24. Chapter Twenty-Four
Chapter Twenty-Four
Chase
I’m watching her eat ice cream, the way her tongue flicks out to catch the melting drips. Millie’s sitting next to Lily, laughing at something she said. Her eyes sparkle with happiness and I can’t help but be in awe.
She’s perfect. Her jeggings cling to her curves, I’m mesmerized by the way she moves and the way she smiles.
I notice Finn watching Millie too. The way his eyes track her every move, his expression softens. It’s like he’s seeing her for the first time, but I know he’s seen her before. He’s remembering, just like me.
“Declan, you okay after that hit?” I ask, turning my attention to him. He got slammed pretty hard during the game.
“Just part of the game,” Declan says, shrugging it off.
Finn laughs. “Remember how you lost your front teeth when we were playing hockey in high school?”
Millie gasps. “You lost your teeth?”
Declan chuckles. “Yeah, but I got them fixed. Good as new.”
“I’m suddenly very glad I work with animals and not people,” I say, shaking my head.
Chase turns to Millie. “How’s the blog going?”
She lights up. “After the vlog with Troy and Axel, it went viral. Nike even approached me to work with them.”
“I’m proud of you,” I tell her, meaning every word.
Finn chimes in. “Me too. I’m glad you followed your dream.”
She’s beaming now. “Thanks, guys. I think that sports coverage and fitness topics will be much more lucrative than baking ever was.”
Declan raises an eyebrow. “What does that mean?”
Finn leans back, a smirk on his face. “The night we met, Millie told me all about how she wanted to be serious with social media. I’m proud she’s going through with it.”
Millie looks surprised. “You remember that?”
“I remember everything from that night,” Finn says softly.
I watch Millie blush and I can’t help but wonder if she’s thinking about their one-night stand. My curiosity gets the better of me. I expect a knot of jealousy to form, but it doesn’t. Instead, I surprise myself by saying, “Want to continue the after-party at my apartment?”
Millie looks at me, then at the two men. “Are you sure?”
I nod. “Yeah.”
Lily yawns. “I need to put Lily to bed first,” Declan says. “Then I’ll come over.”
Finn stretches. “I need a shower and meds, but then I’ll be there.”
I take Millie’s hand and smile. “Good. Let’s meet up in about an hour?”
They nod and we all take our ice cream to go. We head to our cars, driving to the same building. Anticipation coils low in my belly. This is going to be interesting.
Back at my apartment, I’m pacing, waiting for everyone to show up. Millie’s sitting on the couch, scrolling through her phone. She looks up at me, her eyes full of curiosity.
“Why did you invite them over?” she asks.
I shrug. “Why not? Thought it would be fun.”
She smirks. “You’re full of surprises, Chase.”
Declan arrives first, looking a little tired but still game. “Lily’s asleep. She conked out as soon as we got home.” He holds up a baby monitor. “Figure she’s basically two doors down and the baby monitor will work perfectly since we’re so close.”
Finn shows up next, looking refreshed. “Ready to party,” he says, grinning.
We all settle in, the tension in the room palpable. I can’t stop looking at Millie, the way she lights up the room. Finn and Declan are watching her too and I can see the same admiration in their eyes.
“So, Millie,” I say, breaking the silence. “What’s next for your blog?”
She perks up. “I’ve got a few collaborations lined up. Nike is the big one, but there are a few smaller brands too. It’s exciting.”
“I bet,” Declan says. “You’ve worked hard for this.”
She nods. “Yeah, it feels good to see it paying off.”
Finn leans forward. “You deserve it, Millie. You’ve got the talent and the drive.”
She blushes again and I feel a pang of jealousy. But then I remember why we’re all here and I push it aside.
“Anyone want a drink?” I ask, heading to the kitchen.
“I’ll take a beer,” Declan says.
“Same,” Finn adds.
“Wine for me,” Millie says.
I grab the drinks and come back, handing them out. We sit in comfortable silence for a while, just enjoying each other’s company.
“So,” I say, breaking the silence again. “What did you guys think of the game today?”
“Brutal,” Declan says. “But fun.”
“Yeah, it was intense,” Finn agrees.
Millie laughs. “I don’t know how you guys do it. I’d be terrified.”
“You get used to it,” Declan says. “It’s all about the adrenaline.”
We continue talking, the conversation flowing easily. I keep sneaking glances at Millie, watching the way she interacts with Finn and Declan. She’s so animated, so full of life. I can see why they’re both drawn to her.
After a while, the conversation starts to slow down. I can feel the anticipation building again and I know everyone else can too.
“So,” I say, clearing my throat. “Should we move this to the bedroom?”
Millie looks at me, her eyes wide. “Are you sure?”
I nod. “Yeah. Let’s do this.”
Declan and Finn nod in agreement. We all stand up and head to the bedroom, the air thick with anticipation.
Once we’re in the bedroom, I take Millie’s hand and pull her close. “You ready?” I whisper.
She nods, her eyes full of excitement. “Yeah.”
Declan sets his phone on the nightstand, the screen lit up with the baby monitor app. He gives us a thumbs-up, indicating he’s ready.
I turn back to Millie, my hands roaming her body. I kiss her deeply, my tongue exploring her mouth. She moans softly, her body arching towards mine.
“God, you’re so beautiful,” I whisper against her lips. She blushes, her eyes filled with desire.
I slowly drag her sweater higher, exposing her soft, creamy skin to our hungry eyes. I pull down her tight pants, revealing her lacy panties. She shivers as the cool air touches her exposed skin. My hands roam her thighs, feeling the smoothness of her skin.
“Look at you,” I murmur, my fingers tracing the edge of her panties. “You’re perfect.”
I lean in to kiss her again, my tongue tangling with hers. Her hands grip my shoulders, pulling me closer. I can feel the heat of her body, the anticipation building between us.
Declan and Finn move closer, their eyes fixed on Millie. I can see the desire in their eyes, the hunger. They’re just as eager as I am to explore her, to make her feel good.
Finn leans down, his lips brushing against her neck. She gasps, tilting her head to give him better access. Declan’s hands move to her breasts, squeezing them gently through the fabric of her dress.
“We’re going to take good care of you, baby,” Declan whispers, his lips brushing against her ear. “Just relax and let us do all the work.”
I pull back, my hands moving to the clasp of her bra. “Let’s get this off you,” I say, my voice husky with desire.
She nods. I unhook her bra and toss it to the floor. She’s left in just her panties, her body trembling with anticipation.
“Beautiful,” Finn murmurs, his hands roaming her exposed skin. “So fucking beautiful.”
I lean in to kiss her again, my hands covering her breasts. She gasps as I tweak her nipples, her back arching toward me.
Declan’s hands move to her breasts as well, squeezing them gently. “God, you’re perfect,” he says, his voice filled with awe.
I kiss my way down her body, my tongue teasing her nipples. She moans, her hands tangling in my hair. Finn’s hands move to her hips, his fingers tracing the edge of her panties.
“Let’s get these off too,” he says, his voice rough with desire.
She lifts her hips, helping him slide her panties down her legs. She’s completely naked now, her body on display for us. I take a moment to just look at her, to take in every inch of her.
“Fucking gorgeous,” I murmur, my hands roaming her body. “Absolutely perfect.”
Finn and Declan start undressing too, their clothes falling to the floor in a heap. I can see their hard cocks, their desire for Millie evident. Declan’s cock has a ring around it, glinting in the low light. Finn is stroking himself slowly, his eyes fixed on Millie.
I lean in to kiss her again, my tongue exploring her mouth. She moans, her body arching toward mine. My hands roam her body, feeling the smoothness of her skin, the softness of her curves.
“Spread your legs for me?” I ask, my voice husky with desire.
She nods, her eyes wide with anticipation. “Of course.”
I kiss my way down her body, my tongue teasing her nipples, her stomach, and then her thighs. I settle between her legs, my hands gripping her hips. I look up at her, our eyes locking.
“You’re going to feel so good,” I whisper, my tongue flicking out to taste her.
She gasps, her hands gripping the sheets. I take my time, exploring her with my tongue. She’s sweet, her taste intoxicating. I suck her clit into my mouth, my fingers sliding inside her. She screams my name, coming undone immediately. Her body convulses with pleasure and I don’t stop until she’s a trembling, breathless mess.
Finn and Declan are watching, their hands moving faster on their cocks. They’re close, I can tell. Declan’s cock is hard, the ring glinting as he strokes himself. Finn is panting, his eyes fixed on Millie.
I kiss my way back up her body, my fingers still inside her. “You okay, baby?” I ask, my voice filled with concern.
She nods, her eyes glazed with pleasure. “Yes,” she whispers. “More.”
Finn moves closer, his hand still on his cock. “My turn,” he says, his voice thick with desire.
I move aside, giving him space. He settles between Millie’s thighs, his tongue lapping at her clit. She gasps, her body arching towards him. Declan is watching, his hand moving faster on his cock. I can see the tension in his body, the desire in his eyes. He’s close, I can tell.
Finn is relentless, his tongue and fingers working together to bring Millie to the edge. She’s gasping, her hands gripping the sheets. I can see the pleasure building in her, the tension coiling tighter and tighter.
“God, Finn,” she moans. “I’m going to come.”
I watch as Finn brings her to the edge, his tongue and fingers moving faster. She screams, her body convulsing with pleasure. He doesn’t stop, his tongue and fingers working together to bring her to the edge again and again.
Declan is close, his hand moving faster on his cock. He’s panting, his eyes fixed on Millie. “Fuck, that’s hot,” he mutters.
Declan moves to the bed, his cock still hard, the ring making it look even more impressive. “My turn now,” he says, positioning himself between Millie’s legs.
Finn takes over, helping direct us. “Millie, on your knees. Declan, you take her from behind.”
Millie rolls over, getting on her hands and knees. Declan slides in behind her, his cock slipping into her wet heat. She moans, pushing back against him, taking him deep.
“Good girl,” Finn says, his voice low. He moves to her side, guiding her hand to his cock. She starts stroking him, her movements unsteady but eager.
I watch, my own cock throbbing with need. Millie looks up at me, her eyes full of desire. “Chase, baby , come here.”
I move to her other side, my cock brushing against her lips. She takes me into her mouth, sucking me eagerly. I groan, my hands in her hair, guiding her movements.
Declan starts thrusting, his cock sliding in and out of her. Millie’s moans are muffled by my cock, her body moving with the rhythm. It’s an incredible sight, seeing her so lost in pleasure.
“Fuck, Millie,” I groan, thrusting into her mouth. She’s so good, her tongue working me just right. I can feel the heat building, my orgasm close.
Finn’s hand is on her ass, guiding Declan’s thrusts. “Harder, Declan. Make her come again.”
Declan picks up the pace, his hips slamming into her. Millie’s cries get louder, her body trembling with the force of her pleasure. I can practically see her clenching around Declan’s cock, her orgasm building again.
“Oh God, I’m gonna fucking come,” she whimpers, her voice muffled.
I pull out of her mouth, wanting to see her face. “Do it, Millie. Come for us.”
She screams, her orgasm hitting her hard. Declan keeps thrusting, riding out her waves of pleasure. It’s an amazing sight, seeing her so completely undone.
When Declan finally pulls out, Finn takes his place. “My turn,” he says, his voice rough with desire.
He positions himself behind Millie, sliding into her with one smooth thrust. She gasps, her body tensing for a moment before relaxing into it. I watch, mesmerized by the way they move together.
Finn’s thrusts are deep and steady, his hands on her hips, guiding her. “That’s it, Millie. Take it all.”
She moans around my cock, her body trembling with pleasure. I can feel the heat building, my orgasm close. Finn’s thrusts get harder, more urgent and I know he’s close too.
“Come for us, Millie,” I say, my voice rough with desire.
She screams again. Finn follows right behind her, his own orgasm spilling into her. I pull out of her mouth, watching her face as she comes down from her high. I want to beg her for a turn in her wet pussy, but she looks exhausted already.
My cock is still hard and wet from her saliva as I squeeze the tip.
Declan slides off her, kissing her back gently. Finn is smiling as he takes her lips.
In between the kisses, she turns to me. “Aren’t you going to ask for your turn?” she says, mocking the two men.
I laugh as I smack her ass gently. “You know I am more of an edging kind of person. Plus seeing you come was better than any orgasm.”
“You sure?” she asks.
Finn cocks his eyebrow at me, “I can’t lie, but I am going to side with your girl on this. That pussy is straight fire. Are you sure you don’t want to…”
“I can wait,” I grunt.
We all collapse onto the bed, exhausted but satisfied. Millie’s lying between us, her head on my chest. I can feel her breathing, slow and steady.
“That was incredible,” she says softly.
“Yeah,” I agree. “It really was.”
Declan and Finn nod, their expressions content. We lie there in silence for a while, just enjoying the moment.
Eventually, we start to drift off to sleep, the room filled with the sound of our breathing. I can feel Millie’s warmth next to me and I know this is where I’m meant to be.
As I close my eyes, I can’t help but smile. This is just the beginning. There’s so much more to come and I can’t wait to see where this takes us.
The next morning, I wake up to find Millie still lying next to me, her head on my chest. I can hear the soft sounds of Declan and Finn stirring and I know it’s time to face the day.
“Morning,” I say softly, kissing Millie’s forehead.
She smiles, her eyes still half-closed. “Morning.”
Sometime in the night, we all slipped into our boxers and fell asleep, but Millie remained gloriously naked. I brush a strand of hair from her face. “I’m going to get some water and check on Peanut. Do you need anything?”
She shakes her head, curling up on the pillow. “No, I’m good.”
I smile, sliding out of bed. A quick glance at the monitor shows Lily is still asleep. Making my way to the kitchen, I find Peanut surprisingly asleep as well. I fill his bowl and get myself a glass of water.
Just then, Millie strides in wearing Finn’s shirt. She looks so young and beautiful that my chest aches at the sight. “You okay?” I ask.
“Yeah,” she says, “just wanted to make sure you were too.”
“I promise, I’m fine,” I tell her, smiling.
She bites her lip. “You didn’t come last night and I had to share you with other men.”
I smile again, shaking my head. “I swear, I’m okay.”
“Was it weird?” she asks, her voice soft.
“No,” I say, moving closer to her. “I liked seeing you come so hard and cry out so much. Are you okay?”
“A little sore,” she admits, “but its morning now.”
I raise an eyebrow. “What does that mean?”
She steps closer, kissing me. I melt into her, feeling her warmth. “You didn’t get to come,” she whispers, her nails digging into my thigh. “Please, can you come for me?”
I groan, lifting her onto the counter. “Are you truly sore?”
“A bit,” she says, her eyes dark with desire.
I grab an ice cube from the freezer, running it gently along her inner thighs. She gasps, shivering under my touch. “How’s that?”
“Cold,” she breathes, but her body leans into it.
I slide the ice cube higher, watching her reaction. Her nipples harden and she moans softly. “Better?”
“Yeah,” she whispers, her eyes fluttering shut.
I lean down, replacing the ice with my tongue, soothing her. She moans louder, her hands gripping my shoulders. I position myself at her entrance, rubbing the tip of my cock against her wetness. “Ready?”
“Yes,” she breathes, her nails digging into my back.
I push into her slowly, savoring the feel of her tightness around me. She gasps, wrapping her legs around my waist. “Fuck, you feel so good.”
“Chase,” she moans, her hips meeting mine. “Harder.”
I oblige, thrusting into her deeper and harder. Her moans fill the kitchen, driving me wild. Just as I’m about to lose myself, Declan walks in, looking bleary-eyed. “I need coffee.”
I pause, but Millie’s eyes are glazed with pleasure. Declan smirks, heading to the coffee maker. “Don’t stop on my account.”
I continue thrusting, my rhythm faltering as I watch Declan. He makes his coffee, then turns to us, leaning against the counter. “Mind if I join?”
Millie’s eyes light up. “Please,” she whispers.
Declan sets his coffee down, stripping off his boxers. His cock is already hard, the ring around it making it look even more impressive. He positions himself behind Millie, his hands on her hips. “Ready for more?”
“Yes,” she breathes, her body trembling with anticipation.
Declan positions himself behind her and lifts her off the counter, holding her up. I stay inside her, thrusting deeper as Declan spreads her cheeks, his fingers teasing her ass. “You’re so tight here,” he murmurs, pushing a finger inside her. Millie gasps, clenching around me.
“Fuck, Declan,” she cries, her nails digging into my shoulders.
Declan grins, adding another finger, stretching her. “It’ll feel so good when I take you here,” he says, his voice low and rough.
Millie’s moans grow louder, more desperate. I can feel her tightening around me, her body trembling with pleasure. “I’m gonna come,” she gasps.
“Come for us,” Declan growls, his fingers thrusting deeper into her ass.
She screams, her body convulsing with pleasure. I thrust harder, deeper, chasing my own release. The sight and sound of her coming undone pushes me over the edge and I spill into her with a groan.
We take a moment to catch our breath. Millie’s body is still trembling, her eyes half-closed. Declan withdraws his fingers. “Now it’s my turn,” he says, a dark gleam in his eyes.
He flips her around, laying her back on the counter. I step back, watching as he positions himself at her entrance. “Ready?”
“Yes,” she breathes, her eyes filled with anticipation.
Declan thrusts into her, his cock sliding deep. Millie moans loudly, her body arching off the counter. “Fuck, yes.”
I stand by, stroking myself as I watch Declan fuck her. His thrusts are hard and deep, driving her wild. She’s moaning, crying out and her hands are gripping the edge of the counter.
I lean down, sucking on her clit as he thrusts. “You like that?” he growls.
“Yes,” she cries, her body shaking with pleasure.
He thrusts harder, his cock hitting deep. She screams, coming again, her body convulsing. Declan doesn’t stop, driving her higher and higher until she’s a trembling, breathless mess.
“Fuck, you’re amazing,” Declan groans, his own release hitting him. He spills into her, collapsing onto the counter beside her.
We lie there for a while, catching our breath. Millie’s lying between us, her chest rising and falling rapidly.
“That was incredible,” she says softly.
“Yeah,” I agree, my voice rough with exhaustion.
Declan nods, his expression content. “We should do this more often.”
Millie laughs softly. “I think I need a break.”
I chuckle, kissing her forehead. “You did great.”
She smiles, her eyes closing. “Thanks.”
“I think I’ll grab my clothes and get back to my place. I don’t want Lily to wake up and not find me there,” Declan says.
Millie can barely stay awake and I plan on taking her back to bed after he leaves.
“That’s okay…” she whispers. “Do you have practice today?”
“I am not sure yet. If I do, it will be up to you guys to wake Finn up,” he says.
“I’ll make sure he’s up,” I say, handing him the cup of coffee. “You can bring the cup back later.”
“Okay.”
Then he walks to the bedroom to get dressed and I am left peppering kisses on my barely awake girlfriend.
“Fuck, I think I need to sit in ice,” she laughs. “I don’t think I can have sex again for weeks.”
I laugh as I nuzzle her neck. “I am sure the others will be very disappointed in that particular piece of news.”
She looks up at me, biting her lower lip before she asks. “So for real, you are okay with all of this? I would totally understand if you weren’t, Chase.”
I take her hand and bring it to my lips. “Last night was an experiment. I will admit that I was curious to see how they actually treated you. I wanted to make sure that I trusted them to take care of you and make you feel safe. It’s clear baby, I can tell they care about you. So, my question is, do you want to do this again?”
She nods before leaning in to kiss the corner of my mouth. “Ye-es.”
“Then that it is all that matters.”
I am still kissing her bruised lips when Declan comes back fully dressed. “He’s still out,” he points towards our bedroom.
“That’s okay. He can totally sleep in…” I tell him.
And then he walks over and softly presses his lips to Millie’s lips. “Bye Amelia. You can take today off. You totally deserve it.”
That causes a bubble of laughter to erupt from her. “Gee thanks. I would sure hope so.”
He cups her cheek slapping it gently before kissing her forehead. “Such a brat.”
Then he turns to me. “Thanks, Chase…for the beer and for last night. Really!”
“Thank you for the open mind,” I tell him.
Then he’s gone and I’m carrying Millie back to bed. Finn instinctively turns in his sleep and braces an arm around her. Then he growls something inaudible and drifts back to sleep.
Millie chuckles softly as she settles her head on the pillow. “Come sleep for a while. It is barely six.”
“I planned on it,” I say, sliding in beside her. She wraps her arms around my neck and buries her face around my chest before falling asleep.
I watch her. She is so fucking breathtaking. “Mine,” I whisper. And then I watch Finn’s fingers flex in his sleep.
“Ours,” I amend, and that is the last thought I have before slipping off into sleep.