Chapter 4
The Unconditional Surrender
Eli
We don’t bother with boxers tonight, or even put panties or a t-shirt on Harper. My mind’s still struggling with what’s waiting for us beyond these walls. Someone is planning shit and it’s not just one person.
Who do we trust outside of our own circle?
I draw Harper closer as I bring her to the bed. When she crawls up, I grab her hips. Honestly, I should give the girl a break, but fuck. I just want to lose myself in her over and over until I don’t have to think anymore. No worrying about someone getting to her when we can’t be there for her.
She glances over her shoulder at me with those warm brown eyes. The question in them slowly changes to lust. She lowers her chest and head to the bed while watching me. Submitting to me. Giving me her control. My cock sinks into her warm, wet pussy.
A little gasp parts her lips. My collar is back around her neck where it belongs. I own her. Every inch of her is mine.
Those assholes think they can break us through her. They aren’t far off the mark. The only one who could truly break us is her.
She pushes back into me as I thrust in and out of her pussy. Her hips have little bruises forming from our fingers. I press on one and she moans.
“Did you enjoy the hunt, kitten?” I part her ass cheeks and look at her puckered hole and my cock shuttling in and out of her wet pussy. Her ass is always hot and tight, but fucking it with Caden in her pussy made her squeeze around me achingly sweet.
Her moan is my only answer.
Caden taps my arm. I glance over at the glistening plug in his hand. I stop my thrusting and she whimpers, her hips still rocking, still seeking.
“Patience, kitten.”
Caden presses the tip to her asshole and slowly eases it inside her. Her pussy tightens around me as she lets out a guttural noise. When he gets it all the way inside, he pulls it out and pushes it back in.
Her pussy gushes around my cock as she tries to rock against me, but I hold her hips steady.
“Please,” she cries.
“What do you need, kitten?” I lick my lips as I look at her holes stuffed. “Do you need to get fucked?”
“Yes, sir.”
My dick throbs at the title. Fuck, this girl is under all of our skin. I pull out and thrust in hard. She lets out a little cry.
“Again,” she pants.
I pull out, drawing it out slowly to torment her before punching back in hard, jostling the plug.
“Oh, fuck.” She rubs her face on the comforter. “Again.”
Over and over I give her what she asks for, feeling the pressure welling inside of me. Her body glistens with sweat. I pull on the plug before thrusting both my cock and the plug deep inside her.
“Again.” Her voice is strained.
The others are watching, their gazes intent on our prize. We took her. We claimed her. She’s ours.
I go faster, harder, needing to push both of us over the edge. Needing to feel her milk my cock for my cum until she’s so full it leaks out of her. I can’t imagine any other girl I’d feel like this with. She’s amazing and so fucking curious.
And so fucking close, her cunt flutters around me.
I lean forward and pinch her clit.
She screams as her pussy clenches in orgasm around me, drawing me into mine. I paint her insides with my cum, knowing she’ll be getting more. I don’t think any of us are sleeping tonight.
She pants against the bedspread as I draw out of her. When my cum dribbles out with my cock, I slide my fingers through it and push it back inside her with my fingers. A little aftershock ripples around them.
“Good girl.”
Harper
I don’t move as Eli steps away. I don’t even open my eyes. Jack thrusts his cock inside me. My body shimmers with energy and lust. I need more.
I want them to take me. To possess me. The alcohol is just a dull buzz now. Jack made sure I drank water before we left the bathroom. This is all me and my needs.
“We’re going to stuff you full, sweetheart. Fill this pussy with our cum.” Jack twists the plug and a rush of sensation flows over me.
“Jack,” I whimper.
He’s like a jackhammer, constant and pounding into me. I love how he takes me. I love how they all take me. He rubs his fingers over my clit and circles it slowly, almost reverently, compared to how his cock fucks in and out of me.
I’m keyed up. I can’t imagine stopping. They’ll all take me and I want it. Fuck, I love being claimed by them. He presses down on my clit and a white hot burst of release pulses through me.
I cry out and he thrusts a few more times before he groans his release, filling me.
He pulls out and Nico glides in while I’m still fluttering from my last orgasm. I moan.
“Fuck, sunshine.” His hands grip my hips as he drives in and out of me. “You’re so fucking perfect.”
This isn’t normal, but fuck normal. I want all five of my guys. I need Nico to fuck me and fill me with his cum. Everything inside me craves the release he’ll give me. Because while the motions are similar, they each have their own pace. The way they touch me is unique to each of them.
Maybe I’m greedy, but I don’t want to stop this.
Eli lays down next to me and brushes a strand of hair behind my ear.
“We can do this all night, kitten.” He trails his fingers down my neck to where I saw red marks in the mirror from the negligee straps. “Keep fucking you. Filling you full of us. Do you want that?”
His dark brown eyes search mine, deep and rich, filled with desire. I wet my lips before a moan takes me over. Nico pulls out the plug and pushes it back in, causing a tremor to chase through me.
I take a breath and open my eyes. Eli cups my cheek.
“You good, kitten?”
The amount of stimulation is overwhelming, but I don’t want to stop. It’s not like before with them fucking me together, taking three of them. It’s just continuous fucking. It’s them taking me, claiming me, owning me.
I shatter and cry out as I tighten around Nico’s cock. He pulls out the plug and it tips me even higher. I pant as he thrusts in deep and comes inside me.
Eli is still right here. No one steps up to fill me. I ache, cold and empty, wanting to be filled.
“Yes, Eli.” I wet my lips. This whole thing is too much.
I want to forget everything outside of this room.
Feel something besides this fear that all this will be ripped away from me.
“I want this to continue all night. To fuck all night whether I’m awake or passed out.
I want one of you inside me. I need it.”
If it’s only us, we’re safe. I’m protected. I’m cared for. Luke takes hold of my hips and he brushes his thumb over a small bruise. My breath shudders out of me.
These guys are mine and I want to be theirs. As he eases his cock into my pussy, I can’t think anymore. It may feel like fucking, but it’s not. It’s become something more.
Something I don’t want to let go.
Luke pulls out and I whimper at the loss, but then he rolls me onto my back and draws my leg up before sinking back inside me.
“Your back is lovely, pet, but I want to see your eyes when you come.”
I cup his jaw, feeling the scratch of his five o’clock shadow against my palms. It’s impossible to hide from him. Impossible to feel nothing. This whole thing was supposed to be a necessary evil.
They would fuck me and I’d get an experience that would live with me forever while I moved on. Moved on to another guy in college, someone who wouldn’t be a horseman.
I don’t think I can ever move on. Not from him.
His blue eyes sear into my soul. But it’s not only him I couldn’t move on from. Not from any of them.
He comes down over me and takes my mouth. Claiming every inch of me as his. And I let him because he’s mine. My hips fall into rhythm with his thrusts, taking everything he gives me.
His hand cups my breast and tugs on the nipple, sending a bolt of lust spiraling through me until it explodes. Shattering pieces of me everywhere. I arch into him as I come.
“That’s it, princess.” He whispers against my lips. “Come one more time for me.”
His finger slides between us and he strokes my clit. My eyes widen at the heat in his normally cool blue eyes as he pushes me back over the edge. I cry out as my whole body trembles beneath his.
He smirks and drives into me hard and fast, taking his pleasure. From me. No one else. Only me. He shudders and his cock twitches as he fills me. His lips brush over mine as he pulls away.
I stare up at the ceiling and try to catch my breath, but then Caden is there. He gathers my body as he comes down over me, dragging my legs up and out before he eases his thick cock into me.
“I’m going to enjoy using you tonight, little nympho.” He brushes his lips over mine as he begins a relentless pace between my legs. Fucking in and out of me while holding me open for him.
“Hold her hands.”
I don’t look away from Caden’s fierce green eyes as the others take my hands, holding them down on the bed.
He smirks. “Tonight you’re mine. You’re ours. If a cock isn’t inside you, we’re doing something wrong.”
My pussy clenches around his cock.
“Caden,” I whimper.
“You’re ours. No one else is going to fuck you like this.
No one else will see you like this.” He leans down and sucks my breast, making me arch into him with a moan.
“Your skin flushed with desire. Your body tight with need. Every inch of you rising to meet my thrusts, knowing I’ll make you come.
I’ll give you pleasure before chasing my own. ”
“Please,” I sigh and meet him thrust for thrust as much as I can since he’s holding me down.
“Come for me, little nympho.” He captures my lips and I explode. My body arches into his. He fucks me through my release before he thrusts in deep and groans. His warm cum spills inside me.
He touches his forehead to mine, still buried deep inside me. “I won’t let you go.”
His green eyes cut right into my heart as I lift to kiss him. “Never let me go.”
I wake with Luke’s cock buried inside me. He’s asleep in front of me. I breathe out and brush his hair from his face.
Jack kisses my shoulder. I turn and cup his jaw as he smiles down at me.
“I didn’t mean to wake you.” His words are quiet. Everyone else is passed out around us.
“What time is it?”
He breathes out. “Early. I have to do that flag football thing with Coach Turner.”
“You want me to come with?”
As if sensing me pulling away, Luke tightens his grip on me and his cock thrusts deeper. I turn and he’s still asleep. I smile softly at his possessiveness. So many things I could never say to him.
“No.” Jack kisses my temple. “It’s only a couple hours and then I’ll be back and we can go to my place.”
I reach out my hand and he takes it. “Thank you.”
He agreed to it to protect me.
“Besides, I’m going too.” Caden strides across the bedroom, dressed in athletic wear with his shoes on.
Jack raises an eyebrow. “You’re volunteering to go help kids?”
“Yeah, let’s go. I want to grab a coffee.” Caden leans over me and kisses my temple. His hand runs over the curve of my ass. “Fuck. Let’s go before I change my mind.”
Jack squeezes my hand. “See you, sweetheart.”
My heart flutters as they walk away. It’s easier when we’re all together. But it’s not feasible. We can’t spend our whole lives tangled up in bed. Though it would be nice.
Someone’s phone vibrates. Eli rolls over on the bed and grabs it.
“Yeah.” His voice is rough in the morning and he’s obviously not happy about being woken up.
Luke rocks his hips against mine and I turn my head to find he’s awake now. His eyes are hooded. “Morning, princess.”
“Death.” I smirk.
He nuzzles against my neck. I squeal at the roughness of his unshaven jaw.
“Give us an hour.” Eli tosses his phone on the nightstand and sinks back onto the bed. “Fuck.”
“What now?” Nico blows out a breath and his hand trails over my shoulders. I get it. It seems like we keep rolling from one crisis to the next.
“Breakfast with the girl squad.” Eli groans and meets my eyes. “I want one more fuck before we have to face the day.”
My cheeks flush with heat, but I get it. It’s a way to focus on something we can control. Before we go out into the real world and figure out how all this ties together.