Chapter 18 Trace
TRACE
“What the fuck did you just say?”
Both Olivia and her friend stand up to question me.
Both share the same look of utter bewilderment strewn frustratedly across their faces.
And as much as I can feel the tension radiating from the rest of the useless idiots watching on, I’m still only paying attention to Liv, not letting my eyes waver even for a second.
I can see out of my periphery when Alli sits back down, still probably looking at me in disbelief but Olivia stands her ground.
I just had to watch my little flower open her fucking mouth for a hypothetical dick and all I can think about is making that my fucking reality.
My whole body buzzes with need to make her fucking submit to me; to come down her pretty throat.
And I know she only did it to provoke me, to spite me.
So she’s going to have to sit through more torment because of it.
“Wait, that’s your dare? For me to come? You just expect me to put on a show by myself for everyone here?” I finally break my stare with Olivia to look over to her friend who is motioning her hands at everyone in the circle as whispers start to scatter around the fire.
“Not by yourself. I dare you to let them do it.” I nod my head over Ev and Sage.
“No, absolutely not!” Olivia says and I smirk at her which only pisses her off more.
She’s so fucking pretty when she’s mad. And when I look at her, I think I could forget about the plan to make her hurt for me.
Instead, I could tell her just how pretty I think she is, and to kiss her softly.
But I know that the moment I get her alone again, I’m going to make a filthy mess out of her. It’s what I need. It’s what she needs.
“I wasn’t talking to you,” I state and I feel Jensen glaring at me from where he sits.
“Well, I’m talking to you. I said no.” Olivia takes a step forward which causes everyone to quiet down.
After the little stunt she pulled earlier on top of what she’s doing now, she’s going to cause a scene.
And it’s not the scene I want. The scene I want is going to keep everyone busy for a while, which is what I need to get Olivia alone.
“It’s okay,” Alli says to Olivia which causes her to twist her head around.
“Alli, this is crazy. And you two would really do that?” She looks over to Sage and Evrin who both just shrug their shoulders.
“I mean, I’m strictly dick so it’ll be mostly him but I can help,” Sage says and Evrin agrees.
“And what about you?” She points to Banks who simply looks up at her.
“She can do whatever the fuck she wants,” he says.
Olivia looks back at me before accepting defeat, deciding to sit back down next to Sage. The circle of idiots surrounding me starts expressing their interest, obviously eager for the display they’re about to get, before the chick sitting next to Jensen speaks up.
“So, Alli. Are you gonna do the dare or cop out?”
I turn my head to look at her for just a second and in doing so, I catch Jensen scribbling something down on a piece of paper. He senses me and looks up, giving me a smug stare, but only for a second before his eyes catch behind me. I feel territorial knowing who he’s looking at now.
I turn my head back to watch Olivia who is looking over at her friend for a moment before turning her eyes back down to the ground. Silence breeds as everyone waits for Alli’s answer. I stay seated, not even caring to look anywhere but Olivia.
“Yeah, I’ll do it.”
Cheers erupt and Olivia drops her head even further as Alli gets up to situate herself between the two boys; Evrin sliding down next to Banks.
“So, how do you want to do thi-” Alli attempts to ask but the boys cut her off as they lean over her to meet each other, immediately starting to kiss. “Oh?” she says and voices break out, laughing and cheering and whispering as the action takes place.
Alli grabs both of them by the hair and pushes them even further into each other.
Evrin makes the first move by reaching between them for her breast, pawing it through her shirt.
She throws her head back on the impact, obviously enjoying the pleasure.
Banks leans back and watches the three of them, just as everyone else does.
Sage eventually finds where Evrin’s hand is and makes an assist, tearing down Alli’s shirt, exposing her bare breast.
“Shit,” she hisses out as she slides off her jacket and tosses it on the ground behind her.
Sage breaks the kiss to pull down her top on the other side, exposing both of her tits now. He leans down to suck on one while Evrin leans in to kiss Alli, his hands skating down her stomach to enter her pants. He slides his hand under and the moment he reaches her pussy, she moans.
“Oh, fuck.”
Everyone is on the edge of their seat. Everyone is watching the show unfold.
Everyone except Olivia.
The sounds of kissing and sucking and moaning start to echo through the forest, and not just from the trio subjected to the dare now. More people break out into their own sexual activity, having likely gotten horny from the show I dared to be put on. All according to plan.
I stare at Olivia, tuning out everything else.
I want her to fucking look at me. Look at me, damn it.
And just like I knew she would, she feels me watching her.
She shifts, turning her head up, aiming her stunning blue eyes right at me.
Her cheeks are red as there’s an undeniable layer of lust coating them, swimming in her eyes too.
But a tear falls down her cheek. She’s breaking.
“Look,” I mouth to her. And she shakes her head.
“Look,” I mouth again, lowering my eyes at her for a darker effect.
And this time, she squeezes her eyes shut for a beat before turning her head to witness her friend getting absolutely wrung for pleasure next to her.
Alli is breathing hard, moaning as Evrin fingers her. Sage is sucking on her tits.
She looks back at me and another tear sheds. I keep my eyes on her as the moaning gets louder.
“Fuck, fuck, fuck,” Alli chants over and over.
Our eyes are locked. She’s losing it. I can tell.
Her fucking control is slipping. Another tear.
Vulnerability is hovering over her. I want it to consume her, it’ll be easier to break her that way.
Her fists are so tightly clenched together.
And right before she’s forced to bear witness to her friend’s public orgasm, she gets up out of her seat, turns and runs.
No one is paying attention to her. Everyone is locked in on the display in front of them.
I stay, counting. And right as Olivia disappears behind a tree, I stand.
“What the fuck are you doing?” I turn around to find Jensen is glaring at me with a challenging look spread across his features.
Even though he’s attempting to make a scene, the people around us could care less. Not when public porn is literally unfolding in front of their eyes.
“Mind your own fucking business.” I spit at him.
He stands, something I internally laugh at. I watch as his eyes steady me, attempting to threaten me. I spot the glint of gold shining from his neck, the letter S hanging from a chain. It causes my blood to boil, knowing that he used to call Olivia his sunshine.
He has no idea who he’s attempting to threaten. No idea just how fucking blood thirsty I am right now, especially knowing that I have someone waiting for my return, tied up in a basement. Someone that I can take out all my aggression on but I’m here handling this bullshit instead.
“Don’t you dare think about hurting her or else-”
“Or else what? You’ll throw a fucking football at me?
” I taunt, mocking him. A few people now notice our little interaction, but I ignore them stepping up to him while I lower my voice for only his pathetic ears to hear.
"You seem to have a very impractical interest in something that clearly belongs to me," I say and the slight smirk that curls across his face has me clenching my fist.
He scoffs, "Calm down, killer. You can have her." His voice drops. "But just remember that I was the last one who fucked that tight little pussy of hers."
I swing, connecting my fist with his jaw. He stumbles back but ultimately takes the hit better than most. I hear a few gasps spread out as I reel him back in by gripping the collar of his shirt, but I ignore them as I make my statement clear.
"If I catch you anywhere near my girl, I'll make sure that you never get to see another fucking football field ever again, that understood?"
He scoffs before rolling his eyes. But he accepts defeat, deciding to sit down while coddling his jaw before he further makes a fool out of himself. And before I can decide that now is as good of a time as any to fuck up his face anyway, I focus on my priority.
Hunting down my sweet little prey.