Chapter 5 Cobbler, Clues, and Chemistry
?
If sanctuary had an address in Western North Carolina, it was Callahan & Company Estate Liquidations & Antiques.
The air smelled of lavender beeswax, cedar, aged paper, and the comforting heat of the woodstove.
I sank onto our moss-green sofa, kicked off my clogs, and exhaled.
"My feet," I announced to the ceiling, "are officially filing for separate legal representation."
"Your feet have nothing on my nerves," Birdie declared, slumping into the wingback chair as her turquoise wrap pooled over the arm. "If I heard Gregory Vance whine once more about soup ladles while a coroner wheeled an appraiser down the drive in a body bag, I was going to grab a fireplace poker."
Buster trotted over, his heavy golden retriever paws clicking against the wide-plank oak floor. He rested his chin on my kneecap, looking up with soulful eyes.
"You were very brave today, Buster," I said, scratching behind his ears. "Even if you tried licking Sheriff Lawson's boots."
"Lawson deserved a little boot-licking," Birdie grunted, reaching into her tote for her brass reading glasses. "At least he ordered Gregory and Vanessa to take their high-end tantrums back to the Grove Park Inn until tomorrow. God forbid they spend an evening in the Cove without room service."
"They aren't grieving, Birdie. They're circling like buzzards," I said, watching the embers pulse behind the stove’s glass door. "Eleanor isn't cold a month, Julian is dead in her carriage house, and all Gregory cares about is whether the yellow tape delays Friday's auction."
"Because Gregory is flat broke," Birdie said flatly. "I called my cousin Donna at the Raleigh clerk’s office while you were giving your statement. Gregory has two tax liens on his condo, a vicious ex-wife's lawyer, and an active SEC audit."
I stared at her. "It took you twenty minutes to uncover that?"
"Clerks are a sisterhood, Maggie. We share pie recipes and dockets. Gregory needs this liquidated yesterday, or he’s bankrupt by Thanksgiving."
Before I could answer, the brass bell above the front door jangled cheerily.
A gust of spruce-scented mountain air swept into the shop, followed immediately by Luke Sterling.
He wore his faded denim jacket, dark hair ruffled by the wind. But it was the heavy cast-iron skillet he held with thick leather welding gloves that commanded our attention.
A heavenly aroma rolled off the skillet, conquering the lavender wax: bubbling butter, cinnamon, brown sugar, and mountain peaches beneath a golden cobbler crust. In his other hand, Luke swung a paper sack from the local creamery.
"Tell me nobody's on a diet," Luke said in his slow, resonant mountain baritone.
Birdie sat bolt upright. "Luke Sterling, if you weren't young enough to be my little brother, I'd divorce my third husband again and marry you on this rug."
Luke chuckled, setting the smoking skillet on our zinc-topped potting table. "Glad to see your spirits haven't completely soured, Birdie. Evening, Maggie."
His hazel eyes crinkled with warmth that sent a flutter straight to my ribs. "You look like you've been through a timber planer."
"Thank you, Luke. That’s my 'recently questioned in a homicide' look," I said with a tired smile.
"You survived," he said gently, placing vanilla bean ice cream beside the skillet. "And surviving Frank Lawson and two greedy heirs earns warm peach cobbler from my grandmother's skillet."
Buster abandoned my knee and glued himself to Luke’s boots, tail thumping like a metronome.
"Don't look at me like that, buddy," Luke said, scratching the dog's chin. "Cobbler isn't for hounds. But I didn't forget you."
From his pocket, Luke produced a butcher-wrapped marrow bone. Buster gave a joyful chuff, snatched it, and settled onto his rug.
Birdie was already bustling around our small kitchenette, returning with three ironstone bowls and silver spoons. Moments later, three steaming bowls of peach cobbler sat before us, each topped with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream.
Birdie took a bite and groaned. "If heaven doesn't serve this crust, I’m requesting a transfer."
I took a bite, the warm peaches and cold cream anchoring me after a grueling day.
"Alright," Birdie said, setting down her spoon and pulling out a yellow legal pad. "Let's talk murder. Frank Lawson is a fine sheriff, but he has the investigative imagination of a turnip. And Maggie’s name was the last one on Croft’s visitor log."
"Frank knows Maggie didn't do it," Luke said firmly, leaning against the counter with a mug of black coffee. "Croft was struck with a thirty-five-pound brass beam scale. Maggie couldn't swing that overhead if her life depended on it."
"Thank you for the vote of athletic confidence," I remarked dryly.
"Just stating facts," Luke smiled, his gaze holding mine. "You're deadly with a varnish stripper, Maggie, but you're no killer. The real question is who else slipped into that carriage house."
"Let's look at the suspects," I said, focusing on the cold facts. "First: Gregory Vance. He claims he was on the phone in his rental car between two and three, but nobody can verify it. And as Birdie discovered, he's drowning in debt."
"Pure desperation," Birdie noted, writing fast. "Vanessa brought Julian in to challenge the estate. If Julian found something cutting Gregory out, Gregory had every reason to silence him."
"Second: Vanessa Vance," I continued. "She acts like a delicate grieving socialite, but her eyes are flint. When Julian confronted us this morning, he looked at Vanessa with contempt—or fear."
"Or blackmail," Luke added quietly. "Croft was an insider in the high-end secondary art market. You don't survive in that world without stepping on toes or trading in dirty secrets."
"Which brings us to the real puzzle," I said. "The Moravian secretary desk."
Birdie nodded, her pen poised. "The secret drawer was pried open. When we cataloged it Monday, the cavity held something heavy—a clean rectangle in the dust where a ledger rested for decades."
"And Julian recognized that desk instantly," I said. "He called it an eight-hundred-dollar Victorian knockoff to trick us into devaluing it. But when his body was found, his trouser pockets were turned inside out. The killer was looking for whatever Julian took from that secret compartment."
"The 1845 Vance ledger," Luke said, his jaw tightening. "A century-old family record."
Right then, Buster let out an inquisitive grunt from the entryway, busily nosing through a pile of items Luke had set by the coat rack—a crumpled dry-cleaning bag and discarded papers.
"Buster, leave it," I warned.
"Wait, that's my fault," Luke said, straightening up. "When I backed the truck out of Blackwood's drive, the wind blew trash from Croft’s rental into the rhododendrons. I scooped it up so it wouldn't foul the creek and tossed it in the cab."
Buster snuffled through the crinkled trash, clamped his jaws onto a folded receipt, trotted over, and dropped it into Luke’s hand.
"What did you find, boy?" Luke murmured. "It's a gas receipt. Shell station off Highway 25 in Hendersonville, yesterday afternoon."
"Fascinating," Birdie sighed. "Julian bought twenty dollars of premium gas. Case closed."
"Wait," I said, leaning closer under the hanging lantern. "There's writing on the back."
I took the receipt, my fingers brushing Luke's warm hand. A brief, electric spark caught me off guard. I cleared my throat and flipped the paper over.
There, scrawled in Julian's flamboyant purple fountain pen ink, were three hurried lines:
*S. Gable – Blue Ridge Appraisal & Fine Arts. $75,000 agreed for 1845 Vance Ledger. No heirs, no cops.*
Birdie gasped so loudly she nearly choked on her coffee. "Sweet mother of Chippendale."
"Sterling Gable," Luke growled, his voice dropping into a dark, dangerous timber. "Sly Gable."
The warmth seemed to vanish from the room.
"Julian wasn't just planning to flip the desk," I whispered, the ugly truth snapping into focus.
"He already had a buyer lined up before he ever set foot in Black Walnut Cove.
He stole the ledger from the secret compartment this morning, intending to deliver it to Sly Gable for seventy-five thousand dollars. "
"Sly Gable is the most ruthless, crooked antique dealer in Western North Carolina," Birdie spat, her knuckles whitening around her pen. "He was banned from two Charleston auction houses for selling looted goods, and runs his Asheville gallery like a front for stolen heirlooms!"
"Seventy-five thousand dollars," Luke said slowly, staring at the purple scrawl. "For an old family record book. What on earth did Eleanor’s great-grandfather write in that ledger?"
"Whatever it was, Julian thought it was his golden ticket," I replied, my heart thumping. "And whoever met him in that carriage house either wanted that money for themselves... or couldn't afford to let that ledger reach the light of day."
"Or," Birdie added grimly, "Sly Gable decided thirty-five pounds of brass was cheaper than paying seventy-five thousand dollars."
A heavy silence fell over the shop. Outside, the wind gusted against the plate glass. On his rug, Buster gnawed his bone, oblivious that his scavenged trash had cracked the case wide open.
Birdie stood, grabbing her purse. "I’m going home, bolting my doors, and calling my cousin at the courthouse. If Sly Gable is here, nobody is safe."
"Be careful driving home, Birdie," I cautioned.
"You be careful, Maggie Callahan," she retorted, pausing at the door with her wrap tight around her shoulders. "Croft was killed on your site, the heirs are furious, and an Asheville shark was circling. Don't you dare investigate alone."
With a firm nod, Birdie slipped out into the chilly night.
I locked the heavy brass deadbolt, turned the door sign to *CLOSED*, and leaned my forehead against the cool glass. The weight of the day settled over me like a slab of mountain granite.
A pair of warm, solid hands rested gently on my shoulders.
I didn't step away. Through my blouse, Luke’s steady warmth was grounding and undeniably comforting.
"You're running on fumes, Maggie," he said softly, standing close enough that I could catch the scent of sawdust, pine, and sweet brown sugar clinging to his jacket.
"I'm fine," I murmured, turning to face him. "Just calculating the liability insurance implications of a dead appraiser."
Luke didn't smile. His hazel eyes were steady, earnest, and intensely focused on mine. Slowly, he raised a calloused hand, brushing a stray hair from my cheek. His fingers lingered just long enough to set my pulse racing.
"You don't have to carry the whole mountain by yourself, Mags," he said in a low, quiet voice.
"Julian Croft was mixed up with dangerous people.
But you've got friends who care about you.
Birdie. Buster." A faint, tender smile touched the corners of his mouth.
"And me. I’m not letting anything happen to you. You hear me?"
"I hear you, Luke," I whispered, my voice barely more than a breath.
For a heartbeat, neither of us moved. The space between us hummed with unspoken tension—three years of safe boundaries suddenly feeling paper-thin.
Then Buster let out a resounding, contented snore from his corner, breaking the silence.
Luke chuckled softly, letting his hand drop. "I'll wash the cobbler bowls before I head out."
"Luke, you don't need to do dishes—"
"I know," he said, already heading toward the sink with the skillet. "That’s why I’m doing them."
I stood in the quiet shop, touching the spot on my cheek where his fingers had rested.
Outside, the mountain wind stirred the hemlocks, but inside, surrounded by old cedar and warm cobbler, the shadows felt far less threatening.
Between a stolen Moravian ledger, a murdered appraiser, an Asheville dealer, and the handsomest carpenter in North Carolina washing dishes in my back room, my peaceful second act was proving anything but quiet.