CHAPTER FOURTEEN
Jake leaned back against the headrest as Jenna's patrol car cut through the October darkness.
Every interview, every dead end, every concerned face from Leith Walsh's book club—they all swirled in his mind. In spite of a very long and complicated day, he and Jenna hadn’t had any luck trying to use the Snow White story to lead them to the next potential victim.
“What do you think we’re missing?” he asked, breaking the silence that had settled between them as Jenna drove him home.
“I don't know. Every member of that book club seemed genuinely shocked about Claudia.”
Jake recalled the tearful faces of the women who gathered monthly to discuss literature over wine and cheese.
They'd interviewed all four of the club members throughout the day, and each one seemed to be more distressed than the last. None had provided anything substantial beyond confirming that Claudia had seemed normal at their meeting three days ago—happy, even, despite her separation from Keir.
“What do you think about that Walsh woman now?” Jake asked.
“Leith sees the world through books, through all kinds of stories.” Jenna made a smooth turn onto Maple Street.
“It's her way of processing just about everything. But I don't think she knows anything useful about Claudia’s murder. And I certainly don’t suspect her of being the killer. Like she said, she barely leaves the bookstore at all. Everybody in Trentville knows that.”
Jake silently agreed. He’d never meant Leith Walsh until today, but she seemed to live solely in a world of words.
He just couldn’t imagine her committing a flesh-and-blood act of violence against anybody.
And interviewing Claudia’s neighbors and just about everybody who knew her—including the principal of the school where she taught and her fellow teachers—hadn’t yielded any useful information.
The town of Trentville slept around them, storefronts dark and sidewalks empty. Jake studied Jenna's profile in the half-light. Fatigue showed in shadows beneath her eyes and he fought the urge to reach across the console and touch her arm.
“You should get some rest tonight,” he said instead. “We've exhausted every angle for now.”
“I'll try,” she replied, the weariness in her voice telling him she likely wouldn't.
The sudden trill of Jenna's phone cut through the car. Jake plucked it from the center console, glancing at the screen.
“It's Dr. Stark,” he told her, then answered and activated the speakerphone. “Dr. Stark, it's Deputy Hawkins. You're on speaker with Sheriff Graves.”
“Jake, Jenna,” Melissa Stark's voice came through, crisp despite the late hour. “I've completed the bloodwork on Claudia Kingsley and found something you both need to hear.”
“What did you find?” Jenna asked, keeping her eyes on the road.
“She was killed by an injection of what appears to be a home-made toxin—quite the cunning mixture.” Dr. Stark's voice carried the clinical precision that Jake had come to associate with her findings.
“Foxglove, jimsonweed, and snake venom, combined in specific proportions. It would have caused almost immediate paralysis. Death would have followed within minutes, perhaps even seconds.”
Jake found the image horrific—Claudia in her final moments, unable to move, unable to call for help.
“Is this something traceable?” he asked. “Something that would require specialized knowledge?”
“Unfortunately not,” Dr. Stark replied, disappointment clear. “It's the kind of recipe that can be found on the internet with a simple search. Anyone with basic research skills and determination could concoct it.”
“So we're looking for someone methodical enough to research and create a poison, but who doesn't need a chemistry degree,” Jenna summarized, turning onto Jake's street.
“Precisely,” Dr. Stark confirmed. “I'll email you the complete report, but I wanted you to have this information tonight.”
“Thanks, Melissa,” Jenna said. “We appreciate it.”
After they ended the call, silence reclaimed the car.
Jake rubbed his temples, considering this new information.
This killer was someone who had researched how to cause a quick, efficient death.
A person who made murder that easy wasn’t likely to stop.
He wondered if either Jenna or her twin would pick up anything helpful before there was another.
And if Piper did, what would it mean for her own well-being?
“Are you worried about Piper?” he asked as Jenna pulled up to his ranch house. The porch light cast a warm glow over his small front yard.
“Yes,” she admitted. “I've been checking in with her throughout the day. She's ...” She trailed off, searching for the right word.
“Struggling?” Jake offered gently.
“Fluctuating,” Jenna corrected. “One moment she's excited that she might be able to help with the case, the next she's terrified that somehow she's causing these events. That old fear has never truly left her.”
“Has she had any more visions related to the case?”
“No,” Jenna said. “And I don't know whether to feel grateful or disappointed about that.”
The engine idled softly as they sat in front of his house.
A cricket chorus rose from the nearby hedges, filling the sudden awkward silence that fell between them.
Jake became intensely aware of Jenna's presence beside him—the quiet rhythm of her breathing.
He shifted in his seat to face her. Their eyes met, and the months of carefully maintained professional distance seemed to collapse into the small space between them.
The dashboard lights cast soft shadows across her face, highlighting the conflict in her expression.
Something unspoken passed between them—a shared understanding of complications, of boundaries about to blur.
Professional boundaries, small-town scrutiny, their own uncertainties—all hung in the balance as his hand drifted across the center console to find hers.
"We'll figure this out," he said, deliberately leaving the statement's meaning ambiguous—was he referring to the case, or to them?
Her fingers curled around his, squeezing with a warmth that lingered longer than usual. "Get some sleep, Jake," she murmured, her voice softer than it had been all day.
He held on for a moment more before reluctantly releasing her hand. "You too, Sheriff," he replied, injecting a lightness into his tone that he didn't really feel.
As he climbed out of the car, the cool October air rushed in, clearing his head. He stood in his driveway, watching as Jenna's taillights disappeared around the corner. Only then did he turn toward his empty house, hoping they would both find some peace before dawn brought them back to the hunt.
*
The moon hung like a sliver of bone above Heritage Park, casting barely enough light to navigate the winding paths.
The woman moved stealthily, her footfalls muffled by the carpet of October leaves.
The glass dome in her gloved hands caught what little moonlight filtered through the branches, transforming the container's grim contents into something almost beautiful.
She thought it a fitting display case for her message—a preview of tomorrow's tale.
It was past midnight, and the park stood empty.
Only the occasional rustling of night creatures disturbed the silence.
Perfect. Witnesses would only muddle the narrative she was carefully constructing.
She found the spot she had selected days ago—a wooden picnic table under a shelter with a wooden roof.
Families would gather here in the morning, the first to see her warning.
Then the woman hesitated, wondering if this was too close to the children’s playground. She hoped that adults would be the first to discover the thing that she was leaving here tonight. She didn't want to frighten children unnecessarily. They were, after all, the ones she was trying to protect.
A quick glance around reassured her that this was the best place available.
Carefully, she placed the glass cake stand in the center of the table.
In the weak light, its contents were dark and indistinct.
Then she unfolded a white sheet and draped it over the lid.
She stepped back to admire her work. It would be unmistakable once found—a display that harkened back to the original tales, before they were sanitized and stripped of their true purpose: to warn.
Satisfaction hummed through her veins. The first two tales had already been executed perfectly.
Claudia, as Red Riding Hood, lost in the woods, is a cautionary tale about straying from the path.
Claudia had been so willing to believe in the safety of familiar places.
How easily she had been taken, never suspecting danger lurked so close.
The mixture had worked just as she'd researched—quick, efficient, merciful even. She wasn't cruel; she was methodical. A storyteller with a purpose.
And then the Snow White parallel—she smiled to herself in the darkness—that would be discovered soon enough.
Her unwitting collaborator in that murder hadn’t yet revealed her body.
When they found her, the authorities might begin to understand the pattern, though not quickly enough to prevent what came next.
Tomorrow would bring her crowning achievement.
After years of waiting, planning, refining her purpose, she would finally free Loyalynne from her glass prison.
That doll had been kept there far too long, displayed like a curiosity, denied her true purpose.
Just as the witch had trapped Hansel and Gretel, she had trapped Loyalynne behind glass, keeping her magic contained.
“Soon,” she whispered, the promise carrying on the night air.
Her connection to the doll had sustained her through the darkest days of her childhood.
Loyalynne had been her only friend, her protector in spirit if not in body.
She'd stared at her through the display case glass many times, their silent communication a lifeline.
If only she had been allowed to hold her, to take her home—how different things might have been.
But tomorrow would correct that ancient wrong. The symmetry pleased her—a glass case now, a glass case then. The message she was leaving tonight was merely prologue to the next chapter.
She backed away from the picnic table, her work complete.
The park grounds stretched before her, manicured and orderly in the moonlight.
Such artifice. Just like the sanitized stories they told children, pretending the world held no darkness, no danger.
Her work would remind them of the truth that lay beneath that fake surface.
With each step away from her message, power surged through her.
This was her purpose—to restore the darkness to the tales, to remind a forgetful world that evil existed and must be acknowledged.
She was not the villain; she was the truth-teller.
The collector of endings too long forgotten.
The one determined to warn others before it was too late.
Dark trees loomed overhead as she made her way toward the street where her car waited.
In the day to come, her third correction would begin.
The woman who kept Loyalynne captive would never understand the gift of her ending—how it would finally set Loyalynne free.
How it would complete a story that had been decades in the making.
She slipped between two hedges and emerged onto a quiet street, becoming just another shadow in the night. Tomorrow, she would claim what had always been meant for her. Tomorrow, a cage would be opened, a spell broken.