
She’s close to coming again. Her eyes lose focus. I tighten my hand in her hair, tugging to bring her back with pain.
“Answer me, kitten.”
Her eyes squeeze shut and her mouth opens in a silent scream as she bucks back against Caden.
“Good job, little nympho.” He thrusts his cock once inside her. She lets out a gasp before he pulls out and removes his finger. She doesn’t move as he steps away.
I envy the others their view of her swollen cunt and the cum trickling out of it. Her ragged breath saws in and out.
“Kitten?”
Opening her eyes, she finally focuses on me. She releases her breath.
“Yes, Eli, I liked it.”