Chapter Eighteen
Madelyn felt her panties pulled down her legs and thrown to the side. Next came her skirt and then her shirt and bra. When she lay between them naked with them still clothed, she felt more vulnerable.
“Take off your clothes,” she begged.
Both men stood and pulled their shirts over their heads. Just the way they did that was sexy and made her mouth water. Next, they took off their shoes and socks before pulling off their pants and boxers.
When she got her first look at their cocks, her mouth dried up, and her anxiety spiked again.
“Hey, listen,” Trey said as he lay down beside her. “Everything’s going to be okay.”
“You don’t understand. Two of your fingers were bigger than my husband’s dick, and I had trouble stretching for your fingers, and your cocks are twice that size.”
Garrett’s cock looked a bit shorter but thicker than Trey’s.
“Baby, there is nothing we will do that will hurt you. If it does, remember, all you have to say is yellow .”
She nodded at Garrett and then relaxed.
“We’re going to fit, Baby. I promise,” Trey said. “You’ll love every inch of cock we give you.”
“And you’ll beg for more,” Garrett added.
Garrett went in for a kiss, and then she felt Trey start sucking on one of her tits. The dual sensations made her body instantly feel hot and achy. Her cunt juice gushed out of her. She hoped they didn’t see it because it embarrassed her.
Her thoughts scattered, and a sharp throbbing began to pulse deep inside her.
Garrett continued to hungrily take her mouth with a burning intensity when she felt Trey’s fingers sliding through her pussy lips, and then one of them worked its way into her cunt. Her body was a riot of sensations, and she couldn’t decipher what was making her hotter.
When Garrett started playing with her breasts, a coiling pressure in her gut grew. Everything in her body shifted suddenly, making her hold onto Garrett’s muscular arm for stability.
Their touches grew in force, making her breathing uneven and her heartbeat rise.
She wanted to yell at them to hurry, but she couldn’t get the air she needed to talk. She tried lifting her hips, but one of the men pressed his hand down on her lower stomach, keeping her in place.
“Babe, is there a chance you could get pregnant?” Trey asked.
She frowned, not understanding him.
“Can you still get pregnant?” he asked again.
She thought about it for a moment and then shook her head. “No.”
“Would it be okay for us to go without condoms? We’ve not dated since we got divorced, and we got tested after that.”
She nodded at Trey. “Yes. I’d rather feel your skin.”
Trey smiled at her gently. “We would, too.” He moved up and started kissing her, exploring her mouth with his tongue and sucking on hers, making her gasp.
She hadn’t realized Garrett had moved down and was between her thighs.
“Garrett is going to take your cunt, and I’ll be the first to take your ass.”
Her mouth dropped open. “Wait. I can’t…” Her ass? There was no way.
“Babe,” Garrett interrupted her. “He knows what he’s doing. He is going to make it so you love every bit of it. The last thing we want is for you to hate something we do to you.”
Her thoughts scrambled when Garrett started to push the head of his cock into her. The stretching sensation intensified and made her body tense.
Trey pressed a kiss to her temple. “No, Baby. Relax and let him get it in. He’s going to make you feel so good, and when he’s done, I’m going to fuck you until we both explode.”
Her cunt spasmed and grew wetter, which made Garrett groan and helped him to slide in another inch. Trey tried distracting her by kissing her with a dark intensity. It made her womb clench tighter.
His hand went to her breasts. He played with them while his brother continued to move farther inside of her. A gasping scream tore from her when Garrett rammed the last few inches into her. It didn’t hurt, but she felt fuller than she ever had before.
Madelyn blinked her eyes and realized both men had stopped and were staring down at her with different degrees of caring, pride, and feral desire.
Trey moved back a little to give his brother room to brace himself to thrust into her.
Garrett started slow and easy. On one hand, her desire was to build, but she already needed him to go faster.
Her nails dug into his biceps. “Garrett.”
“I know, Babe. This feels so fucking good. I don’t ever want it to end.”
Trey kissed her forehead. “Don’t worry, Love. I know that face. He’s barely hanging on.”
“Fuck off,” Garrett growled.
Trey chuckled and started playing with her breasts.
Garrett started to ride her slowly, letting her get used to his size. Before long, she started to need more. More of what, she didn’t know, but her body was screaming at her.
“Please,” she begged.
“Easy, Love, just another minute,” Trey said.
She felt like she’d burst, and it only grew stronger. She suddenly felt Trey start to press on her clit, and her body tensed and then bowed off the mattress.
“There you go,” Trey said as he continued to stroke her. “Keep going.” She closed her eyes and saw a kaleidoscope of light and colors.
She heard Garrett’s deep groin over her pounding heart and then felt his cum shoot from his cock and fill her cervix.
The strength left her body, and felt like it would shatter for a moment before something inside her relaxed. She sagged against the mattress. She lay still and concentrated on slowing her heart rate.
She flinched when Garrett pulled out of her but then felt him lie beside her and cup her face.
“That was beautiful, Babe,” Garrett said before he kissed her. He was so gentle it brought tears to her eyes.
Madelyn felt her legs being separated, and then Trey moved in between them.
“Can you take me, Love?” Trey asked.
She pulled her mouth away from Garrett and nodded. “Yes. Please. I need you, too.”
“And you’ll get me anytime you want,” Trey said.
She had thought she wouldn’t be able to feel desire again and certainly not be able to come, but Trey was slowly building her need for release, taking her by surprise.
He didn’t take it slow like Garrett, but his brother had stretched her enough for her to take him easily.
“Jesus, fuck,” Trey said through gritted teeth. “You’re so fucking tight. I have never felt anything this good before.”
“I agree. I could live in her,” Garrett said before pressing a kiss to her temple.
Trey didn’t pause and started to pound into her. With Garrett, the build to climax came slowly, but with Trey, he took her immediately to the peak.
Her body felt like it would shatter into a million pieces, and she heard herself begging him. But it didn’t frighten her for some reason. It only heightened her craving for release, but something was holding her back.
“She’s fighting it,” Trey said.
“Well, we can’t have that,” Garrett said.
She felt his hand slide under her hips, felt his finger rubbing against where she and Trey met, and then one of them thrust into her ass. The unexpected move threw her over.
She heard herself scream and felt her body floating. Her whole body tingled and throbbed. She barely felt Trey finish but heard his groan fill the room.
She lay there in a daze as the men cleaned her up and positioned her where they wanted her, which was between them.
Madelyn was drifting, barely awake, when she heard the men praise her and tell her how much she meant to them.
The night was an experience she wanted to live over and over for the rest of her life.