Chapter 10
Downtown Starlight Shores on a Tuesday morning looked like a town that had forgotten anyone was watching.
Melissa stood on the corner of Harbor and Second with her camera bag over one shoulder and let the street arrange itself in front of her.
A produce truck was double-parked outside Bayview General, its back gate down, and a man in a ball cap was carrying crates of tomatoes through the front door while Sally Morris held it open with her hip.
Across the street, someone had left a bicycle leaning against the lamppost outside Tides & Tales with a paper bag in the basket.
A striped cat sat on the warm sidewalk near the bookstore and watched the bicycle with the patient disinterest of an animal that had nowhere to be.
She unzipped her bag and pulled out the camera.
She’d charged the battery the night before and cleaned the lens with the microfiber cloth she kept in the inside pocket, the one she’d bought at a camera shop in Baton Rouge six years ago when her gear bag smelled like river water and everything she owned needed wiping down.
Old habits. The cloth was soft and gray, and she rubbed it between her fingers for a second before tucking it away.
She lifted the camera and framed the bicycle.
Good subject. The handlebars caught the morning sun, and the paper bag in the basket had a grease spot spreading through the bottom, probably a pastry from Harbor Brew.
The lamppost made a strong vertical line, the bike a diagonal against it, and the whole composition had a stillness to it that felt deliberate even though nobody had arranged it.
She took the shot.
Then another one, tighter, just the basket and the grease-spotted bag. Then a wider angle that caught the bike and the bookstore window behind it, where Marty Fuller had stacked a pyramid of local history paperbacks under a hand-lettered sign that said GULF COAST STORIES.
Safe and inanimate. She could do this all day.
She moved down the block. The Sandpiper had chairs on the covered deck, and somebody had left a coffee mug on the railing that caught the light.
She photographed the mug. Then the row of potted palms along the deck, each one in a painted ceramic pot, blue and white and cracked in different places.
The worn wooden menu board propped by the entrance with today’s specials chalked in Bryan’s handwriting, the letters a little uneven where he’d run out of room at the bottom.
This is fine. This is the job.
She kept walking. Past Harbor Brew, where Jan had propped the door open and the smell of coffee drifted out to the sidewalk.
Past the general store, where Sally’s window display had a row of local honey jars and hand-poured candles arranged on a step stool with a card that said ALL LOCAL, ALL GOOD in Sally’s blocky print.
Next she turned toward a row of storefronts with their awnings cranked down against the morning sun, the fabric striped and faded and sagging a little in the middle.
She photographed the awnings and the honey jars in Sally’s window. Then she captured a coil of rope hanging from a dock cleat at the end of a side street, the harbor sparkling behind it.
Thirty-one frames in forty minutes and not a single person in any of them.
She sat on a bench near the marina and reviewed the shots on the camera’s display, scrolling through them with her thumb. They were competent. Clean compositions, good exposure, nice use of the morning light. They looked like a real estate listing for a charming Gulf town.
Exactly what you agreed to. Documentation. Town shots. Objects.
She kept scrolling.
And then she stopped.
Frame nineteen. She’d been shooting the honey jar display outside Bayview General, and at the left edge of the frame, almost out of focus, Sally Morris was leaning across her front counter laughing with a man in a straw hat.
A vendor, maybe, or a regular customer. Sally had her head tipped back and her mouth open and one hand flat on the counter as if the laugh had surprised her.
The man was turned halfway toward her with his own grin just starting.
It was blurry. It was cropped wrong. It had more life in it than all thirty other frames combined.
She stared at it for a long time.
She scrolled back further. Frame seven. She’d been shooting the bicycle and the lamppost, and in the background, the delivery man was setting a crate down on the sidewalk while a woman she didn’t recognize handed him a bottle of water.
He was taking it without looking at her, still steadying the crate with one hand, but his free hand touched her wrist. A tiny gesture. Gratitude or habit or both.
Frame twelve. The Sandpiper’s deck chairs, and beyond the railing, barely visible, two teenage girls sitting on the seawall sharing a bag of chips. One was talking. The other was listening with her chin on her knees.
Three accidental people shots that breathed life.
Melissa lowered the camera and sat on the bench while the morning moved around her.
She found Cassidy at Heron Cottage that afternoon.
Cassidy was on the upper deck with her laptop and a glass of iced tea. A sunburn was forming on the bridge of her nose. She waved Melissa up without asking why she was there, which was one of Cassidy’s better qualities. She didn’t need a reason for every visit.
“I have some test shots,” Melissa said as she walked out on the upper deck.
“Already?” Cassidy closed the laptop. “It’s been three days.”
“Don’t get excited.”
“Too late.” She pulled a chair closer and patted the seat. “Show me.”
Melissa sat down and turned the camera so Cassidy could see the display. She scrolled through the shots slowly. The bicycle. The awnings. The menu board. The honey jars in Sally’s window. Cassidy nodded at each one, engaged but clearly waiting for something else.
“These are great,” Cassidy said. “The bicycle composition is really nice. The light on those honey jars is beautiful.”
“But.”
“I didn’t say but.”
“You were about to.”
Cassidy took a sip of tea. “They’re exactly what we need for the website. Clean, well-lit, professional. Linda will be thrilled.”
“You’re being very diplomatic.”
“I’m being honest. They’re good shots, Melissa.”
“They’re boring.”
Cassidy didn’t argue with that. She just waited.
Melissa scrolled to frame nineteen. Sally and the man in the straw hat. The laugh. The hand on the counter. The slight blur.
Cassidy leaned in. Her finger hovered over the display without touching it. She studied the image for a long time, longer than she’d spent on any of the still lifes.
“That one,” Cassidy said. “That’s the town.”
“It’s out of focus. Sally and that man are slightly out of focus in the bokeh.”
“I don’t care.”
“The composition’s wrong. She’s barely in the frame.”
“I don’t care about any of that.” Cassidy looked up. “That woman is having the best moment of her morning. You can feel it. The honey jars are nice, but this is the one that makes you want to come to Starlight Shores.”
Melissa knew she was right. She’d known it on the bench by the marina, scrolling through the display before she’d even decided to bring the camera to Cassidy. The buildings and objects were competent. The accidental people had soul.
“There are two more like that,” Melissa said. She showed Cassidy the water bottle handoff and the girls on the seawall.
Cassidy looked at each one carefully. “These are all accidents?”
“Edges of frames. I wasn’t aiming at them.”
“Your edges are better than most people’s centers.”
“Don’t.”
“I’m not flattering you. I’m telling you what I see.” Cassidy handed the camera back. “The still lifes are good and we’ll use them. But if you can get more of those…” She pointed at the display where Sally’s laugh still glowed on the screen. “That’s the project.”
Melissa turned the camera off and set it in her lap. The Gulf water stretched out below the deck, blue and flat, and a seagull stood at the edge doing absolutely nothing.
“I didn’t mean to take those shots,” she said.
“I know.”
“I was specifically trying not to take those shots.”
“I know that too.”
“I don’t know if I can do it on purpose.”
Cassidy picked up her iced tea and settled back in her chair. “Can I say something? And you can tell me to shut up if it’s too much.”
“Go ahead.”
“When I was running campaigns in New York, the best content we ever produced was the stuff the clients hadn’t asked for.
Somebody’s phone would catch a warehouse worker laughing during a product shoot, and that one frame would outperform everything we’d spent three weeks planning.
” She waved her hand. “The client would always ask if we could do more of that. And we’d just say we could try. ”
“That’s very inspirational.”
“Don’t be mean to me on my own deck.”
Melissa almost smiled. “I’m not being mean. I’m being scared.”
The word came out before she could pull it back. She hadn’t planned to say it. Cassidy looked at her, and whatever business-mode response she’d been forming softened.
“Of the people shots,” Cassidy said. It wasn’t a question.
“Of taking something from someone.” Melissa looked at the seagull. It still hadn’t moved. “There’s a line. Between capturing a moment and stealing it. I crossed that line once and somebody’s life got worse because of it.”
Cassidy was quiet for a moment. The breeze off the water moved her hair across her forehead, and she pushed it back.
“Can I ask you something?”
“You’re going to anyway.”
“The Sally photo. Did you steal that?”
“I wasn’t even aiming at her.”
“But if you had been. If you’d seen the laugh happening and raised the camera on purpose. Would that have been stealing?”
Melissa didn’t answer right away. She turned the question over in her head the way she turned a lens cap in her fingers, feeling the edges of it.
“I don’t know,” she said.