Epilogue
Nick
“We cook and clean regularly. How do they know that we’re doing it tonight because people are coming over?” I gesture toward Trixie and Sammy, who’ve been watching the front door for the past twenty minutes, tails wagging.
My brother shrugs. “They must read our text messages.”
“That’s fine, as long as they don’t learn how to buy themselves treats online. Can you get the broccoli out?”
Rudy scans the contents of the refrigerator. “Did we forget to buy champagne?”
“Jasper and Felix are bringing it, and Holly’s bringing a cheesecake, remember?”
“Oh, right. It’s been a busy week.”
It has been, in a good way. Our practice was only open for two days between Christmas and New Year’s, but we spent a full day with Holly after Christmas, and saw her two more times after that, once with the Winters, and once without.
Both of those were late nights, each great in their own way. Actually, one was great. The other could be better classified as mind-blowing.
“Still thinking about it?” Rudy asks as he reaches for a knife from the block.
“Thinking about what?”
He gives me a look that tells me we both know exactly what’s on my mind. “The thing we both can’t stop thinking about.”
“Yes. My god, it even randomly popped into my head while I was doing a dental exam on Mr. Ritter’s cockapoo yesterday. I had to hide my boner behind the exam table.”
Rudy chuckles for a moment, then sobers. “Holly’s incredible.”
“She is. When she said she wished we could both be inside her at the same time, I didn’t think she meant it literally.”
My brother pauses, knife resting against the broccoli. I’m sure he’s replaying the scene like I’ve been doing, remembering how the two of us played with Holly’s ass, lubing her up and eventually teasing in our little fingers.
“I wonder how she’ll like the plug,” Rudy says.
“Maybe we’ll find out later tonight. I’ve been wondering if she also talked to Felix and Jasper about it.”
Rudy resumes cutting the florets. “We’ll probably find that out later, too. We need to go slow, though. Make sure she’s fully ready before things really get wild.”
“Agreed.” With four of us sharing her, things are already wilder than I imagined. I love the intimacy when it’s just her, Rudy, and me, and I know the two of us can thoroughly please her, but with all of us together, her pleasure is multiplied in ways that go beyond what two of us can do.
I didn’t think I wanted to share her with anyone but my brother, but it turns out that I don’t mind, now that I know the Winters are good men. Seeing her get off is a turn-on, even when someone else is making it happen.
Excited barking cuts into my thoughts.
“Sounds like they’re here.”
Rudy puts down his knife and wipes his hands on a towel. “Better than a doorbell.”
I quickly wash my hands so I can greet our guests, too. It’s the Winters’ first time here.
Holly is standing between them at the door, the same radiant smile on her face that’s been there all week.
I didn’t know exactly how stressed she had been about choosing between us until the need for her to make a decision was removed.
She looks the happiest she’s looked since we met her, and that makes me happy.
After she kisses Rudy, who takes the cheesecake box from her, I pull her into my arms and get a good, long taste of her sweet lips. “Happy New Year’s Eve.”
“It still looks like Christmas over here.” She gestures toward our front yard with a tilt of her head just before she bends to pet Trixie and Sammy.
“Yeah, we have a lot of work ahead of us out there, packing all of that up.”
Felix and Jasper shake Rudy’s hand as they come in, then reach for mine. “Want help with it?” Jasper asks.
“The decorations?”
“Yeah. It’ll go faster with four of us. Where do you even keep all of that?” he asks.
“The garage, the attic, and we have a shed out back.” Rudy chuckles to acknowledge how much we go overboard on the holiday.
“We’d be glad to help.” As Felix says this, Holly’s smile beams at the idea of us men working together.
“Thanks. We’re planning to take stuff down this weekend, if you’re available. A week after all that snow, it’s supposed to be sixty-five and sunny on Saturday.”
“Sounds like a plan.” Jasper crouches to meet Trixie and Sammy, then fully sits down on the floor to satisfy their requests for belly rubs and petting. His brother joins him, and our dogs look nearly as happy as Holly.
We have appetizers, then beef tenderloin for dinner, and as midnight approaches, we pour champagne.
“Should we toast?” Rudy asks.
Felix raises his glass. “To more nights like this.”
“To being lucky enough to meet such a wonderful woman,” I say, and Rudy and the Winters echo their agreement.
There’s a lot more I could add, like being lucky enough to have found the woman my brother and I want to spend the rest of our lives with, but this is all new, especially with Felix and Jasper now involved, and it’s another thing that will be best taken slow. Slow and steady.
Holly’s eyes are sparkling as she looks around at us. “I’m the one who’s lucky. I could have never chosen between you, and I’m so grateful that I don’t have to. My heart was split in two, and the four of you made it whole.”
My chest fills with warmth, and by the looks on the other men’s faces, her words are affecting them, too.
We move toward her, wanting to touch and kiss her, but she’s still holding her glass aloft.
“Here’s to the coming year,” she says. “If it’s half as happy as this holiday season has been, it will be a wonderful year.”
Smiling at her, I shake my head. “Not half. How about four times as happy?”
Jasper
“Another holiday, another fancy resort. You spoil me,” Holly says as Felix and I escort her up the grand staircase at the Charlotte resort where we’re spending a long weekend.
“You deserve all the best things in life,” Felix tells her.
She squeezes my hand, and is likely squeezing my brother’s too. “I have everything I need to be happy.”
I love to hear it, and I believe it, because I feel the same, but that doesn’t mean we won’t continue to give her all the good things we can.
At our suite, I knock on the door, and a moment later, Nick opens it, pulling Holly into his arms for a kiss. Rudy’s there next, handing her a champagne flute before kissing her, too.
The Frost brothers came ahead to get things ready, and it looks like they’ve been busy.
The room is filled with dozens of red roses and heart-shaped balloons.
Romantic music is playing, and on the table near the fireplace, there’s a charcuterie board and a tray of chocolate-covered strawberries. All of it screams Valentine’s Day.
“Oh my gosh! I wasn’t expecting all this.” She wanders around the space and spots the rose petals scattered on the bed through the open door of the bedroom. Turning to Felix and me, she says, “I thought you said we were going horseback riding and getting spa treatments this weekend.”
Felix’s brow wrinkles. “We are.”
She spreads her arms wide and twirls in a circle. “But I don’t think I’m going to want to leave this room.”
I wrap her in my arms and pull her close. “Don’t worry. We have plenty of time for everything.”
We do have more time, now that Felix and I no longer dance at Club Red. While working there, we managed to build up good savings as well as help our grandparents, but now we want to be available every night, so we can be with Holly as much as possible.
The five of us go out as a group often—or stay in. Other times, Felix and I take her out, and a few times, each of us has had one-on-one dates with her. On the nights we’re not with her, my brother and I have started doing custom work on cars to keep busy, and to keep our accounts growing.
We’re still househunting, but that situation is up in the air, because Holly is our future. We want to do what works best for her.
Nick steps up and gives her a kiss while I’m still holding her. “We have dinner reservations at seven, but we can hang out here for the next couple of hours and do whatever you want.”
Holly tugs him closer with one hand and strokes my thigh with her other. “Only a couple of hours? Not nearly as much time as I need for all that I want to do with all of you. We’ll have to be efficient.”
All the blood in my body rushes to one organ. Efficiency means one thing: all of us in on the action at the same time.
It’s been about a month since we took things to the next level. Holly raised the idea when Felix and I were alone with her, and apparently, she had a separate conversation with Rudy and Nick about the same thing.
During our two-on-one dates we gave things a try, and when it went well—very well—we elevated our group activities. All of this is a tactful way of saying that Holly loves it when as many of us as possible are inside her at the same time.
After over a month filled with a lot of practice, we all work together now like a well-lubed machine.
Here in the suite, the four of us set the champagne aside and surround our woman. Clothes quickly disappear, the rose petals are brushed away, and Holly’s in the middle of the big bed, eight hands and four mouths making her moan.
“It’s not just the suite,” she says, already sounding out of breath. “I never want to leave this bed.”
I gently draw my teeth over one of her nipples. “After a few more good orgasms, you’ll be ready to get on with the evening.”
Her head falls back on the bed as she laughs. “I’ll be lucky if I’m still able to walk.”
Nick looks up from his position between her legs. “Yeah, no promises there.”
Two orgasms later, Holly’s riding me while I lie on my back near the bottom of the bed. She’s stroking Rudy’s and Nick’s cocks while Felix lubes her rear entry. I know the moment his finger presses inside her, by the way her muscles clench around my cock.