Chapter 1 #5
As he gets closer I can see he’s wearing a full-face skull mask and I can’t help but smile. I don’t say anything as he stops in front of me. When he puts his hand on my hip, I put my hand on his chest and push him back a half step.
“Codeword, sir,” I say.
“Pineapple,” he says. “Good girl. Thought I’d have to punish you for that.” His voice is husky and not at all familiar.
“I take it back then,” I say with a grin.
“Yeah? You want me to punish you?” he asks. “Who are we trying to forget?”
“Someone who I wasn’t supposed to be fucking in the first place,” I say. “I think I accidentally caught feelings, but he stomped all over them then he made plans not involving me even though he was never mine to make plans with.”
“Does he know you’re mad at him?” he asks as he pushes me back against the table and slides his hand up my thigh to my pussy. “Fuck, you’re wet.”
“Stranger danger is hot, apparently,” I say and he laughs before turning me to the table.
He positions me so that my hands are on the edge of the table and I am bent slightly.
I see Cory’s car as clear as day beside mine and he is leaning against the rear bumper looking at me. “Yeah… I should warn you of something.”
“That guy by your car is him, isn’t he?” he asks as I hear him open the condom.
“Yeah. He won’t come over here. Not until you leave at least,” I say.
“Are you safe with him?” he asks.
“Yeah. He won’t hurt me. Can I admit something and not get shamed by a stranger?”
“You can. I’ve done some fucked up shit, so I have no room to judge,” he says. I feel him at the entrance to my pussy and he’s big, but nothing like Cory.
“He’s my older brother,” I say quietly. “We fucked on accident at a masked party not knowing who each other was, but then we just kept doing it.”
“Wanna know something?” he asks as he pulls my dress up.
“Why not,” I laugh. He grabs a hold of my underwear and pulls them down my thighs.
“If you were my sister, I’d wanna fuck you too,” he says.
“That’s the creepiest but sweetest thing anyone has ever said to me,” I laugh. He chuckles and slowly fills me with his cock.
“Let’s make your big brother jealous then, huh?” he says.
“Fuck,” I groan. “Fuck me like you hate me then.”
He grunts before gripping my waist and surging into me. I hold onto the table as he fucks me hard and fast. I am dead-locked in a staring competition with my brother, but I can’t and won’t stop moaning. I thought I’d have to fake the moans, but they spill out of me naturally.
“Fuck, no wonder he kept coming back for more,” the man groans. He wraps his hand around my throat and pulls me back against him. My back is arched dramatically allowing him to push deep.
It’s weaker than I got used to with Cory, but a climax builds. I can’t help but wish that it was Cory inside of me. Just the thought of him heightens my pleasure and forces me into an orgasm. The man grunts and groans through his orgasm before pulling out of me.
“Cory is going to be real pissed off that you let his best friend hit it,” he says, kissing my cheek. It suddenly hits me. I do recognize the voice. I just haven’t heard it in person in a few years.
“Fuck, Jason,” I sigh. He throws his hand up before fixing my clothing. “I should have fucking known he was looking at my stuff.”
“Yeah. He saw your profile the moment you posted it,” he says as he turns me to face him before looking my body up and down. “You are a surprising little thing.”
“I don’t know how to take that,” I admit. “You knew already, didn’t you?”
“Yeah. I knew the night of the party,” Jason says. “The only reason that I knew it was you was because I was in the hall right before you pulled your mask on, and then I saw Cory come out without one on.”
“Great,” I deadpan.
“I will admit, it took me by surprise that you two have kept it up, but somehow it’s also not surprising,” he says before nodding to who I assume is Cory behind me.
“I’m past the point of caring,” I say. “I haven’t thrown myself into traffic for everything with Cory, so I can handle you two tricking me.”
“I wouldn’t call it tricking,” he laughs. “I would have told you if you had asked. Plus… It was fun fucking you while he watched. Let me know if he pisses you off again.”
“Oh, I will,” I smile. “Bye, Jason.”
I turn and face Cory and he looks pissed. I can’t help but laugh. “You think this is funny?” he asks as he steps closer to me.
“I do,” I say. I keep backing up until he takes a larger step than I expected and he grabs me by the back of the neck and pulls me against him so he can wrap his hand around my throat.
He doesn’t squeeze but it’s at this moment that I realize that I have pushed him to a breaking point.
He reaches between my legs and pushes his fingers into me.
“Fuck,” I hiss.
“Fight it all you want, little sister, but this pussy is mine. Do you understand me, Bella?” his voice is dangerously low and it’s honestly hot as fuck on how possessive over me he’s being.
“Yes,” I say quietly.
“Say it,” he growls.
“It’s yours, Cory. My pussy is yours,” I say almost inaudibly. I don’t know what he is doing to me, but I am practically a puddle of my former self with how he melts me.
“Let’s play a game of hide and seek, Little Sister,” he says with a crooked grin.
“You’re about to fuck me in the woods like an animal, aren’t you?” I ask with a sigh.
“Why don’t you hop along and find out, bunny?
” he says seriously. “But first, let’s see how far you can get with this.
” He pulls something out of his pocket that I can’t make out before he moves my feet apart and slips his hand into my underwear.
I gasp when he pushes something inside of me.
It’s also against my clit, so I’m slightly confused until Cory lets go of me and takes a step back.
The thing inside of me suddenly comes to life and I gasp loudly when vibrations shoot through me. It’s hitting all of my sensitive areas perfectly. “You don’t play fair,” I whine. It shuts off and he smiles.
“If you take it out, I’m taking your ass right here in these woods,” he threatens.
“You would not,” I laugh. “You know that would hurt me and I know you’d never hurt me.
“Do you want to find out, Bella?” he asks, stepping closer.
“No,” I smirk.
“Run,” he growls.
I turn on my heels and run down the trails. I am not the fastest runner, but Cory is. He played football and did track through high school, whereas I read. I can hear him behind me, and he is gaining on me fast.
“You’re making it too easy for me, baby sister,” he taunts me. The vibrations shoot through me again and I stumble.
“Cory!” I gasp when he grabs me and drags me to the ground. He straddles my body and sets his phone on my chest before tapping the screen. The vibrations intensify and I groan. An orgasm washes over me and I squirm under him. “Cory, please.”
“Beg your big brother to make it stop, Bella,” he says. “Beg me to stop.”
“Oh God,” I moan again as another orgasm tears through me. “Please stop, Cory. Please stop.”
“I can’t hear you,” he smiles.
“Please. Please. Stop, Cory. Please,” I beg.
He finally shuts the device off and I relax with a whimper. He gives me no time to relax as he spreads my legs and rips my underwear off. He pulls the device out and shoves it in his pocket before pulling himself out of his pants.
He kisses me hard and slams himself deeper with each thrust. He replaces his lips with his hand as he continues to pound into me. He’s pushing so deep that it brings tears to my eyes and the only thing I can do is whimper as he angrily fucks me.
“You’re mine, Bella,” he growls. “No one gets this pussy but me. I don’t care what I have to do. You’re mine.”
“Mhmm,” I moan. My belly aches but the string of orgasms easily flood out of me. Even though he is abusing my pussy in the best possible way, he is still tender, in a way.
“Fuck, I shouldn’t want this. You’re my fucking sister, Bella,” he says with anger in his tone.
They fuel his thrusts into my body, making me whimper each time he slams against my cervix.
He wraps his hand around my throat and squeezes this time.
I grab his wrist when I suddenly can’t breathe.
Cory continues to pound into me until finally our orgasm breaks together.
He releases his hold on his and crushes his lips against mine.
I kiss him desperately as I cry out my pleasures.
“I’m sorry,” I say tearfully when he pulls out of me.
He sits against a tree and cradles me in his lap as I cry. “I’m so sorry, Bella,” he whispers.
“Why does this have to be so hard?” I ask
“I don’t know, honey,” he says. “I love you, Bella. More than I should and it terrifies me. Please don’t go fuck other people when I make you upset. Okay?”
“Okay,” I sniff. “I love you too, Cory.”
“God, this is so fucked up,” he sighs and kisses my head. I lay my head on his chest and relax into him. “Please move in with me. I don’t care if we have to move to a different city. I want you in my bed every night. I will walk away from everything I have built to keep you.”
“I’m not going anywhere,” I say. “I’ll move in with you.”
It’s been a month since I moved in with Cory and six weeks since the party where this all started. Every day is like a dream with him. We spend basically every waking moment together and we don’t get sick of it. We’ve never gotten sick of being together.
No one at his work knows who I am to him, but we are very careful to not let anyone see us being close beyond what would be appropriate for siblings in public.
Behind closed doors, he power fucks me every single night.
The only time he has not made me tired by forcing a string of orgasms out of me, was when I had a migraine.
I have my room here fully set up. Looks like I stay there because all of my things are there but I sleep in bed with him every night.