Chapter Four
Amanda was horrified to have Robert Thorne walk into the dining room unannounced and catch her crying in her father's arms like a big baby.
It was embarrassing, and to make matters even worse, she really needed to apologize again for offering him a piece of pie made with soap.
She'd been so ill, and eating was still difficult because her stomach was a bit queasy and she could still smell and taste the soap when she tried to eat.
She also couldn't sit down without considerable pain after the strapping her father administered the day before.
"Rob, what is wrong?" she heard her father ask.
"I apologize for intruding," Rob said, "but I felt it imperative to inform you that two of my men were murdered today while working on the south section of my ranch. They came across the ones rustling my cattle," he explained, and with a look at Amanda he added,
"I knew you would wish to keep Amanda safely at home until these men are captured. It would not be safe for her to come across them while riding her mare."
"No, it sure as heck wouldn't be safe at all," Matt agreed. "No riding anywhere on your own, Mandy, until I tell you otherwise."
"Papa, no! I love to ride Glimmer, and we are not having problems with rustlers. It seems to be Mr. Thorne's problem."
"When there are rustlers about, daughter, the problem belongs to all of us. Now, go and set a place for Rob at the table. She didn't cook today, son, so you'll be safe."
"Papa!" Amanda's face turned beet red and she wanted to sink through the floor.
"Do what I said, girl," Matt ordered crisply, "and bring a set for yourself, too. You're eating at the table tonight."
Amanda looked at him in horror. "Papa, I cannot possibly join you." Hadn't she suffered enough?
"You can and you will," was Matt's response.
She stomped out of the room after flashing her parent a withering look.
"I can see she is as feisty as ever," Rob grinned.
"She's sore at me for giving her the strapping she earned for giving you that soap pie," Matt admitted.
"You punished her when she was so ill?" Rob asked in genuine disbelief. "I regret you felt the need to be so harsh, Matt. Surely, suffering the effects of the soap was sufficient punishment?" He did not want the lovely Amanda to hate him.
Amanda heard Rob's last comment and felt her anger towards him dissipate somewhat.
"I embarrassed Papa, Mr. Thorne, and I do want to apologize once again. It was a childish thing to do, but I also want you to know I had no idea it would make you so ill if you had eaten the pie. I promise I have learned my lesson, and I will never serve anyone anything unfit to eat.
I hope you will excuse me. Since Papa has seen fit to humiliate me further by admitting he punished me, I am sure you will understand that I am somewhat indisposed and joining you this evening is out of the question. Goodnight."
Amanda turned to make her escape but her father moved quickly for a man of his years.
He caught her arm and marched her to her chair, pulled it out from the table, and then proceeded to sit her down on her chair with a thump.
"Owwww!" she cried out in pain. She immediately tried to jump to her feet, but Matt's strong arms kept her where she was.
"You are joining us, Mandy. Is that clear? You try runnin' from this room again before you're excused and I'm going to treat you like you deserve."
"Matt, Amanda is truly miserable," Rob remonstrated with her parent on her behalf.
"That is the consequence of her behavior." Matt was not going to give in, and Rob felt sorry for the pretty redhead. She had already been punished thoroughly for her misdeed, and continuing to torture her was a bit harsh in his opinion.
"We shall eat quickly, Amanda," he said, winking at her.
The food was brought into the dining room, but it was soon obvious that the lovely redhead was in too much discomfort to touch her food.
She was growing pale from the effort of trying not to squirm on her chair and refrain from crying.
The twin spots of embarrassment coloring her cheeks only made her look ill, and Rob found that he was unable to enjoy his meal.
The front door opened and there were running footsteps in the house before one of the men pushed his head in the dining room and said, "Boss, there's a fight down at the cook shack. You'd better come or Shorty is going to carve Gus!"
Once more Matt jumped to his feet and moved with lightning quickness, his face set in determination to prevent bloodshed. "Damned fools!" Amanda heard him mutter as he headed for the bunkhouse.
Once the door slammed, Rob was on his feet in the next second, pulling Amanda to her feet.
"I am sorry your father is being so harsh with you, Amanda. He is trying to show you he loves you and make up for all the years he was not permitted to be a father to you. He is going too far in the other direction now."
"He had a right to be upset with me," she whispered in total honesty.
"Perhaps, but there was no harm done to me. It is you who has suffered so much. Go on to your room, and I will tell him you were feeling quite ill."
"I do feel ill," she conceded. To her genuine surprise Rob leaned over and kissed her forehead. Tears filled her eyes and she asked, "Why are you being so kind to me, Mr. Thorne?"
"Because I think you need a bit of kindness right now, Amanda, and it would please me if you address me as Rob or Robert. Go on now before Matt returns and I am forced to scold him for being too severe."
Amanda smiled, and then she giggled. "I would almost like to see the look on Papa's face, and on yours when he chews you up and spits you out!" After those words, she lifted her skirts and left the room, running up the steps and shutting the door to her room just as Matt returned to the house.
"Where is Amanda?" Matt asked with a scowl as he stomped into the dining room.
"She is upstairs, sir. Surely you noticed she was ill?" he asked calmly.
"She is just pouting."
"No, sir, she is still ill from the soap. And she was in pain and trying to maintain her dignity by sitting still."
He grinned at the older man and then said in a dry tone of voice, "It has obviously been a while since you were thrashed, and girls are delicate and bruise easily. Amanda is suffering, Matt, and needs compassion and forgiveness now."
"Do you think I injured her? Do I need to call Doc out here to tend her?" Matt demanded, his eyes full of worry for his child.
"Calling the Doctor would humiliate Amanda, sir. She will recover, but it will be some days before she willingly sits for any length of time, and I do not think she will attempt to ride her little mare, either. Perhaps that will give me time to uncover the rustlers and bring them to justice."
"I'll help you all I can, Rob." Matt suddenly pushed his plate away. "I feel like a jackass right now," he muttered angrily.
"I understand," Rob said softly, getting to his feet and picking up his hat from the sideboard and putting it on his head. "Thanks for dinner, Matt. Keep an eye out, and I will keep you informed if I discover anything."
Matt watched the young man leave and then smiled.
Apparently a pie made of soap wasn't enough to turn the Englishman away from his feisty Amanda.
He got to his feet and went upstairs. He knocked on his daughter's door and turned the knob and walked right in.
Amanda let out a squeal of embarrassment and too late Matt realized that he should have waited for her to give him an invitation to enter.
She was in the process of changing her clothing, and was dropping her nightdress over her nude body.
Matt got a good look at her bruised backside before the gown hid her from view.
"Papa!" Amanda scolded, humiliated.
"Good God, Mandy!" Matt whispered in shock. "I'm sorry!"
"Ohhhhh!" She stomped her foot in outrage as she put her wrapper over her gown and tied it with angry motions.
"Will you please wait for an answer before you barge in on me?"
she demanded, her temper flaring. She raised her eyes to look at him, and saw tears in his eyes.
"What's wrong, Papa?" she asked, walking over to where he stood staring at her.
"Oh, Mandy, how can you ever forgive me for bruising you like that? I was brutal! You're black and blue!" He reached for her and pulled her close to hug her tightly. "I'm so sorry, baby girl. Papa is so sorry! I'll send for Doc. He'll help you, baby."
"No! Don't you dare send for the Doctor, Papa! I will be fine," she insisted, mortified at the mere thought of her father sending for the Doctor to treat her because of a spanking!
"I was already sore when you strapped me... and I had a few marks from when Robert struck me. Besides, what I did was deplorable. I am still smelling and tasting soap," she confessed.
"I would safely say I have learned my lesson."
"I meant to give you a lesson, but I didn't mean to go as far as I did, honey. I will never take a belt to you again. You have my word on that," he said firmly.
"Goldie was right when she told me a strap was too harsh for a delicate girl. Can you forgive an old fool, Mandy?"
he asked so sincerely that Mandy was hard-pressed not to smile.
"Papa, how many times have you forgiven me?"
she asked. "Of course I forgive you; you only spanked me because I was horrible, and it was my own fault for acting like a spoiled brat. If I'd served a normal piece of pie I wouldn't have ended up over the table for a strapping. Can we put this behind us now, please?"
she asked. "By that I mean, please don't punish me further by asking me to sit at the table right now. I promise you I am not sulking and pouting or trying to punish you for punishing me."
"We'll put some pillows on your chair, Mandy," Matt promised. "And I'll ask Goldie what we can do to make your belly feel better, and if she knows of something to help with the bruises," he added guiltily.