Chapter 13 Isla #2
"Am I? Neither is this." Isla gestured at the space between them.
"We tell each other we love each other in private, and then in public you won't even make eye contact.
We sleep in the same bed and then pretend we barely know each other.
I feel like I'm living two separate lives, and I don't know which one is real anymore. "
Marianne was silent. When she spoke, her voice was quiet. "They're both real. The public performance and the private truth. We just don't get to have them overlap."
"And you're okay with that?"
"No." The word came out sharp, almost angry. "I'm not okay with any of this. Do you think I enjoy treating you like a stranger? Do you think it doesn't kill me to stand in the same room with you and pretend I don't want to touch you?"
Isla was startled by the intensity in Marianne's voice. This was the first crack in her composure all evening.
"Then why—"
"Because I'm terrified." Marianne's hands gripped the steering wheel so tightly her knuckles went white.
"I'm terrified of losing you. Of losing my career again.
Of watching everything fall apart because I couldn't control myself for a few more weeks.
I've already had one career destroyed by institutional politics.
I can't survive that again. And I definitely can't survive losing you on top of it. "
A beat passed. Marianne's breath was coming faster now, her composure cracking under the pressure of everything she had been holding back.
"I'm surviving it. That's the best I can do.
" Marianne reached out and took Isla's hand.
"I'm sorry tonight was hard. I'm sorry I can't give you what you deserve, what we both deserve.
But the alternative is losing everything.
Losing our careers, our reputations, maybe even each other.
If Shaw gets proof of our relationship, he'll use it to destroy us both. "
Isla looked at their joined hands in the darkness. Marianne's fingers were cool and elegant, her grip gentle but firm. This was the woman she loved. The woman who loved her back. The woman who was asking her to accept a reality that felt more and more unbearable with each passing day.
"I know you're right." The admission cost her. "I know the risks. I know why we have to be careful. But sometimes I feel like I'm going crazy, loving you in secret while the rest of the world thinks we're enemies."
"We're not enemies." Marianne's thumb stroked across her knuckles. "We've never been enemies. We've just been playing roles that the situation demanded."
"And how long do we keep playing them?"
"As long as we have to." Marianne lifted Isla's hand and pressed a kiss to her palm. "Until we find a way out of this. Until the audit is done and the pressure eases. Until we can figure out how to have both our careers and each other."
"And if we can't?"
Neither of them wanted to examine the implications.
"Then we'll deal with that when we have to." Marianne's voice was steady, but Isla could hear the fear underneath. "But not tonight. Tonight, let me take you home. Let me hold you. Let me show you that the private truth is more real than any public performance could ever be."
Isla should have pushed. Should have demanded more answers, more guarantees, more assurance that they weren't just postponing an inevitable disaster. But she was tired, and she wanted comfort more than she wanted certainty.
"Okay." She squeezed Marianne's hand. "Take me home."
They drove the rest of the way in silence, but it was a different kind of silence now. Less angry. More resigned.
At Marianne's apartment, they fell into bed together with a desperation that felt more like grief than desire.
They moved against each other with rough urgency, trying to bridge the gap that the evening had opened between them.
When they finally lay still, both breathing hard in the darkness, Isla felt something new in the space between them.
A brittleness. A fragility that hadn't been there before.
They had confessed their love. They had shared their scars and their stories.
But the weight of their impossible situation was pressing down on them, making everything feel precarious.
The sex had been good - it was always good - but something was missing.
Some spark of joy that had been replaced by desperation.
"I'm sorry I got angry." Isla said into the darkness.
"I'm sorry I hurt you." Marianne's voice was soft. "I never want to hurt you."
"I know." Isla turned on her side, facing Marianne's profile. "I just... I need to know this is worth it. That we're not just torturing ourselves for something that can never really work."
Marianne was quiet. When she spoke, her voice was barely audible. "I don't know if it will work. I don't know if we can have both the relationship and the careers. But I know that what I feel for you is real. And I know that I don't want to give it up without a fight."
"Even if the fight destroys us?"
"Even then." Marianne finally turned to face her. In the darkness, her eyes were soft with love and fear both. "Because a life where I never took the risk would be worse than a life where I took it and lost."
Isla reached out and touched Marianne's face, tracing the line of her cheek. "I feel the same way."
"Then we keep going. We keep being careful in public and honest in private. And we hope that eventually, things change enough that we don't have to choose."
It wasn't a guarantee. It wasn't even a plan. But it was something. A shared commitment to try, even in the face of impossible odds.
Isla pulled Marianne close and held her tight, feeling their hearts beat against each other in the darkness.
She stared at the ceiling and tried to believe that love would be enough.
But doubt had taken root, quiet and insistent. And Isla wasn't sure anymore if she could outrun it.