Chapter 38
Creed
DAYS LATER
“Oh, fuck, harder Ri. Deeper—” Collins moans out the moment she pops off of my cock, her tits bouncing and her entire body rocking back and forth with the force of Riley fucking her from behind.
A sheen of sweat coats Riley’s skin, and his hair is stuck to his sweaty forehead. He’s flushed all over, and I can’t be sure if it’s from overexerting himself or from something else.
“Baby, if he fucks you any deeper or harder, he’s gonna puncture your cervix.” I chuckle, but it tapers off into a groan followed by a hiss when Collins swirls her tongue over the tip of my cock before wrapping her sinful lips around the piercing and giving it a light tug with her teeth.
My hands fly to her hair and grip it tight, but not hard enough to hurt her. I lean forward in my seated position and get right in her face, my grin a little crazed.
“Teeth and claws out today, Stardust?”
She just meets me head on, her eyes blazing up at me from her position on all fours. Riley is so lost in her that he’s not paying attention to our mini conversation.
“They only come out when someone—oh my god—someone t-tries to tell me what I can and cannot handle,” Collins grits through her teeth, struggling to form coherent sentences.
I can’t blame her. Riley’s cock is enough to knock the wind out of you just at first sight.
“You want him deeper?” I ask as she reaches for my cock once more, and she nods, her lips parting on an O when Riley slams back in.
Leaning forward a little more, I reach for Riley’s hands.
Collins takes that moment to run her tongue along the topside of my cock, and I moan out loud, catching Riley’s attention.
He looks down at me, his brown eyes meeting mine, and he blushes, his freckles popping beneath the pink of his cheeks and chest.
He’s so goddamned sexy like this, and I can’t help how badly I want him, too, especially when his tongue darts out to run along his bottom lip. Instead of taking his hands, I grab his neck and pull him into a hard kiss, ultimately spit-roasting Collins between us.
She gags and moans around my cock as I claim Riley’s mouth. He tastes like her when my tongue meets his, and it’s got my cock twitching, ready to fucking blow.
Pulling back to meet his glazed-over gaze, I can’t help but smile. He may be fucking her, but he’s putty in our hands, and that alone is a turn on. Riley’s not dominant; he’s a soft top, and he’s fucking perfect for us.
“She wants it deeper,” I mutter, grabbing each of his hands, “and you’re going to give it to her.”
His eyes widen, and he looks a little panicked, so I add, “She knows her limits, baby. She will tell you if it’s too much.”
Slowly, I guide one of his hands up and around until we meet Collins’ throat. Meanwhile, I’m barely hanging onto my orgasm that she’s threatening to suck from my body through my cock.
“Pull her up against your chest,” I manage to say before throwing myself back against the pillows, popping free from Collins’ mouth.
She whimpers, but it quickly morphs into a borderline pornographic moan when Riley follows my instruction and pulls her up until their bodies are flush.
His face is buried in her neck, kissing and nipping at the skin there, which has her crying out, all kinds of sinful sounds falling from her lips.
I wrap my hand back around my cock, now desperate to come with them because I can tell they’re both riding the edge, trying to hold off the inevitable orgasm they’re pulling from one another.
“You like when I fuck you like this?” he asks, his voice low, sounding unlike himself—all grit and gravel. I think my brain short-circuits.
Collins must notice, too, because I watch her eyes roll back. “Fuck yes.” She’s barely able to mumble the words in between Riley’s thrusts. “Oh my g—fuuuuck, right there,” is what follows as she pants and moans and grits through her teeth. “So fucking good, I’m gonna come soon.”
I’d usually tell Riley to touch her clit to give her what she needs, but I’m starving for them all over again.
Pushing up to my knees, I move closer until my chest is flush with hers, and her body bumps against mine as Riley continues to impale her on his cock.
“You two are so fucking sexy together,” I whisper against her lips when I grab her face before kissing her deeply. I guide my cock, slick with precum, until it meets her clit and I thrust.
I’m not inside of her, but this sensation is just as heady because not only am I helping her out, but my cock also brushes against Riley’s. Feeling him move in and out of her tight pussy has me nearly seeing stars.
“Fuuuuck,” Riley moans, his forehead dropping to the back of Collins’ shoulder. He looks up at me when I push my cock forward again, our combined arousal slickening my length as I glide smoothly against her clit and through her lips until I touch his thrusting cock.
My free hand reaches out, banding around Riley’s lower back, smashing all three of us impossibly closer. “I can’t wait to feel your pussy stretch around the two of us one day, Stardust.”
They both moan, but Riley barely chokes out, “I’m gonna come.”
“Yes,” Collins hisses when I brush her clit over and over, “come inside me, Ri.”
Her green eyes meet mine, “Creed,” she whispers, and my cock throbs at the sound of my name on her lips.
We may all be together in this, but there’s something so fucking sexy about her crying out for me while being fucked by another man.
No, not another man, Riley. Call it selfish, but I fucking love it.
Just as much as I love it when she cries his name while riding me into oblivion.
“Come with me,” she squeaks out, and I can tell she’s not just begging me, but it’s also a plea for Riley. She loves it when we finish together, and honestly, I can’t blame her. I love that shit, too.
It only takes a handful of thrusts before Riley moans into Collins’ shoulder, his movements stuttering as he releases inside of her.
Collins cries out, her orgasm ripping through her, and she sinks her nails into my bicep.
The feel of both of them fluttering and pulsing with their orgasm has my balls drawing up tight.
Riley’s cock starts to slip free of her pussy, and I can feel him trying not to slump over, completely spent.
I push them both back until they’re lying, Collins stacked on top of Riley.
I’ve got her legs thrown over my shoulders, and my cock buried deep inside of her pussy before Riley’s cum has a chance to drip free. I pound into her, their combined releases making the sloppiest sounds with every thrust, and it’s music to my fucking ears.
“This pussy is fucking divine, baby,” I grit out, bending her in half so I can kiss her hard.
Riley looks blissed out beneath her, his hands lazily exploring her body while I fuck her into oblivion.
“You want your sweet little pussy filled up with both of our loads, huh?”
She nods, her hands gripping my waist, pulling me against her harder. “Please, please, please,” she begs, and with that, I’m gone.
“Fuuuuuck.” I bury myself to the hilt as my orgasm slams through me, and I pour myself deep inside of her.
Keeping myself buried inside of her, I lean down until the three of us are stacked, and I press my lips to Collins’, this time slow and deep.
“I love you,” I can’t help but whisper against her lips.
“I love you, too,” she whispers back, her voice all sleepy and raspy.
She’s so perfect. She’s everything. I’ve been obsessed with her for years now, but it pales in comparison to the way I love her now.
Riley hums beneath us, and I turn to see he’s watching me intently. Sensing what I need before I do. Collins taps my biceps, and I lift, helping her up.
“I’m going to start the shower.” She gingerly untangles herself from between us and scoots off the bed, turning to where I’m now kneeling between Riley’s legs. “Join me in a minute?”
“Fuck yeah,”
“Of course,” we both answer at the same time, and she smiles, sauntering towards the bathroom. Riley and I both keep our eyes locked onto her tiny frame until she disappears behind the door.
I turn to the man beneath me, lowering myself until my hips part his thighs and our cocks press together.
My forearms rest on either side of his head.
This is the first time we’ve ever been in this position, and I hope like hell it’s not the last. I’d love to sink my cock into Riley’s tight ass someday, if and when he’s ever ready for it.
“You good down there?” I tease, and he just nods, smiling sleepily at me. I press more of my weight into him so I can reach his lips. I have this borderline feral need to claim him, too.
The moment my lips meet his, my mind feels wholly at ease. Riley is a lovable person who has only ever craved just that. I’ve loved him from the moment I met him, but the way I feel about him now is a completely different kind of love.
Just like Collins, this is all-consuming…two bricks on the throttle and no brakes in sight.
My chest aches with the need to finally spit out the words I’ve been withholding from saying out loud.
Breaking the kiss, I pull back until I meet his eyes. The way he looks at me could bring me to my knees if I weren’t already lying on top of him.
“I love you,” I say, my voice thick with emotion. Saying it just feels right. Because I do love him. Wholly. Completely. And he deserves to hear the words.
Riley looks completely gobsmacked by my admission, though. His eyes widen, lips parting in surprise.
I smile, chuckling softly. “What? It’s nothing but the truth here.
” I nip at his bottom lip, and he whimpers, making my cock twitch between us.
“You’re my boy, and you’ve been mine from the moment I brought you home.
Now you’re mine in a whole new way, and the love I harbored for you has shifted.
Changed into something new. Something right. ”
Tears build against his dark lashes, and I wipe the first one away with my thumb before it can meet his sweaty hairline.
“You’re so easy to love.”
He looks like he wants to argue, but I cut off his line of thought by kissing him again.
My tongue brushes his lips, and he opens eagerly for me.
He consumes me. Riley is just as much a weakness to me as Collins is.
He just fits so seamlessly and perfectly into my life that there was never a question about who he belonged to.
The moment our lips part, it’s my turn to be rendered speechless when he whispers against me, “I love you, too.”
I drop my forehead against his. “Fuck, Riley.”
In the back of my mind, I already knew this, but holy fuck, does it feel so damn good to hear the words fall from his lips. Like admitting it was as easy as breathing to him.
But he keeps going, and I’m all too willing to listen.
“I’m not sure when it all started to shift for me, and I honestly didn’t think I’d ever be capable of falling in love with more than one person.
” He swallows thickly, working through his thoughts.
“It feels…normal. Better than normal, actually. It feels like…it’s supposed to be this way. ”
“That’s because it is,” I say, smiling, “the three of us were inevitable. Falling in love was just another step. Though if the two of us had only remained friends, that would’ve been okay, too.
“Like I said.” I kiss the tip of his nose, then push myself to a kneeling position.
“You’re my boy. I need you in my life anyway I can get you. ”
I look down to see our cum-slicked cocks lying side by side, and I can’t help but grab both of them in my hand.
“Shit,” Riley hisses, and I love the way his chest flushes when I touch him.
“You have to admit this is a nice bonus.” I lazily stroke our lengths together.
“Mmm.” He hums as he squirms beneath me, “but I’m too fucking sensitive right now, and I’m afraid my dick might fall off if I come again so soon.”
At that, I really laugh and push off the bed, then help him up. He’s coming out of his shy little shell that’s held him back all these years, and it’s a damned beautiful thing.
“Come on,” I hedge, lacing his fingers through mine and pulling him towards the bathroom. “Let’s get cleaned up and go for a late night ice cream run. I’m fucking starving.”
“You’re always hungry for something,” he teases as he steps into the shower with Collins, shocking me again with the innuendo.
She watches us curiously, a sweet smile on her face, as she rinses the intoxicating coconut shampoo from her hair.
I’m about to bend her over and fuck her all over again as I watch her wash her body, when she asks, “Did I hear ice cream?”
Damn.
“You sure did, Snow,” Riley answers, bending down to kiss her lips before reaching for his body wash. “Last one out has to drive and pay.”
This little shit.
“You fucker.” I chuckle when he tosses the soap out of the shower, and Collins laughs, darting for her towel.
Obviously, I lost, but with these two looking so bright and happy as they inhale their ice cream, I’m pretty damn sure I won.