Chapter 24
Chapter Twenty-Four
AIDEN
My balls ached from this stupid game Sonny was playing with us. I was seeing fucking double, my cock so painfully hard I might have gone blind if I didn’t come soon.
“You’ve made all the rules tonight,” Ella told Sonny. “Now it’s my turn.”
“Yeah?” Sonny cocked his head at her, and a strand of blond hair dropped onto his forehead. “What do you have in mind, beautiful?”
“I love seeing you and Aiden together.” She licked her lips, eyes darting between us. “I want to watch you.”
“I’m down with that.” Sonny grinned like a fucking idiot. He tilted her head to the side and kissed her neck. “Who knew our girl was so dirty?”
I moved beside them, stealing Ella away so I could lick her neck, keeping my eyes on Sonny. “Naughty girl.”
I grabbed a fistful of her hair and sank my teeth into her skin, tugging hard enough to leave a mark. “Are you sure you’re a virgin?”
“Yes,” she moaned. “You’ll find out soon enough.”
“Who do you want to pop your cherry, baby?”
Ella clutched my forearm and whispered, “I want both of you.”
“I know. But only one of us can be your first.”
She promised all of her firsts to me. But now Sonny was involved, and that pretty motherfucker was very convincing.
“Aiden,” she whimpered as Sonny slid his fingers inside her pussy. Whimpers slipped past her pretty lips as she rode his hand, desperate to come. “But I want to fuck both of you.”
“At the same time?” Sonny’s eyebrows rose an inch. “That’s a little too advanced for your first time. It’s going to hurt. A lot.” He glanced at me. “Aiden’s big dick might split your tight pussy in half.”
Sonny was close in size to me, give or take half an inch. If we were to line our cocks up, they looked almost the same.
I fucking loved it.
“No, that’s not what I meant,” Ella moaned with each thrust of his skilled fingers. “I want you to take turns.”
“Yeah?” Sonny winked at me. “You good with that, Sunshine?”
Sonny knew this was more than sex for me. I had real feelings for Ella. She was the first person, other than my sister, to whom I felt an instant connection. I had that with Sonny, but it wasn’t the same. What I felt for one was different from the other.
Right before Ella was about to come, Sonny withdrew his fingers. He raised them to his mouth and sucked her cum from his skin. She was so wet and dripping, making a puddle on the sheets.
I need to be inside her.
“Not again,” Ella whimpered, shoving the sweaty hair behind her ears. “Sonny, I can’t take much more of this.”
“You can handle it, babe.” He hooked his arm around her and flattened her onto her stomach, gripping her ass from behind. “Your first orgasm will feel like fireworks shooting off inside your body. It’s worth it.” His hand crashed down on her ass, and she whimpered. “You like getting spanked, don’t you?”
“Yes,” she moaned, gripping the sheets between her fingers, teeth gritted. “Please let me come, Sonny. It’s starting to hurt.”
“Not yet,” he teased, sliding his thumb between her pussy lips to spread her open, letting her cum drip onto his hand. “You’ll be fine. No one’s ever died from not having an orgasm.” He plunged two fingers inside her. “The pressure that’s building up will go away soon. We’re all feeling it, El. It’s not just you.”
“Oh god,” she muttered, head turned to the side so I could see her eyes close. “That’s so… good.”
He slapped her ass while pumping into her. “Do you trust me?”
“I don’t know.” Her eyes opened and found mine. “We barely know each other.”
“You know Aiden,” he said, looking at me. “Do you trust him?”
“Yes,” she said without hesitation.
“And do you trust him to make you feel better?”
“Uh-huh,” she mumbled.
Once again, Sonny being a sadist and an asshole, removed his fingers from her pussy. She whined from the loss this time. So I peeled her from the mattress and held her in my arms.
“Sonny’s mean.” I kissed her lips. “But I’m going to make the pain go away. Okay?”
She bobbed her head. “Please.”
My lips crashed into hers, my tongue forcefully sweeping into her mouth. I usually kissed her slowly and took my time, but not tonight. She wrapped her arms around my neck and climbed onto my lap, rubbing her wet pussy on my cock.
“Fuck me,” she said between kisses. “Please, Aiden.”
Before I could react, Sonny ripped Ella’s lips from mine, shoving his tongue into her mouth. He kissed her like he wanted to tear her to pieces. She threw her arms around his neck and bit his bottom lip between kisses. They took turns kissing and nibbling on each other, and I was starting to feel left out.
Finally, Sonny turned his head and kissed me. His lips collided with mine in a kiss that could start a war. When we kissed, there was so much sexual tension and built-up testosterone we could have killed each other. Our lips separated long enough to brush Ella’s. The three of us stuck out our tongues, kissing and getting spit all over the place.
It was kind of awkward and messy, but I didn’t care. I liked claiming both of them.
“I want to watch,” Ella said, moving out from between us. She inched toward the headboard, leaned back on a stack of pillows, and spread her thighs. “Pretend like I’m not here.”
“That’s hard to do,” I said.
Sonny grunted in agreement. “Play with yourself, El. Spread your legs wider for us.” She followed his orders and was rewarded with, “Good girl. Fuck yourself, baby. But don’t make yourself come yet.”
We kissed with our eyes open, watching her play with her clit. My heart pounded like a drum as our tongues tangled, hands roaming over each other’s bodies like we were exploring a new land. Each kiss was primal and set my insides on fire.
“You two are so fucking hot,” Ella said as she leaned back, eyes wide and fingering her pussy. “I want more.”
Sonny curled his hand around my throat, and I matched him, applying the right amount of pressure as we kissed. His hand trailed down my chest, brushing over my nipple. He continued his slow exploration, taking my cock in his hand and giving it a few strokes until he found the perfect rhythm.
After only a few quick hookups, we knew each other’s bodies. I was only two inches taller than him, around the same build and weight, but Sonny had more muscle. The joke was on him, though, because I never worked out. Most of my muscle mass was natural.
I glanced at Ella, watching my dirty girl fuck herself into oblivion. Sonny noticed me staring at her and wanted to give her a good show. So he tackled me to the mattress. He was between my thighs, looking up at Ella and me. I couldn’t see her from this angle, but he could.
Sonny dragged his tongue up my shaft, and I hissed at the sudden volt of electricity that shot down my legs. My eyes snapped shut as he sucked me deeper into his mouth. Finally, I was going to come. And if I didn’t, I might have lost my mind.
Since I couldn’t see Ella, it didn’t feel the same. I needed to see her. Touch her. Put my hands on every inch of her beautiful body.
I raised my hand to beckon her. “Come here, Cinders.”
My hand fell to the back of Sonny’s head, encouraging him to take more of me.
Ella scooted across the bed, now kneeling in front of my head.
“Get on top of me, baby.” I licked my lips, staring between her legs. “I want to eat your pussy.”
“How do I…” Ella bit her lip. “Which way…”
“Get on top of Aiden and turn around to face me,” Sonny said, lifting his head, and my cock popped out of his pretty mouth. “I want to watch Aiden suck the cum from your pussy.”
A little apprehensive, Ella climbed onto my chest and swiveled around to look at Sonny. I lifted her by the hips, positioning her perfectly so I could eat her pussy. Sonny went back to licking up and down my shaft, driving me fucking wild.
As I held Ella up, her legs trembled. She struggled to maintain her balance and fell forward. So I clamped my fingers around her wrist and placed her palms on my chest. This seemed to help. She stopped shaking and moving around as much and focused on the sensations.
I licked her from front to back, tasting her sweetness before driving my tongue inside her. She tasted so good I ate her pussy like it was my last meal.
“Aiden,” she whimpered. “Oh god. I’m so close.”
As Sonny went to town on my dick, a tremor shot down my legs, and Sonny pinned me to the mattress and pressed his weight into me. I came so hard it shot out of me like a rocket. Sonny sucked even harder, not letting his pace falter until he got the last drop.
“You taste good, Sunshine.”
I couldn’t see him with Ella smothering me with her pussy. And this time, when Ella’s legs trembled, I gripped her hips, holding her in place.
“I’m coming.” Ella rocked her hips to get more of my tongue. “Oh god. Aiden.” She moaned. “Sonny. Oh fuck. That feels…”
A second later, her cum squirted out of her like a faucet, soaking my tongue, cheeks, and chest.
“Oh, no.” Ella slid off me and stared at my face, then saw the cum on my chest and Sonny’s forehead. “What the fuck just happened?”
“Hey, baby, it’s all good.” Sonny captured the cum on his forehead with his thumb and sucked it off his skin. “You can squirt on my face any time.”
Ella jumped off the bed and slowly inched away from us, covering her mouth with her hand. She couldn’t look at either of us.
“Cinders, stop freaking out.” I sat up and offered my hand. “Get back in bed with us.”
“But I…” She wrapped her arms around herself. “How did I?” Ella shook her head. “What did I…”
She sounded like Alex during one of her manic episodes. It scared the shit out of me. I got off the bed to comfort her, hoping to calm her down, and she ran into the bathroom, slamming the door.