Chapter 9 The Wrong Date #2
"...you're present, but your heart seems somewhere else."
Alex looked down at his untouched coffee.
"I didn't mean to make you feel that way."
"I know."
Rachel reached for her purse.
"I actually think you're a really nice man."
"But?"
She smiled with quiet understanding.
"I don't think you're ready to date."
Alex wanted to disagree.
Instead, he realized he couldn't.
Rachel wasn't offended.
If anything, she looked sympathetic.
"I hope whoever you're thinking about realizes how lucky they are."
Alex blinked.
"I'm not thinking about anyone."
Rachel laughed softly.
"If saying that helps."
He didn't answer.
They left the restaurant a few minutes later.
Outside, the evening air was cool enough to carry the scent of approaching winter.
Alex walked Rachel to her car.
"I'm sorry," he said honestly.
She smiled.
"You don't have to apologize."
"I feel like I wasted your evening."
"You didn't."
Rachel shook her head.
"I had good food and good company."
She hesitated before adding, "I just don't think I was the company you were hoping for."
Alex smiled apologetically.
"I wish you were wrong."
"I know."
She opened her car door before looking back at him.
"When you figure out who you're really waiting for..."
Her smile became warm.
"...don't make them wait too long."
Before Alex could respond, she climbed into her car and drove away.
He stood alone in the parking lot for several minutes.
Her words echoed quietly inside his mind.
Who you're really waiting for.
He immediately dismissed the thought.
She was mistaken.
She had to be.
Jamie was his best friend.
Nothing more.
Nothing less.
Yet when Alex climbed into his truck, he didn't feel disappointed because the date had failed.
He felt relieved because he was going home.
The drive across the city felt strangely peaceful.
Traffic had already thinned, leaving long stretches of quiet roads illuminated by streetlights.
Without thinking, Alex turned on the playlist Jamie always insisted was better for driving at night.
Soft acoustic music filled the truck.
For the first time all evening, he relaxed.
He reached the apartment building just after nine.
The hallway smelled faintly of cinnamon.
Jamie must have been baking again.
The thought made Alex smile.
He unlocked the apartment door.
Warm light spilled into the hallway.
The familiar scent of garlic, butter, fresh basil, and baked bread greeted him before he even stepped inside.
His shoulders relaxed immediately.
Jamie looked up from the kitchen.
"There you are."
His voice carried the same quiet warmth it always did.
"I was starting to think you might've stopped for coffee."
Alex slipped off his shoes.
"I thought you said you weren't waiting up."
Jamie looked mildly guilty.
"I wasn't."
Alex raised an eyebrow.
"Really?"
"I just..."
Jamie smiled sheepishly.
"...happened to make too much pasta."
Alex looked toward the dining table.
Two plates had already been set.
Soft candlelight flickered between them.
Fresh bread rested inside a woven basket beside a bowl of parmesan cheese.
A vase of white flowers sat in the center of the table.
Alex laughed quietly.
"You accidentally set the table for two?"
Jamie looked down at the candles.
"When you say it like that..."
"I know."
Jamie rubbed the back of his neck.
"It looks suspicious."
Alex couldn't stop smiling.
"It does."
Jamie quickly blew out one of the candles.
"I was testing whether they still worked."
Alex laughed harder.
"That's an impressive excuse."
"I panicked."
"I noticed."
Jamie finally gave up trying to explain and laughed with him.
"I figured if your date went well..."
He shrugged.
"...I'd have leftovers tomorrow."
"And if it didn't?"
Jamie looked at him.
"I didn't want you coming home to an empty apartment."
The simple honesty settled quietly between them.
Alex looked around.
The apartment felt exactly as it always did.
Warm.
Peaceful.
Safe.
Somehow, it felt even more welcoming after spending hours pretending to enjoy a date with someone he barely knew.
Jamie walked toward the stove.
"So..."
He kept his voice deliberately casual.
"...how did it go?"
Alex loosened his tie.
"She was nice."
Jamie nodded.
"I'm glad."
"But..."
Alex sighed softly.
"...there won't be a second date."
Jamie focused on serving the pasta before answering.
"I'm sorry."
Alex watched him carefully.
"Are you?"
Jamie looked up.
"I wanted you to be happy."
"I know."
Jamie carried two bowls to the table.
"And?"
Alex pulled out his chair.
"I don't think we had much chemistry."
Jamie smiled gently.
"Sometimes that happens."
Alex nodded.
"It does."
They began eating.
For several minutes, conversation drifted toward safer topics.
Work.
Emma's latest text message.
Marcus accidentally setting off the smoke alarm while attempting homemade pizza.
By the second bite, Alex realized he had been smiling almost continuously since walking through the door.
Jamie noticed too.
"What?"
Alex looked up.
"I forgot how good your cooking is."
Jamie laughed.
"You had Italian food."
"I know."
"And you're complimenting my pasta."
Alex took another bite.
"I mean it."
Jamie smiled.
"I'm glad."
The candlelight reflected softly across the dining table.
Outside, rain tapped gently against the balcony windows.
Inside, the apartment felt wrapped in quiet warmth.
Alex suddenly understood something Rachel had accidentally shown him.
He hadn't spent the evening comparing Rachel to some impossible fantasy.
He had spent the evening comparing her to the life he already had.
He looked across the table.
Jamie was telling a story about an elderly customer who had insisted on paying him with homemade jam after a photography session.
His hands moved animatedly while he spoke.
His eyes brightened whenever he laughed.
Alex realized he had stopped listening to the actual story.
Instead, he found himself simply enjoying watching Jamie talk.
Watching him smile.
Watching him exist.
Jamie noticed.
"You've gone quiet again."
Alex smiled.
"I'm listening."
"I don't think you are."
"I am."
Jamie laughed.
"What did I just say?"
Alex admitted defeat.
"I have no idea."
"I knew it."
Jamie shook his head with exaggerated disappointment.
"You were somewhere else."
Alex looked into Jamie's eyes.
"No."
His voice came out softer than he intended.
"I think I was exactly where I wanted to be."
Jamie blinked.
For a brief moment, neither of them spoke.
Then Jamie smiled awkwardly and reached for another piece of bread.
The conversation continued naturally.
Yet Alex couldn't stop thinking about the evening.
The expensive restaurant.
The elegant atmosphere.
The perfectly pleasant date.
None of it had made him feel the way this simple dinner did.
There were no grand gestures here.
Just homemade pasta.
Warm candlelight.
Easy conversation.
And Jamie.
As they cleared the dishes together, Alex quietly accepted a truth that felt impossible to ignore.
He had spent months believing he needed to find someone to build a life with.
Now, standing beside Jamie in their shared kitchen, laughing over whose turn it was to wash the dishes, he realized something that both comforted and terrified him.
If given the choice...
He would rather spend every ordinary evening like this with Jamie than chase a hundred perfect dates with anyone else.
· ? ·