The Pact

54

SUTTON

The four of us stand at the edge of the bed, staring at Thea. Her eyes are wide and I wonder if she’s second guessing her decision. No way Damian’s letting her out of it now.

My gaze traces up her tan bare legs, the same ones I’ve had wrapped around me while I’ve fucked her. My cock aches, needing her again despite our morning fun. I don’t think there will ever be a day I don’t want to be inside of Thea.

Damian steps closer to her, placing one hand on the footboard while the other reaches forward to grip her jaw. “On your hands and knees, princess.” He kisses her roughly before pushing her backwards and letting go.

It’s taken some time for me to adjust to how he and Wesley handle her. At first it bothered me—I’m not sure why. They’ve always been rough with the women we’ve dated. But Thea holds a special place in my heart. The need to protect her is powerful. Then, I realized she likes it.

I’ve noticed how she smiles when she finds a mark from one of them, remembering how she got it. She wants it. Thea wants what each of us has to offer, and we want all of her.

She follows Damian’s instructions, getting into position. Fuck me. With her legs spread open, we have the best view of her from behind. My mouth’s watering just thinking about tasting her.

“You’re going to suck Sutton’s cock while Wesley fucks you,” Damian explains. It’s not up for debate. He’s calling the shots tonight. She nods. Knowing that she wants all of us at the same time makes me love her even more. I want her to feel all the pleasure in the world. We can give that to her.

I climb onto the bed, positioning myself in front of her. Bending down, I take her face in my hands. “You’re so beautiful, baby.” Capturing her lips, I deepen the kiss momentarily before pulling back.

Thea doesn’t have to do anything to get my cock ready. It’s standing at attention, eager for her mouth. I grip it, pushing towards her parted lips. She holds my gaze as I slide it in, those blue eyes sparkling with excitement.

“God damn,” I mutter as her warm, wet mouth wraps around me. I let her decide how much of me to take, wanting this to be as enjoyable for her as it is for me. Thea thrusts her head forward until my cock hits the back of her throat. She pulls back and shoves it in again. “Fuck, Thea.” She’s got me out of breath already as she pushes herself to the limit.

I watch Wesley crawl onto the bed behind her. She feels it too. I see a flash of nervous anticipation in her eyes. “Hey, this is going to feel good. I promise,” I reassure, sweeping aside a damp lock of hair that’s fallen in front of her face.

Wes skates his hand over the inside of her thigh. She shudders under his touch. The movement makes me groan in pleasure. His hand moves back and forth between Thea’s legs. I can tell he’s teasing her. The moans coming from her mouth vibrate over my cock and her body tenses the moment he slides his fingers in.

“She’s soaking wet.” The grin on Wesley’s face is contagious. I can’t wait to watch him fuck her while she sucks me off. But first, Wes dips his face between her legs and I know he’s tasting her sweet pussy. A flare of jealously hits me. I want some.

Thea’s mouth picks up the pace as Wesley pushes her closer to her release.

“Fuck her,” Damian growls. His impatience is going to ruin this. There’s no rush tonight.

Wesley takes his time pulling away from her. I watch as Cole and Damian move to the side to get a better view. They want to see him stretch out her pussy. Taking his thick cock in his hand, Wes guides it between her legs, pushing into her.

She whimpers over her mouthful of me.

He tries to take his time easing into her, but Thea is eager to feel all of him. She shoves her ass backwards, impaling herself. They both gasp as he bottoms out inside of her.

“Baby, you’re taking Wesley so well. I bet his cock feels so good stretching you out, huh?” She nods as her big blue eyes stare up at me through dark lashes. Thea’s losing focus on me as she adjusts to his cock. My hands cradle her face. I help her keep the rhythm—pulling and pushing her mouth over me.

Wesley grabs onto Thea’s shoulders for leverage. He starts slowly at first, sliding in and out, forcing me deep into her throat with each thrust forward. Then he slams into her body. At first, I’m nervous for her, however, that’s soon chased away as her muffled cries and moans tell me she’s loving the feel of Wesley’s aggressive fucking.

“God, she loves all of this attention,” Cole groans.

I look up and find him stroking himself to the sight of Thea’s holes being filled. I need her to come. Reaching down, I capture her nipple between my fingers, rolling it with just enough pressure to send sparks of electricity through her body.

“Baby, we need you to come. You can do this. You’re perfect for us.” My encouragement makes her whimper.

Wesley reaches around the front of her. His fingers massage her clit as he crashes into her body over and over. Without warning, she tenses, then clenches and screams around us. Her mouth slows as she rides out the intense climax hitting her body.

I take over, thrusting into her fast and deep. Fuck, I’m close.

My cock explodes, shooting my come down her throat. I breathe through the aftermath and the shudders hitting my body. Pulling out of her mouth, I lift her chin up and watch as she swallows me down. Thea smiles sweetly and I’ve never been more turned on.

Wesley pulls out of her right after me. I look down and see her confusion.

“Thea, you’re going to ride Cole now,” Damian tells her. I shift to the side, giving my brother enough room to get his fill.

COLE

Getting onto the bed, I help Thea rise to her knees. She’s still shaky from her orgasm. “Hi, love.” I smile warmly, running a thumb over her flushed cheek.

“Hey,” she answers back softly.

There’s smudged mascara under her eyes and her chin is slick with drool from blowing Sutton. I want to clean her up, but it’s no use. She’ll be a mess again when I’m done with her.

I lean down and kiss her, not caring that Sutton’s just filled her mouth with his come. Thea arches into me, running her fingers over my arms and back. Pulling away, I search her eyes for any sign that she doesn’t want to do this anymore.

They’re bright and wide. She bites her lip and gives me a smirk. Thea wants this. There’s no doubt about it.

I lie on my back, my hands folded under my head. Just as I get comfortable, Damian grabs a hold of my ankles and yanks me to the end of the bed until my legs are hanging over the edge.

Thea’s as confused as I am. “Get on top of him,” Damian tells her.

She doesn’t question him. Swinging a leg over me, she centers herself over my cock. As she lowers herself, I swipe my tip over the length of her—slicking myself and teasing her. I guide myself to her entrance, then she sinks down until I’m fully inside of her. “Oh,” I moan as my eyes roll back.

Thea teased me about how hard it would be to get over her once I’d gotten under her. I don’t think she realizes how true that is. I will never get over her and I hope I never have to. Opening my eyes, I see her staring down at me, smiling softly. It’s clear that she loves me. There’s nothing else I need in this world other than that. I’d do anything to protect her…us.

“I love you,” I mouth to her. She echoes it back.

My hands rest on her waist as she rolls her hips, sliding me in and out of her. Her palms connect with my chest—she leans down and kisses me with urgency. My tongue sweeps over hers as I buck my hips up, pushing into her as deeply as I can. Thea gasps, although doesn’t miss the chance to grind herself into me.

“Fuck…Cole, I love how you feel inside me,” she rasps. Christ, she knows just what to say to drive me wild.

Her head falls back, lost in the bliss of us fucking, so I help her along. My fingers dig into her as I drag her hips over me in quick, fluid movements. Thea’s pretty lips part as moans of satisfaction pour from her mouth.

“Tell me what you need, love.” She’s too far gone to censor herself. I want all of her truths.

Between heavy breaths, she says, “I want all of you now. I want Sutton and Wes touching me.”

“What about Damian? You can’t forget him.” I push her to keep going.

“I’d never forget Damian,” she pants out. “I want him to fuck me like only he can.” My hands tighten at her response. My brother sucks in a sharp breath.

Sutton and I gave her a taste of that this morning. I didn’t get a chance to ask her if she enjoyed it, but now, I know she did. And she wants more.

Looking over, I see Sutton watching her with hungry eyes, devouring the sight of her riding me. I don’t blame him. Thea’s tits bounce every time we come back together. Her long dark hair spills over her shoulders. A thin layer of sweat makes her skin shine. Everything about her is fucking breathtaking.

I motion for him to come closer.

Then, I give a nod to Wes on the other side of me, signaling him to join. He stops stroking himself and comes to Thea’s side. I can get her there myself. However, that’s not what tonight is about. Tonight, we all share in her pleasure.

Peering around Thea, I catch Damian smoothing a hand up her back. “Princess, I’m going to need you to lean all the way forward.” His voice is strained. I don’t need to ask Damian what he’s going to do. I know his plan is to have both of us fuck her at the same time. Sutton had her ass this morning—she’s not ready for that again.

Anxiety rushes through me. But I can’t question Damian, especially not right now. I have to trust my brother’s judgment.

I force her hips to stop and wrap my arms around her back, pulling her to my chest so that Damian has perfect access.

“Hey, what…” Thea’s confused by the sudden change of position. She tries to twist around to glance at Damian, but I’m holding her tightly.

“Look at me,” I instruct. She stills and stares into my eyes.

Damian’s voice is low and gruff. “Thea, relax your body for me.” It does the opposite. She tenses at his words.

“Damia—” Her words are cut short as he pushes into her. I assumed he was going to fuck her ass, but I feel the tip of his cock press against mine. Shit, he’s going for her pussy.

“There’s a reason I had Wesley fuck you first. I wanted him to stretch you out for this.” I roll my eyes. I guess my brother’s cock is good for something. “I want you to take a deep breath as I enter you. Now, princess.”

I can tell that she wants to question him. She inhales instead.

I’m not sure how it feels for Thea, but fuck, I can’t begin to describe the feel of Damian’s cock sliding into her. He enters her slowly, taking his time to let her adjust. Thea’s panting against my chest. “Need to stop, love?” I’m giving her the out, if she wants it. She shakes her head.

Damian pushes in farther and then he’s all the way in. The two of us take up every inch of her.

“That’s it. You’re such a good girl taking both of us.” Damian’s praise makes her body relax some. My arms loosen, knowing that she’s not going anywhere. Thea glances back over her shoulder at him. “We’re going to fuck you now. Are you going to come for us again?”

“Yes,” she answers obediently.

DAMIAN

I can’t believe Thea’s cooperating so well. My cock’s fully in her now, pressed up against Cole’s. This is new for all of us, although I can tell this won’t be the last time we stretch her out like this.

Wesley kisses up Thea’s arm as his fingers trace lazy circles over her back. Sutton takes her nipple into his mouth, letting his teeth and tongue alternate between circling and nipping at her. I can feel her body slowly relax and push back into me, urging me to fuck her.

I can’t wait any longer. Thrusting my hips into her, I start slow, easing her into this new feeling. On one side, I have Thea’s pussy clenching down on me. On the other, I feel Cole’s cock as I slide back and forth over him. I’ve never felt anything this good before. I’m going to come much sooner than I want.

“Fuck,” Thea moans loudly. It’s enough to make me speed up. “This feels so good.” Her words make my cock throb. I love that she’s enjoying this so much. I wonder what else she’d like. My mind runs through a handful of things I want to do to her. “Tell me how it feels for you,” she pants out.

Oh, God.I freeze. What am I supposed to say? Am I supposed to tell her that being between her and Cole is the best feeling in the world? Is that weird?

Thea looks over her shoulder. “I didn’t say to stop,” she grits out. I thrust into her again.

Thankfully, Cole speaks up. “Love, you’re so fucking tight. There’s barely any room for us. I can feel every part of you and Damian.” Cole’s honesty relieves me.

I soak in every sensation my dick is feeling—her slickness, the way she tightens the muscles in her pussy, the twitch of Cole’s cock as I fuck her. “How does it feel for you, princess?” I’m eager for Thea’s words.

Between moans, she answers. “It feels amazing. Mmmm. I love how both of you are stretching me out. Fuck. I never want this to end.” Jesus, I’m going to explode if she keeps talking like this.

Thea’s hair is too tempting not to wrap around my wrist. I gather it and twist it around my hand, pulling her head backwards as I fuck her. I slide out, then slam into her. Slide out, slam. Slide out, slam. My skin feels unbearably hot as I get closer to coming.

Wesley encourages her. “C’mon blue eyes, come for us.” He bites down on her shoulder and she cries out, her body tensing and her pussy clamping down on our cocks.

Sutton pulls away from her tit. “You look so pretty taking both of them, do you know that?”

She whimpers out a yes. I can’t take it anymore. She needs to finish now.

“Fuck,” I grate out. “You need to come in the next three minutes or I’m going to fuck you in the ass.” Switching holes is the only way I’ll be able to hold off my release.

The time limit and threat of consequences work rather well. Thea’s screaming and coming all over us just a minute later. I come with her. My body shudders as she clenches tightly around Cole and I.

“That’s my good girl,” I praise breathlessly.

Cole isn’t far behind. He’s rocking his hips into her, chasing his own release. Thea leans forward, kissing his mouth, then his neck. Her tongue flicks over his skin and her teeth nip at him. He wraps his arms around her, holding her tight as he pounds her pussy.

“You feel so fucking good, love.” The words leave his mouth and a second later, he’s spilling into her. “Mine. All mine.” I barely hear him whisper it. Anger surges through me, but I push it back down. We aren’t finished with her yet. That’ll have to be a conversation for another day.

I pull myself out of Thea. Reaching under her arms, I drag her limp body off of Cole’s. Her head falls back against my shoulder. “You have one more cock to drain, princess. Can you do that for Wes?”

“Always,” she mutters. I kiss her cheek and hand her off to him.

WESLEY

I take Thea from Damian’s arms and pull her limp body toward the headboard. Poor thing. We’ve done a number on her tonight and she’s taken us all so well. I don’t mind being last, although I’m torn between what I want to do and what she needs.

Thea’s body won’t be able to handle my usual aggressiveness. Tonight, I can take it easy on her.

Sitting with my back against the headboard, I shift my hips forward. I want to bury myself as deeply as I can inside her. I help steady her as she swings a leg over my lap and lowers herself. Taking my cock in my hand, I find her entrance easily. It’s slick with come from her, Damian, and Cole.

I slide myself in. She’s stretched out and takes me eagerly. “Wes,” she pants. “I need you to come inside me. Please,” she pleads. Something about her begging for me to fill her up satisfies me.

“Anything you want, blue eyes.”

Hooking my arms under her thighs, I lift her. Thea reaches behind me and holds on to the headboard for support. I raise her up a few inches, then let her sink back down onto my cock. She’s moaning instantly, making my cock swell more.

I study her as I fuck her. Her teeth pull over her bottom lip and her lashes flutter as she struggles to keep her eyes open. God, she’s so damn pretty. I kiss down her pink cheeks to her parted mouth. My tongue invades her. She willingly accepts it.

Damian comes up behind Thea. I pull away from her and he wraps his hand around her neck. There’s a momentary flash of fear in her eyes at the unexpected gesture. I have to hold myself back from what I want to do. Her fear does something to me. It calls to an animalistic side of me. I push the urge away.

Sutton kneels next to Thea, gripping her jaw and turning her head to him. I watch him flick his tongue over her lips. She pants against his mouth, needing more. Cole must sense that. He kneels at her other side and brushes his fingers lightly over her ribs. She shudders under his touch.

“That’s our girl. You’ve been such a good girl tonight. We’re proud of you,” Damian praises as his fingers tighten around her throat. I feel her pussy clench at his words.

“Don’t stop,” she moans out. She lets go of the headboard and claws at my back. The sharp pain of her nails scraping over my skin pushes me closer to my release. I let the smallest amount of that primal urge loose. My fingers dig deeply into her thighs. She’ll have bruises tomorrow. I smile at the thought.

Cole encourages her. “Come one more time, love. It would make us so happy. Can you do that for us?” His voice is dripping with persuasion.

“I want to,” she admits.

Damian slips his other hand around the front of Thea, dipping between her legs to find her clit. I look down, watching as my cock thrusts into her and Damian’s fingers tease her. Damian leans close to her ear and I just barely make out his whisper. “You’re perfect, Thea. You’re everything we’ve ever wanted.”

He isn’t lying. Thea is exactly what we’ve been missing. I can’t imagine life without her. The thought still scares me. If she ever leaves, I don’t know what I’ll do. I can’t ever lose her.

Thea comes again, her pussy clamping down on me. She’s pulling at my hair, while Sutton presses his mouth to hers, swallowing down her screams. I follow her release with my own, filling her just like she asked.

Sutton pulls away to tell her, “I love you, Thea. I love you.” It’s such a beautiful moment. I watch his amber eyes fill with affection and Thea’s widen in surprise.

She reaches a hand out to caress his face. “I love you too, Sutton.” Warmth fills my heart, looking between the two of them. But I also feel a pang of jealousy. Mostly that Sutton can express himself so freely, without the fear of getting hurt.

That feeling is chased away when I see tears spill from Thea’s eyes.

THEA

My heart feels entirely full, almost too full. I’ve never felt this loved and cared for before. How can this be what I was missing out on my entire life? How could I have gone this long without knowing true happiness?

I bury my face in Wesley’s shoulder, trying to hide the emotions spilling over. I don’t want them to worry or think I’m upset.

But it’s useless. They’ve already seen the tears.

Wesley’s hands run up my back and his body stiffens. “Thea, what’s wrong?”

I feel fucking stupid and I don’t want to answer. I just want to go to sleep cuddled up between the four of them.

Sutton brushes my hair from my face. “Are you okay? Are you hurt?” It comes out panicked.

“She isn’t hurt,” Damian assures them. “She’s having a drop.” There’s silence. “This was intense for her. Her body is coming down from it.” I feel his hand on my back. “What do you need, princess?”

“I want to be held,” I confess tearfully.

Wes slides me off of him. Cole pulls back the covers and I’m placed beneath them. I’m being handed a water bottle. I eagerly drink all of it. Sutton slides in behind me, his hand smooths over my hair and he kisses the back of my head.

Cole settles under the covers in front of me, scooting in close and draping an arm over me as he presses his forehead against mine.

Damian spoons Cole. He reaches over and pulls my leg up over Cole’s hip, leaving his hand on my calf as he gently massages. I assume Wesley is spooning Sutton. I think I feel his fingers tracing over my arm. However, I’m too exhausted to see if it’s him.

“Do you want to talk about it?” Damian offers.

My lip trembles. Instinctively, I want to hold on to everything I’m feeling to protect myself. Giving them this part of myself is scary.

I’m not sure what I’m afraid of exactly. I guess that they might use it to manipulate me or that they could hurt me with it later. That’s what people do—they use weaknesses as weapons. At least everyone I’ve loved has. Although the alternative is that I keep my walls up and never experience true vulnerability with them.

“I’ve never felt anything like that before. It was…life altering.” I know it sounds dramatic, but I wish they could feel what I’m feeling. “My whole body felt alive and connected with all of you. It’s hard to describe.”

Damian nods over Cole’s shoulder. “I know what you mean. I think it was like that for all of us.” His admission makes me feel a little better. “Is that why you’re crying?”

My eyes close tightly as a fresh wave of stinging hits me. “No. I-I spent so many years living a shadow of a life, settling for less than I deserved. Years wasted being miserable, letting life pass me by. And now…I’ve never felt this happy. I didn’t know it was even possible.”

My chest feels tight and aches with the words I haven’t said. Tears roll down my hot cheeks.

A thumb brushes the wetness away. I open my eyes and see Cole staring at me like I’m breaking his heart by being upset.

“I don’t know what I’ll do if this ever ends. I can’t go back to before all of you. I’ll never find this kind of happiness anywhere else.” My voice cracks as I admit the thing that scares me the most. Losing them.

“Thea.” Damian’s voice edges on warning. “The only way out of this is death. Even then, we’ll find you. You’re ours, now and forever.”

He’s propped up on an elbow, staring at me. “Promise?” I ask as I search his eyes for any trace of hesitation.

“On my life, princess,” he vows. His icy blue gaze hardening with conviction.

“On my life, baby,” Sutton echoes.

Wesley pledges. “On my life, blue eyes”

I look at Cole as he smiles at me. “On my life, love.”

I believe each of them, even if the logical part of me thinks it’s ridiculous. The part of me that cares for them pushes away rationality.

I fall asleep fast to the promise that they will not walk away. I dream of a life far into the future where we’ve built something indestructibly beautiful. For the first time in a long time, I don’t think my ability to see beauty in the darkness will ruin me—I think it might save me.