Chapter 24
Chapter Twenty-Four
A noise woke me. Or at least, I thought I heard a noise. I sat up from where I lay between Colt and Creed and looked around the dark room. The bedroom door was still shut and I couldn’t see anything in the darkness.
Feeling silly, I lay back. Just as I closed my eyes, I heard the doorknob turn. As the door began to open slowly and light from the hall bled into the room, I reached for Creed and Colt. “Wake up,” I whispered, grabbing their shoulders. Before I could shake them, I froze. Their skin was cold and wet.
The door opened wider, casting on us a beam of light. I looked down at my now-wet hands and saw that they were covered in blood. I looked from Colt to Creed, my breathing picking up as my wide eyes took in the horror. Their throats were cut and there was blood down their chests and soaked into the sheets.
“Wake up! Please wake up!” I screamed and shook Creed.
“Shiii...loooh,” a voice sang from the hall just before the light was blocked.
I slowly looked back at the door and there he stood, knife in his hand.
Mr. X.
I shook my head, refusing to believe what I was seeing.
“I found you,” he said and stepped into the room.
“No!”
“No!” I yelled, sitting up.
“Hey, it’s okay.” Colt’s voice filled my ear before his arms wrapped around me.
“Shit, she left her medicine at home last night,” I heard Creed say as the light flicked on.
I saw Colt first and nearly burst into tears. I grabbed his face as I straddled his lap. “Thank you. Thank you. Thank you,” I thanked the universe before kissing him. I ran my hands down his neck and chest, just to make sure. “You were dead,” I said, wrapping my arms around his neck. “You both were.”
Colt rubbed his hands up and down my back, soothingly. “It was just a nightmare.”
“This one was probably the worst one I’ve ever had,” I said as I kissed Colt again. This time I ran my tongue along his lips, demanding entry. He put a hand behind my head and opened for me.
The bed dipped and Creed asked, “Do you want to talk?”
I broke the kiss and began to trail my mouth and tongue down Colt’s neck. “After.” I would tell them all about it after. Right now, I needed them. I needed to feel them—to connect with them—and to feel reassured, because the fear of losing them was still making me tremble.
“After?” Creed repeated.
I leaned back a little and pulled off the shirt Creed had lent me to sleep in before we’d climbed into Colt’s bed. I tossed the shirt away and glanced at Creed. “After,” I said again.
Creed’s brows were trying to touch his hairline, but then he recovered. “Alright, after.” He leaned over and kissed me.
Colt’s hands went to my breasts, cupping them as his thumbs brushed over my nipples.
I pulled away from Creed. “I need to tell you something before the three of us have sex.”
Colt looked concerned, but asked, “What is it?”
“I don’t think I’m ready to have anal,” I said.
I received stunned silence before Creed snorted behind me and he rested his forehead on my shoulder as he laughed. Colt was at least fighting not to laugh.
“I’m serious. A threesome can lead to double penetration and I don’t think I’m ready for that,” I said.
Creed erupted with loud laughter and Colt fell back on the bed, covering his face as his body shook.
“Don’t laugh.” Trying not to smile, I playfully hit Colt in the stomach.
Colt flinched. “We’re not laughing at you. We just weren’t expecting you to say that.”
“I want to know how she learned about double penetration,” Creed said as he knelt behind me.
“I did some research,” I grumbled.
Creed moved my hair away from my neck and began kissing me there. “Did it turn you on when you did all this research?”
I tilted my head to give him better access. “Maybe.”
“Did you touch yourself?” he whispered in my ear, making me blush.
“With how red her cheeks are, I’d say that’s a yes,” Colt said, grinning up at me.
Creed chuckled. “And you call us dirty.”
“What I did wasn’t dirty,” I argued, blushing even harder. “It was clean because it was in the shower.”
They both chuckled. “You’re adorably sexy,” Colt said as he reached between my legs. His fingers found my clit right away and began rubbing me through my underwear.
“I want to know what she was picturing in the shower as she made herself cum,” Creed said.
“Both of you,” I answered honestly.
“And what were we doing?” Colt asked.
“Well…I was between you two,” I said.
Creed moved to the other side of my neck and kissed me there. “Between us like you are now?”
The corners of my mouth lifted. “No. I was on my hands and knees.”
“I think you’re just as dirty as we are, Shi.” Creed moved his hands to my hips. “Get into position. Show us,” he ordered as he pulled on me a little as he scooted back.
I moved between Colt’s legs on my hands and knees and Creed knelt behind me. “Did you imagine us taking you like this?” he asked as he pulled my underwear down to my knees.
I reached the band of Colt’s boxers. “Yes.”
Colt lifted his hips and helped me move his boxers down to the middle of his thighs. I looked up at Colt before dipping down to lick up his hard shaft.
He hissed and his hands went to the back of my head. “Damn, babe.”
“Condom?” Creed said behind me.
“Nightstand,” Colt said with a strained voice as I licked him again.
The bed moved as Creed reached for the nightstand and retrieved a condom. I’d started taking birth control yesterday. According to my doctor, it would take a week to become fully effective.
Grabbing the base of Colt’s cock, I took the tip of him into my mouth. I did a few shallow bobs before taking him in as far as I could.
“Fuck,” he groaned.
“She feel good?” Creed asked as he pushed a finger inside of me.
“Yes,” Colt panted as I continued to suck on him. “Did you teach her this?”
“Fucking Keelan,” Creed grumbled. He removed his finger from me and replaced it with his cock.
As he pushed into me, I had to take my mouth off of Colt. I put my forehead on his thigh, whimpering as Creed completely sheathed himself inside me.
“She’s so tight,” Creed groaned, his hand grabbing one of my hips. “Probably not as tight as she is here.” With the finger he’d pumped inside me, he rubbed my essences around my other hole.
My head lifted from Colt’s thigh. “Creed.”
Creed began rocking his hips, moving his cock in and out of me, as he continued to rub me. “You brought up anal and now I can’t stop thinking about taking you here.”
“I said I wasn’t ready,” I said with a shaky voice because what he was doing felt good.
“I respect that and we won’t do that tonight,” Creed said. “But I feel like I should give you a little sneak peek to ease your fears.”
“What’s a sneak peek?” I asked.
“Try to relax,” Creed said as he pushed his finger into my back entrance.
My breath hitched and I went still.
Colt stroked my cheek. “Relax, babe.”
Creed withdrew his finger as he withdrew his cock and pushed both back in simultaneously. I let out a loud, drawn-out moan.
Creed continued to slowly move in and out of both my holes. “That feel good, Shi?”
I nodded.
“Good. Now put Colt back in your mouth,” he ordered.
I did as he said and took Colt’s cock back into my mouth. I bobbed and sucked on him. I even relaxed my throat to take more of him, which made him groan and fist my hair.
“Let me fuck your mouth, babe,” he said, holding me still as he thrust his cock in and out, the tip kissing the back of my throat each time. I sucked and licked him each time he withdrew. “If you keep doing that, I’m going to cum in your mouth.”
Wasn’t that the point? Loving the way he was coming undone, I held his hips down and bobbed my head as fast as he had thrust into my mouth.
“I’m about to cum,” he hissed and I didn’t stop. “Babe—” His cock swelled just before jets of hot liquid filled my mouth. I quickly swallowed it down and released him.
Colt was panting with his hands fisted into his own hair. “You didn’t have to swallow.”
Creed, who had stopped moving, chuckled. “What a dirty girl.” He began moving in me again and this time he didn’t go slow. He went faster, harder. It felt so good, I almost couldn’t stand it.
“Was I not supposed to?” I asked between pants.
“You can swallow my cum anytime you want,” Creed said as he pounded into me and I felt my orgasm hurtling toward me fast.
Colt sat up and kissed me as I came. His lips muffled my cries. My entire body shook and shuddered. Creed withdrew his finger to hold me by both my hips as he chased his own release. He let out a grunt and thrust into me one last time, burying himself deep as he came.
With heavy breathing, Creed rested his forehead on the center of my back. “You okay, Shi?”
“Yeah,” I breathed. “That was fun.”
They both chuckled. Colt pulled up his boxers as Creed slid out of me and left the room to go to the bathroom. I climbed off the bed and my underwear fell to my ankles. I didn’t want to put them back on because they were wet. Instead, I stepped out of them and searched for the shirt Creed had lent me. I found it by the foot of the bed and put it back on.
Creed returned from the bathroom and the three of us got back into bed. Snuggled between them, I told them about my nightmare.