Chapter 19 - Jason
JASON
Several months later, the Lighthouse Diner still hummed.
Not in a metaphorical way. The espresso machine sang sea shanties any time someone ordered the triple-shot seafoam latte.
Off-key. Always off-key. I’d threatened to unplug it more than once, but tourists clapped every time it hit the chorus, so we let it live. Emily said it gave the place character.
She would know. Seven months pregnant and somehow still in charge.
She ran the marketing with her sleeves rolled up and a clipboard under one arm.
Two high school interns followed her like baby ducks, scribbling notes while she explained things like “target demographics” and “emotional resonance.” I didn’t understand half the words she used, but I understood the results.
Newsday featured our enchanted pancake flight on the front page last week, and we had a two-hour wait on Sunday.
All for mini pancakes that made people cry and hug strangers.
But we hadn’t lost our regulars. Earl still ordered burnt toast and argued about baseball with Aunt Ophelia when she visited.
The tip jar still had a sticker that said ‘Witch, Please’.
And I still brought Emily the first mug of fresh drip coffee every morning, right before I flipped the chairs down.
This morning had been the usual chaos. A full breakfast rush, two dropped plates, and someone accidentally enchanted the ketchup bottles again. I flipped the last batch of pancakes, handed off the spatula, and scanned the room.
There he was. Andrew Rowan. Corner booth. Same scarf, fogged-up glasses, and that expression that made him look like he’d wandered into the wrong universe. I slid his plate onto the table.
“Your usual, Andrew. Triple stack with cinnamon butter. Side of existential dread.”
He blinked at me. “Oh. Thank you.”
I followed his gaze.
Fiona stood two tables over, taking an order with a crooked grin and a pen tucked behind one ear. Her curls bounced every time she laughed. Andrew looked like he’d just seen the sun for the first time.
“You know,” I said, “you could say hi. You’re allowed.”
He turned red. “I talk to her. Sometimes. About muffins.”
“Nothing gets the heart racing like bran,” I said. “Real seductive stuff.”
Andrew stared at his fork like it might whisper advice. “She’s… very vibrant.”
“You mean terrifying. Yeah. Most witches are. You’ll live.”
I clapped his shoulder and left him to stew.
Emily sat behind the counter, sorting through the mail. Her belly pressed against the ledge, stubborn and round. I leaned beside her.
“Andrew’s got it bad.”
“For Fiona?” she asked, pen in her teeth.
“Hasn’t stopped staring. I told him to talk to her. He mumbled something about muffins and died inside.”
“That’s precious.” She pulled out a flyer and waved it at me. “But look at this.”
I squinted at it. Valentine’s Day Storefront Decoration Competition! Red glitter letters. Cartoon cupid. Cash Prize. Town Pride.
“This is very us,” she said.
I laughed. “Like the Fourth of July display with the sparklers and that eagle that wouldn’t stop saluting?”
“It was tasteful.”
“It set Levi’s apron on fire.”
She smiled. “He’s fine.”
I looked at the flyer again. “It’d be fun. But with the baby coming, can we really glue sequins to every window and build a cupid out of soup cans?”
“My ankles protested the walk to the mailbox. So I vote no.”
I pinned the flyer to the corkboard next to the specials list. “Let’s put it out there. Staff wants to run with it, they’ve got my blessing and a full glitter budget.”
She raised her coffee cup. “To delegation.”
I clinked mine against hers. “To romance and reckless craft projects.”
“Think Fiona might be up for it?” she asked.
“I think if she is, Andrew will suddenly discover leadership skills he didn’t know he had.”
Emily grinned.
“You’re thinking something,” I said.
“I’m always thinking something,” she said.
Which meant someone, probably Andrew, was about to learn the true meaning of construction paper hearts and overly emotional playlists.
And that was the magic of this place.
Not just the coffee or the pancakes that made you feel feelings. Not even the off-key espresso machine. It was the way something unexpected always took root here. Something good. Messy. Real.
This was the Lighthouse Diner, after all.
A place of waffles and weird magic. Of second chances. Of people finding their way back to each other, or forward into something new.
Why shouldn’t it happen again?
Want to read Fiona and Andrew’s story? Get your copy of When Hearts Bloom today!
She’s a green witch with no art skills. He’s an air elemental afraid to love again. Valentine’s Day has other plans.
A green witch with dirt under her nails and hope hanging by a thread, Fiona is barely scraping by as a waitress at the Lighthouse Diner.
After escaping an abusive relationship with a volatile fire mage, she’s landed in Chrysanthemum Cove with nothing but her magic, her stubborn resilience, and a quiet dream of someday starting a flower farm of her own.
When Fiona asks her boss for a raise, she doesn’t get one.
Instead, she gets an unexpected challenge: enter the town’s Valentine’s Day Storefront Decoration Contest. The prize money could change everything.
There’s just one problem. Fiona has zero artistic talent and a long history of surviving, not shining.
Enter Andrew Rowan.
Andrew is a soft-spoken high school art teacher, an air elemental, and the kind of man who makes Fiona feel safe without asking her to explain why that matters.
When he volunteers to help her decorate the diner, their practical arrangement turns into late nights on ladders, glowing lights strung with care, shared laughter, and touches that linger a second too long.
As Valentine’s Day approaches, the Lighthouse Diner transforms into something magical.
So does the space between them. But with money on the line and emotions growing harder to ignore, Fiona must decide if she’s ready to risk her heart again—and Andrew must decide if he’s brave enough to believe that love might finally be meant for him.
In a cozy seaside town where magic is subtle, healing takes time, and everyone is watching, sometimes the most beautiful thing you create is the future you never planned for.