Chapter Twelve #2
I looked over for the baby wrap carrier and then remembered I left it upstairs.
“Elijah!” Lucy screamed, and I groaned on the inside. My child was too friendly. She didn’t see a stranger which worried me sometimes. I should probably stop thinking of Elijah as a stranger. After all, we knew each other’s names. “Come see the toys I got.”
“Did you get a new toy?”
Fudge. He sounded close. I stood with Eli in his car seat and pushed the diaper bag up on my shoulder.
Elijah was on the other side of the car.
He had some hair on his chest that I couldn’t notice so far away.
And with all his tattoos, it was a wonder I saw it at all.
I flushed head to toe. His shorts were loose and hung off his hips. He was so…sexy.
Stop staring at his happy trail!
“Today’s my birthday. I turned four.” Lucy held up four fingers.
“You’re messing with me.” He placed his hands on his hips and glanced down at her. “Mine too.”
“Really?” Lucy and I said together. The previous time we spoke was last month—May—and he’d mentioned his birthday coming soon. It was June.
He glanced at me. “Yeah, really.” His gaze swept over me. “Your hair is down.”
Oh, fudge! In this smothering heat, I didn’t even want to know what it looked like. I grabbed at it self-consciously. “Oh, yeah. Big mistake in this heat.”
“Have you had cake?” Lucy asked him, and my heart pitter-pattered a frantic beat. I knew where she was going with her question. “We brought mine home from the party. I’ll give you some.” She glimpsed over at me knowing exactly what she was doing. “Can he come up and eat cake?”
“Lucy… I’m sure he’s busy.” I didn’t even look at Elijah. It was already awkward enough.
“Are you?” she asked him .
“I don’t mind after I finish cutting the grass,” he replied. “If that’s all right with your mom?”
I lifted my head and gazed up at him. Elijah was serious. At that moment, he watched me and waited for an answer.
“Yay! I’ll show you what toys I got,” Lucy exclaimed.
Not knowing how to leave this situation properly, I went to the trunk and tried to grab the first bag, forgetting that I’d planned to go upstairs first and grab the carrier.
“Need help?” I tensed as I felt his smoldering body temperature hit my back, then his shirtless, slightly dewy chest brushed against me as he leaned over and grabbed the bags. “Is the cake up front? Want me to grab it first?”
“S-sure,” I stammered as I gripped the car seat tighter and side-stepped out of his way. “Come grab one, Lucy.” She did and a minute later, Elijah was following us up the steps. He carried every single bag and the cake while Lucy held a Barbie doll she had to show him.
Once we reached our apartment on the third floor, I put in the passcode and let us in.
Elijah stood in the hall and dropped the bags at the entrance.
Eli was getting fussy strapped in, but I still sat it down so I could take the cake from Elijah’s outstretched hand.
“I don’t want to step inside with grassy tennis shoes.
” He searched my face as I took the dessert from him.
“I’ll come up once I’m finished?” he sounded like he was asking to make sure again.
“Okay!” I said a little too cheery. I was trying to act normal, but didn’t know how to when Lucy had invited a man over like it was no big deal.
“Okay.”
I shut the door and didn’t even get to breathe because I was rushing over to Eli who wanted out of his car seat. He was boob-hunting the moment he landed on my chest. Lifting up my shirt, I unsnapped the nursing bra and fed him while picking up the cake and slowly maneuvering it to the fridge.
“Take your toys to your room,” I told Lucy.
Thirty minutes later, they were scattered all over the living room floor instead.
She couldn’t figure out which toy—the dolls or the ponies—she wanted to play with the most. Papaw bought Lucy some cars, and she had those on the coffee table, creating a town with them and playing when Elijah knocked on the door.
Cradling Eli, I wiped my mouth and glanced down at the jogging pants and spaghetti-strap top I had changed into .
It was okay , I told myself. I wasn’t dressing to impress him.
I felt Elijah simply wanted to be friends.
That was okay… Well, I wanted it to be. The only way to get used to having Elijah around was to be around him .
When I opened the door, a spicy, heavenly cologne filled my nostrils. Elijah had showered and tossed on a white T-shirt and black silky shorts. His dark hair still dripped a bit. Elijah’s tattoos were both captivating and menacing-looking on his arms as he stepped in.
He took off his shoes at the door. It was what my family did, and I liked that he did it without being asked. Good manners.
Wow, I thought Elijah and I could really be friends as I watched him cross the tiny hallway into the kitchen and the living room. “Forgive the mess,” I said.
“Elijah!” Lucy jumped up. “Look at my cars.”
“You like playing with cars?” he asked, sounding shocked. Maybe it was because she was a girl. I played with them when I was younger too.
“Yes. My papaw bought these for me.”
“I used to paint model cars when I was little. They came in these kits where you put them together and everything.” He scratched his chin as he squatted beside her and picked up a blue car from the coffee table. “I haven’t in a long time... I might have to order me one online.”
“Can I have one too?” Lucy asked.
“You’d be interested in something like that?” He sounded surprised again.
She nodded her head vigorously. “Can I paint mine pink?”
He chuckled. It was a deep sound. One I felt in my stomach. “I don’t think they offer pink paint in the kit. If they don’t, I can find some pink for you.”
“And blue for Bubby.” My heart warmed at that. Lucy was coming around to liking Eli more. She wasn’t as jealous, and she thought he was pretty funny when he laughed. Said he looked like an old person without teeth.
“We can make him one too,” he told her, then he gazed up at me. I realized I had been smiling the entire time since Elijah’s attention wasn’t on me.
“Do you want a piece of cake?” I asked quickly, hurrying into the kitchen with Eli in my arms.
I heard his knees crack as he got up and followed me. I pulled the cake out of the fridge and cut him a piece before asking. “We have juice and milk…”
“Milk’s fine.” I opened the cabinet. His arm reached past me before I grabbed the glass.
“I can get it.” Elijah’s deep voice rumbled.
“Nonsense. You’re a guest.” I took the glass from his hand, filled it with chocolate milk—he said he liked it—and gave it to him.
I wasn’t sure if I should sit down at the table with him or not.
Elijah was in my apartment. How did that happen?
“Is today really your birthday?” I blurted .
He looked up at me while eating. “It is. I’d be at work otherwise, but they ran me out today on account of what day it is.”
Slowly, I took a seat across from him. I studied him, or more accurately, his tattoos and finally asked, “May I ask what it is you do?”
“I own two tattoo parlors.” Another bite.
“Two?”
Wow, that explained his tattoos.
“Yeah, one’s back in Jeffrey though.”
“Why two?”
“Can’t give up my first baby because I moved back home.” His lips tipped up on the right side, and he gave me a shy smolder. “At least, I’m not ready to let it go just yet.” His gaze skimmed over me blatantly before he took the last bite of his cake. “Do you have any tattoos?”
I shook my head. “No, but I’ve always wanted one. Just never really had time to get one.”
He smirked, tipping his head to the side as if remembering something. “Lucy made a comment when she first saw my tattoos. Something about her grandpa not liking tattoos or maybe he thought they were ugly.”
“Yeah, he’s stuck in his ways.” The understanding gleam in his eyes and grin made me smile too. “My dad’s a good person though.”
“Hank wasn’t a fan of them either when I first decided tattooing was something I wanted to do for a living. Now he has a few.”
“Hank?”
“My mom’s husband.” I didn’t ask why he didn’t say stepdad. The way he smirked at the memory told me he was fond of him regardless of why he didn’t .
Carrying her ponies now, Lucy scooted the chair out beside Elijah. She laid out her toys on the table and sat down. “Do you like scary stuff, Elijah? Is that why you have them on your arms?”
This little listener. I should have known she was sitting around eavesdropping. My child was a creeper, a very observant one.
“I guess so… Does that make me a bad person?” he asked her.
She tossed her hands up. “I don’t think you’re bad, anymore.” She turned to me. “Can I get a tattoo?”
“You’re too little. When you grow up, maybe…”
Eli whined. I glanced down to see him staring up at me. As soon as he had my focus, he stopped fussing and smiled.
“All right, you little attention seeker.” I beamed at him.
“Does that mean Bubby wants one too when he grows up?” Lucy asked.
I snorted, going along with her. “Maybe.”
“He’s such a copycat,” Lucy said, clearly making up a crazy scenario in her head. Elijah laughed.
My cell phone, still in the living room, rang.
I got up with Eli and went to answer it.
When I saw Scott’s name displayed, I panicked.
I thought about Elijah, and then remembered that he wasn’t Scott’s concern.
Besides, we weren’t doing anything wrong.
“Lucy. Come answer this. It’s your dad.” When she climbed down from her seat, I caught the frown on her lips.
I’d forgotten about the party since she’d perked up since we came home.
Her feet padded across the carpet and she took it from my hand.
I glimpsed over at Elijah to see him watching us. When Lucy began speaking, she headed to her room.
Elijah said, “You’re not with their father?” I shook my head and his shoulders seemed to relax. “I knew I never saw anyone when you guys— ”
“Nope. It’s just us.”
“Out of choice or…”
“Yeah, some choice. I caught him cheating on me with my cousin.”
“That’s fucking shit,” he muttered, and I glanced over my shoulder to make sure Lucy wasn’t in the living room again.
“Yeah, but it’s fine.”
“It’s not.”
“Better to have found out, than to still be with him and not know what he was doing behind my back.” I shrugged as if the entire thing hadn’t broken me and my trust. Eli grabbed my shirt in his tiny hand and tugged at it.
Elijah nodded reluctantly. “That’s not what I meant. He’s a prick for doing that to his kids’ mom.” Elijah’s anger gave me pause and something fluttered in my stomach. “Were you married?”
“No.” But I thought I meant something to him. Despite the awkwardness of the conversation, I laughed. Now I was afraid Elijah might look down on me for being an unmarried mother. I was still working on not caring what others thought.
Lucy ventured out of her room with a slight frown on her lips as she brought the phone to me. “Dad says he’s coming over.”
I sighed. When Scott asked me earlier, I told him no. If Lucy wanted to go with her dad, I wouldn’t mind, but I hated when he tried to weasel his way back into my bed.
I wanted to ask her what was wrong, but wouldn’t do it in front of Elijah. The kitchen chair scraped the floor, and I glanced up at him. “I should go.”
That was probably a good idea with Scott coming. “Yeah… Happy birthday, by the way. ”
A smile touched his lips. “Thanks.” He tilted his head. “I’m right next door if you need anything.” I didn’t know what made him say it, but I liked that he did. It was a nice feeling when someone unrelated said something like that.
“Okay.”
Elijah saw Lucy pouting. He bent down and messed with her hair. “I’ll look into those model cars.” He stood and gawked at Eli like he wanted to say something. Elijah’s gaze widened as he backed away, not saying anything to the baby in my arms.
Then he was out the door.