Chapter 8 #3
“Easy, baby,” I tell her, voice low and rough as I rub the lube around her rim.
“Gonna open this pretty ass up for me. You’re already full of Finn’s cock…
and pretty soon you’re gonna take mine too.
Right here.” I press one slick finger against her and slowly push inside.
“Gonna fuck this tight little hole while he’s buried in your pussy.
You’re gonna feel both of us at the same time. ”
She moans into Finn’s mouth, hips twitching. I work my finger deeper, then add a second, stretching her carefully while Finn keeps rocking up into her in slow, shallow thrusts.
“That’s it,” I keep talking, watching my fingers disappear into her. “Look at you taking it so well. Can’t wait to slide my cock in here and feel how tight you are around both of us. You’re gonna be so fucking full, Maddie. Stuffed with cock in both holes.”
Finn breaks the kiss just long enough to look up at her. “You ready for that, baby? Ready to take both of us?”
“Yes,” she breathes, voice shaking. “I want it. I want both of you.”
I keep fingering her ass, scissoring gently, getting her ready while I watch the way she moves on Finn’s cock. The anticipation is almost as good as the real thing.
“Breathe for me,” I tell her, adding a third finger when she’s ready. “You’re doing so fucking good. Look at this pretty ass opening up for me. Can’t wait to feel it wrapped around my cock while Finn’s still buried in that tight pussy.”
She whimpers, forehead dropped to Finn’s. He’s stroking her back, hips still giving her those slow, deep thrusts from below.
“She’s dripping down my cock,” Finn mutters, voice strained. “Every time you push those fingers deeper she clenches around me.”
“I can feel it,” I say. “She’s gonna take us both so well.”
When she’s loose enough and rocking back onto my fingers like she needs more, I pull them free and coat my cock in more lube. I press the thick head against her stretched rim and look up at her.
“Ready, baby?”
“Yes,” she breathes. “Please. I want you.”
I push in slow. The tight heat of her ass grips me inch by inch. She gasps, body going rigid for a second. Finn stills completely underneath her, giving her time.
“Easy,” I soothe, one hand stroking down her spine. “Just breathe. You’re taking me so good. Almost there.”
I keep going until I’m fully seated, my hips flush against her. The pressure is insane. I can feel Finn’s cock through the thin wall separating us, hard and throbbing inside her pussy.
“Jesus Christ,” I groan. “I can feel you in her. She’s so fucking tight like this.”
Finn’s hands tighten on her waist. “You okay, Maddie?”
“Yes,” she manages, voice shaky but clear. “Just… full. So full. Don’t stop.”
We start moving.
I pull back almost all the way and push in again while Finn thrusts up.
We find a rhythm, when I sink deep into her ass, he pulls back a little; when he drives up into her pussy, I ease out.
The dual stretch has her trembling between us, soft broken sounds spilling from her mouth every time we bottom out.
“That’s it,” I rasp, watching my cock disappear into her. “Take both of us. Look at you, stuffed full of cock. Your ass is gripping me so fucking tight while he’s in your pussy.”
“Feels so good,” she moans, pushing back to meet us. “Don’t stop. Please, both of you, harder.”
We give her harder. The wet slap of skin and the filthy sounds of us fucking both her holes fill the room. I reach around and rub her clit in tight circles. Finn lifts his head and sucks one of her nipples into his mouth.
She comes with a sharp cry, body clamping down on both of us at once. The way she squeezes my cock while fluttering around Finn pulls a groan out of both of us.
“Fuck, I’m close,” Finn warns, thrusting up harder.
“Me too,” I grit out. “Gonna fill this tight little ass. You want that, baby? Want us both coming inside you?”
“Yes,” she gasps. “Come in me. Please, both of you, ”
Finn breaks first. He drives up deep and comes with a low, guttural groan, pulsing inside her pussy. The feel of him throbbing against me through her pushes me over the edge. I bury myself to the hilt in her ass and empty everything I have into her, groaning against her shoulder as I fill her.
We stay locked together for a long moment, just breathing hard. She’s shaking between us, completely spent. I press soft kisses to her spine while Finn strokes her hair and murmurs quiet praise.
When we finally pull out she whimpers at the loss. I grab a warm cloth and clean her carefully, taking my time, while Finn pulls her down against his chest. Once she’s cleaned up I stretch out on her other side, sandwiching her between us.
“You did so fucking good,” I tell her, voice still rough. “First time taking both of us like that. Proud of you.”
Finn kisses her forehead. “So proud. You were perfect.”
She turns her face into his neck, still catching her breath, one hand reaching back to find mine. I lace our fingers together over her hip and hold on.
She’s safe. She’s ours. And after the day we’ve had, having her like this, open, trusting, completely claimed by both of us, feels exactly right.