Chapter 7 #4
“Did he tell you why he’s having you come over?” he asks as he pulls into the driveway and parks.
“No. He just said he wanted to see me,” I answer. Finn chuckles and gets out before I have a chance to interrogate him. I get out before he can reach my door.
Instead of walking toward the house, I stop in the driveway.
Something feels off and I can’t place what it is.
I run through a mental checklist to make sure I haven’t done anything to piss Cole off.
Obviously, the first thing that comes to mind is the fact that I ditched him last week.
He wouldn’t be mad enough to hurt me, right?
Why did I just blindly get into the car with someone and put myself in a position where I literally have no way to escape outside of running?
The sex was good, but it wasn’t good enough to get murdered over.
I don’t actually know if he’s mad. I could be throwing myself into a panic attack for no reason, then I look like a lunatic.
I do think that I shouldn’t step into that house until I am sure though.
My gut is telling me something is off, but I can’t tell if it’s a warning for me to run away again or not.
“Riley,” Finn says softly. When he touches my arm, I jump away from him. Instead of letting me back myself down the driveway, he carefully grabs my waist and moves me so I am leaning against the car. “What’s wrong?”
“I’m sorry,” I say with a shaky voice.
“What’s wrong, Riley?” he asks again.
“I just... I freaked myself out. I just need a second,” I say honestly.
“I’ll sit with her,” Cole says as he walks over to us.
“I’ll meet y’all inside,” he says before walking away.
“You look terrified, Riley. What’s wrong?” Cole asks, lifting my chin. When he sees I have tears in my eyes he wraps me in a hug.
“This is just new to me, and I just basically isolated myself. I’ve always been a careful person, but I had a weird feeling when I got out and I just spiraled from there,” I say honestly.
“Were you afraid I was mad at you?” he asks, and I nod.
“Riley, baby. If I am mad at you or upset in any way, I will come to you. I won’t send Finn to get you and I would never intentionally isolate you,” he says.
“Also, because you and I both know where this is coming from, I would never hurt you. We don’t touch innocent people, and you are about as innocent as they come. ”
“I feel offended by that,” I say and Cole chuckles.
“I won’t even intentionally corrupt you, but I won’t stop you from being involved. So long as you are with me, you have assumed permission to have a say.”
“So long as I am with you?” I repeat. “Are you claiming me now?”
“I am unless you don't want me to claim you,” he says.
“W-What does that mean exactly?” I ask.
“Let’s go inside and we can talk, okay?” he asks, and I nod hesitantly. “We can hang out here for a while if you want, but this is a conversation best had inside.”
“Why?” I ask. “Why not here?”
“Because it involves more than just me, Riley,” he says.
“I don’t care who it involves,” I say with an attitude. “I need something to go off here, Cole.”
“You will be mine, but I will freely share you,” he says bluntly.
“Excuse me?!” I ask, shocked.
“Again... this is a conversation that needs to happen inside with everyone else,” he says. “I want you to have all of the information first, and that can’t happen out here.”
“Okay,” I say after a second.
I follow Cole inside and everyone that showed up last week is here. Alex is off by himself but paying attention. Everyone else is together near the couch and chairs. Cole points for me to sit on the couch and he sits across from me on the coffee table.
“I’m going to be very blunt with you because… well, I don’t think you’ll listen to me otherwise,” he says, and I smile.
“You make me sound stubborn,” I say, and Finn laughs this time.
“Riley, you argued with me over getting a shorter break because you were bored,” Finn says.
“That’s fair,” I shrug. “Let’s hear it.”
“Okay, so when I say you’ll be mine, I mean that in the sense that you and I will be dating. You have absolutely no obligation to let anyone touch you. That includes me,” he says.
“But?” I prompt.
“But if you agree… they have free use of you, so long as your safe word and boundaries are respected,” he says.
“By free use you mean….”
“I mean you will get fucked by all eight of us,” he says. “Alex isn’t allowed to touch until he is a fully patched member.”
“So… I’m tiny compared to you all,” I say and he smirks.
“We won’t hurt you,” he says.
“Cole, sweetie. Define hurt, because I was sore for three days after you damn near killed me.”
“Not everyone will take you the same way, for one. Two, not everyone fucks like I do,” he says.
“Anything else I should know? You look like you’re holding back,” I ask.
“Yeah,” he says. “I want you to move in.”
“Like… permanently?” I ask and he nods. “Why?”
“Because I want you in my bed at night and I want to take care of you,” he says. “You won’t have to work. You can help me if you wish, but you won’t be obligated to anything specific.”
“Any rules?” I ask.
“This isn’t a prison, little canary. This would be your home,” he says before kissing my hand.
“So, I can change my mind and leave if I want?” I ask.
“Yes,” he says. “This isn’t like sex slavery. This is me asking you to be willing to dive in headfirst but also to let my friends fuck you.”
“And everyone is clean?” I ask.
“Yes.”
“What happens if I end up pregnant?” I ask. “I take birth control, but anything can happen.”
“Then you and I will raise the child unless you decide to terminate,” he says.
“Have you done this before with exes?” I ask.
“Yes, and I know you’ll ask so I’ll tell you. Her name is Megan. She and I split more than a year ago and simply put… We just didn’t mesh well. We always argued,” he says. “What else?”
“When?”
“Tonight,” he says, trying to dampen his smile. ”They’d go get your belongings tomorrow.”
“Why me?” I ask.
“I could sit here and name all the ways I think you’re amazing, but we would be here a while. To sum it up though… You’re gorgeous and kind-hearted,” he says.
“Okay,” I say before I can talk myself out of it. “I need names.”
“Well, you know Finn and Alex. Finn is my second in command so, in order from him to Alex is Max, Ryan, Luke, Jake, Nate, and Eli.” Cole points to each man individually and they all look like they’re about to pounce on me.
“I hope you know I’m going to hyperventilate at some point,” I laugh nervously.
“We can handle it,” Finn says as he sits next to me. My breath catches in my throat when Finn places his hand on my thigh. “But she hasn’t eaten today so she needs to be fed first.”
“Let’s eat dinner and we can just go from there,” Cole says. “But I need to hear the consent.”
“I don’t know how to word that,” I say honestly.
“Let’s start with this. Do you want to be in a relationship with me?”
“Yes,” I say honestly.
“Okay, are you willing to explore me sharing you with them so long as your boundaries are respected?” he asks.
“Yes.”
“What are your hard limits?” he asks.
“No permanent marks or hits to the face. No bodily fluids other than come. Nothing intense like fisting. I will draw better lines as I learn what I don’t like.
“Then just use yellow if we approach a line,” he says. I simply nod because I can’t speak. Finn has slid his hand up my thigh and is gripping me at the bend of my hip.
“Let the girl breathe, Finn. Damn,” Max laughs. Finn smirks at me before releasing his grip, letting me relax.
“Thoughts on taking more than one of us at a time,” Finn asks in a soft tone that sends a shiver up my spine.
“Uhm… I… that’s fine,” I say. I am far past the point of nervousness, and I can’t stop fidgeting.
“Riley,” Cole says with amusement in his voice.
“I’m okay I just… I’ve never…” I start to say but he puts his hand up to stop me.
“We won’t hurt you,” he says softly. “You are leading this and despite Finn looking like he’s ready to pounce on you, he will be good and follow your lead. Everyone will.”
“So how does this work exactly? The sharing,” I ask.
“They have free use of you unless you say your safe word,” he says. “You are mine though, no matter how many times Finn corners you.”
“So, here’s the thing, Cole,” I say. “I have attachment issues. If I am just free to use, it’s going to fuck with my head.”
“As long as you are in my bed at night, I won’t be upset if you end up developing feelings for anyone,” he says as he takes my hands into his.
“So, is this like one giant reverse harem where the girl walks funny for the rest of her life?” I ask.
“Something like that,” Cole laughs. “No one outside of us can touch you.”
“And if they do?” I ask.
“Then I’ll cut off whatever they touch you with,” he says seriously. “But you don’t seem like the cheating type.”
“Okay,” I smile.
Everyone switches gears and we go to the kitchen, and I am sat on the counter so I can watch them cook.
Once they are done, we go to the dining room and eat.
The guys talk about some issues that Finn’s bike is having.
Cole and Finn have their hand on my thigh and are gently stroking my inner thigh with their fingertips.
I can feel the heat of their skin through the thin fabric of my work pants and it’s making my pussy pulsate with a need to be filled.
“You’re awfully squirmy,” Finn says softly in my ear. “Thinking about all of us using your tight little body?”
He squeezes the bend of my hip and I whimper softly. No one acknowledges what he’s doing but Cole joins in, and they both press their fingers into the bend of my hip. “Oh,” I moan. I push my plate away and rest my head on my arms.
“I think dinner is done,” Alex laughs. “Can I make a suggestion that might help her not panic?”
“What’s that?” Cole asks.
“Blindfold her,” he says.
“That’s a good idea,” Finn says as Cole has me stand up before grabbing me and throwing me over his shoulder. He carries me to his bedroom, and I hear everyone following. When he tosses me on the bed, I giggle.
Cole and Finn immediately start to undress me. The feel of their hands on my body is intoxicating and all I want is to have them inside of me. “Ready to sing for us, little canary?”
“Yes,” I say before he pulls me into his lap. I gasp when I slowly lower myself onto his dick. “Oh, good heavens.”
A blindfold is placed over my eyes and tied tightly before the person behind me starts kissing and biting my neck and shoulder. Cole holds me in place and my breathing quickens when I hear someone open a bottle of lube. “Relax,” Finn whispers in my ear.
Cole lays back and pulls me down to lie across his chest so Finn can tease me with his fingers.
After a while, he replaces his fingers with the head of his cock.
He slowly pushes just the tip into me, and I groan.
He doesn’t move for a few seconds. I can feel it in the way that Cole holds onto me, Finn is about to destroy me.
“Hold your breath,” Finn says, kissing my back. I listen to him and he surges into me with one quick stroke. Despite holding my breath, I still yell out. Just as pain is about to rip through me, Cole starts moving and pleasure is all that my brain recognizes.
“Oh fuck,” I moan. They are alternating strokes into my body, and I feel like I’m floating. The first orgasm hits me unexpectedly and it’s nearly blinding.
The moment I come, I am passed off to someone else.
Quickly, their bodies diving into mine becomes a blur of sensations.
Hands caress and cradle me as I get pounded by two equally massive cocks.
I don’t know how many of them have been inside of me, but everyone feels different in the most spectacular way.
I can pick Cole out easily because he is the only one who is pierced, and he is the biggest. Slowly and individually, they fill me with their come.
Being filled with come from eight men is both gross and amazing. The evidence of their arousal and satisfaction is dripping from me and just when I think it can’t get any better, I am laid on the bed and the blindfold is taken off.
“Alright, Riley. You ready?” Cole asks with a grin.
“My insides feel like mush,” I whine.
“Nothing internal,” he says, kissing me. “You are going to help us make Alex here a fully patched member.”
“Okay,” I say. “What’s happening?”
“Alex has one final test,” Finn says as Alex smiles deviously at me. ”He is going to eat our come out of you and his goal is to make you come until you call your word."
Alex spreads my legs and gently kisses my inner thigh.
“Fuck,” I groan and arch my back when he thrusts his tongue into me.
I quickly fall into another orgasm and he sucks me so hard that I can’t hardly breathe.
My entire body is shaking as he takes from me.
As soon as he fulfills his duty to eat all the come out of my pussy, he sets in on trying to suck the life out of me.
I feel the pressure building and it’s so intense that it makes my body stiffen.
The world goes silent and my eyes roll back.
When the orgasm breaks, my arousal floods out of me.
Alex growls as he drinks from me as if dying of thirst. He can’t get enough but as soon as the feeling fades, my body starts to reject the feeling.
“Stop,” I whimper. “Please stop. Red. Stop. God, please.” Hearing that word, Alex stops instantly.
When Cole scoops me up, I am nearly disassociated when he takes me to the bathroom to help clean me. By the time he takes me back to the bed, the blanket has been changed, and we are alone.
Cole lays me in bed before climbing in behind me. I roll to face him before snuggling closer. “A girl could get used to this,” I mumble.”
“Oh, there is more where that came from, baby. That was just the tip,” he chuckles.