40. Chapter Forty #2
Morgan’s face remained completely serious.
“There’s something weirdly appealing about them both wanting you.
I mean, I got you first. You will always be mine.
But there’s also that sense of extra security, knowing that Nyrah, you know, has the same sort of um…
drive that I have. She would do anything to keep you around.
She will always protect you. Having someone else in my corner that matches my level of intensity feels more like a gain than a challenge.
She will make sure you’ll never get away from us, ever again. ”
“Us…?” Cody asked.
“Us,” Morgan confirmed. “Like I said, I talked to Nyrah about the harem stuff. I thought about it more. As long as I’m still your Number One Best Girl, I’m okay with sharing.”
Cody swallowed the nervous lump that had risen in his throat. This was every plot of Grandpa Sam’s books unfolding in his very own bedroom. With three of the most beautiful women he had ever met.
“So, just to be clear: you’re okay with the whole harem thing?” Cody said. “The thing I have been fighting since day one, is now good to go?”
She smiled and he leaned in to kiss her, but she held up her hand, stopping him.
“To clarify, I’m not only talking about foursome sex stuff.
Yes, that can be a possibility in our near future if the other girls are cool with it, but I’m talking about actual relationship stuff.
I’m talking about the two of them staying here, you Romancing both of them in order to beat the game, and seeing if this is something we all want, permanently and regardless of the game. ”
“Less than a week ago, you and Nyrah tried to kill each other…And now you want to have a fuck puddle with Nyrah and Yana?”
“We tried to kill each other because we both want you and would do anything for you,” Morgan said sweetly.
“I don’t want to keep fighting her, especially since if we went Round Two I’m pretty sure she’d win.
She has fucking claws. And I definitely don't want Temica to win. I want Nyrah to be on the same team that I’m on.
The team that collectively loves and protects you, Cody. ”
“This is fucking wild…” Cody couldn’t wipe the grin off his face if he tried.
Morgan kissed him, slow and sensual, before pulling away and giving him a serious look. “But let’s get one thing straight: I’ll be the one who reaches full Romance first.”
The first time they had sex since the incident was after Gracie’s birthday party, which had earned Morgan her eighth level up. It had been slow and cozy sex before falling asleep in each other’s arm, not a crazy fuck-fest attempting as many level ups as possible.
“We only have two more level ups to make that achievement,” Cody said. “You game for doing both tonight?”
“Fuck yes.” Morgan reached under the covers to shove his pants down and he kicked them off, and his shirt swiftly followed.
Before he could capture her lips in another kiss, she pushed him onto his back and climbed on top of him, pressing her hands onto his shoulders.
Her short nightdress rode up her pale thighs.
It wasn’t high enough to reveal her pussy, but he could already feel her wet heat pressing against his cock and smell the enticing scent of her arousal.
Morgan looked down at him, smiling, long tendrils of copper-colored hair framing her face. “But you want to fuck the other girls, right?”
His brain tried to process what she was asking as she slid her wet pussy lips up and down his length. Instead of answering he gripped her waist and pushed his hips up, desperate to sink into her depths.
“Tell me,” she said, grinding her clit on his cock. “Tell me I’m your Best Girl, but you want to want to fuck the other girls, too.”
“You’ll always be my Best Girl,” he said, smiling up at her.
“And…”
“And?”
“But you're such a fucking stud that you’re going to fuck all of us,” Morgan said.
Cody watched her as she continued to grind on him, her breath growing quicker, her mouth falling open, her eyelids fluttering.
Her cheeks, her neck, and her upper chest were already flushed pink.
He could tell she was about to cum just by grinding on him.
And because she was very clearly getting even more turned on by thinking about him fucking other women.
“You’d like that, wouldn’t you?” he said, playing along.
“Y-yes.” He could tell she was steadily inching closer to her release.
“Who should I fuck first?”
“You always fuck me first.” She pushed her hands down on his shoulders even harder, pressing him into the mattress as she picked up her tempo. “You fuck me and you cum inside of me before your dick gets wet with anyone else.”
“And…what if you’re not around?” They were definitely going to rehash this conversation to work out the details at a later time–you know, when Morgan wasn’t about to cum all over his cock.
He couldn't be sure how much of this was sexy talk or if she was actually laying down the official Harem Sex Rules.
“You can fuck them w-when I’m n-not around.
” Morgan let out a little whimper, her shoulders twitching.
She was almost there. “You can fuck them as much as you want. Fuck them until they c-can’t even w-walk…
oh, fuck…” She let out one final, strangled moan and he felt her pussy quiver on his cock as she came, her thighs squeezing him and her fingers gripping his shoulders, nails digging into his flesh.
[Congratulations! You have completed your ninth Romance Event with Resident Morgan Callahan! Only one more to go until Marriage is unlocked!]
“Congrats, you leveled up,” he told her.